Lubys — Proxy Contest (January 2019)
21 slides from Lubys's proxy contest presentation, Jan 7, 2019
Slide 1: Bandera Partners Presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS)
Bandera Partners Presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS)
Slide 2: Disclaimer
Disclaimer THIS PRESENTATION IS FOR DISCUSSION AND GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL SITUATION, SUITABILITY, OR THE PARTICULAR NEED OF ANY SPECIFIC PERSON WHO MAY RECEIVE THIS PRESENTATION, AND SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS ADVICE O
Slide 3: * !!#!""#!"# $(+" "#!#! !"#! !!"" * %"$!#% $(+" "#!!%!(!" * $!#"(!$$##!(!"$$!""! !#!!%$"#!(## '""%'$#%!#!"#
* !!#!""#!"# $(+" "#!#! !"#! !!"" * %"$!#% $(+" "#!!%!(!" * $!#"(!$$##!(!"$$!""! !#!!%$"#!(## '""%'$#%!#!"# * #!#!"###&# $(+" #!%#! !#!" $##!#"$"##%##" * %#$! $#"!## $(+" !"! * $!"#%"#')%$!"#!"
Slide 4: It is Time for a Change!
It is Time for a Change! ¢ The current Luby’s Board of Directors has overseen a long period of: Disastrous stock price performance Dismal (and worsening) financial results Declining asset values Very poor capital allocation Bloated overhead costs Broken promises, year after year after year BANDERA
Slide 5: )1%7255%00?66-+1-*-'%175)%/)67%7)*-1%1'-%/%1(&%1.-1+%6:)//%65)+8/%725< );3)5-)1'):28/(0%.),-0%&)1)*-'-%/%((-7-21727,)…
)1%7255%00?66-+1-*-'%175)%/)67%7)*-1%1'-%/%1(&%1.-1+%6:)//%65)+8/%725< );3)5-)1'):28/(0%.),-0%&)1)*-'-%/%((-7-21727,)2%5( > #-'),%-50%12*21) 7%5/2&%/'48-6-7-216%!);%6&%6)(35-9%7))48-7<*-507,%7-19)676 35-0%5-/<-15)%/)67%7)%6:)//%6)48-7<'5)(-7%1(27,)5*-1%1'-%/%66)76 > #-'),%-50%12*" 19)670)17%1.*520)'
Slide 6: * ()+& &'#$%& " " " " " #(% ##!% &#"(%) '
* ()+& &'#$%& " " " " " #(% ##!% &#"(%) '
Slide 7: & #%'! ""!" "# ! "" #"% "! "! !$ % $"" ("(((##&+%*(.*&(% (%)*+(%*)%
& #%'! ""!" "# ! "" #"% "! "! !$ % $"" ("(((##&+%*(.*&(% (%)*+(%*)% %%.)&('&(*!&% ,( &!$!#(&$'*!*&() %- !" # "# ! ""!" "# !#$! # %"
Slide 8: $ !"#$!!!!$&%$ / "'%(&.0*$'***'#%#&)&+.)* / ,.0* "*!&)+& &%'%!" "$$$" "!'-)+"(*+ #-.)* ()+#&!&'% +&'% #$
$ !"#$!!!!$&%$ / "'%(&.0*$'***'#%#&)&+.)* / ,.0* "*!&)+& &%'%!" "$$$" "!'-)+"(*+ #-.)* ()+#&!&'% +&'% #$ & &%' ',),.0* ')%
Slide 9: .&3-$)21#!1("30-)-'./%0!2).-13"581 #.-2)-3%12.1%++0%!+%12!2% .&!11%211.+$1)-#% .0!".326 /%03"581 1(!0% 7 "! 7 3"581 0…
7 .&3-$)21#!1("30-)-'./%0!2).-13"581 #.-2)-3%12.1%++0%!+%12!2% .&!11%211.+$1)-#% .0!".326 /%03"581 1(!0% 7 "! 7 3"581 0%#%-2+5!--.3-#%$!/+!-2.1%++ ,)++).-!11%21 3,3+!2)4%0.#%%$1&0.,11%2!+%1 3"51..*!+3%/%0(!0% .30#%3"581 .0,
Slide 10: #$& )/ +, $("+*$&0,#+$(%$(")'*(0-#-$,.+($(",#(, &&$("+ & ,-- -),-0 !&)-.02, )+#,' ()*+)"+ ,,-+$''$(")/ +# ),-,
1 #$& )/ +, $("+*$&0,#+$(%$(")'*(0-#-$,.+($(",#(, &&$("+ & ,-- -),-0 !&)-.02, )+#,' ()*+)"+ ,,-+$''$(")/ +# ),-, / +# ),-,, ))%&. +#+ ).+ .02, )+'
Slide 11: %#&#&!)' #+#%#+.#*#&!')(')+,)" , %#' '+#%#%$#%')%*$"&&%#& #)%'$&') +%&#%$#%')%*$"&"*#&)* $ ') ')(')+,)" ')(')+,)"* -(…
%#&#&!)' #+#%#+.#*#&!')(')+,)" , %#' '+#%#%$#%')%*$"&&%#& #)%'$&') +%&#%$#%')%*$"&"*#&)* $ ') ')(')+,)" ')(')+,)"* -(&** #&)* %#& ( (()#&"'#$)( )"$%$"(&%(")"%$% *'!%()( #(% (+-& #%!
Slide 12: ($$')$"% #"#!# / '& '($%&%%'&) ''!&-($ )(( %'#"$ " !#$ &'($($&# .( $#'#$(! #
($$')$"% #"#!# / '& '($%&%%'&) ''!&-($ )(( %'#"$ " !#$ &'($($&# .( $#'#$(! # ('!+ ((&! (- $"$$ $ $ # " !! $#"$#-!$' #%)! $"%#- "$ " %'# # &"# $ *%(0/ / #("$* (&&$%$! +'&"$*&$" ' -#,"*. ' %$' ( $#)(+'&( #( %&-&' *,"-*& *+(' #&!$)#'!)-0' '( !!&( #')!!( "'&$!& #%%*#!!#' &!( $#',)( *'*&!'# $&!!,)( *'##
Slide 13: !(&)'1('-"'.,-( +,,"/%1"'/,-"'.14, '.+.$+,(')-,0"-!)((+ +-.+', 3 "' -!(&)'1!,"'/,-&(+-!' &"%%"('"'-('*.","-"(',0!"% +…
3 !(&)'1('-"'.,-( +,,"/%1"'/,-"'.14, '.+.$+,(')-,0"-!)((+ +-.+', 3 "' -!(&)'1!,"'/,-&(+-!' &"%%"('"'-('*.","-"(',0!"% +-.+'"' '()"-%-(,!+!(%+,!",!,')+-"%%1.'-!+(. !,%%"' &"%%"('( ,,-,&(,-%1+%,--'-!+(. !"'.++"' - 3 (.14, 0,&"%%"('&+$-)"-%"2-"('(&)'1(1,!+!(%+,4 *."-1",/%.-#.,- &"%%"('1-!).%"&+$- " " !
Slide 14: ".5&$%-&0)4-"+!&01."/&0%,"01.+ : '41+5'+/7'45+/).03'5*#/ ,# -&0) 4157/ 1.."+0*.("0 -&0)&60&,+07'35*' 1#45&'%#&'!'3/+"…
".5&$%-&0)4-"+!&01."/&0%,"01.+ : '41+5'+/7'45+/).03'5*#/ ,# -&0) 4157/ 1.."+0*.("0 -&0)&60&,+07'35*' 1#45&'%#&'!'3/+"$0&2"&+ 6.6-#5+7'!%26+4+5+0/4+/%'" &, 063%'6$8;4 03. 05'&, &'(+/' -'44#+/40/44'5#-'41-64 44'5.1#+3.'/541-64'13'%+#5+0/#/&.035+9#5+0/
Slide 15: Luby's Only Plan: More of the Same
Luby’s Only Plan: More of the Same Despite over a decade of failed investments into Luby’s and Fuddruckers, the Luby’s current Board has no plans to change course. The Board’s recent letter to stockholders promises an “aggressive plan to increase profitability” and promises to “invest appropriately
Slide 16: - " *"(,0& &'#$%*& .#(%#%"!"!"''!)&'%' %#*'$ "#%(,0& &"'#%'$%#' %#*'" #"'%!&%# %) (/ - "
- " *"(,0& &'#$%*& .#(%#%"!"!"''!)&'%' %#*'$ "#%(,0& &"'#%'$%#' %#*'" #"'%!&%# %) (/ - " *"(,0& &'#$%*& .%!"#""'''#(% #"'%!&'%' $ "* ""&%# %) (/ - " *"(,0& &'#$%*& . )'''#(&+('#"##(%"% '%!" #"'%!$ "&* ""&%# %) (/ - .'#"&*0)'"''%$#&'#"'#!$",#%"" #"'%!&%# % ) (/ - .)$ "&"$ '#%#*##(%%"&&#$$#%'("'&'#!$%
Slide 17: "&+ !!& ! !!&!!! " ( )&! !' " !"!! $$$" ! !!" !
"&+ !!& ! !!&!!! " ( )&! !' " !"!! $$$" ! !!" ! * ( ) ! " % ! &!"!"# !! $! "!"! ! * ( )!!!!# !! $! "!!" ! ! * ( ) !!"&#"!" ! +! !!$ ! !!!!# ! !' !!"! *
Slide 18: '!)(&%!$ # )'*(38-/,, (., & -.. $-**,$- . * ,-#, ( .)!&& . 4
'!)(&%!$ 4 # )'*(38-/,, (., & -.. $-**,$- . * ,-#, ( .)!&& . 4 # , (.',% .0&/ )!/38- * ,-#, 4 #'!) ()"" $*()) &'(' $+"*"-('"()) (,%') $ )$(%*./( $*#$) %'% ')%'( &&' ("())"*)% ) *.()%!' 4 )/-.)(#,)($& +/). -)" -*$.&)*$0 /38- -.)%#)& ,.#.#-)1( -#, - !),)0 , 3 ,- 4 )/, /&$ 2-)/(.3**,$-&-!),/38-)1( *,)*
Slide 19: + $ ",##'"$) #$$ " "$"#'& $ '"$&$"#$""&"#$%$$)$#%#$' "# $$$""#%$# + $'' + #%"$"%
+ $ ",##'"$) #$$ " "$"#'& $ '"$&$"#$""&"#$%$$)$#%#$' "# $$$""#%$# + $'' + #%"$"% "#&#$"$"&' "$%$#$(* #""&% + $"$#$%$$$$$"&'" "$&"#$# + "$##%")$ + &'$ ),#%$#&%$%)'"#$%"$,# ""&"#%#$$"#&%$%") " "$) + )""%#)##$&#$$#'$%$"#""$%"&#$ $ + $%$"$"$#& $" $$ " #$%""$#$"$)") " "$)!%$#$ $%### $
Slide 20: )!*+'( )&))!*((*&+ !&,%&+,04* ')&))'.$0 .'&()'/0! +!&*+%!,* (!+$!& *(!+ )'%%&!&+ )',+'',)%!,* &'%!&* 1 2$!-+ +,0*
1 )!*+'( )&))!*((*&+ !&,%&+,04* ')&))'.$0 .'&()'/0! +!&*+%!,* (!+$!& *(!+ )'%%&!&+ )',+'',)%!,* &'%!&* 1 2$!-+ +,0* **,))'%)$+!-$0('')')(')+ '-)&&()+!*3(')+&,)0 1 &0'+ !**,* ! $! +0%!,* ()*!*+ 1 %!,* '%($!&+ +,04* ')$$'.+ ((*)'+ )*+' !&)*+ !)'.&)* !(. !$#(!&('!*'&(!$$+'$!%!+'+ )*+'# '$) (,) ** 1 ((*
Slide 21: ! # $ !($# & .# ,,!., .$& , &* )0 ,#/&),)!$, .),-( **)$(.(
! # 5 $ !($# & .# ,,!., .$& , &* )0 ,#/&),)!$, .),-( **)$(.( 1.) , &$'$(. 2.,#$,'(! - 5 "$$(/-.,$&-**#$, '(/!./, , &* .# ),)0 ,- ,-.$)-./..$("(-#/$&$(")1 , ),! - 5 1. ,,$"#.-)'*(3 &*$(".)')( .$4 -- .-(/.)* ,.$(" )-.-)1 , ),! - 5 " /.$)(&.,0 &)'*(3 &* .# ),'% .# $!!$/&. $-$)(.)&$+/$. .# )'*(3, ./,($(