Argo Group International Holdings Ltd

Argo Group International — Proxy Contest (May 2019)

68 slides from Argo Group International's proxy contest presentation, May 2, 2019

  1. Slide 1: Argo Group: Driving Growth and Value for Shareholders

    Argo Group: Driving Growth and Value for Shareholders May 2019 1

  2. Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statements

    Forward-Looking Statements This presentation may include forward-looking statements, both with respect terrorism or outbreak of war; 17) shareholder activism and 18) availability of to Argo Group and its industry, that reflect our current views with respect to reinsurance and retrocessional coverage

  3. Slide 3: Maximizing Value for Shareholders Through Commitment to Strong Stewardship

    Argo Group – Maximizing Value for Shareholders Through Commitment to Strong Stewardship Strategy Driving Company performance is top among peers and exceptional relative Shareholder Value to the market overall Our Board’s Our Board of Directors is committed to ensuring strong corporate Commitment to

  4. Slide 4: Argo's Board and Management Team Consistently Delivers Shareholder Value

    Argo’s Board and Management Team Consistently Delivers Shareholder Value Our Board and management team have built a distinctive specialty insurance franchise that delivers sustainable long-term shareholder value through top line growth and continuous improvement in operating performance • Best-in-cl

  5. Slide 5: Superior Total Shareholder Returns

    Superior Total Shareholder Returns 1-Year Total Shareholder Return 3-Year Total Shareholder Return As of Voce As of Voce 13D Filing1 13D Filing1 Argo 36% 26% Argo 89% 54% S&P 500 13% (2)% S&P 500 52% 48% 2 2 Peers 12% 3% Peers 44% 31% 5-Year Total Shareholder Return As of Voce 13D Filing1 Argo 164%

  6. Slide 6: Our Board's Commitment to Stewardship

    Our Board’s Commitment to Stewardship Argo’s Board is keenly involved in approving corporate strategies, executive compensation and oversight of the risks and opportunities embedded in our business. Thoughtful Board composition and refreshment is and has been a priority We have strong and sound corp

  7. Slide 7: Voce's Campaign of Misinformation and Falsehoods

    Voce’s Campaign of Misinformation and Falsehoods ✘ Voce has not engaged in constructive dialogue with Argo or shown any credible ideas to promote long-term shareholder value ✘ Voce’s nominees are not additive to our director mix either in terms of skills or depth of high quality industry experience

  8. Slide 8: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 1 Argo Overview 2 Argo has Generated Superior Shareholder Returns 3 Argo’s Fundamental Operating Strategy is Delivering Results 4 Our Board’s Commitment to Investor Stewardship 5 Voce’s Campaign 6 Concluding Remarks 8

  9. Slide 9: Distinctive Specialty Property & Casualty Insurance Platform

    Distinctive Specialty Property & Casualty Insurance Platform • Global underwriter of specialty insurance and reinsurance NWP Mix by: • Trailing Twelve Months (“TTM”) Gross Written Premiums (“GWP”): $3BN Business Type Geography • Strategically located in major insurance centers • Across the U.S. | Be

  10. Slide 10: Benefits Derived From a Truly Global Insurance Organization

    Benefits Derived From a Truly Global Insurance Organization Distribution Partner relationships enhanced affording increased relevance Brand Enrichment facilitating high quality talent and influence with both global brokers acquisition and development, fostering innovation and reinsurance brokers and

  11. Slide 11: Innovative and Diverse Operations

    Innovative and Diverse Operations Geographic and product line diversification prevents dependency on any single market and provides broad spread of risk and earnings streams U.S. Operations International Operations Leading Performance With 5-Year Average Combined Ratio of 89.7%1 Growing Platform Wit

  12. Slide 12: International Segment has been a Key Contributor to Argo's Results

    International Segment has been a Key Contributor to Argo’s Results Operating Income After-Tax International Operating 38% 37% 26% NM 21% 31% Income Contribution: Global Catastrophe Activity – Hurricanes Harvey, Irma and Maria, Mexico earthquake, California wildfires $189 $165 $172 $159 $50 $62 $36 $

  13. Slide 13: Evolution of Argo

    Evolution of Argo Argo has delivered sustainable and increasingly profitable premium growth through both organic channels and a disciplined M&A strategy $2,955 Gross Written Premium 2002 First full year 2008 2017 following acquisition of our Excess / Acquired Ariel Re acquired to Surplus Line Underw

  14. Slide 14: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 1 Argo Overview 2 Argo has Generated Superior Shareholder Returns 3 Argo’s Fundamental Operating Strategy is Delivering Results 4 Our Board’s Commitment to Investor Stewardship 5 Voce’s Campaign 6 Concluding Remarks 14

  15. Slide 15: Argo's Shares Are Outperforming

    Argo’s Shares Are Outperforming Total Shareholder Return: 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 5-Year Total Shareholder Return Argo 35.9% 88.8% 164.5% S&P 500 13.5% 51.6% 73.3% Peer Group1 11.8% 43.8% 74.0% +175% 164.5% +150% +125% +100% 73.3% +75% 74.0% +50% +25% +0% (25%) Apr-14 Sep-14 Feb-15 Jul-15 Dec-15 May-16

  16. Slide 16: Best-in-Class Shareholder Returns

    Best-in-Class Shareholder Returns 1-Year Total Shareholder Return 3-Year Total Shareholder Return 5-Year Total Shareholder Return Argo 36% SIGI 114% SIGI 237% RLI 32% Argo 89% Argo 164% WRB 27% WRB 77% THG 140% ACGL 26% AFG 69% RLI 139% SIGI 22% THG 56% WRB 133% JRVR 20% JRVR 56% AFG 112% Y 14% S&PS

  17. Slide 17: Recent Share Price Performance Supported by Fundamental Results

    Argo’s Recent Share Price Performance has been Supported by Fundamental Results November 2018 (3Q 2018 Earnings Call) 4/29/19 (1Q 2019 Earnings) “What we care most about is underwriting margin or combined Argo reported 1Q adjusted operating EPS of $1.18 ratio. And we'd like to see that in the low 90

  18. Slide 18: Argo's Strategy to Drive Value is Being Recognized by the Market

    Argo’s Strategy to Drive Value is Being Recognized by the Market Selected Wall Street Research Commentary1 “[1Q 2019] highlighted strong growth levels and loss performance in the U.S. book (54% of business mix), and improving expense leverage. Argo’s developing technology platform suggests these tre

  19. Slide 19: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 1 Argo Overview 2 Argo has Generated Superior Shareholder Returns 3 Argo’s Fundamental Operating Strategy is Delivering Results 4 Our Board’s Commitment to Investor Stewardship 5 Voce’s Campaign 6 Concluding Remarks 19

  20. Slide 20: Strategy Aligned Toward Shareholder Value Creation

    Strategy Aligned Toward Shareholder Value Creation Our strategy, which is predicated on underwriting excellence, prudent investment management, and thoughtful capital allocation has generated a 9% CAGR in BVPS1 since 2002, the first full year following the formation of Argo Group A B C D Underwritin

  21. Slide 21: Argo's Fundamental Strategy Delivers Results

    Argo’s Fundamental Strategy Delivers Results A Underwriting Superior Underwriting Results: 97.9% combined ratio in 2018 vs. Profitability peer average of 100.7%1; target of 93% by 2020 Total Return Conservative Investment Portfolio Composition with Consistent B Investing Results: Supportive of our u

  22. Slide 22: 1Q 2019 Operating Results: Continued Momentum and Improvement

    A 1Q 2019 Operating Results: Continued Momentum and Improvement % Change / 1Q 2019 1Q 2018 Difference Gross Written Premiums $760.8 $710.5 7.1% • 7.1% increase in gross Earned Premiums 420.5 414.7 1.4% premiums compared to 1Q 2018 Underwriting Income $21.9 $17.3 26.6% Operating Income Before Taxes $

  23. Slide 23: Consistent Underwriting Results

    A Consistent Underwriting Results Loss Ratio1 Expense Ratio2 Combined Ratio Sustained Outperformance vs. Peers Improving Expense Ratio Consistent Underwriting Performance 58.7% 58.0% 60.8% 68.8% 66.6% 35.6% 35.8% 35.8% 35.0% 34.1% 94.4% 93.8% 96.6% 103.8% 100.7% 107.2% 3 97.9% 96.0% 94.9% 96.2% 94.8

  24. Slide 24: Superior Underwriting Results

    A Superior Underwriting Results Argo’s 2018 combined ratio outperformed the peer average by 275bps 2018 Combined Ratio 5-Year 94.4% 95.3% 91.3% 98.8% 95.7% 98.5% 96.9% 97.6% 101.3% 99.3% 99.5% 96.7% 99.7% 105.4% Average: 118.6% Peer Average 108.6% Combined 103.5% Ratio1: 100.7% 99.7% 100.2% 101.3% 9

  25. Slide 25: Argo Continues to Drive Its Digital Transformation

    A Argo Continues to Drive Its Digital Transformation Over the last 5 years Argo has achieved a 43% improvement in GWP per employee Transform Core Business Explore Adjacencies • Processed over $1BN GWP through • Built a self-serve digital portal our newly implemented flagship driving engagement with

  26. Slide 26: Argo's 3 Pillars to Digital Strategy

    A Argo’s 3 Pillars to Digital Strategy Digitize distribution Leverage data to Automate the & secure less become the fastest process freeing expensive and smartest risk people up for high- alternative channels assessor value work Increases underwriting efficiency Benefits top line growth and the Bene

  27. Slide 27: Argo 2.0 Process and Technology Program

    Argo 2.0 Process and Technology Program – Enables A Cost Effective Scale Argo began a process called Argo 2.0 approximately 5 years ago; investments in technology, process optimization and outsourcing have enabled profitable growth and the financial benefits will accelerate as additional scale is ac

  28. Slide 28: Conservative Total Return Focused Investment Portfolio

    Conservative Total Return Focused Investment B Portfolio Portfolio Characteristics Investment Income ($MM) • Duration of 2.6 years1 – focused on asset-liability management Total Return3: $144.2 ($15.6) $176.1 $243.2 ($27.4) $148.0 • Average rating of ‘A1/A+’ Cumulative Total Return $668.5MM • Fixed

  29. Slide 29: Operating Growth Momentum

    C Operating Growth Momentum Argo has achieved scale in highly desirable markets that will support continued margin improvement and growth in book value per share Scale 2002 2006 1Q 2019 2002-1Q 2019 Factor Gross Written Premiums $622 $1,156 $3,006 4.8x Net Written Premiums 484 847 1,759 3.6x Net Ear

  30. Slide 30: Active Steward of Shareholder Capital

    D Active Steward of Shareholder Capital From 12/31/10 to 3/31/19, GAAP book value grew from $1.6BN to $1.9BN and $655 million of capital was returned to shareholders • While our #1 priority remains deploying capital into the businesses where we see attractive returns, we have a strong track record o

  31. Slide 31: Book Value Per Share Growth Driving Value

    D Book Value Per Share Growth Driving Value We consider growth in book value per share (which is a product of ROAE and capital management actions), inclusive of cash dividends paid to our shareholders, to be the key financial measure of building shareholder value • December Capital Markets Dislocati

  32. Slide 32: Achieving Our Target ROAE

    D Achieving Our Target ROAE A 93% combined ratio meets our ROAE target of 10% under current conditions Pre-Tax Income Contribution Underwriting Net Premiums Earned Combined Ratio $126MM Contribution ~$1.8BN (1 – 93%) Investment Investment Assets Net Investment Yield $138MM Contribution ~$5BN ~2.75%

  33. Slide 33: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 1 Argo Overview 2 Argo has Generated Superior Shareholder Returns 3 Argo’s Fundamental Operating Strategy is Delivering Results 4 Our Board’s Commitment to Investor Stewardship 5 Voce’s Campaign 6 Concluding Remarks 33

  34. Slide 34: Our Board's Commitment to Stewardship

    Our Board’s Commitment to Stewardship Argo’s Board is keenly involved in approving corporate strategies, executive compensation and oversight of the risks and opportunities embedded in our business. Thoughtful Board composition and refreshment is and has been a priority We have strong and sound corp

  35. Slide 35: Strong and Sound Corporate Governance

    Strong and Sound Corporate Governance Argo’s board has a longstanding commitment to the highest standards of corporate governance Governance Highlights Adoption Among the S&P 500 Independent Chairman ✔ 31% Shareholder right to call a special meeting at 10% ✔ 64% Majority vote standard ✔ 90% Single v

  36. Slide 36: Board Expertise Aligned with Strategy

    Board Expertise Aligned with Strategy Our Board has the necessary expertise to oversee Argo’s strategy and effectively balances continuity in an industry marked by long business cycles, with the need for fresh, diverse perspectives Strong, Independent Oversight Enhanced by Diverse Mix Argo’s Directo

  37. Slide 37: Strong Commitment to Ongoing Board Refreshment

    Strong Commitment to Ongoing Board Refreshment Argo’s refreshment process began long before Voce, highlighting the Board’s commitment to proactive self-evaluation to maintain the highest level of corporate governance Dymphna A. Lehane Anthony P. Latham Al-Noor Ramji Samuel G. Liss Kathleen A. Nealon

  38. Slide 38: Qualified and Engaged Board of Directors

    Qualified and Engaged Board of Directors Argo’s longer-serving directors have driven significant change over time, overseeing the company’s strategy and positioning Argo to deliver superior shareholder returns over time Gary V. Woods Mark E. Watson III Independent Chairman President President, McCom

  39. Slide 39: Qualified and Engaged Board of Directors (Cont'd)

    Qualified and Engaged Board of Directors (Cont’d) As part of its ongoing refreshment process, Argo has appointed five new directors with new, highly relevant experiences and perspectives since 2017 Anthony P. Latham Former Managing Director – Global Risks Division, RSA Group Samuel G. Liss Managing

  40. Slide 40: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 1 Argo Overview 2 Argo has Generated Superior Shareholder Returns 3 Argo’s Fundamental Operating Strategy is Delivering Results 4 Our Board’s Commitment to Investor Stewardship 5 Voce’s Campaign 6 Concluding Remarks 40

  41. Slide 41: Voce's Campaign Overview

    Voce’s Campaign Overview ✘ Voce has not engaged in constructive dialogue with Argo or shown any credible ideas to promote long-term shareholder value ✘ Voce’s nominees are not additive to our director mix either in terms of skills or depth of high quality industry experience ✘ Voce's is attempting t

  42. Slide 42: Voce Engagement Timeline

    Voce Engagement Timeline Rather than engage in a constructive dialogue, Voce has built a campaign based on falsehoods and misdirection in order to try to make a quick profit at the expense of our long- term shareholders. We also note that Voce has not demonstrated any experience in insurance company

  43. Slide 43: Voce's Nominees Will Not Enhance Breadth of Skills, Depth of Experience

    Voce’s Nominees Will Not Enhance Breadth of Skills, Depth of Experience, or Relevant Industry Knowledge of Current Board Argo has stringent criteria and conducts a thorough and extensive evaluation process for all director nominee candidates Voce’s Hypocritical Reasoning • Voce criticizes overlaps o

  44. Slide 44: Falsehoods About Offices and Investment Properties

    Falsehoods About Offices and Investment Properties Cannot Detract from Argo’s Value-Enhancing Consolidation Efforts Voce combines falsehoods and misdirection in its attempt to discredit what is a cost-conscious, focused real estate program. The truth was easily available to anyone who chose to ask t

  45. Slide 45: Sensationalist Claims About Corporate Aircraft Program

    Sensationalist Claims About Corporate Aircraft Program Based on Fundamentally Wrong Analysis Voce has chosen to disregard the truth in favor of fabricating a narrative of excess, when in reality the program is right-sized for business needs and enables effective execution in an industry built on per

  46. Slide 46: Client-Targeted Sponsorship Programs Strengthen our Business

    Client-Targeted Sponsorship Programs Strengthen our Business in a Cost-Effective Manner Our sponsorship programs costs on average less than $1mm per year, materially less than available information for others in the industry, to provide client-targeted programming that is a key element of our succes

  47. Slide 47: Voce has a History of Destroying Shareholder Value

    Voce has a History of Destroying Shareholder Value Every campaign in which Voce has won or been awarded a board seat has resulted in TSR underperformance relative to the S&P 500 Date of Voce End Date of Estimated Absolute Estimated TSR vs. Voce Holdings with Number of Highest Stake Director(s) Voce

  48. Slide 48: Today's Agenda

    Today’s Agenda 1 Argo Overview 2 Argo has Generated Superior Shareholder Returns 3 Argo’s Fundamental Operating Strategy is Delivering Results 4 Our Board’s Commitment to Investor Stewardship 5 Voce’s Campaign 6 Concluding Remarks 48

  49. Slide 49: Concluding Remarks

    Concluding Remarks • Our operating strategy is delivering superior shareholder returns and has received support from the sell-side and investment community • Argo is driving strong results by executing on a well-articulated strategy • Established leader in niche insurance and reinsurance segments ac

  50. Slide 50: Appendix: Operating Performance

    Appendix: Operating Performance 50

  51. Slide 51: Loss Ratio Performance

    Loss Ratio Performance Argo’s consistent loss ratio performance reflects disciplined risk selection 2018 Loss Ratio 5-Year 48.5% 57.7% 59.2% 59.6% 63.6% 61.6% 63.3% 64.2% 67.4% 70.7% 62.9% 59.0% 66.4% 68.6% Average: 79.9% 73.6% Peer Average Loss 70.5% 70.7% 71.5% 68.9% Ratio1: 66.6% 66.6% 62.4% 64.0

  52. Slide 52: GAAP ROAE Performance

    GAAP ROAE Performance GAAP ROAE Company 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 1Q 2019 Average Alleghany 9% 7% 6% 1% 1% NA 5% W.R. Berkley 14% 11% 12% 10% 12% 13% 12% James River 6% 8% 10% 6% 9% NA 8% The Hanover Group 10% 12% 5% 6% 13% NA 9% Selective 12% 12% 10% 10% 10% NA 11% Global Indemnity 7% 5% 6% (1%) (8%

  53. Slide 53: U.S. Operations (58% of TTM GWP)

    U.S. Operations (58% of TTM GWP) GWP by Business Mix (TTM 3/31/2019) Segment Overview • Excess & Surplus Lines – Non-standard (hard-to-place) risks, with focus on small/medium accounts • Argo Pro – Customer service focused D&O and E&O specialty platform Professional Lines • Trident – One of the larg

  54. Slide 54: International Operations (42% of TTM GWP)

    International Operations (42% of TTM GWP) GWP by Business Mix (TTM 3/31/2019) Segment Overview • Bermuda platform underwrites excess casualty, property and professional lines insurance as well as property reinsurance • Property cat, short tail per risk and proportional treaty reinsurance worldwide P

  55. Slide 55: Appendix: Environmental, Social & Governance

    Appendix: Environmental, Social & Governance 55

  56. Slide 56: Compensation Overview

    Compensation Overview Compensation program thoughtfully designed to align pay and performance and incentivize sound Annual Incentive Plan risk management • Earned based on performance against pre-tax operating income target, and subject to individual performance modifier of up to +/- 30%, based on a

  57. Slide 57: Incentivizing Continued Outperformance

    Incentivizing Continued Outperformance 2018 performance-based equity awards incentivize achievement of ambitious three-year stock price performance and expense ratio reduction goals • To incentivize continued outperformance over the next several years, in November 2018, the Human Stock Price Targets

  58. Slide 58: Highlights of Our 2019 Incentive Plan Proposal

    Highlights of Our 2019 Incentive Plan Proposal The 2019 Omnibus Incentive Plan will allow us to grant equity and cash awards to further align the interests of our employees and non-employee directors with those of shareholders 2019 Omnibus Incentive Plan Plan Governance Highlights • Our Board is req

  59. Slide 59: Responsible and Effective Use of Equity

    Responsible and Effective Use of Equity Our Board of Directors is committed to using equity strategically and responsibly in order to best align incentives with shareholder interests throughout our entire organization Reasonable Historic Burn Rate Broad-Based Use of Equity Annual Share Usage Under 2

  60. Slide 60: Board Oversight of Risk Management

    Board Oversight of Risk Management Board oversees development of Risk Management Policy and Chief Risk Officer’s application of that Policy Goals of Risk Management Framework Board-Level Responsibilities Risk Governance & Culture • Define clear accountabilities and foster a risk aware culture in • E

  61. Slide 61: Governance and Oversight of Sustainability

    Governance and Oversight of Sustainability Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) factors are overseen by our Board and embedded throughout Argo’s operations, coordinated by our Sustainability Working Group Board of Directors  The Risk & Capital Committee receives periodic updates on material r

  62. Slide 62: Argo's Focus on Climate Change

    Argo’s Focus on Climate Change Our ERM function recognizes the potential impact of climate change on Argo’s business operations, insurance products and clients as a key risk that demands our attention and response • Our Board’s rigorous oversight process regards climate risk as it would other signif

  63. Slide 63: Corporate Responsibility Initiatives

    Corporate Responsibility Initiatives Human Capital Management Information Security & Data Protection Maintaining and developing a diverse workforce is key to our The smart, accurate and safe use of data is essential to our success and fundamental to our culture long-term success and growth  Trainin

  64. Slide 64: Seasoned and Accomplished Corporate Executive Team

    Seasoned and Accomplished Corporate Executive Team Consistent management direction balanced with upgrading of talent to position Argo for disciplined and strategic growth Years Experience Name Position Previous Employers Industry / Argo Tenure Mark Watson President & CEO 31 / 20 Titan Holdings, Krol

  65. Slide 65: Appendix: Reconciliation of Operating Metrics

    Appendix: Reconciliation of Operating Metrics 65

  66. Slide 66: Adjusted Operating Income Reconciliation

    Adjusted Operating Income Reconciliation 1Q 2019 1Q 2018 2018 Reported Net Income $91.2 $24.8 $63.6 Income Tax (Benefit) Provision 8.9 0.2 4.1 Net (Loss) Income, before taxes $100.1 $25.0 $67.7 Add (Deduct): Net Realized Investment Losses (Gains) ($52.5) $15.7 $72.0 Foreign Currency Exchange Losses

  67. Slide 67: Expense Ratio Reconciliation (2018)

    Expense Ratio Reconciliation (2018) Net Premiums Underwriting Corporate Amort. Of As Reported Adjusted Company Commentary Earned Expenses 1 Expenses Intangibles Expense Ratio Expense Ratio  Includes corporate expenses and $1,732 $655 NA NA 37.8% NA amort. of intangibles  Adjusts for corporate expe

  68. Slide 68: Notice to Recipient

    Notice to Recipient ABOUT ARGO GROUP INTERNATIONAL HOLDINGS, LTD. Argo Group International Holdings, Ltd. (NYSE: ARGO) is an international underwriter of specialty insurance and reinsurance products in the property and casualty market. Argo Group offers a full line of products and services designed

Argo Group International Holdings — Proxy Contest (May 2019) on 6ix