Bob Evans Farms — Proxy Contest (August 2014)
70 slides from Bob Evans Farms's proxy contest presentation, Aug 11, 2014
Slide 1: Transformed and Ready to Grow
Exhibit 99.1 Transformed and Ready to Grow August 2014
Slide 2: Important Additional Information
Important Additional Information Bob Evans Farms Inc. (the “Company”), its directors and certain of its executive officers are participants in the solicitation of proxies in connection with the Company's 2014 Annual Meeting of Stockholders. The Company has filed a definitive proxy statement and form
Slide 3: Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Non-GAAP Financial Measures The Company uses non-GAAP financial measures within this presentation. These financial measures are used by management to monitor and evaluate the ongoing performance of the Company. The Company believes that the additional measures are useful to investors for financial a
Slide 4: Agenda
I. Introduction – The Fundamental Choice II. The Transformation of Bob Evans III. Our Value Creation and Growth Plan – Prudent, Responsible and Focused IV. Sandell’s Demands – Short-Sighted, Unsustainable and Not in the Best Interests of All Stockholders V. Our Leadership – Independent, Highly Quali
Slide 5: I. Introduction – The Fundamental Choice
I. Introduction – The Fundamental Choice
Slide 6: Executive Summary: Consider the Facts
Executive Summary: Consider the Facts The Bob Evans Board believes that: o We have transformed the business while returning over $800 million to shareholders since FY07 (including over $250 million in FY14) o We have a clear plan for continued, sustainable value creation as we emerge from this inves
Slide 7: Proactive Evaluation of the Business
Proactive Evaluation of the Business As part of its commitment to drive stockholder value, the Bob Evans Board employs a rigorous and disciplined process to continually review its business and either grow, fix or exit assets Bob Evans Restaurants (e.g., Farm Fresh Refresh, carryout growth, new units
Slide 8: The Fundamental Choice
The Fundamental Choice The 2014 annual meeting presents stockholders with a fundamental choice between what we believe to be two very different approaches: Sustainable, Disciplined, Unsustainable, Responsible, Open-Minded Not in the Best Interest of All Stockholders Continue to drive profitable grow
Slide 9: II. The Transformation of Bob Evans
II. The Transformation of Bob Evans
Slide 10: Our Vision: Make Regional Brands Powerful National Brands
Our Vision Make Our REGIONAL BRANDS Powerful NATIONAL BRANDS 10
Slide 11: Overview: Regional Brands, National Potential
Overview: Regional Brands, National Potential Founded in 1948 Ticker: BOBE Market capitalization: ~$1.1bn Two synergistic business segments Bob Evans Restaurants (“BER”) Bob Evans Foods (“BEF”) Rev: Rev: $957mm $372mm (72%) (28%) Leading full-service Midwest-based restaurant Vertically integrated si
Slide 12: Our Guiding Principles
Our Guiding Principles ct “ / | TENTLY | a CONSISTEN ‘DRIVE SALES GROWTH meetin \MARGINS WITH AN EYE ON CUSTOMERS Stee \. ON INVESTED / CAPITAL FARMS®
Slide 13: A Track Record of Balanced Capital Allocation
A Track Record of Balanced Capital Allocation Bob Evans has returned meaningful capital to stockholders in a prudent, consistent fashion Fiscal 2007-2012 Fiscal 2013 Fiscal 2014 $167M $52M $130M $30M $118M $191M $225M $485M $339M $63M Debt Repayment Over $800 million returned FY15 Capex expected to
Slide 14: Track Record of Meaningful Dividends and Share Repurchase
Track Record of Meaningful Dividends and Share Repurchase Annual Dividend Per Share has Doubled Since FY08 Trailing 12-month yield (8/8/14): $1.205 BOBE: 2.6% $1.075 S&P 500: 1.9% $0.95 $0.78 $0.68 $0.56 $0.60 $0.54 FY 2007 FY 2008 FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 Weighted Average Dil
Slide 15: BER: Remodeled and Ready to Grow
BER: Remodeled and Ready to Grow Farm Fresh Refresh Transformation Recently completed Farm Fresh Refresh o First comprehensive remodeling program in brand history o 76% maintenance capex and 24% growth capex o Refreshed restaurants have consistently outperformed non-refreshed restaurants We are conf
Slide 16: Farm Fresh Refresh Driving Sales
Farm Fresh Refresh Driving Sales The Company recently completed a multi-year renovation program of all its units Refreshed stores consistently outperformed the non-refreshed stores over the last three years According to WD Partners and Nation’s Restaurant News, Bob Evans has made significant progres
Slide 17: Industry Traffic Has Been Soft Across Dayparts and Segments
Industry Traffic has Been Soft Across Dayparts and Segments, Particularly in Midscale Distribution of Traffic and Trend by Segment and Daypart – Qtr. Ending June ‘14 QSR Midscale Casual Dining YoY YoY YoY 4% NA Morning Meal 23% +3% 25% -4% 33% -1% Lunch 33% -1% 35% -5% Supper 26% 59% -4% -1% 38% -4%
Slide 18: Leveraging a Remodeled Base: Product and Operational Innovation
Leveraging a Remodeled Base: Product and Operational Innovation to Drive Positive Same-Store Sales in FY'15 and Beyond Menu Innovation Objectives: Drive traffic Increase avg. check Leverage off-premise Enhance margins All Initiatives Rigorously Tested Operational Innovation New Sales Layers New Kitc
Slide 19: Farm Fresh Refresh Will Catalyze Further Growth in Carryout Sales
Farm Fresh Refresh Will Catalyze Further Growth in Carryout Sales Carryout sales have demonstrated consistent growth trajectory since 2006 Off-Premise Sales Mix and Growth % by Year As a result of FFR, 100% of BER units now have Catering/Carryout 12.5% carryout capabilities +2.4% 12.0% +7.9% 11.5% B
Slide 20: Broasted Chicken Has Reversed Dinner and Lunch Sales Declines
Broasted Chicken has Reversed Dinner and Lunch Sales and Traffic Declines in its Test Markets Bob Evans menu is subject to continuous consumer testing, review and revision with particular focus on increasing differentiation across users and platforms Broasted chicken is now the number one top seller
Slide 21: Broasted Chicken Is Fueling Incremental Carryout Sales
Broasted Chicken is Fueling Incremental Carryout Sales in its Test Markets Broasted meals accounted for 56% of carryout sales increase th th 1 Cincinnati D.M.A. (April 17 – July 27 ) Sales % of Variance ($) Total Dine-In Sales $122,526 23% Carryout Sales 407,710 77% Total $530,236 Broasted accounts
Slide 22: BEF: Restructured and Ready to Grow
BEF: Restructured and Ready to Grow Restructured to streamline and focus on more profitable businesses Distribution Presence 100% vertically integrated cost structure with Kettle Creations acquisition Mitigated over $66mm in sow cost inflation since 2009 Four key lines of business o Refrigerated Sid
Slide 23: The Run-Up in FY14 Sow Costs Made it Difficult to Guide
The Run-Up in FY14 Sow Costs Made it Difficult to Guide Our Profit Forecasts The increase of sow costs, largely driven by unforeseen PED virus outbreaks, has been the main reason we have reduced our guidance $105.00 $101.16 $100.00 $93.39 $95.00 USDA $95.17 $89.02 $89.18 $90.00 Cost $84.93 $85.59 $8
Slide 24: Significant Intersegment Synergies
Significant Intersegment Synergies We believe that the combination of BER and BEF offers significant intersegment synergies, including: Brand and Advertising Synergies (e.g., TV, Print and In-Store) Product Innovation Between BEF and BER (e.g., Mashed Potatoes) Supply Chain Savings by Joint Procurem
Slide 25: Consistent Value Creation
Consistent Value Creation Since Steve Davis was hired as CEO in May 2006, Bob Evans has consistently outperformed Sandell’s designated Family and Casual Dining Peers and performed generally in-line with Bob Evans’ proxy peers, until Fall of 2013 200% October 2013 Proxy Peers: 150% +136% 100% +102% S
Slide 26: Sandell Manipulates the Data to Justify His Flawed Agenda
Sandell Manipulates the Data to Try to Justify His Flawed Agenda Sandell has repeatedly shifted his “peer group” to blatantly exclude underperforming peers o Sandell’s three presentations – filed with the SEC on September 24, 2013, December 9, 2013 and April 24, 2014 – compare Bob Evans’ 1 stock per
Slide 27: Record Sow Costs and Severe Weather Impacted Our Stock Price
Record Sow Costs and Severe Weather Have Been the Primary Factors Adversely Impacting Our Stock Price Since Last Fall Since hitting nearly $60/share, the Company’s stock has been adversely impacted by both severe weather and record sow costs Unusually severe winter weather disproportionately Dramati
Slide 28: Setting the Record Straight: Total Shareholder Return
Setting the Record Straight: Total Shareholder Return Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ 1 The Facts Overstated Criticisms Sandell claims that Bob Evans’ Sandell’s own analysis illustrates that the Company outperformed the S&P 500 by over 10% over stockholders have “suffered the last 10 years and performe
Slide 29: III. Our Value Creation and Growth Plan
III. Our Value Creation and Growth Plan – Prudent, Responsible and Focused
Slide 30: Our Plan: Transformed and Poised for Growth
Our Plan: Transformed and Poised for Growth Bob Evans Restaurants Bob Evans Foods Corporate Farm Fresh Refresh Completed Side Dish Vertical Integration Capital and Resource Allocation Up to 8 New Restaurants in FY15 Margin Innovation Sausage Network Optimization 10-12 Annually Thereafter 10-20 BEX t
Slide 31: Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions
Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions: Over $125 Million of Asset Dispositions Since FY06 Business Springfield, Ohio Mimi’s Cafe Sold/Divested distribution center Asset Ready-to-eat Sausage operations Consolidation (five facilities into two) operations (four facilities into one) Business Headquart
Slide 32: Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Investment
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Investment Significantly Enhances Our Capabilities ERP Investment BEF Business IT Supply Payroll Financial Insights Systems Chain and HR Controls SKU Level Cost and Platform for Growth Cost Insights and Payroll Co-Sourcing Taxes and Fixed Profit Insights Speed to M
Slide 33: Our Long-Term Goal and Strategic Pillars
Our Long-Term Goal and Strategic Pillars 10 – 12% Long-Term EPS Growth Goal PROFITABLY SELECTIVELY DRIVE GROW & INVEST IN STOCKHOLDER HIGH R.O.I.C. CONTINUE VALUE WITH GROWTH TO TRANSFORM DISCIPLINED OPPORTUNITIES OUR CORE CAPITAL (Internal & ALLOCATION BUSINESS External) 33
Slide 34: Our Long-Term Goals
Our Long-Term Goals Net Sales Operating Margin Annual Growth Initiatives FY13-FY18 Improvement Initiatives Up to 8 new restaurants in FY15; 10-12 restaurants Sales forecasting/labor thereafter management Same-store sales and new Food cost optimization 3.0% - 3.5% restaurants expected to 7.8% 11.2 -
Slide 35: Analysts Appreciate the Company's Strategy
Analysts Appreciate the Company's Strategy “In our opinion, Bob Evans Farms will experience impressive margin expansion in F2015 and F2016. Bob Evans remains our favorite small-cap pick in the family and casual dining space, owing primarily to the significant margin growth we foresee. Management has
Slide 36: IV. Sandell's Demands – Short-Sighted, Unsustainable
IV. Sandell’s Demands – Short-Sighted, Unsustainable and Not in the Best Interests of All Stockholders
Slide 37: Sandell Asset Management
Sandell Asset Management Overview Selected Background Founded by Thomas Sandell in 1998 Sandell Asset Management reportedly managed approximately $7.5 billion in assets at its peak; as of Thomas Sandell previously worked as co-head of Risk 2013, the fund managed approximately $1.0 billion Arbitrage
Slide 38: Sandell's Shifting Demands for Financial Engineering
Sandell’s Shifting Demands for Financial Engineering AUGUST 5, 2013 SEPTEMBER 24, 2013 NOVEMBER 11, 2013 DECEMBER 9, 2013 APRIL 24, 2014 JUNE 10, 2014 JULY 2, 2014 JULY 28, 2014 Spin-off at 10x+ Spin-off, or sell Sell, or sell 19.9% Sell 19.9% via Analyze / Sale or spin-off of Explore / Strategic re
Slide 39: Sandell Remains Focused on a Flawed Agenda
Sandell Remains Focused on a Flawed Agenda for Short-Sighted Financial Engineering After pushing specific financial engineering for nearly a year, Sandell suddenly seeks to distance himself from his own economic agenda by scrubbing from his latest presentation any mention of the flawed plans he has
Slide 40: Your Board Believes Sandell's Demands are Short-Sighted
Your Board Believes Sandell’s Demands are Short- Sighted, Unsustainable and NOT in Your Best Interests Though Sandell’s specific proposals have continuously changed over the past year, he has repeatedly demanded the following financial engineering 1 Separate BEF Divest BEF now, before reaping benefi
Slide 41: BEF: A Powerful Growth Engine
1 BEF: A Powerful Growth Engine BEF is an important component of the Company’s long-term growth plan and your Board believes that an immediate disposition does not maximize stockholder value In our view, Bob Evans is uniquely poised to reap the rewards of its recently completed, multi-year investmen
Slide 42: Real Estate: A Strategic Asset
2 Real Estate: A Strategic Asset Based on our analysis, we believe that Sandell’s rationale for a sale-leaseback of the Company’s real estate assets is flawed Factors Overlooked by Sandell Others are Also Skeptical of Sale-Leaseback Increased rent expense “With regard to a potential sale leaseback,
Slide 43: Leveraged Repurchase
3 Leveraged Repurchase Sandell’s share repurchase demands are based on what we perceive to be unrealistic assumptions; Bob Evans has consistently and responsibly returned over $800 million of capital to its stockholders since FY07 In the summer of 2013, the Company announced it would increase its bu
Slide 44: Sandell Agenda Would Put the Company at Undue Risk
We Believe the Sandell Agenda Would Put the Company at Undue Risk For example, if the Company were to undertake a sale-leaseback and share repurchase as proposed by Sandell, it would lead to an untenable amount of leverage Enter into sale-leaseback for 50% of BER sites assuming highest proposed valu
Slide 45: While Sandell Makes Generic Suggestions, Our Board Takes Action
While Sandell Makes Generic and Non-Substantive Operational Suggestions, our Board Takes Action In an attempt to argue its nominees have a plan for improving operating performance, Sandell presents generic, “low hanging fruit” platitudes which appear attractive on their face but lack substance or ar
Slide 46: Setting the Record Straight: Margins
Setting the Record Straight: Margins Sandell makes a number of claims about Bob Evans that we believe are false or misleading. For example – a non-exhaustive list of Sandell’s misleading claims: Sandell’s Claim1 The Facts Considering The Facts Sandell claims that our SG&A Sandell does not adjust Bob
Slide 47: G&A Reconciliation
G&A Reconciliation In order to properly analyze the Company's G&A expense, it is important to consider the Company's relatively unique business model and significant non-recurring charges We believe the items in BER and BEF adjustments noted below are generally not included in SG&A FY14 SG&A $ in th
Slide 48: V. Our Leadership – Independent, Highly Qualified and Open-Minded
V. Our Leadership – Independent, Highly Qualified and Open-Minded
Slide 49: Bob Evans' Proposal for a Fresh, Independent Board
Bob Evans’ Proposal for a Fresh, Independent Board 11 of 12 are independent (all but CEO), at least six are current or former CEOs and at least eight have other public company board service A majority of the independent directors would have been added within the last two years Cheryl L. Krueger Mary
Slide 50: Committed to Transparency and Fresh Thinking
Committed to Transparency and Fresh Thinking Bob Evans has consistently demonstrated its commitment to transparency and fresh, independent thinking Investor friendly – receptive to feedback; regularly meets and engages with stockholders Added four new independent, highly qualified directors in the l
Slide 51: Committed to Corporate Governance Best Practices
Bob Evans is Committed to Corporate Governance Best Practices All independent directors (except CEO) Annual director elections – no classified board Majority vote election standard with a director resignation policy Entirely independent nominating, audit, finance and compensation committees A lead i
Slide 52: Governance Compares Favorably with Sandell's Peer Group
Bob Evans’ Governance Compares Favorably with Sandell’s Peer Group Institutional Shareholder Services (“ISS”) has awarded Bob Evans the highest possible corporate governance score ISS Overall Governance QuickScore Versus Sandell Family & Casual Dining Peers Plus DENN, DIN and RT¹ Mean ex. BOBE: 4.8
Slide 53: Open to Constructive Dialogue
Open to Constructive Dialogue Bob Evans has attempted to engage in constructive dialogue with Sandell on numerous occasions Sandell has rebuffed several attempts by the Board to settle the proxy contest In January 2014, the Board attempted to settle the contest by offering Sandell the opportunity to
Slide 54: Open to Constructive Dialogue (cont'd)
Open to Constructive Dialogue (cont’d) Bob Evans is and has been willing to settle the proxy contest with the addition of an appropriate number of open-minded, independent directors Following Bob Evans' disclosure of its repeated attempts to settle, Sandell contacted the Board with an "exploding" of
Slide 55: Would Sandell's Slate Make Their Own Independent Decisions?
Would Sandell’s Slate Make Their Own Independent Decisions in the Best Interest of All Stockholders? None of Sandell’s nominees agreed to the Board’s good-faith effort to meet to evaluate their candidacy in accordance with the Company’s best practices o Immediately after the period for stockholder n
Slide 56: Setting the Record Straight: Governance
Setting the Record Straight: Governance Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ The Facts Overstated Criticisms ¹ Sandell claims that “All eight of Each of Sandell's nominees is contractually prohibited from publicly expressing any opinion on Bob Evans, Sandell’s nominees are completely including on Sandell’s
Slide 57: Sandell Has Misled Investors From the Beginning
Sandell has Misled Investors From the Beginning Throughout his year-long campaign, Sandell has regularly distorted the truth, overstated his claims and made unfounded allegations, a few of which are highlighted below Sandell’s Misleading Claims/ The Facts Overstated Criticisms On May 30, 2014, Sande
Slide 58: VI. Conclusion – Bob Evans: The Clear Choice
VI. Conclusion – Bob Evans: The Clear Choice
Slide 59: We Are the Right Team for Bob Evans and its Stockholders
We Believe We are the Right Team for Bob Evans and its Stockholders We have transformed the business while returning over $800 million to shareholders since FY07 (including over $250 million in FY14): o Divested Mimi's Café o Invested in BER restaurants (Farm Fresh Refresh program) o Consolidated an
Slide 60: The Choice is Clear
The Choice is Clear Stockholders have a clear choice between what we believe are two very different approaches for Bob Evans’ future: Sustainable, Disciplined, Unsustainable, Not in the Best Interest of All Responsible, Open-Minded Stockholders Continue to drive profitable growth of existing Divest
Slide 61: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 62: Bob Evans' Highly Qualified Director Nominees
Bob Evans’ Highly Qualified Director Nominees Kevin M. Sheehan, 60, Independent Director – Director since 2014 Experience: o President and Chief Executive Officer of Norwegian Cruise Line, since 2010. o Chief Executive Officer of Norwegian Cruise Line since 2008, Chief Financial Officer of Norwegian
Slide 63: Bob Evans' Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont'd)
Bob Evans’ Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont’d) Kathleen S. Lane, 57, Independent Director – Director since 2014 Experience: o Executive Vice President and Chief Information Officer of TJX Companies, Inc., a specialty multi-national apparel retailer with leading retail brands such as T-J-Maxx
Slide 64: Bob Evans' Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont'd)
Bob Evans’ Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont’d) Eileen A. Mallesch, 58, Independent Director – Director since 2008 Experience: o Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Nationwide Property & Casualty Insurance, a $16 billion property & casualty insurance company (Nationwide Insur
Slide 65: Bob Evans' Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont'd)
Bob Evans’ Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont’d) Steven A. Davis, 56, Chairman & CEO – Director since 2006 Experience: o Chairman of the Board of Bob Evans Farms, Inc. since September 2006. o Chief Executive Officer of Bob Evans Farms, Inc. since May 2006. o President, Long John Silver’s and A
Slide 66: Bob Evans' Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont'd)
Bob Evans’ Highly Qualified Director Nominees (cont’d) Michael J. Gasser, 63, Lead Independent Director – Director since 1997 Experience: o Executive Chairman of the Board of Greif Inc., a manufacturer of shipping containers and containerboard, since 2012. o Chief Executive Officer and Chairman of t
Slide 67: Substantial Progress Made Remediating Material Weaknesses
Substantial Progress Made Remediating Material Weaknesses Complex Transactions Fixed Assets Taxes Errors concerning complex or • Open reconciling items for • Unreconciled deferred fixed Material infrequent transactions - cost basis and accumulated asset and current stock Weakness Mimi’s Café disposi
Slide 68: Historical SG&A Reconciliation
Historical SG&A Reconciliation FY09 FY10 (1) FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 Net Sales 1,750,512 1,726,904 1,676,906 1,654,413 1,608,909 1,328,552 SG&A 152,952 139,419 146,098 144,342 153,672 144,587 % of Sales 8.7% 8.1% 8.7% 8.7% 9.6% 10.9% BEF Transportation in SG&A 10,232 10,561 10,034 12,548 11,426 17,109 B
Slide 69: FY15 Guidance Bridge
FY15 Guidance Bridge Guidance Issued on 3/4/14 2015 EPS Guidance EPS $2.80 - $3.30 Same Store Sales Growth of 3.0% to 3.5% Sow Costs $70 per hundred weight Revised Guidance Adjustments to Early Guidance Normalized EPS Sow Costs $85 per hundred weight ($0.41) EPS $1.90 - $2.20 Same Store Sales Growth
Slide 70: Reconciliation of Adjusted EBITDA (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted EBITDA (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) April 25, 2014 ($ in thousands) BER BEF GAAP Segments as Reported April 25, 2014 Net Sales $956,579 $371,973 ($ in thousands) Cost of Sales 244,871 204,199 BER BEF Operating Wages and Fringe Benefits 360,646 40,609 Non-