Benihana — Proxy Contest (August 2011)
11 slides from Benihana's proxy contest presentation, Aug 17, 2011
Slide 1: Confidential Presentation
Confidential Presentation: Strictly Confidential
Slide 2: Background of the Proposed Reclassification
Background of the Proposed Reclassification The proposed Reclassification is another example of the influence that Benihana‘s sole preferred stockholder, BFC, continuesto exertat the Board level at the expense of non-preferred stockholders 1 Benihana of Tokyo, Ine. Class A Commonstod (“BOT is seekin
Slide 3: False Rationale for the Proposed Reclassification
False Rationale for the Proposed Reclassification The Board's stated reasons for adopting the Reclassification are false and misleading Board Rationale: G Combining the Common and Class A stock will result in improved liquidity and tradingefficiencies. Reality: Gi Benihana’s Common stockis closely h
Slide 4: Insiders' Motivation for the Reclassification
Insiders’ Motivation for the Reclassification O BOT agrees with Institutional Shareholder Services that dual class stock structures are normally etockholder unfriendly. a O The BFC controlled Series B Preferred shares have extens Insiders on the “Executive Comnamittes” have the meet to benefit from
Slide 5: A Disturbing Pattern of Manipulation and Self Dealing
A Disturbing Pattern of Manipulation and Self Dealing January 2010 Boat sought approval for 12,000,000 additional Class A shares that would effectively give the Company the ability to conduct ahighly dlutive issuance to all stockholders except for BFC. ‘When it appeared that the issuance would not r
Slide 6: A Disturbing Pattern of Manipulation and Self Dealing
A Disturbing Pattern of Manipulation and Self Dealing Board has conspiredto manipulate the vote by adjusting the record date whenit benefits Insiders Cl With the Reclassification vote scheduled for September 2013, BRC recently converted part of its Seriee B preferred into Common stock and Coliseum C
Slide 7: BFC's Track Record in Similar Investment Scenarios
BFC’s Track Record in Similar Investment Scenarios Gi Itappears tous that BFC’s modus operandi, onceit identifies a target, isto: (obtain a significant ownership position; (2)condueta highly dilutive rights offering to further increase its position; and (a)complete its assertion of control. G BOT be
Slide 8: BFC's Track Record of Destroying Stockholder Value
BFC’s Track Record of Destroying Stockholder Value Do notlet Benihana becomethe next BFC, Bluegreen or BankAtlantic! 40.00% BFC Portfolio Companies’ Relative Price Performance 20.00% dune 22,2006 to August 9, 2011 0.00% 20.00% 40.00% 60.00% Jute Sep- Now Feb- Apr Jub Sep Nor Feb- Apt Juk Sep- Dec Fe
Slide 9: Worst 5-Year Stock Return of the Relevant Peer Group
Worst 5-Year Stock Return of the Relevant Peer Group Benihana has systematically underperformedits relevant casual dining peers under BFC’s watch Multi-concept Casual Dining Operators '5.Year Relative Stock Price Performance August 12,2006 to August 11,2011 100.00% 20.00% e00% an.00% 20.00% 00% 2.00
Slide 10: Worst 5-Year Stock Return of the Relevant Peer Group
Worst 5-Year Stock Return of the Relevant Peer Group Benihana has systematically underperformedits relevant casual dining peers under BFC’s watch Benihana vs Casual Dining Index 5:Year Relative Stock Price Performance August 12,2006 to August 11,2011 100 00% 80.00% 60.00% 40.0% 70.00% 0.00% 200% 40.
Slide 11: Lack of Board Level Independence
Lack of Board Level Independence The Board conducteda flawed process in consideringand approvingthe Reclassification © BOT believes at least five of the ton Board members have interests in the Reclassification that significantly diverge from the best interests of the unaffiliated Common stockholders