Bob Evans Farms — Proxy Contest (August 2014)
12 slides from Bob Evans Farms's proxy contest presentation, Aug 6, 2014
Slide 1: Setting the Record Straight
Exhibit 99.1 Setting the Record Straight August 2014
Slide 2: Important Additional Information
Important Additional Information Bob Evans Farms Inc. (the “Company”), its directors and certain of its executive officers are participants in the solicitation of proxies in connection with the Company's 2014 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. The Company has filed a definitive proxy statement and form
Slide 3: Executive Summary: Consider the Facts
Executive Summary: Consider the Facts The Bob Evans Board believes that: o We have transformed the business while returning over $800 million to shareholders since FY07 (including over $250 million in FY14) o We have a clear plan for continued, sustainable value creation as we emerge from this inves
Slide 4: Sandell Remains Focused on a Flawed Agenda for Short-Sighted Financial Engineering
Sandell Remains Focused on a Flawed Agenda for Short-Sighted Financial Engineering After pushing specific financial engineering for nearly a year, Sandell suddenly seeks to distance himself from his own economic agenda by scrubbing from his latest presentation any mention of the flawed plans he has
Slide 5: Sandell's Shifting Demands for Financial Engineering
Sandell’s Shifting Demands for Financial Engineering AUGUST 5, 2013 SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 NOVEMBER 11, 2013 DECEMBER 9, 2013 APRIL 24, 2014 JUNE 10, 2014 JULY 2, 2014 JULY 28, 2014 Spin-off at 10x+ Spin-off, or sell Sell, or sell 19.9% Sell 19.9% via Analyze / Sale or spin-off of Explore / Strategic re
Slide 6: Sandell Continues to Make Misleading Statements and Overstated Claims
Sandell Continues to Make Misleading Statements and Overstated Claims A few of his misleading statements and overstated claims are highlighted below Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ The Facts Overstated Criticisms¹ Sandell claims that Bob Evans’ Sandell’s own analysis illustrates that the Company outper
Slide 7: Sandell Continues to Make Misleading Statements and Overstated Claims (cont'd)
Sandell Continues to Make Misleading Statements and Overstated Claims (cont’d) Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ The Facts Overstated Criticisms 1 Sandell claims that Bob Evans’ Bob Evans has the most Midwest exposure of any sizable family or casual dining chain “exposure to the weather was not Analysts
Slide 8: Sandell Continues to Make Misleading Statements and Overstated Claims (cont'd)
Sandell Continues to Make Misleading Statements and Overstated Claims (cont’d) Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ 1 The Facts Overstated Criticisms Sandell claims that average Sandell presents old, stale and inaccurate portraits of your Board's composition; he overstates director tenure is in excess of 14
Slide 9: Sandell Manipulates the Data to Try to Justify His Flawed Agenda
Sandell Manipulates the Data to Try to Justify His Flawed Agenda Sandell has repeatedly shifted his “peer group” to blatantly exclude underperforming peers o Sandell’s three presentations – filed with the SEC on September 24, 2013, December 9, 2013 and April 24, 2014 – compare Bob Evans’ stock perfo
Slide 10: Sandell has Misled Investors From the Beginning
Sandell has Misled Investors From the Beginning Throughout his year-long campaign, Sandell has regularly distorted the truth, overstated his claims and made unfounded allegations, a few of which are highlighted below Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ The Facts Overstated Criticisms On May 30, 2014, Sande
Slide 11: Bob Evans' Proposal for a Fresh, Independent Board
Bob Evans’ Proposal for a Fresh, Independent Board 11 of 12 are independent (all but CEO), at least six are current or former CEOs and at least eight have other public company board service A majority of the independent directors would have been added within the last two years Cheryl L. Krueger Mary
Slide 12: The Choice is Clear
The Choice is Clear Stockholders have a clear choice between what we believe are two very different approaches for Bob Evans’ future: Sustainable, Disciplined, Unsustainable, Not in the Best Interest of All Responsible, Open-Minded Stockholders Continue to drive profitable growth of existing Divest