Rubicon Technology, Inc. · OTC:RBCN
Rubicon Technology — Proxy Contest (February 2022)
30 slides from Rubicon Technology's proxy contest presentation, Feb 24, 2022
Slide 1: Paragon Technologies Transforming Rubicon Technology: A Plan for Renewal and Compounding Value
PARAGON TECHNOLOGIES TRANSFORMING RUBICON TECHNOLOGY A PLAN FOR RENEWAL AND COMPOUNDING VALUE FEBRUARY 2022
Slide 2: Introduction: Paragon and Rubicon
INTRODUCTION Paragon Technologies is one of the largest shareholders of Rubicon Technology, (RBCN) owning approximately 2.7% of the outstanding shares of the Company. In 2016 and 2017 Paragon Technologies publicly presented a plan in order to unlock the potential value imbedded in RBCN assets. W
Slide 3: Introduction: Paragon Technologies
INTRODUCTION Paragon Technologies is a diversified holding company with business activities in automation, technology distribution, real estate, and investments. Sham Gad, current Chairman and CEO of Paragon was appointed to the Paragon Board in 2010, appointed Chairman in 2012 and CEO of operatio
Slide 4: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS I. Real Change is Required at RBCN – NOW. A. RBCN is failing operationally and strategically B. RBCN management and Board are failing shareholders C. RBCN corporate governance entrenches insiders II. RBCN Transformation Opportunity A. Acquisition Opportunity on Day One B. Share pri
Slide 5: Real Change Needed
REAL CHANGE IS NEEDED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY
Slide 6: The Problem and The Answer
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY The Problem Rubicon has failed to provide any strategic plan since new CEO was appointed in 2017. Management continues to operate a business with upside down margins that is structurally unable to earn profit now or in the future. Haphazardly acqui
Slide 7: Management is undisciplined and unfocused
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Management is undisciplined Management continues to run a dying sapphire business with an upside - down cost structure. Management is unfocused 1. SEC 2020 FORM 10 - K 2. OPERATING EXPENSES EXCLUDE ONE - TIME GAINS OR LOSSES 3. 2021 PROXY FILING 4. 202
Slide 8: Insiders Get More, Shareholders Receive Less
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Insiders Get More…. …while Shareholders Receive Less 1. SEC 2020 FORM 10 - K 2. 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020 PROXY STATEMENTS FILED WITH SEC 3. DATA PROVIDED BY YAHOO FINANCE FROM 4/1/2077 THRU YEAR END 2021 Insiders benefit at the expense of outside sharehold
Slide 9: Poison Pill insulates management from accountability
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Poison Pill insulates management from being held accountable 1. RUBICON 2020 10 - K FILED WITH THE SEC. RBCN has installed a deceptive poison pill In December 2017, Rubicon adopted a shareholder rights plan (‘poison pill’) in order to “preserve the Com
Slide 10: Analysis of Rubicon's NOLs
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Analysis of Rubicon’s NOLs… 1. 2020 FORM 10 - K FILED WITH SEC. 2. 2017 FORM 10 - K FILED WITH SEC. RBCN shareholders will NEVER realize any benefit from these NOLs Federal NOLs are growing due to continued losses and began to expire in 2021 1 Illino
Slide 11: RBCN not applying poison pill restrictions to all investors
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY RBCN not applying poison pill restrictions to all investors 1. BASED ON BENEFICIAL SECURITY OWNERSHIP DISCLOSURE FROM 2017 AND 2020 PROXY STATEMENTS FILED WITH THE SEC Defending the Poison Pill to protect NOL’s is wholly misleading to the public Since
Slide 12: Operational and Strategic Risk
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Operational and Strategic Risk Management decisions based on NOLs and taxes versus sound business judgement. Risky and costly business decisions without concern for consequence from shareholders Time and expense incurred protecting, maintaining, an
Slide 13: RBCN continues to disclose that NOLs will not be fully utilized
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY RBCN continues to disclose that NOLs will NOT be fully utilized! 1. 2021 FORM 10 - Q FOR 9/30/21 FILED WITH SEC. RBCN management admits that NOLs likely to expire worthless For years Rubicon has disclosed in its SEC filings: “We are in a cumulative los
Slide 14: RBCN has failed shareholders
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Years of anemic performance due to failing and ineffective management. Radical change is needed immediately in order to save Rubicon. Our plan revives and revitalizes the company while delivering on what counts – an increase in intrinsic and market per s
Slide 15: Conclusions
REAL CHANGE IS REQUIRED AT RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Conclusions: Current leadership team has proven over the past five years that they are not capable of producing the transformational and necessary change required to position RBCN for profitable growth. The company requires radical and immediate acti
Slide 16: Rubicon Transformation Opportunity
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY I. RBCN Transformation Opportunity A. Acquisition Opportunity on Day One B. Share price appreciation of 2x to 4x in three years C. Future Growth Opportunities II. 100 Day Plan
Slide 17: Acquisition Opportunity
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Acquisition Opportunity We have identified a high quality, profitable company that has expressed a good faith interest in being acquired and we believe Rubicon to be perfectly positioned to make the acquisition. The business has produced a track record of sales
Slide 18: A great business for Rubicon
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY A great business for Rubicon Business earns tens of millions of dollars a year in revenues with proven pricing power. Strong margins. Operating Earnings in the low single millions each year. Quality balance sheet with little debt and quality management team t
Slide 19: Extremely compelling opportunity for RBCN: scenarios
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Extremely compelling opportunity for RBCN Scenarios 1 Contraction Realistic Growth Revenues $60 million $80 million $110 million Op. Income $3 million $4 million $6 million Earnings Multiple 15 - 20x 15 - 25x 15 - 25x Implied Valuation $45 to $60M $60 - $100M $90 -
Slide 20: Today: acquisition candidate and pipeline
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Today Acquisition candidate is experiencing strong demand with purchase orders being delayed due to capital access, giving RBCN opportunity to deploy capital at attractive rates of return. Support industries that are expected to have long - term growth prospect
Slide 21: Paragon Then and Now
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Paragon Then: Paragon has diversified into a diversified holding company with three wholly owned indepenent subsidiaries. Our revenues are now diversified through different industries, geographies, markets and supported by high quality assets. Our distributio
Slide 22: Results with alignment between management and shareholders
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Results with complete alignment between management and shareholders 2015 2020 % change Revenue 1 $11.6 million $108 million +831% Net Income 1 $848,000 $3.6 million +325% S. Equity 1 $3.6 million $42.5 million +1,080% Shares Out. 1 1,684,745 1,704,745 +1.2% Share P
Slide 23: Our 100 Day Plan
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Urgent Execute Present and execute acquisition candidate to shareholders Plan Present strategic plan to shareholders Fix Eliminate and reduce all unneeded costs and take swift action to cease the losses at the sapphire business. Declassify Declassify the board of d
Slide 24: Scorecard since Rubicon new management started
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY Scorecard since Rubicon new management started. 2017 2020 % change Revenue 1 $5.0 million $4.5 million - 10% Net Income 1 ($17.9M) ($1.1M) n/a Sh. Price 2 $8.00 $8.97 2 +12.4% S&P 500 3 +91.5% Nasdaq 3 +135.6% The time to act is now. Rubicon 2017 2020 % change Reve
Slide 25: A Complete Transformation
RUBICON TRANSFORMATION OPPORTUNITY A Complete Transformation The existing team at Rubicon has had five years to demonstrate their focus and ability to deliver growth and shareholder value. The result speak loudly and clearly – management has failed its shareholders Shareholders have waited patie
Slide 26: Offer to Acquire Rubicon Technology
OFFER TO ACQUIRE RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Paragon Technologies, Inc.
Slide 27: Offer to acquire shares held by directors and executives
PARAGON TECHNOLOGIES OFFER TO ACQUIRE RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Paragon is offering to acquire all the outstanding shares held by directors and executives, approximately 17% of the outstanding shares of the Company, for $10.10 per share in cash. Offer represents significant premium to 90 - day share pr
Slide 28: Option 2: Public Tender Offer for 20% of Shares
PARAGON TECHNOLOGIES OFFER TO ACQUIRE RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Paragon is prepared to announce a public tender offer to acquire up to 20% of the outstanding shares held by shareholders for $10.10 per share in cash. Offer represents significant premium to 90 - day share price and a real premium to Rubi
Slide 29: Acquisition or Tender Offer Contingent Upon
PARAGON TECHNOLOGIES OFFER TO ACQUIRE RUBICON TECHNOLOGY Termination of Rubicon’s poison pill. Appointment of Paragon’s director designees Resignation of CEO and the majority of current Board of Directors Preservation of the company’s cash and short - term investments No extraordinary acti
Slide 30: It's Now or Never for Rubicon
IT’S NOW OR NEVER FOR RUBICON Conclusions: Radical, and transformational change is needed at Rubicon now. We are past the point of repair. Shareholders deserve an opportunity to benefit from a new management and restructured Board. RBCN management has had five years. They have not delivered un