Rand Logistics Inc

Rand Logistics — Proxy Contest (September 2014)

56 slides from Rand Logistics's proxy contest presentation, Sep 4, 2014

  1. Slide 1: Schedule 14A - Rand Logistics, Inc.

    United States Securities and Exchange Commission Washington, DC 20549 Schedule 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a Party other than th

  2. Slide 2: Filing fee offset information

    ¨ Check box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Exchange Act Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing for which the offsetting fee was paid previously. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing. (1) Amount Previously

  3. Slide 3: RLOG: A Crisis of Confidence

    RLOG: JWEST,ALLC crisis of confidence

  4. Slide 4: Rand Logistics company description

    RAND LOGISTICS, INC. “Rand Logistics, Inc. is a leading provider of bulk freight shipping services throughout the Great Lakes region. The Company is the only carrier able to offer significant domestic port-to-port services in both Canada and the U.S. on the Great Lakes.” Sources: -Quote and slide im

  5. Slide 5: Disclaimer

    FUND THESE Disclaimer AFFILIATES. AND MATERIALS ANSUCH INVESTOR. AN SHALL OFFER NOT TOeconomic CONSTITUTE SELL OR SOLICITATION AN OFFER TO OF SELL AN OFFER OR THETO SOLICITATION BUY INTERESTS OF MAY AN OFFER ONLY TO BEonly BUY MADE ANYPURSUANT INTERESTS of TO IN DEFINITIVE ANYinvestment isFUND SUBSC

  6. Slide 6: Why JWEST has been invested in Rand

    ••WhyHigh is JWEST Very Unique High Should Belief JWEST, barriers little • Backwards fixed LLC have that invested to business direct asset cost RLOG entry to strong in RLOG competition portfolio way play stock? infrom the the improving incremental will benefit river class market aggregates margins c

  7. Slide 7: Underperformance despite little direct competition

    Underperformance oligopoly? JWEST, LLCYou can’t inbe anserious Despite RLOG being set up to succeed in a market with very little direct competition, the Company has consistently fallen short of management’s expectations.

  8. Slide 8: How did we get here?

    •HowLack did we focus get here? of leadership JWEST,LLC As will be demonstrated throughout this presentation, we believe RLOG has suffered from a lack of focused and accountable leadership which contributed to missed projections. Sources: -Image obtained from http://foreverfail.com/clearly-i-have-ma

  9. Slide 9: Delusions of grandeur

    Delusions “Over and -increased JWEST,LLC Laurence bythe better customer next of Levy, grandeur aligning 24Executive months, demand our assets we Chairman, reinforces remain to thehighly our trade 8-15-11 confidence patterns confident (Q1 2012 that inthat the they Earnings we positive are willbest Ca

  10. Slide 10: Sounds promising, but words are just words

    Sounds Tell JWEST,LLC me promising… more Sounds promising, but words are just that.... Words.

  11. Slide 11: Stock performance versus Russell 3000 index

    Stock19, Aug INDEXRUS 60% RLOG-12.73% 2012 JWEST,LLC 40% 2013 Price 2011 20% 2014 –SELL:RUA RLOG – 0% Jul -20% 31, vs2014 RUA -40% +64.43% Index How did the stock perform subsequent to Laurence’s quote? As you can see from the graph (RLOG in blue and the Russell 3000 Index in orange), RLOG was not e

  12. Slide 12: Total shareholder returns versus peers and indices

    Total Shareholder 1-Year RLOG KEX AGMJF RUA JWEST,LLC 37.89% Index 3-Year 21.51% 18.01% 16.35% 99.69% 5-Year (18.77)% 62.82% Returns 58.40% 214.67% 276.75% 125.93% 119.87% RLOG has under-performed for shareholders compared to relevant peers and indices. Note that the 5 year returns include a substan

  13. Slide 13: Management confident on pricing forecasts

    •Pricing—forecasts 8-15-11 through 2-10-12 2-7-13 existing JWEST, contractual (Q1 formalizing (Q3 (Q3 LLC 2012 on contract 2013 Earnings andprice certain Earnings increases…” Call) contracts renewals.” Call) ––“Pricing Call)– as “… over “…we well innext asthink we24 efficiency this months may gains

  14. Slide 14: Operating leverage claims versus actual results

    RLOG’s •Where JWEST, 35,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 15,000 -F 5,0002-10-2012 kind 10,000 Y 2012is Actual of theupward 28,922 pricing (Q3 Results: Revenue/Day 11,828 LLC FY 2013 10,6972012 leverage 30,035 FYleverage? Earnings 10,712 2014 30,760 that we Call) Vessel can–get “Soinroughly Margin/Day our bu

  15. Slide 15: Management over-promised and under-delivered on pricing

    Pricing 6-12-14 Ed JWEST, Levy–(Q4 LLC -actual “We 2014 haven’t Earnings seenCall) price–increases yet” Management over-promised and under-delivered on pricing.

  16. Slide 16: Mechanical incidents and maintenance claims

    •Mechanical 6-16-2010 that’s we significant have inherent Incidents SENSE-O-METER JWEST, LLC better (Q4 amount in luck 2010 theof intrading Earnings time that regard inpatterns the Call) month so–far that “…from to ofwe this May, trade date. anlate operating in,Now, April/May we trade westandpoint,

  17. Slide 17: Mechanical incidents history

    •Mechanical 11-10-2010 with JWEST, ourpreviously 2-14-2011 that, exceeded as LLCIncidents historic (Q2 our (Q3 2011 experiences.” historic 2011 Earnings stated, Earnings experienceCall) and –can management “While Call)—“During regards we be grouped the cannotsixeliminate as non-recurring. first into

  18. Slide 18: Problem solved, says management

    Don’t worry, PROBLEM JWEST, LLCSOLVED management says it’s under control Great, sounds like management has these past mechanical incidents under control. Sources: -Image obtained from http://m.crazyhyena.com

  19. Slide 19: Lost sailing days

    140 Lost 77 100 120 123 83 80 61 60 Sailing Days 40 20 0FY 2011 LLC JWEST, FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 If you recall, the quotes from management on having addressed the problem of mechanical incidents came from FYE 2010 and 2011. So let’s look at what happened in the years following those quotes.... The

  20. Slide 20: Lack of oversight by the board

    •Mechanical 11-8-2012 weakness maintenance JWEST, LLC Incidents was (Q2 procedures more 2013in Earnings the that lack were Call) of oversight ongoing – “Not on so – that much board was inefficiency inone thatof vessel” the in vessels getting that it back was newly into service, acquired a lot within

  21. Slide 21: Free cash flow forecasts

    ••Free11-10-2010 Cash Flow 2-14-2011 benefits 6-29-2011 8-15-2011 and JWEST, $36 LLC to -(Q2 (Q3 be (Q4forecasts million, (Q1 2011 derived 2011 Earnings from and Earnings 2012 that free Call) thecash newly Call) ––“Both flow“..we “Based acquired “…we are the per common are reaffirming onvessels.” cu

  22. Slide 22: Free cash flow per share under-delivered

    $Actual $0.40 $0.80 $1.20 ($0.40) $0.00 ($1.20) ($0.80) ($0.09 0.23) 0.53) JWEST, FY Free 2011 FYCash LLC 2012Flow 1.04) per share FY 2013 –Show me the money! FY 2014 Management over-promised and under-delivered on free cash flow per share. Sources: -Actual free cash flow obtained from Bloomberg Fin

  23. Slide 23: Management's preferred dividend forecasts

    •Management’s 6-29-2011 potentially 6-8-2012 refinance the stock JWEST, LLC (Q4 Preferred tomillion.” elimination of $15 (Q4 the buy 2011 of backDividends Earnings some$11.5 approximately 2012 the Earnings annual common Call) forecasts ––“One dividend Call) “We stock.” million on also the of ourdoke

  24. Slide 24: Preferred dividends on hold

    Preferred Dividends — on hold JWEST,LLC Instead, management opted to defer paying down a portion of the accrued preferred dividends for several years. Sources: -Image obtained from http://dobrador.com/procrastination-workshop/

  25. Slide 25: Cost of procrastination: interest expense

    ••The Interest Price ––of2.4 2011 2012 2013 2014 JWEST, 11.8 2-6-2014 expense Procrastination 2.8 3.2 3.4 •—————————————- Total collaboration LLC on preferred dividends: Million Million Million (Q3 and 2014theEarnings directionCall) that –these “Finally, discussions we continue are advancing.” to be

  26. Slide 26: Accrued preferred dividends paid

    EXTRA “As JWEST, of March EXTRA! LLC 31, 2014, READthe ALL Company ABOUT has IT!fully paid all accrued dividends on its preferred stock.” Finally! Looks like this is a step in the right direction..... Where did RLOG get the money? Sources: -Quote was taken from the 2014 10-K filed June 12, 2014 -Ima

  27. Slide 27: More debt to pay accrued dividends

    •Where More Too Completed JWEST,did much debt LLCRLOG debt? will a $212.5M fix get the cash? that! financing comprised of a $140.0M senior secured credit facility and a $72.5M second lien facility to refinance its existing senior secured debt and accrued preferred dividends – 3-13-2014 Management to

  28. Slide 28: Debt snapshot

    Debt March b) c) 63,325 55,246 quarterly 2under — RLOG JWEST, 8,572 Black U.S. snapshot Fourth 31, consolidated term LLC Creek payments 2014 loan Amended U.S. March bearing ofterm twoUS 31, and loans loan interest $138 $181 2013 Restated bearing during commencing at LIBOR Credit FY interest 2014 Agr

  29. Slide 29: Sounds great, but let's take a closer look

    Sounds great, JWEST, LLC but let’s take a closer look Sources: -Image obtained from http://slaan.ru/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=130&Itemid=267

  30. Slide 30: Higher-rate Guggenheim debt to pay off $40M

    Wait a) $upon b) $— March $38,300 $72,500 Turns JWEST, 34,200 U.S. amaturity out minute… 31, 11, Dollar $— LLCthat 2020. 2014RLOG denominated onMarch March took 31, 11,out 2013 term 2020. additional Loan loan (Second (Second debt with Lien LienGuggenheim U.S. CDNterm Term Loan) Loan) at a higher bea

  31. Slide 31: 10% debt to pay down 5% debt

    So RLOG I’m JWEST,LLC confused used here… 10% debt to pay down 5% debt? Doesn’t make much sense, does it? Sources: -Note: Interest rate percentages are rounded percentages. Actual percentages obtained from the 2014 10-K were within 100 basis points.

  32. Slide 32: More debt?

    Moreare “We LAND JWEST,LLC debt? OF comfortable MAKE BELIEVE with our debt NEXT levels, RIGHT and you know, so are our lenders.” - Laurence Levy Sources: -Quote was taken from the Q4 2011 Earnings Call on 6-29-2011 -Image obtained from http://blog.konstantinos.dk/wp/2014/03/20/markets-of-make-believ

  33. Slide 33: Retained earnings

    Pure2011 FY ($5,000,000) ($4,028,000) ($4,000,000) ($3,234,000) ($3,067,000) ($2,535,000) ($3,000,000) ($2,000,000) ($1,000,000) $0 JWEST,LLC Retained FY 2012 Earnings FY 2013 FY 2014 Sources: - Data obtained from Bloomberg Financial Statement Analysis

  34. Slide 34: Net debt to equity ratio

    And 0123Net 2.895 2.074 1.639 FY JWEST,LLC .5 2014 .914 2011 2012 2013 Debt how to wasEquity it financed? Ratio How were the accrued dividends on the preferred stock financed? Not with Free Cash Flow... with debt of course!! As a result, our shareholder value is getting destroyed! Sources: -Net Debt

  35. Slide 35: Wealth transferred from shareholders to debtholders

    Management has reduced shareholder value to… JWEST,LLC Management has effectively transferred wealth from shareholders to debtholders. Sources: -Image obtained from http://www.bitcoinlab.appspot.com/page/13

  36. Slide 36: Weighted average cost of capital

    But 2011 Weighted FY 5.00% 5.50% 6.00% 6.50% 7.00% sometimes FY Average 2012 debtFY Cost is 2013 cheaper, of Capital FY 2014 right? (WACC) Nice try, guess again! Sources: -WACC data obtained from Bloomberg terminal Excel Add-In on 7-23-2014

  37. Slide 37: Why take on additional debt burden?

    •–SoWere why Refinanced takegoing Extended 6-12-2013 not 6-12-2014 existing on(Q4 this twice additional financing in amortization to 2014 2013 meet 2period yearsburden? arrangements.” covenants arrangement EarningsandCall) increased related which “…we to EBITDA – “We was interest recognized rates re

  38. Slide 38: Management's ROIC forecasts

    •Return 8-10-2010 flow onper Invested 2-10-2012 grow our 6-12-2014share (Q1business core (Q3 (Q4 per Capital 2011 year 2012 2014 Earnings (ROIC)—forecasts guidance Call) that– we at an attractive “Wehave would rate.” “The hadalready expect again approval presented.” each of these demonstrated or the

  39. Slide 39: Management under-delivered on ROIC

    RLOG’s 1.60% 6.00% 3.71% 9.00% 6.91% 12.00% 15.00% FY 0.00% 3.00% 6-8-2012 everything 20111.46% Levered FY (Q4 is2012 measured 2012 ROIC FY Earnings 2013 on that FYCall) 15% 2014– unlevered “We have ROIC been very metric. transparent And we with don’teverybody see foreseethat thatallchanging.” of ou

  40. Slide 40: Management's EBITDA forecasts

    •Management’s 2013 Forecast: 2012 FY 2011 EBITDA$23 $41-43 forecasts $34-36 Million Million Wow that looks great! How are you going to get there? <A - Joseph W. McHugh>: “Yes. I think – I guess that’s the way to put it David, I think the three buckets that you ought to be thinking about are – if you

  41. Slide 41: What really happened

    What missed Only really happened… it by THIS much

  42. Slide 42: EBITDA forecast versus actual

    EBITDA 35 30 40 50 23 Millions 20 0F 10 18.4 Y35* 42 2011 Forecasted 31.2 FY – Management’s 2012 28.3EBITDA FY 32.52013 Actual Forecast FY EBITDA 2014vs Actual Management over-promised and under-delivered on EBITDA. Sources: -Forecasted data from Q4 Earnings Calls and related supplemental presentati

  43. Slide 43: There seems to be a theme

    There seems to be a theme… Management has habitually over-promised and under-delivered. Sources: -Image obtained from http://www.memecenter.com

  44. Slide 44: Why does RLOG consistently disappoint?

    Why does RLOG consistently disappoint? Sources: -Image obtained from http://david-e-owen.blogspot.com/2013/03/disappointment.html

  45. Slide 45: Need for a dedicated CEO

    –•We Webelieve Senior Lack ofRLOG believeOversight Management habitually Leadershiplocated that Laurence over-promises on 5th Levy, andAvenue and under-delivers in NYC his affiliation andHyde with Boston, Massachusetts. Park Operations Holdings, is costing RLOGlocated in Port Dover, Shareholders mon

  46. Slide 46: Lack of oversight from 450 miles away

    Lack of Oversight How can management possibly oversee the company from over 450 miles away?

  47. Slide 47: Laurence Levy: even jugglers have limits

    Laurence Levyhave Even jugglers – anlimits accomplished individual Laurence is an accomplished individual with an impressive list of companies he has created. We believe his ability to focus on Rand Logistics Inc. is limited by his involvement in his other ventures. Laurence has been instrumental in

  48. Slide 48: Laurence Levy's affiliations and roles

    Laurence ••Rand Founder and Levy—“Under focus Executive Lakes andonEssex Towing Chairman growth Chairman Ltd., our aof and ofnew Hyde companyacquisition structure, Park Holdings, initiative, IInc. will set acorporate the private strategic investment culture direction and firm organizational ofknown

  49. Slide 49: Self dealings

    Self dealings What’s the impact of all of Laurence’s affiliations on RLOG? Sources: -Image obtained from http://vipdictionary.com/collusion

  50. Slide 50: RLOG payments to Hyde Park affiliates

    RLOG’s $250,000 2009 $150,000 2010 payments $225,000 2011 2012 to$200,000 Hyde 2013 Park 2014 $175,000 affiliates We believe RLOG’s arrangement with Hyde Park and its affiliates is an unnecessary sunk cost. We also believe this arrangement diminishes RLOG’s credibility on Wall Street. Sources: -Figu

  51. Slide 51: Laurence's salary

    Laurence’s $450,000 2011 $300,000 $350,000 $400,000 2012It’s 2013 salary good 2014 to be King Laurence’s responsibilities decreased in his move from CEO to the Chairman of the Board. Additionally, company performance didn’t improve. Why is he still making the same amount of money (Base salary)? “The

  52. Slide 52: How does RLOG get to where it wants to be?

    How does RLOG get to where it wants to be? Sources: -Image obtained from http://s96854.wix.com/feelgreatcoaching

  53. Slide 53: Our proposal

    Proposal from Here is our proposal, as shown in Form SC 13D/A filed 7/1/14. For more info, please contact us 317-819-6200 Or visit our website at http://jwestllc.net

  54. Slide 54: JWEST director candidates

    aSean private projections, management in the Mr. two director Board O’Connor O’Connor O’Connor, man realChair candidates. firm estate securing consultant isin received beneficially for age known also entities 1987, Providence 53, construction thehis and is for and Managing formed one owns Bachelor h

  55. Slide 55: Jonathan Evans biography

    Jonathan with Conseco’s Brandywine in 2009. In Mr.assets 2008, February Evans Heartland From Mr. during R.beneficially effort 2009 of Evans Evans, Blue Evans 2013, Capital his toto mutual grow believed two age 2012, Mr. owns Management 45, year their Evans funds. Mr. graduated there period 488,901 v

  56. Slide 56: Proxy meeting of stockholders disclaimer

    Proxy meeting JWEST WILL In addition, Disclaimer CONTAIN has STRONGLY of stockholders JWEST filed with IMPORTANT will ADVISES theof provide Securities Rand ALL Logistics, INFORMATION. copies and STOCKHOLDERS of Exchange the Inc., proxy a Delaware Commission SUCH statement IN PROXY corporation THE wi

Rand Logistics — Proxy Contest (September 2014) on 6ix