Intevac — Proxy Contest (April 2014)
45 slides from Intevac's proxy contest presentation, Apr 21, 2014
Slide 1: t t © Voce Capital Management; April 2014
0 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t © Voce Capital Management; April 2014
Slide 2: Intevac, Inc. Accountability at Last
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Intevac, Inc. Accountability at Last April 2014
Slide 3: Table of Contents
2 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Table of Contents ▪ Summary 3 ▪ Our independent nominees 7 ▪ Long - term underperformance 11 ▪ Poor capital allocation 18 ▪ Inefficient capital structure 24 ▪ Weak and ineffective corporate governance 29 ▪ Conclusion 41 ▪ Sources 44 Section Page
Slide 4: Summary
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Summary
Slide 5: About Voce
4 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t About Voce ▪ Voce Capital Management is an employee - owned investment manager ▪ Advisor to Voce Catalyst Partners LP, which owns 117,325 shares (0.5%) of Intevac stock ▪ J. Daniel Plants is the founder of Voce and one of Voce’s nominees ▪ Voce’s
Slide 6: Why we invested in Intevac
5 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ We invested in Intevac because we believe it is undervalued – substantial assets include : ▪ Dominant hard disk drive (HDD) business ▪ Photonics unit with differentiated technology ▪ Significant cash ($ 81 million) ▪ Yet in the last 10 years,* I
Slide 7: Executive summary (continued)
6 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ The Board’s actions have been reactive and inadequate ▪ Hastily announced capital return plan ▪ Appointment of a lone new director ▪ Modest reduction in operating expenses ▪ Revolving door of management ▪ The current Board should be: ▪ Held acco
Slide 8: Our independent nominees
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Our independent nominees
Slide 9: Marc T. Giles
8 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Marc T. Giles Mr . Giles was the President and CEO of Gerber Scientific, Inc . (NYSE : GRB), a conglomerate of technology - focused businesses, from 2001 until February 2012 . Prior to joining Gerber, Mr . Giles served in several senior positions
Slide 10: Joseph V. Lash
9 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Joseph V. Lash Mr . Lash is the Managing Member of VT Capital, LLC, a private equity investment firm, which he founded in 2010 . Prior to that, he was a senior executive with Tontine Associates, LLC, a private investment partnership and held a num
Slide 11: J. Daniel Plants
10 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t J. Daniel Plants Mr . Plants is the founder and Managing Partner of Voce Capital Management . Prior to Voce, he served as a Managing Director and Head of Communications Technology and Media for Needham & Company LLC and held a number of positions
Slide 12: Long-term underperformance
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Long - term underperformance
Slide 13: Intevac snapshot: a mini conglomerate
12 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t 3 businesses reported in two different segments ▪ C ore HDD business: highly attractive ▪ Market share (60%) and technology leader ▪ Cyclical business ▪ Near break - even at trough of cycle ▪ Cumulative >$200mm in profit over last 10 years ▪ Phot
Slide 14: Substantial value destruction
13 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t $0.00 $5.00 $10.00 $15.00 $20.00 $25.00 $30.00 $35.00 Stock price Substantial value destruction… Mid 2009: Enters solar market 2007: Enters 45nm etch market after failing to gain traction in 65nm 2006: Enters 65nm etch semiconductor market 1/07:
Slide 15: Relative underperformance
14 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t -100% -50% 0% 50% 100% 150% 200% IVAC Peer group IWM QQQ …relative underperformance… QQQ IVAC IWM Peer group Note: November 21, 2003 through November 21, 2013, the date on which Intevac announced it was adopting part of Voce’s recomme nda tion fo
Slide 16: What Intevac predicted versus results
15 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Division What Intevac predicted Solar Solar will be a $2.1 billion market by 2013 and a $3 billion market by 2015 x Intevac dramatically overestimated the market and now forecasts a market that will grow to $200 million in 2017 2012 was to "be th
Slide 17: Profligate spending
16 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t …and profligate spending... -50 0 50 100 150 200 250 Equipment: HDD Equipment: all other Photonics Corporate Total Cumulative 10 year operating profit ($mm) Over the last 10 years, Intevac spent more than the $200 million in operating profit it g
Slide 18: Depressed valuation
17 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t …leading to a depressed valuation. Prior to Voce’s involvement, the markets assigned only $44mm to all three businesses combined:* Hard Disk Drive Photonics Solar $40mm to $200mm cumulative operating income through 2017** $37mm of revenue & cash
Slide 19: Poor capital allocation
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Poor capital allocation
Slide 20: Intevac has siphoned HDD profits into costly investments
19 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Business Investment Revenue Status Solar >$70mm Negligible Currently spending $5mm per year to maintain platform until market returns Semiconductor ~$80mm Negligible Sold business for ~$3mm Photonics >$50mm $37mm in 2013 Achieved break-even opera
Slide 21: Intevac's Solar eclipse
20 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t [P]eople will always buy technology [regardless of overcapacity] if it can …lower their costs. And that is our strategy in this industry. – Former CEO Fairbairn** ▪ Consistently overestimated market size and revenue ramp ▪ Previously estimated th
Slide 22: Intevac's Solar eclipse (continued)
21 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Poor execution ▪ Failed in efforts to share cost burden ▪ Licensing ▪ Partnerships ▪ Customer reimbursements for bespoke engineering (NRE) ▪ Pursued as many as five different technology platforms rather than focusing efforts ▪ Pressured enginee
Slide 23: Solar is only the most recent example: Semiconductor
22 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t “[W]e would feel more comfortable…in less critical, more cost sensitive [65nm] dielectric etch…, but here, the company already failed to win customer adoption.” * ▪ Overestimated revenue ▪ Predicted it could capture 10% of $2.5b market ▪ Poor bus
Slide 24: Solar is only the most recent example: Photonics and DeltaNu
23 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Projecting $100mm in long term revenue since at least 2007 ▪ Attempted and failed to penetrate commercial market ▪ Projected $45mm to $60mm of revenue ▪ Lack of synergies with existing products ▪ Attempted and failed to enter the medical diagno
Slide 25: Inefficient capital structure
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Inefficient capital structure
Slide 26: Intevac is overcapitalized
25 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% Cash and equivalents / market capitalization 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% Cash and equivalents / total assets Intevac is overcapitalized Note: Comprised of the peer group from Intevac’s 2014 proxy statement *
Slide 27: Retaining excess cash has destroyed shareholder value
26 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Excess capital has adversely affected Intevac by: ▪ Tempting the Board to gamble on massive, speculative ventures ▪ Excusing expense laxity ▪ Limiting negotiating leverage with customers ▪ Reducing returns on capital and equity ▪ A cash buffer
Slide 28: A purely reactive buyback announcement
27 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t A purely reactive buyback announcement… $0.00 $5.00 $10.00 $15.00 $20.00 $25.00 $30.00 $35.00 Stock price No capital returned to shareholders Voce first suggests it may nominate directors Intevac suddenly announces open market share repurchase pr
Slide 29: Squandering a golden opportunity to retire shares
28 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t 0.0x 0.5x 1.0x 1.5x 2.0x 2.5x Price / book value …squandering a golden opportunity to retire shares Intevac suddenly announces first open market share repurchase program Voce first suggests it may nominate directors Voce first meets with Intevac
Slide 30: Weak and ineffective corporate governance
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Weak and ineffective corporate governance
Slide 31: The Board faces many crucial questions
30 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ What is Intevac actually spending on the Solar business? * ▪ Is the expense reduction to $5mm per year enough ? ▪ What alternative business models could be used to reduce/shift solar costs? ▪ What milestones does the Solar business need to hit
Slide 32: Still more crucial questions
31 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Capital allocation ▪ How much current excess cash should be returned to shareholders? ▪ What is the best mechanism to return cash, especially given the recent run in the stock price? ▪ What should Intevac do with proceeds as it harvests its bus
Slide 33: Accountability is long overdue
32 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Accountability is long overdue These three senior directors have an average tenure of 10 years on the Board and hold three of the Board’s five leadership positions * Through November 21, 2013, the date on which Intevac announced it was adopting p
Slide 34: David S. Dury
33 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Has history of leading boards that destroy shareholder value ▪ Was successfully targeted for removal by shareholders as Chairman of Phoenix Technologies LTD in 2007 ▪ Phoenix was criticized for: ▪ Long - term underperformance ▪ ~50% decrease in
Slide 35: Stanley J. Hill
34 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ “Independent” technically, but not substantively ▪ Mr. Hill was CEO of Kaiser Aerospace and Electronics Corporation ▪ Kaiser provided Chairman Pond with the majority of the equity financing to found Intevac in 1991 ▪ Mr. Hill was appointed to t
Slide 36: Ping Yang
35 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Bears responsibility for Intevac’s long - term track record ▪ Joined Board in 2006 as Intevac embarked on its semiconductor adventure ▪ Chair of Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee ▪ Stale and limited experience ▪ Does not hold any ot
Slide 37: The Board reacts only to shareholder pressure
36 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t $4.50 $5.00 $5.50 $6.00 $6.50 $7.00 $7.50 $8.00 $8.50 $9.00 Stock price The Board reacts only to shareholder pressure 06/13: Initial meetings between Voce and IVAC; IVAC unwilling to repurchase shares 11/19/13: IVAC reiterates opposition to share
Slide 38: Adding one director was reactionary and insufficient
37 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Intevac’s appointment of Matthew Drapkin on December 10 was in response to pressure applied by Voce ▪ Voce informed the Company on November 25 and on November 27 that it was contemplating nominating directors ▪ Intevac postponed the nomination
Slide 39: Current board dynamics don't favor change
38 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Age 75 65 72 61 63 71 40 0 5 10 15 20 25 Mr. Pond Mr. Dury Mr. Hill Dr. Yang Mr. Rohrs Mr. Schaefer Mr. Drapkin Years served Director Current board dynamics don’t favor change Average service: 10 years Cumulative service: 61 years Average age: 68
Slide 40: How does Intevac's Board view governance and shareholder rights?
39 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ The Board’s description of Voce’s efforts on behalf of shareholders are apparently viewed as a risk to the Company ▪ Yet interestingly Mr. Drapkin doesn’t warrant the same level of concern… ▪ Is it because as a lone member he will be limited in
Slide 41: Conclusion
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Conclusion
Slide 42: Conclusion: Making a difference
41 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t ▪ Providing missing skillsets ▪ Public company CEO experience ▪ Capital markets expertise ▪ Capital allocation experience ▪ Reinvigorating the Board ▪ Removing over - tenured directors ▪ Placing multiple change agents on the Board ▪ Providing fre
Slide 43: Legal Disclaimer
42 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Legal Disclaimer THIS PRESENTATION INCLUDES INFORMATION BASED ON DATA FOUND IN FILINGS WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION, INDEPENDENT INDUSTRY PUBLICATIONS AND OTHER SOURCES . ALTHOUGH VOCE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT LLC, ITS AFFILIATES AND NOM
Slide 44: Sources
voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Sources
Slide 45: Sources
44 voce capital r e s e a r c h | m a n a g e m e n t Sources ▪ Page 12: S&P Capital IQ; Intevac Investor Presentation; Form 10 - K; Transcripts ▪ Page 13: Forms 10 - K; Transcripts; Sell - side research ▪ Page 15: Transcripts ▪ Page 16: Intevac Investor Presentation; Forms 10 - K ▪ Page 17: Transcr