Life Storage Inc

Life Storage — Proxy Contest (February 2023)

36 slides from Life Storage's proxy contest presentation, Feb 24, 2023

  1. Slide 1: Supporting Response Materials to PSA's Proposal

    February 2023 Supporting Response Materials to PSA’s Proposal Staten Island (NYC) (Store #998)

  2. Slide 2: Forward Looking Statements

    Forward Looking Statements This presentation may contain forward looking statements as defined in Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, and in Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. Forward looking statements address matters that are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties.

  3. Slide 3: LSI at a Glance

    LSI at a Glance 80% 35+ 440 1,198 Quarterly 91.4% Years in the Properties Stores in 37 dividend Same-Store self storage managed for states increase during Occupancy rd business 3 Party Entities last four years 149% Investment 675K+ 4.8x $12.0B Grade Rated 5-year Moody’s: Baa2 Customers Debt to EBITD

  4. Slide 4: PSA's Proposal is Not in the Best Interests of LSI Shareholders

    PSA’s Proposal is Not in the Best Interests of LSI Shareholders 1 PSA’s Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and the Company’s Prospects for Value Creation 2 LSI’s Operating Strategy and Execution have Resulted in Best-In-Class Performance in Attractive, Rapidly Growing Markets 3 LSI’s Size and Op

  5. Slide 5: PSA's Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and the Company's Prospects for Value Creation

    Miami, FL (Store #1009) 1 PSA’s Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and the Company’s Prospects for Value Creation

  6. Slide 6: History of Leading Total Shareholder Returns

    1 Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and Prospects for Value Creation 6 History of Leading Total Shareholder Returns Total Return Since March 1, 2019 5-Year Total Return2 (LSI CEO Tenure)1 149.3% 97.1% 135.1% 94.2% 113.3% 78.6% 98.4% 71.4% LSI EXR CUBE PSA LSI EXR CUBE PSA LSI has a proven track

  7. Slide 7: Consistent Dividend Growth

    1 Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and Prospects for Value Creation 7 Consistent Dividend Growth Dividend Growth Since March 1, 20191 # of Dividend Raises Over Observed Period1 100% 88.4% LSI 6 80.0% EXR 5 80% CUBE 4 60% PSA 1 53.1% 50.0% 40% Note that PSA raised its 20% dividend on February 5

  8. Slide 8: Track Record of Delivering Results

    1 Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and Prospects for Value Creation 8 Track Record of Delivering Results Actual Adjusted FFO per Share vs. Consensus Analyst Estimates1 by Quarter and Year (Beat, Miss, Meet) 2020² Year 2018 2019 2021 2022 (COVID-19) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Actual Adjusted FFO per Share vs.

  9. Slide 9: FFO Growth Outperformance

    1 Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and Prospects for Value Creation 9 FFO Growth Outperformance FFO per Share Growth¹ LSI 2019-2023E CAGR: 13.3% LSI EXR 2019-2023E CAGR: 12.6% PSA 2019-2023E CAGR: 9.3% EXR Note that CUBE 2023E 30.9% CUBE guidance was not available 27.7% 28.4% at time of this p

  10. Slide 10: LSI is Poised for Continued Growth in 2024

    1 Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and Prospects for Value Creation 10 LSI is Poised for Continued Growth in 2024 LSI expects low double-digit growth in 2024E due to: 2024E FFO per Share Growth1 Continued same-store growth 9.0%-13.0% Strong demographic outlook Internal Estimates Moderating sup

  11. Slide 11: LSI's Operating Strategy and Execution have Resulted in Best-In-Class Performance

    Las Vegas, NV (Store #589) 2 LSI’s Operating Strategy and Execution have Resulted in Best-In-Class Performance in Attractive, Rapidly Growing Markets

  12. Slide 12: Best-In-Class Operating Performance

    2 Best-In-Class Performance in Attractive, Rapidly Growing Markets 12 Best-In-Class Operating Performance Average Same-Store Revenue Growth 3 Years (2020—2022) 5 Years (2018—2022) 10.4% 10.4% 8.8% 8.1% 7.8% 7.3% 6.2% 5.5% LSI1 EXR CUBE2 PSA EXR LSI1 CUBE2 PSA Average Same-Store NOI Growth 3 Years (2

  13. Slide 13: LSI's Portfolio Located in the Path of Future Growth

    2 Best-In-Class Performance in Attractive, Rapidly Growing Markets 13 LSI’s Portfolio Located in the Path of Future Growth Projected Population Growth Projected Household Growth (2022—2027E) (2022—2027E) 4.1% 4.3% 3.8% 3.9% 3.7% 3.8% 3.7% 3.4% LSI CUBE EXR PSA LSI CUBE EXR PSA LSI has focused on mar

  14. Slide 14: LSI's Growth Driven by Continued Sun Belt Expansion

    2 Best-In-Class Performance in Attractive, Rapidly Growing Markets LSI’s Growth Driven by Continued Sun Belt Expansion LSI’s Sun Belt Expansion LSI Well-Positioned for In-Migration ~70% 140 ~65% Net Population Gains (Loss) Of new acquisitions in New properties Of 3PM/JV asset pool (in thousands) 1,2

  15. Slide 15: LSI's Size and Operating Platform Allow it to Scale Faster

    Lyndhurst, NJ (NYC) (Store #8274) 3 LSI’s Size and Operating Platform Allow it to Scale its Portfolio Faster and More Efficiently

  16. Slide 16: LSI Executes on External Growth

    3 Ability to Scale Faster and More Efficiently 16 LSI Executes on External Growth Wholly-Owned Joint Third-Party Redevelopment Acquisitions Ventures Management Initiatives (“3PM”) LSI has a proven Attractive source of Consistent fee stream Ability to re-develop ability to capital to broaden that str

  17. Slide 17: Accelerating Store Count Growth

    3 Ability to Scale Faster and More Efficiently 17 Accelerating Store Count Growth LSI has identified potential ~$8.0 billion portfolio of managed and JV acquisitions in its pipeline properties is an embedded pool of acquisition opportunities, ~65% of which are in the Sun Belt2 worth $685 million, of

  18. Slide 18: Acquisitions Drive Outsized Growth for LSI

    3 Ability to Scale Faster and More Efficiently 18 Acquisitions Drive Outsized Growth for LSI Wholly-Owned Acquisition Volume Since 2019 as % of 2022 Total Enterprise Value1 30% To reach 30% acquisition volume as % of TEV, PSA would have needed to spend ~$16.0B more on acquisitions from 2019 to 2022,

  19. Slide 19: High-Growth 3PM Business and Strong JV Partners

    3 Ability to Scale Faster and More Efficiently 19 High-Growth 3PM Business and Strong JV Partners 3PM / JV Store Count and Fee Income 5202 Rapidly Expanding 3PM Program 550 $50 440 ons) â–ª 227 new managed stores since 20191, with 65 net 440 $40 lli transfers from other REITs 330 367 Mi es 330 297 $

  20. Slide 20: Redevelopment Improves Asset Base and Profitability

    3 Ability to Scale Faster and More Efficiently 20 Redevelopment Improves Asset Base and Profitability LSI is committed to investing in its current asset NOI Margin1 (Excl. Real Estate Taxes) base through upgrading assets and improving the customer experience 80% 78% $208 million of redevelopment com

  21. Slide 21: LSI has Significantly Expanded its Operating Margins

    Brooklyn, NY (NYC) (Store #1153) 4 LSI has Significantly Expanded its Operating Margins and has Numerous Initiatives Underway to Build on its Progress

  22. Slide 22: Sector-Leading Margin Improvement

    4 Expanded Operating Margins and Numerous Initiatives Underway 22 Sector-Leading Margin Improvement Same-Store NOI Margin Expansion Since the Beginning of 20191 6.3% 3.9% 2.4% 1.4% LSI EXR PSA CUBE LSI expects ~70 bps of additional margin improvement over the next ~24 months through identified margi

  23. Slide 23: Margin Normalization Comparison

    4 Expanded Operating Margins and Numerous Initiatives Underway 23 Margin Normalization Comparison 4Q 2022 Margin Comparison Non-controllable geographic street rate PSA LSI differences between the portfolios drive reported margin differential; adjusting LSI’s Direct SSNOI Margins 81.2% 73.7% rent per

  24. Slide 24: The Proposal was Opportunistically Timed

    Columbia, SC (Store #8454) 5 The Proposal was Opportunistically Timed; Does Not Reflect LSI’s Outlook for Continued Industry Leading Growth and Value Creation

  25. Slide 25: PSA's Proposal Takes Advantage of Short-Term Dislocation

    5 Proposal was Opportunistically Timed; Does Not Reflect LSI’s Outlook for Growth 25 PSA’s Proposal Takes Advantage of Short-Term Dislocation NTM FFO Multiples1 19.4x LSI Average Trading Multiple Implied Offer Multiple² 18.2x 17.7x 3-Year 1-Year The implied NTM multiple from PSA’s proposal does not

  26. Slide 26: LSI is Significantly Undervalued Based on Future Growth Expectations

    5 Proposal was Opportunistically Timed; Does Not Reflect LSI’s Outlook for Growth 26 LSI is Significantly Undervalued Based on Future Growth Expectations 2024E FFO Multiple Adjusted for Growth (PEG Ratio)1 2.1x 1.9x 1.6x 1.1x Multiple Implied by PSA Proposal, Adjusted for LSI’s Mid-Point for 2024 Gr

  27. Slide 27: Superior Growth and Value Creation

    5 Proposal was Opportunistically Timed; Does Not Reflect LSI’s Outlook for Growth 27 Superior Growth and Value Creation Faster Growth: Same-Store Revenue and NOI, FFO, Acquisition Pipeline, 3PM, JVs Further Margin Improvement Future Opportunity for Acquisitions Preferred Demographic Exposure to Sun

  28. Slide 28: LSI's Board is Highly Qualified and Strongly Aligned with Governance Best Practices

    5 Proposal was Opportunistically Timed; Does Not Reflect LSI’s Outlook for Growth 28 LSI’s Board is Highly Qualified and Strongly Aligned with Corporate Governance Best Practices Independent & 6 of 8 Directors are independent, including an Independent Chairman Focused 100% Director attendance for Bo

  29. Slide 29: PSA's Proposal Is Not in the Best Interests of LSI Shareholders

    5 Proposal was Opportunistically Timed; Does Not Reflect LSI’s Outlook for Growth 29 PSA’s Proposal Is Not in the Best Interests of LSI Shareholders 1 PSA’s Proposal Significantly Undervalues LSI and the Company’s Prospects for Value Creation 2 LSI’s Operating Strategy and Execution have Resulted in

  30. Slide 30: Appendix

    Chicago, IL (Store #568) Appendix

  31. Slide 31: PEG Ratio Calculation

    31 Page 26 Reference: PEG Ratio Calculation Consensus 2024E FFO Multiple Growth + Dividend Yield Factor PEG Ratio A B A B Consensus Consensus 2024E 2024E Growth Growth and 2024E FFO per 2024E FFO Dividend per 2024E + Dividend Div. Adjusted Share Price Share Multiple 2024E Growth1 Share2 Dividend Yie

  32. Slide 32: Regional Rental Rates Drive Margin Differences

    32 Regional Rental Rates Drive Margin Differences â–ª A comparison of margins should reflect the geographies of the portfolios â–ª The weighted average street rates for PSA’s top 5 and top 10 markets are ~37% and ~19% higher than LSI’s Top 10 Same Store Markets by Portfolio LSI PSA Rank Market % of

  33. Slide 33: Definitions: Supplemental Performance Measures

    Definitions 33 Supplemental Performance Measures Funds from Operations (“FFO”): FFO is defined by the National Association of Real Estate Investment Trusts, Inc. (“NAREIT”) as net income available to common shareholders computed in accordance with GAAP, excluding gains or losses on sales of properti

  34. Slide 34: Non-GAAP Reconciliations: Computation of FFO

    Non-GAAP Reconciliations Non-GAAP Reconciliations Life Storage, Inc. Computation of Funds From Operations (FFO) (dollars in thousands, except share data1) 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Net income attributable to common shareholders $ 206,590 $ 258,699 $ 151,571 $ 249,317 $ 358,128 Noncontrolling interest

  35. Slide 35: Non-GAAP Reconciliations: Same Store Data

    Non-GAAP Non-GAAP Reconciliations Life Storage, Inc. Same Store Data (dollars in thousands) Revenues: Rental income Other operating income Total operating revenues Expenses: Payroll and benefits Real estate taxes Utilities Repairs and maintenance Office and other operating expense Insurance Advertis

  36. Slide 36: Non-GAAP Reconciliations (cont.): 2023 Guidance

    Non-GAAP Reconciliations (cont.) Non-GAAP Reconciliations Life Storage, Inc. 2023 Guidance (dollars in thousands, except share Earnings per share attributable to common shareholders—diluted Plus: real estate depreciation and amortization Adjusted FFO per share

Life Storage — Proxy Contest (February 2023) on 6ix