Buffalo Wild Wings — Proxy Contest (May 2017)
94 slides from Buffalo Wild Wings's proxy contest presentation, May 15, 2017
Slide 1: May 2017 Investor Presentation
MAY 2017 DRAFT PRESENTATION INVESTOR
Slide 2: Important Additional Information
2 IMPORTANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Cautionary Statement Regarding Certain Statements You are urged to exercise caution in considering any trends or guidance disclosed in this presentation. This presentation, as we ll as information contained in oral statements issued by or on behalf of our company c
Slide 3: The Ultimate Social Experience for Sports Fans and Communities
THE ULTIMATE SOCIAL EXPERIENCE FORSPORTS FANS «on COMMUNITIES
Slide 4: Superior Returns for BWLD Shareholders and Refreshed Board
4 SUPERIOR RETURNS FOR BWLD SHAREHOLDERS AND REFRESHED BOARD ENSURING CONTINUED OUTPERFORMANCE… 24% 19% 19% 16% 15% 15% 14% 13% 11% 11% 11% 1% (3%) (15%) Source: Company filings and FactSet. Note: Market data as of April 28, 2017 . 1. Represents annualized TSR since respective IPO for each company.
Slide 5: Marcato Nominee Email to Franchisees
5 THE MARCATO HEDGE FUND EFFORTS TO TAKE OVER THE [BWLD] BOARD AND UNSEAT ALL MANAGEMENT WILL BE SUCCESSFUL… HERE’S WHAT WILL CHANGE…MASSIVE G&A CUTS AND LAYOFFS… LET’S HOPE THE LIGHTS ARE LEFT ON . August 2016 email from Emil Lee Sanders, Marcato Nominee for BWLD Board, to BWLD franchisees to solic
Slide 6: Over 90% of Franchisees Support BWLD Board and Management
6 WE ARE LISTENING TO MARCATO, BUT JUST BECAUSE THEY ARE A FIVE PERCENT OWNER DOESN’T MEAN THEY KNOW… HOW TO ACHIEVE EVEN MORE SUCCESS…[THE FRANCHISEES THAT ALSO OWN STOCK] WILL VOTE IN SUPPORT OF OUR CURRENT BOARD MEMBERS AND…TEAM . – Wray Hutchinson , 45 - unit franchisee and Chairman of the indep
Slide 7: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS Outstanding Financial and Stock Performance 1 2 3 4 5 Unique Strategy Driven by Innovation, Differentiation and Discipline Tactical Responses to Current Environment Right Board with Strong Governance and Appropriate Leadership Incentives Marcato’s Unfounded Criticisms
Slide 8: Executive Summary
8 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1 • Buffalo Wild Wings (“BWLD”) has generated outstanding returns for investors - Annualized total shareholder return of 24% since 2003 IPO - Outperformed casual dining peers over last one, three, five and ten years 1 • Delivered superior operational and financial results over th
Slide 9: Executive Summary (Cont'd)
9 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY (CONT’D ) 4 • Three Directors added in October 2016; nominating two new Directors, including one originally nominated by Marcato • Four legacy Directors will have retired since the 2016 annual meeting, opening seats for fresh perspectives • Governance and executive compensation s
Slide 10: Outstanding Financial and Stock Performance
Outstanding Financial and Stock Performance
Slide 11: BWLD Overview
11 • Unique sports, social and entertainment focus, combined with craveable food • 1,250 restaurants with presence in all 50 states, Canada and five other countries - 51% company - owned - 49% franchised • Winner of dozens of “Best Wings” and “Best Sports Bar” awards - Top draft beer purveyor in the
Slide 12: Long-Term Operating Performance Has Been Outstanding
12 LONG - TERM OPERATING PERFORMANCE HAS BEEN OUTSTANDING 5 YEARS 10 YEARS Source: Company filings. Note: Reconciliations of non - GAAP financial measures can be found in the Appendix. BWLD performance is compared to the mean of the peer group over the periods noted. Data reflects performance over t
Slide 13: Superior Same-Store Sales Performance vs. Peers
13 SUPERIOR SAME - STORE SALES PERFORMANCE VS. PEERS (0.3%) 1.7% 0.9% 0.4% 1.9% (1.0%) (1.1%) 2.7% 6.5% 3.3% 5.6% 2.5% (2.7%) 0.6% 4.5% 6.6% 3.9% 6.5% 4.2% (2.4%) 0.5% Casual Dining Peers BWLD Franchised BWLD Company-owned FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2014 FY 2013 FY 2012 FY 2007 – FY 2011 Avg. Source: Compan
Slide 14: Driving Superior Financial Performance
14 8.6% 5.4% 5.5% 4.1% 18.7% 13.4% 10.5% 3.0% Ten-Year CAGR Five-Year CAGR Three-Year CAGR One-Year Casual Dining Peers 5.9% 3.7% 5.5% 1.4% 22.5% 19.1% 16.3% 9.5% Ten-Year CAGR Five-Year CAGR Three-Year CAGR One-Year ADJ. EBITDA COMPOUND ANNUAL GROWTH RATE EPS COMPOUND ANNUAL GROWTH RATE DRIVING SUP
Slide 15: Excellent Returns on Capital Well Above Cost of Capital
15 • 5 - year average ROIC of 16.5% and FY 2016 ROIC of 14.2%, both exceeding BWLD’s ~9.0% WACC • Average store - level ROIC is in excess of 25% • Management taking proactive steps to improve ROIC - Improving profitability through same - store sales initiatives, cost saving and portfolio rebalancing
Slide 16: Driving Superior Long-Term Returns
16 …DRIVING SUPERIOR LONG - TERM RETURNS 1754% 125% 213% BWLD Casual Dining Peers Russell 3000 1 Source: Company filings and FactSet. Note: Market data as of April 28, 2017. BWLD became publicly traded on November 21, 2003. Casual dining peers index represents median total shareholder return of the
Slide 17: Strong Short- and Medium-Term Returns
17 111.8% 107.3% 102.6% 93.9% 57.0% 51.5% 18.1% 6.3% (2.0%) (9.8%) (14.7%) (21.8%) (66.8%) (67.7%) (99.5%) 2.1% 18.1% Casual Dining Peers BWLD …AND STRONG SHORT - AND MEDIUM - TERM RETURNS Source: FactSet . Note: Market data as of April 28, 2017. Casual dining index calculated as the median of the p
Slide 18: Marcato Does Not Compare BWLD to the Right Peers
18 BWLD carefully evaluated the landscape of public U.S. restaurant companies and selected its peer set based on comparable operating models MARCATO DOES NOT COMPARE BWLD TO THE RIGHT SET OF CASUAL DINING PEERS 1. California Pizza Kitchen and PF Chang’s only used for TSR benchmarking over relevant t
Slide 19: Unique Strategy Driven by Innovation, Differentiation and Discipline
Unique Strategy Driven by Innovation, Differentiat ion and Discipline
Slide 20: Differentiated Strategy
20 DIFFERENTIATED STRATEGY R efine the BWLD experience to address changing consumer behavior Maximize restaurant - level performance and profitabili ty D isciplined unit growth domesticall y and internation ally Continuousl y evaluate our unit footprint and optimize our ownership mix Optimize our ca
Slide 21: Fueling the Sports Fan
21 FUELING THE SPORTS FAN • Craveable core menu featuring freshly spun, best - in - class wings, 21 signature sauces and seasonings, shareable appetizers and a broad lineup of domestic , imported and craft beers • Attractive food and beverage promotions • Dedicated focus on high food quality and saf
Slide 22: Unique Model and Innovation Success with Millennials
22 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% PERCENTAGE OF CUSTOMERS AGE 18 - 34 1 UNIQUE MODEL AND INNOVATION… • Focus on social interaction and sports • Unique Stadia design facilitates sports viewing • Trivia and tablets put our guests in the game • Shareable food makes dining more social • “Digital first” media st
Slide 23: Maximize Restaurant-Level Profitability
23 SALES - DRIVING INITIATIVES Initiatives designed to further improve the fan experience, respond to changing consumer needs, increase traffic and grow average check • Blazin ’ Rewards • Takeout optimization • 3 rd party delivery rollout • Wing Tuesdays/Boneless Thursdays/Happy Hour • Fast Break Lu
Slide 24: Disciplined Unit Growth Drives Value
24 THOROUGH PROCESS • Long - term market plans developed and updated annually (e.g., performance, cannibalization, demographics) • Dedicated teams screen and evaluate potential new locations • Financial forecast models take into account local demographics, cannibalization, costs, etc. • Robust legal
Slide 25: Evolving to Meet the Changing Industry: Takeout and Delivery
25 We believe delivery service is likely to prove to be one of the biggest disruptors of traditional Casual Dining across the Restaurant Industry, especially for more craveable , specialty providers who appear better poised to benefit versus more generic casual dining brands. As a "specialist" in wi
Slide 26: BWLD Has a Clear Technology Strategy
26 “B - DUBS ANYWHERE” • Digital innovation to enable “B - Dubs anywhere” ( i.e., online, mobile) • Applications to support delivery • Guest tablets and B - Dubs TV in - store BWLD HAS A CLEAR TECHNOLOGY STRATEGY AGILE AND SCALABLE • Tools to manage our workforce and allocate resources across stores
Slide 27: International Expansion Offers Low Capital Intensity Growth
27 INTERNATIONAL EXPANSION OFFERS LOW CAPITAL INTENSITY GROWTH TIER I: 50+ TIER II : 31 - 50 TIER III : 11 - 30 TIER IV : 1 - 10 CURRENT DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS Wild Foods S.A. de C.V. (Mexico) 7 Open (Middle East) 4 Open (Mexico) 10 Open • Signed Development Agreement: 7/12 • Opened first restaurant
Slide 28: Balanced Approach to Franchise Ownership
28 COMPANY - OWNED • Provides timely guest experience insight and ongoing feedback • Gives us “skin in the game,” while generating meaningful operating earnings • Enables us to validate material innovations (e.g., Stadia design) before asking our franchisees to implement them • Supports purchasing l
Slide 29: There Is Merit to Owning Units
29 THERE IS MERIT TO OWNING UNITS • Proven history as a successful operator • Increased rate of change in tastes and competitive landscape, requiring fast feedback loop and rapid adjustments • Operational knowledge in different market environments is critical to system - wide success - We lead by ex
Slide 30: Franchising Can Be Attractive in Certain Markets
30 …BUT FRANCHISING CAN BE ATTRACTIVE IN CERTAIN MARKETS RECENTLY ANNOUNCED REFRANCHISING • Evaluated store base to determine units that should be company - owned • Determined to refranchise approximately 13% of store base • Hired Cypress Group in March 2017 to begin marketing effort - Planning to g
Slide 31: Optimizing Our Capital Structure to Lower Our WACC
31 OPTIMIZING OUR CAPITAL STRUCTURE TO LOWER OUR WACC CURRENT TARGETS • Recently set leverage target at 1.5x net debt/EBITDA in August 2016 • Will achieve target leverage by YE 2017 0.2x 0.6x 1.5x FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 Target Net Cash 1. As of April 28, 2017. CONTINUOUS EVALUATION • Board
Slide 32: Sell-Side Analysts Have Confidence in Our Strategy
32 Management's willingness to explore incremental shifts in strategy (e.g. acknowledging the need for a modest amount of refranchising, but well short of what some of the bulls would like to see), reducing unit development and significantly upping share repurchases are all steps in the right direct
Slide 33: Tactical Responses to Current Environment
Tactical Responses to Current Environment
Slide 34: Casual Dining Sector Faces Macro Headwinds
34 CASUAL DINING SECTOR FACES MACRO HEADWINDS SECTOR COST HEADWINDS • Rising labor costs: - New wage laws - Healthcare - Scheduling mandates • New restaurant development pressures: - Development costs/construction expenses - Rent expenses 400 450 500 550 275 295 315 335 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Slide 35: BWLD Has Not Been Immune to These Trends and Costs
35 BWLD HAS NOT BEEN IMMUNE TO THESE TRENDS AND COSTS 17.0% 16.0% 17.2% 16.9% 18.4% 19.4% 18.6% 17.7% FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 Casual Dining Peers BWLD Source: Company filings . Note: Reconciliations of non - GAAP financial measures can be found in the Appendix . Periods reflect quarters and
Slide 36: Investment in Guest Experience Captain Adapted
36 • BWLD’s historical success has been supported by innovation — the Guest Experience Captain is just one example of that innovation • The role of the Guest Experience Captain was focused on continuously enhancing the fan experience and increasing community engagement, resulting in positive same -
Slide 37: BWLD's Actions Which Address Casual Dining Headwinds
37 BWLD’S ACTIONS WHICH ADDRESS CASUAL DINING HEADWINDS INDUSTRY SHIFT SELECTED INITIATIVES EXPECTED SAME - STORE SALES 1 2017 Target Q1 2017 Actual Consumers are increasingly eating at home Takeout 1.0% 1.5% Delivery 0.5% 0.5% Increasing promotional competition from QSR and fast casual players Sing
Slide 38: Bridge to 20% Restaurant-Level Margins
38 BRIDGE TO 20% RESTAURANT - LEVEL MARGINS 17.7% 2016 Margin COGS/Third Party Spend Labor Opex & Occupancy Portfolio Optimization Operating Leverage Industry Headwinds Q4 2018 Margin ~50 bps ~150 bps ~20 bps • Optimize food and beverage SKUs • Value engineering of packaging • Right size quantities/
Slide 39: Actions Recognized by Analysts and Franchisees
39 Collaborative initiatives between the Company and Franchisees around loyalty, order and pay at the table, merchant acquirer and EMV compliance, reduction of remodel costs, launch of a system - wide food safety program, food innovation, online ordering and delivery services are all examples of the
Slide 40: Right Board with Strong Governance and Appropriate Leadership Incentives
Right Board with Strong Governance and Appropriate Leadership Incentives
Slide 41: BWLD Board Nominees and Directors
41 Andre Fernandez (48) • President & CEO, CBS Radio • Former President & COO of Journal Communications Director since 2 016 Hal A. Lawton (42) • SVP of North America of eBay • Former SVP of Merchandising at Home Depot • Former Associate Principal at McKinsey & Co. Director since 2 016 Janice L. Fie
Slide 42: New Directors Provide Critical Skills
42 Cynthia Davis Consumer Marketing, Sports Entertainment Additio ns Retirem ents Andre Fernand ez Media Entertainment, Finance Hal Lawton Retail Operations, Consumer Marketing, Digital Harmit Singh Restaurant, Finance, Franchising, Real Estate Jan Fields (Nomine e ) Restaurant Operations, Franchisi
Slide 43: Nominees Have the Critical Skills Required
43 Board Member Public Company Restaura nt Operatio ns/ Food Retail Consumer Marketin g Sports + Entertai nment Financia l/ Capital Allocati on Franchis ing Internat ional Jerry Rose Chairman Director Since 2010 • • • Sally Smith Director Since 1996 • • • • • • • • Oliver Maggard Director Since 1999
Slide 44: Sustained Success Supported by a Board Expecting Continuous Improvement
44 SUSTAINED SUCCESS SUPPORTED BY A BOARD THAT EXPECTS CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENTS Rigorous Analysis Continuou s Improveme nt • Slowed NROs in 2016 in face of slowing casual dining segment and challenging sales and building environment • Refranchising 13% of store base after extensive analytical review
Slide 45: Executive Compensation Aligns Management and Shareholder Interests
45 • New Compensation Committee Chair • Made significant changes to executive compensation based on shareholder feedback - Short - term: added operating margin and consolidated top - line metrics to focus on same - store sales - Long - term: added ROIC as key metric to equity incentive plan • CEO’s
Slide 46: CEO and Board Ownership In-Line with Peers
46 BWLD’S CEO AND BOARD OWNERSHIP IS IN - LINE WITH CASUAL DINING PEERS MARKET VALUE OF NON - FOUNDER CEO OWNERSHIP 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 4.0x 3.0x $500K $225K NA NA NA REQUIRED STOCK OWNERSHIP BY DIRECTORS 1 Source: Company filings and FactSet. Note: Market data as of April 28, 20
Slide 47: Strong Governance Best Practices
47 Annual election of all Directors Separate Chairman and CEO roles since 1996 Recent rotation of Chairman and all Committee Chairs Right to call special meeting with 10% ownership threshold Directors can be removed with or without cause Governance Committee engaged national recruiter to identify sk
Slide 48: Marcato's Unfounded Criticisms
Marcato’s Unfounded Criticisms
Slide 49: BWLD Has Engaged with Marcato
49 We have been invested in the stock for over a year at this point. We’ve been involved in very active conversations with the Board and the management team throughout that entire period of time . – Mick McGuire (April 2017, CNBC interview) DESPITE MARCATO’S INCONSISTENT CLAIMS, BWLD HAS ENGAGED WIT
Slide 50: BWLD Has Engaged with Marcato and Evaluated Its Critiques
50 ENGAGEMENT • More than 20 phone and in - person meetings between Marcato and management or Board members over the last year • Reviewed and considered five detailed presentations and three letters from Marcato • Hired financial advisor to evaluate a wide range of franchise ownership models and to
Slide 51: Marcato Suggestions Implemented
51 Reinvigorate core business (e.g., improve same - store sales, rationalize costs, international expansion) • Same - store sales initiatives implemented to re - accelerate restaurant traffic • Cost saving initiatives underway to reach 20% restaurant - level margins Establish capital allocation stra
Slide 52: Restaurant-Level Margins Outperform Peers
52 • Consistent outperformance against peers at restaurant - level margin line • Despite same - store sale pressures in 2016, margin remained above peers • Some variability is inevitable: operating leverage, commodity and labor costs, training and new initiatives, etc. • Initiatives in place to achi
Slide 53: Restaurant-Level Margins vs. Franchisees
53 RESTAURANT - LEVEL MARGINS ARE IN - LINE OR SUPERIOR TO MANY FRANCHISEES 1. Two stores have margins below (15.0%). RESTAURANT - LEVEL MARGINS BY COMPANY - OWNED STORE CASE STUDY: WHEN REGIONAL VARIATIONS ARE ELIMINATED…OUR MARGINS ARE OFTEN SUPERIOR OR IN - LINE VARIATIONS DRIVEN BY : • Regional
Slide 54: BWLD vs. SAUC Pricing Differential
54 BWLD VS. SAUC 1 HIGHLIGHTS PRICING DIFFERENTIAL 1. Ticker symbol for Diversified Restaurant Holdings, BWLD’s largest franchisee. FY 2016 RESTAURANT - LEVEL MARGIN [VALUE] 24.3% BWLD Pricing Sales Mix Labor SAUC FY ended Dec 25, 2016 BWLD Company - owned SAUC Restaurants 621 64 AUVs $3.1 million $
Slide 55: International Franchising Supports Long-Term Growth
55 GROWTH CHALLENGES EXPERIENCED IN INITIAL MARKETS • Length of time to obtain building permits • Unpredictability of local officials to complete required inspections • Intermittent work stoppages due to unpredictable design requirement changes of municipalities • Limited availability of local, reli
Slide 56: BWLD Has Been a Disciplined Buyer
56 BWLD HAS BEEN A DISCIPLINED BUYER • ROFR in franchisee agreements enables BWLD to opportunistically pursue acquisitions of successful, established franchised restaurants • Purchases of established restaurants have been accretive to shareholder value - Attractive risk/reward of buying established
Slide 57: Analysts Agreed with Value in 2015 Acquisitions
57 ANALYST COMMUNITY AGREED WITH VALUE IN THE 2015 ACQUISITIONS While it ultimately depends on the performance of the acquired stores, we applaud this acquisition as it adds to earnings growth at what we estimate to be a reasonable price . – Sterne Agee (June 2015) We think this acquisition adds sig
Slide 58: Marcato's 90% Franchise Model Is Unprecedented and Unproven
58 % FRANCHISED — FY 2016 FRANCHISE MIX 1 • No casual dining company has ever moved from a ~50% franchise mix to a ~90% mix in less than four years • Only three casual dining concepts 1 , Applebee’s, IHOP and Denny’s, have over 50% franchise mix - IHOP and Denny’s are “family dining” concepts withou
Slide 59: Casual Dining Restaurants and QSRs Are Different
59 • Marcato continues to erroneously reference the successful refranchising of certain QSR concepts in order to support its case for a large - scale refranchising • Operations of QSR are more formulaic and QSRs are therefore easier to refranchise • Casual dining is particularly unsuited for franchi
Slide 60: Marcato's Status Quo Comparison Is Obsolete
60 MARCATO’S COMPARISON TO BWLD’S “STATUS QUO” IS OBSOLETE AND MISLEADING Marcato clearly omits well - known initiatives implemented by BWLD since June 2016 from its purported “Status Quo” CRITICAL MISSING PIECES • Acceleration of share repurchase program • Cost savings initiatives • 1.5x net levera
Slide 61: Marcato's Case Based on Flawed Assumptions
61 MARCATO’S CASE FOR A 90% FRANCHISE MODEL IS BASED ON FLAWED ASSUMPTIONS BWLD can sell more than 500 stores by 2020 for 6x EBITDA BWLD can repurchase shares for 8x - 9x EBITDA through 2020, before suddenly re - rating to 13x EBITDA BWLD will trade at 13x after refranchising, a higher multiple than
Slide 62: Marcato's Projected Share Repurchase Prices
62 MARCATO’S PROJECTED SHARE REPURCHASE PRICES • For purposes of its buyback math, Marcato assumes the stock appreciates at 15% per year - Implies an 8 - 9x EV/EBITDA multiple • The share price suddenly re - rates to 13x at the end of the projection period, resulting in a ~$400 share price MARCATO’S
Slide 63: Marcato Nominee Views on Refranchising Market Appetite
63 THE MARCATO HEDGE FUND EFFORTS TO TAKE OVER THE BOARD AND UNSEAT ALL MANAGEMENT WILL BE SUCCESSFUL…90 % PLUS OF THE 610 COMPANY UNITS WILL BE REFRANCHISED…IT WILL NOT BE AN AUCTION OR FIRE SALE, BUT WILL CLEARLY REDUCE THE VALUE OF YOUR ASSET DURING THIS PERIOD. TOO MUCH AVAILABLE PRODUCT IN THE
Slide 64: Marcato Disregards Operating Models
64 MARCATO IS DISREGARDING OPERATING MODELS TO DRIVE MISGUIDED CONCLUSIONS • Valuation multiples correspond to divergent operating models (e.g., QSR, fast casual and casual dining) • Denny’s and DineEquity are examples of highly franchised models with multiples in line with casual dining players • N
Slide 65: Marcato Repeating Same Tactic Applied at Applebee's
65 MARCATO IS REPEATING THE SAME FLAWED TACTIC APPLIED AT APPLEBEE’S 30 50 70 90 110 130 $150 Sep 2011 Nov 2012 Dec 2013 Feb 2015 Mar 2016 Apr 2017 DIN BWLD Source: Company filings and FactSet. Note: Market data as of April 28, 2017. 1. Per Marcato 13D filing from December 19, 2012. TSR from filing
Slide 66: Marcato's Slate Would Remove Institutional Knowledge
66 MARCATO’S PROPOSED SLATE WOULD REMOVE ALL INSTITUTIONAL KNOWLEDG E FROM BWLD BOARD AVERAGE TENURE IF SHAREHOLDERS SUPPORT MANAGEMENT’S SLATE 1 AVERAGE TENURE IF SHAREHOLDERS SUPPORT MARCATO’S SLATE 1 Source: Company filings. 1. As of June 2017, in years. 2. Pro forma for 2017 management nominees.
Slide 67: Governance Committee Evaluation of Marcato's Directors
67 O ur Governance Committee, chaired by a new Director, evaluated Marcato’s proposed Directors Scott Bergren Former Yum! Brands Executive • Incumbent Director Harmit Singh was senior executive at Pizza Hut/Yum!; no need to add another Director with background from same organization • Experience is
Slide 68: McGuire Has a Track Record of Losses in the Boardroom
68 0 5 10 15 20 25 $30 Jan 2006 Mar 2007 May 2008 Aug 2009 Oct 2010 Dec 2011 Borders MCGUIRE HAS A TRACK RECORD OF LOSSES IN THE BOARDROOM BORDERS INVESTMENT THESIS BORDERS SHARE PRICE DURING MCGUIRE’S INVOLVEMENT McGuire’s fund takes 11% stake in Borders Group Inc. McGuire Joins Board Borders appoi
Slide 69: McGuire Has No Track Record of Success in a Boardroom
69 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 $50 Nov 2014 May 2015 Nov 2015 May 2016 Oct 2016 Apr 2017 MCGUIRE HAS NO TRACK RECORD OF SUCCESS IN A BOARDROOM MCGUIRE DID NOT CREATE ANY VALUE WHILE AT NCR McGuire joins NCR’s Board in November 2014 NCR announces a strategic partnership with Blackstone McGuire resigns
Slide 70: Emil Lee Sanders's Biography
70 EMIL LEE SANDERS’S BIOGRAPHY “Earlier in his career from August 2001 through April 2007, Mr. Sanders served as Senior Vice President of Development and Franchising for Buffalo Wild Wings. In this role, he successfully planned and led the national rollout and opening of 486 units within seven year
Slide 71: Emil Lee Sanders Lacks Judgment and Is Conflicted
71 My name is Lee Sanders… I am quite excited to write you about a new venture I am working on with Gemspring Capital. We are partnering to acquire quality, successful and sustainable Buffalo Wild Wings franchise networks . – Emil Lee Sanders, Marcato Board Nominee ( Letter to a BWLD franchisee date
Slide 72: Did Scott Bergren's Leadership Hold Back Pizza Hut?
72 20 60 100 140 180 $220 Dec 2010 Dec 2011 Dec 2012 Dec 2013 Dec 2014 YUM! Papa John's DID SCOTT BERGREN’S LEADERSHIP HOLD BACK PIZZA HUT? Bergren promoted to CEO of Pizza Hut U.S. Bergren promoted to Pizza Hut Global CEO Bergren retires from position as Pizza Hut Global CEO Papa John’s 303% Domino
Slide 73: Sell-Side Analysts Skeptical of Marcato's Plan
73 What looks good on paper is not necessarily achievable in reality. The fact that we have not seen as many significant refranchising efforts in casual dining probably also tells us something about the willingness of buyers… Refranchising, especially on a deadline, also brings with it operational a
Slide 74: BWLD Is on the Right Track
74 BUFFALO WILD WINGS IS ON THE RIGHT TRACK . WHETHER IT’S ANNUAL SAME - STORE SALES, AVERAGE CUSTOMER CHECK, UNIT GROWTH AND VOLUME – OR THE ALL - IMPORTANT POPULARITY WITH AND SPENDING BY THE MOST POPULOUS GENERATIONAL SEGMENT, MILLENNIALS – WE THINK BUFFALO WILD WINGS’ RECIPE FOR SUCCESS IS NOT O
Slide 75: Vote for BWLD's Nominees on the Yellow Card
VOTE FOR BWLD’S NOMINEES ON THE YELLOW CARD
Slide 76: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 77: Non-GAAP Reconciliations
Non - GAAP Reconciliati ons
Slide 78: Restaurant-Level Profit and Margin
78 Restaurant - level profit and restaurant - level margin are neither required by, nor presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP and are non - GAAP financial measures. Restaurant - level profit is defined restaurant sales less restaurant operating costs (cost of sales, labor, operating, and occupancy
Slide 79: EBITDA
79 Earnings before interest, taxes, and depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) is not required by, nor presented in accordance w ith U.S. GAAP and is a non - GAAP financial measure. The Company defines EBITDA as net earnings including non - controlling interests plus interest expense, income tax exp
Slide 80: Adjusted EBITDA
80 Adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, and depreciation and amortization (Adjusted EBITDA) is not required by, nor present ed in accordance with U.S. GAAP and is a non - GAAP financial measure. The Company defines Adjusted EBITDA as income from operations plus depreciation and amortization, lo
Slide 81: Return on Invested Capital (ROIC)
81 Return on invested capital (ROIC) is neither required by, nor presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP and is a non - GAAP financial measure. ROIC is defined as adjusted earnings after income taxes divided by average total capital. Adjusted earnings is calculated by adding loss on asset disposals a
Slide 82: Store-Level Operating ROIC
82 Store - level operating return on invested capital (store - level operating ROIC) is neither required by, nor presented in accordanc e with U.S. GAAP and is a non - GAAP financial measure. Store - level operating ROIC is defined as adjusted store - level earnings after income taxes divided by ave
Slide 83: BWLD Director and Nominee Biographies
BWLD Director and Nominee Biographies
Slide 84: BWLD Director and Nominee Biographies
84 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES Jerry R. Rose Director Since: 2010 Age: 66 Board Roles : Chairman of the Board Career Highlights and Experience: Mr . Rose served as Corporate Vice President of Cargill, Inc. from 2004 to September 2012. Mr. Rose began his career at Cargill as a Financial Man
Slide 85: BWLD Director and Nominee Biographies (Cont'd)
85 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES (CONT’D) Career Highlights and Experience: Ms. Smith has served as our Chief Executive Officer and President since July 1996. She served as our Chief Financial Officer fro m 1994 to 1996. Prior to joining Buffalo Wild Wings, she was the Chief Financial Office
Slide 86: J. Oliver Maggard Biography
86 J. Oliver Maggard Director Since: 1999 Age: 62 Board Roles: Audit Committee BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES (CONT’D) Career Highlights and Experience: Mr. Maggard has served as Managing Partner of Caymus Partners LLC, an investment banking firm, since October 2002, and as a Managing Partner
Slide 87: Cynthia L. Davis Biography
87 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES ( CONT’D ) Cynthia L. Davis Director Since: 2014 Age: 55 Board Roles: Compensation Committee Chair Governance Committee Career Highlights and Experience: Ms . Davis served as an executive at Nike for 10 years, most recently as Vice President of Nike Inc. and
Slide 88: Andre J. Fernandez Biography
88 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES ( CONT’D ) Andre J. Fernandez Director Since: 2016 Age: 48 Board Roles: Governance Committee Chair Audit Committee Career Highlights and Experience: Mr . Fernandez is the President and Chief Executive Officer of CBS RADIO. In this role, Mr. Fernandez is respo
Slide 89: Harry A. Lawton Biography
89 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES ( CONT’D ) Harry A. Lawton Director Since: 2016 Age: 42 Board Roles: Compensation Committee Career Highlights and Experience: Mr . Lawton has served as Senior Vice President of North America at eBay, Inc. since May 2015. At eBay, Mr. Lawton’s responsibil iti
Slide 90: Harmit J. Singh Biography
90 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES ( CONT’D ) Harmit J. Singh Director Since: 2016 Age: 54 Board Roles: Audit Committee Chair Career Highlights and Experience: Mr . Singh has served as Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Levi Strauss & Co. since January 2013. He is re spo n
Slide 91: Sam B. Rovit Biography
91 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES ( CONT’D ) Sam B. Rovit Nominated for Election Age: 59 Career Highlights and Experience: Since October 2015, Mr. Rovit has served as President and Chief Executive Officer of CTI Foods, a leading provider of custom food s olu tions to major chain restaurants a
Slide 92: Janice L. Fields Biography
92 BWLD DIRECTOR AND NOMINEE BIOGRAPHIES ( CONT’D ) Janice L. Fields Nominated for Election Age: 61 Career Highlights and Experience: Ms . Fields served as President of McDonald’s USA, LLC, a subsidiary of McDonald’s Corporation, a fast food chain operator and f ran chiser, from January 2010 until h
Slide 93: Questions: Contact the Proxy Solicitor
©0 0 If you have any questions or require any assistance with voting your shares, please contact the Company’s proxy solicitor listed below: MICKENRE 105 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 Call Collect: 212.929.5500 or Toll-Free: 800.322.2885 Email: [email protected]
Slide 94: Buffalo Wild Wings
BUFFALO WILD WINGS