ALTERRA CAPITAL HOLDINGS Ltd

ALTERRA CAPITAL — Merger or Acquisition (December 2012)

16 slides from ALTERRA CAPITAL's merger presentation, Dec 19, 2012

  1. Slide 1: Markel Acquisition of Alterra

    Markel Acquisition of Alterra A new leader in global specialty insurance and investments December 19, 2012

  2. Slide 2: Information concerning forward-looking statements

    Information concerning forward-looking statements: This document includes statements about future economic performance, finances, expectations, plans and prospects of Alterra and Markel, both individually and on a combined basis, that are forward-looking statements for purposes of the safe harbor pr

  3. Slide 3: Key Transaction Terms

    Key Transaction Terms Transaction Merger under Bermuda law. A subsidiary of Markel will merge into Alterra, with Alterra surviving as a wholly- owned subsidiary of Markel Taxable transaction to Alterra shareholders Consideration Implied offer price of ~$31 per Alterra share (1) $10 in cash per Alter

  4. Slide 4: Creating a Winning Combination

    Creating a Winning Combination Combination of Markel and Alterra… Strategic Increases diversification and creates a global franchise with attractive product depth and reach A common culture of underwriting discipline Creates additional size and scale, providing additional insurance and investment op

  5. Slide 5: Markel – Company Profile

    Markel – Company Profile Company overview Markel Corporation is a diverse financial holding company serving a variety of niche markets In each of its businesses, Markel seeks to provide quality products and excellent customer service with the objective of being the market leader Markel’s financial g

  6. Slide 6: Markel – Long History of Producing Results

    Markel – Long History of Producing Results By applying its long-term focus to underwriting and investing activities, Markel achieved consistent, sustainable value creation for its shareholders $500 $1,200 Portfolio Per Share Book Value Per Share CAGR 13% CAGR 17% $1,000 $400 $800 $300 $600 $200 $400

  7. Slide 7: Markel – Strong Underwriting and Investment Performance

    Markel – Strong Underwriting and Investment Performance 125% Combined ratio trend Average difference favorable / (unfavorable) 120% Underwriting Since 1992 4.8% 115% performance 110% Since 2002 3.9% 105% Consistently 100% outperforms the P&C 95% industry combined 90% ratio 85% Markel P&C Avg. (1) 80

  8. Slide 8: Alterra – Company Profile

    Alterra – Company Profile Key highlights Premium summary 1 Global underwriter of specialty insurance and reinsurance Q3 YTD 2012 GPW: ~$1.6bn – Multiple operating platforms - Bermuda, Ireland, Europe, United States, Lloyd's and Latin America By Segment – Strong franchise positions across multiple sp

  9. Slide 9: A Strong Platform for Growth

    A Strong Platform for Growth Combination expands Markel’s insurance platform from three to five key segments Enhances Markel’s E&S, Specialty and London Insurance Market segments 2012E Gross Premiums Written ($ in millions) Pro Forma Excess & Surplus $935 $230 $1,165 Specialty Admitted 655 155 810 L

  10. Slide 10: Well Positioned Operating Profile

    Well Positioned Operating Profile Scale and diversification will create the opportunity to improve the already strong operating performance Year-to-date 9/30/12 ($ in millions, except per share) Pro Forma (3) Gross premiums written $1,906 $1,614 $3,520 Net premiums written 1,687 1,077 2,764 Combined

  11. Slide 11: Strong Capitalization Ratios

    Strong Capitalization Ratios As of 9/30/12 ($ in millions) Pro Forma (1) Total debt $1,511 $441 $1,951 Total shareholders’ equity 3,806 2,923 5,952 (2) Total capitalization 5,317 3,364 7,903 Total debt / total capitalization 28% 13% 25% LTM net premiums written / equity 0.57x 0.44x 0.58x Source: Com

  12. Slide 12: Diversified Premium Mix

    Diversified Premium Mix Fiscal year 2011 ($ in millions) Pro Forma Gross premiums written $2.3bn $1.9bn $4.2bn Other Other Other Property 16% Property 25% Workers 21% Property Workers 19% Workers 35% 29% Line of Comp 10% Comp Comp 6% business 23% 20% 26% 23% Prof / Prod Prof / Prod 22% 22% General L

  13. Slide 13: Underwriting with Global Reach

    Underwriting with Global Reach A combined underwriting platform with the breadth and scope necessary to compete globally Employees: 2,666 Employees: 490 GWP / Headcount: $0.9M GWP / Headcount: $3.9M (1) # of Offices: 37 # of Offices: 31 Headquarters Markel Headquarters Alterra Glen Allen, VA Hamilto

  14. Slide 14: High Quality Investment Portfolio

    High Quality Investment Portfolio As of 9/30/12 Cash & ST $1,564 Equities $2,341 Pro Forma 9/30/12 17% 25% Other 62% of Cash & ST(3) $377 shareholders Equities equity $1,216 $2,341 2% Fixed 7% 14% 57% 39% of pro $5,281 forma shareholders equity Total Portfolio of $9.2bn (1) Investments per Markel sh

  15. Slide 15: A Winning Combination

    A Winning Combination Leading franchise in global specialty insurance and investments Disciplined underwriting combined with successful investing Cultural fit dedicated to underwriting excellence Successful track record of managing investments on total return basis Diversified portfolio of business

  16. Slide 16: Additional information about the proposed merger and where to find it

    Additional information about the proposed merger and where to find it: This document relates to a proposed transaction between Markel and Alterra that will become the subject of a registration statement, which will include a joint proxy statement/prospectus, to be filed by Markel with the SEC. This

Alterra Capital Holdings — Merger or Acquisition (December 2012) on 6ix