Lubys — Proxy Contest (January 2019)
59 slides from Lubys's proxy contest presentation, Jan 8, 2019
Slide 1: Luby's, Inc. Investor Presentation January 2019
Luby’s, Inc. Investor Presentation January 2019
Slide 2: Disclaimer and forward-looking statements
The views expressed in this presentation (this “Presentation”) represent the opinion of Luby’s , Inc. (“ Luby’s ” or the “Company”). This Presentation is for informational purposes only, and it does not have regard to the specific investment objective, financial situations, suitabil ity or particula
Slide 3: Table of Contents
• Executive Summary • Company Overview • Industry Trends & Challenges • Strategy & Performance • The Right Leadership and Board • Engagement with Bandera • Bandera’s Nominees • Appendix o Correspondence with Bandera o Bandera’s Activist Track Record Table of Contents 3
Slide 4: Executive Summary
Executive Summary x Change is already underway at Luby’s and the Board and management team are executing on an aggressive turnaround plan to improve the Company’s financial results and operating performance. Elements of the plan include: x Raise awareness of Luby’s brands x Strengthen core operation
Slide 5: Company Overview
Company Overview *Please note that Luby’s doesn’t receive revenue or royalties from the 37 locations in the Middle East, but these locations reflect the reach of Luby’s brands globally 5 • Founded in 1947 • Listed on NYSE since 1982 (NYSE:LUB) • Headquarters: Houston, Texas • Market Capitalization:
Slide 6: Luby's Operates Several Valuable Restaurant Concepts
Luby’s Operates Several Valuable Restaurant Concepts • An 11 - year old brand founded in Houston • 30 locations as of 11/7/2018 • $25.8M in Annual Revenues for Fiscal 2018 • Provides food service management as an amenity to healthcare, higher education, and corporate dining facilities • A 38 - year
Slide 7: Luby's Brands Resonate with Loyal Customers
#16 Luby’s Brands Resonate with Loyal Customers 63% Source: “Top brands ranked by customer loyalty" Consumer Picks 2018, Nation's Restaurant News, Oct 2018 Source: “Top 10 taste winners” Consumer Picks 2018, Nation's Restaurant News, Oct 2018 Luby’s Restaurant brand ranks in the top 20 nationally in
Slide 8: Industry Trends & Challenges
Industry Trends & Challenges
Slide 9: Industry and Business Have Faced Recent Pressures
Industry and Business Have Faced Recent Pressures The broader casual dining industry has been extremely competitive in 2018 – two year stacked trends in comparable sales and traffic remain below historical trends . • Casual dining chains are facing pressure from fast food chains, independents, groce
Slide 10: An Evolving Casual Dining Landscape
An Evolving Casual Dining Landscape “Negative traffic trends continue across the industry which is relying mostly on pricing. Bar and grill competitors have been aggressive on drinks (especially alcohol, e.g., Applebee’s) and bundled value (e.g., Chili’s), so deal seekers are shifting around.” (11.1
Slide 11: Leadership Steered Company Through Previous Downturns
• In 2009, Luby’s felt the impact of a challenging macroeconomic environment that affected both customer frequency and the amount they spent • Same - store sales declined 8.6% in fiscal 2009 primarily due to declining traffic and dining frequency • Store - level profit decreased to 10.7% in fiscal 2
Slide 12: Leadership Steered Company Through Previous Difficult Periods
Luby’s Leadership has Successfully Steered the Company through Previous Difficult Periods in the Restaurant Industry 12 $ 4.3 0 $ 9.16 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Delivered an Improvement in Same - Store Sales Streamlined Operations and Acquired Fuddruckers brand Reduced Debt - 8.60% - 7.40% 2.50% 2.20% -10.
Slide 13: Strategy & Performance
Strategy & Performance
Slide 14: Our Strategy
Our Strategy: Generate consistent and sustainable same - store sales growth and improved store level profitability to deliver increased shareholder value 14 Maintain Strong Corporate Governance Raise Awareness of Our Brands 1 Strengthen Our Core Operations Optimize the Business for the Future 2 3 4
Slide 15: Raising Awareness of Our Brands
Raising Awareness of Our Brands x Developed new menu options for both our Luby’s Cafeterias and Fuddruckers brands x Made further improvements in mobile ordering capabilities at Fuddruckers and geared up for launching similar capabilities for our Luby’s Cafeteria guests x Partnered with third party
Slide 16: Strengthening Our Core Operations
Strengthening Our Core Operations x Generated 1.5% increase in same - store sales at Luby’s Cafeterias in fiscal 2018 x Luby’s Cafeterias same - store sales increased 3.9% in 4Q18, driven by a 10.3% increase in average spend per guest x Discontinued certain discounting and promotional offers used in
Slide 17: Optimizing the Business for the Future
Optimizing the Business for the Future x Closed 21 underperforming Company - owned restaurants in fiscal 2018 with 13 of those locations closing in the last month of the fiscal year x Closed an additional 6 restaurants subsequent to the end of the fiscal year x Announced an asset sales program of $2
Slide 18: Maintain Strong Corporate Governance
Maintain Strong Corporate Governance x Strong independent chairman presides over Board x Management / Pappas family’s beneficial ownership of approximately 38% of the Company ensures the strongest possible alignment of interests with ALL shareholders x All directors are expected to accumulate shares
Slide 19: Best path to unlocking value is executing the turnaround plan
The best path to unlocking the value of the Luby’s enterprise is to execute against the Board’s turnaround plan, improve results and enhance the stock price. Taking short - term focused actions would be doing shareholders a disservice over the long - term. 19
Slide 20: The Right Leadership and Board
The Right Leadership and Board
Slide 21: Luby's Highly-Qualified Directors and Nominees
Christopher J. Pappas – President & CEO • CEO of Pappas Restaurants, Inc. since 1980 • Director emeritus of the National Restaurant Association • Co - founder and operator of more than 90 restaurants during 40 - year career, including Pappadeaux Seafood Kitchen, Pappasitos Cantina, and Pappas Bros.
Slide 22: The Right Experience and Expertise
Director Restaurant Industry Experience Public Company Board Service Financial, Audit & Accounting Background Management / Operational Experience Stock Ownership / Alignment w/ Stockholders Jill Griffin Christopher J. Pappas Judith B. Craven Frank Markantonis Twila M. Day* Gasper Mir, III Joe C. McK
Slide 23: Twila M. Day
Twila M. Day Independent Experienced Year Nominated 2018 Restaurant / Food Services Industry Experience Served as Chief Information Officer at SYSCO Corporation, a global leader in distributing food products to restaurants from 2006 to 2013 Leads overall strategy, execution, and management of Huntsm
Slide 24: The Directors Bandera Seeks to Remove
The Directors Bandera Seeks to Remove RESTAURANT INDUSTRY EXPERT Director emeritus of the National Restaurant Association and cofounder and operator of more than 90 restaurants during career, including Pappadeaux Seafood Kitchen, Pappasitos Cantina, and Pappas Bros. Steakhouse Has been President and
Slide 25: Committed to Strong Corporate Governance Practices
Committed to Strong Corporate Governance Practices x Separate Chairman/CEO x Strong independent Chairman of the Board x Declassified Board x Majority vote standard x No overboarded directors x 6 independent directors (two - thirds of the Board)* x 3 female directors (one - third of the Board)* x Ask
Slide 26: Stockholders rights plan
• In February 2018, Board unanimously adopted a stockholders rights plan after Chris and Harris Pappas substantially increased their stakes in 2017 to more than 34% • The rights plan was not adopted in response to any takeover bid or in reaction to Bandera or another activist – it was enacted to pro
Slide 27: Bandera's Involvement
Bandera’s Involvement
Slide 28: Luby's engagement with Bandera's demands
• After receiving Bandera’s initial demands, Luby’s extended its nomination deadline as a courtesy to Bandera. • In response, Bandera sent a proposed settlement term sheet with a 48 - hour expiration deadline (see Appendix A ). No public company can responsibly make such a decision in 48 hours, espe
Slide 29: Luby's Repeatedly Attempted to Engage Constructively with Bandera
Luby’s Repeatedly Attempted to Engage Constructively with Bandera 29 • After receiving Bandera’s demand for a list of all shareholders, Luby’s agreed to provide the information subject to the signing of a confidentiality agreement intended to protect the privacy of shareholders, many of whom are ret
Slide 30: Luby's History of Engagement with Bandera
Luby’s History of Engagement with Bandera Date Key Event Nov. 17, 2017 Bandera filed a Schedule 13D disclosing ownership of 5.2%. Oct. 30, 2018 Bandera disclosed an ownership of 6.2%. Nov. 2, 2018 Nine days prior to the Company's director nomination deadline, Bandera called Peter Tropoli , Luby’s Ge
Slide 31: Luby's History of Engagement with Bandera
Luby’s History of Engagement with Bandera Date Key Event Nov. 27, 2018 Bandera issued a public letter to the Board raising a number of criticisms Bandera had not previously shared with the Board or management. Bandera also disclosed ownership of 8.9%. Nov. 29, 2018 The Board met to consider all six
Slide 32: Bandera's Nominees
Bandera’s Nominees
Slide 33: Bandera's Nominees – It's Personal
STACY HOCK Philanthropist and co - owner of Hock, LLC SAVNEET SINGH Interim CEO at PAR Technology Corporation, Partner at Tera Holdings, Inc. and Partner at CoVenture 33 Jointly filed an Amicus Curiae brief in a 2014 education case that was heard before the Texas Supreme Court Serves on board of Tex
Slide 34: Bandera's Nominees Lack Necessary Expertise
Bandera’s Nominees Lack Necessary Expertise Nominee Restaurant Industry Experience Public Company Board Service Financial, Audit & Accounting Background Management / Operational Experience Stock Ownership / Alignment w/ Stockholders Jeff Gramm Phil Gramm Stacy Hock Savneet Singh 34
Slide 35: Bandera's Nominees Lack Necessary Expertise and Independence
Bandera’s Nominees Lack Necessary Expertise and Independence Jefferson Gramm Managing Director, Managing Partner and Portfolio Manager at Bandera Partners LLC Senator William Philip Gramm Former Texas Senator ₓ Limited restaurant experience and mixed at best record of shareholder value creation ₓ TS
Slide 36: Does Mr. Singh Have Time to Serve on Luby's Board?
Does Mr. Singh Have Time to Effectively Serve on Luby’s Board? While Mr. Singh might be accomplished in the technology space and qualified for a seat on the board of a startup tech company, he lacks applicable industry knowledge and experience for a restaurant company like Luby’s. Further, we questi
Slide 37: Mr. Singh's boards defaulted on reporting requirements
• Mr. Singh currently serves on the board of two companies – LottoGopher Holdings Inc. and Blockchain Power Trust – that have defaulted on their financial reporting requirements during his tenure • A December 3, 2018 press release announced that LottoGopher’s CFO had resigned, its accounting firm te
Slide 38: Was Ms. Hock Involved In Questionable Campaign Activities?
• Ms. Hock has served as the Board Chairman for Texans for Education Opportunity since May 2016 and has been on the board since April 2015 This potentially unethical and questionable campaign that took place during Ms. Hock’s directorship should raise questions for Luby’s shareholders Source: http:/
Slide 39: Concerns about Senator Gramm's background
• A March 8, 2017 Politico article suggests that Gramm is engaged in shadow lobbying activities for Lone Star Funds without disclosing his status as a lobbyist • During Gramm’s tenure as Vice Chairman of UBS Investment Bank, the bank reached a $19.4 billion agreement with state and federal regulator
Slide 40: Should Shareholders Really Trust Jeff Gramm and Bandera?
• The dismal track record of Mr. Gramm and his fund Bandera does not support the contention that the election of him and his nominees would be in the best interests of ALL shareholders (see Appendix E for the performance of Bandera’s recent portfolio companies) • The perplexing , inconsistent and at
Slide 41: Don't Take it From Us…
“Over time, I’ve learned that I’m much better suited to finding good investment ideas than managing activist interventions or serving on corporate boards. ” – Jeff Gramm, page xix “Earlier in my career, I fancied that I was a constructive activist who collaborated with good management teams. It didn
Slide 42: Jeff Gramm's Only Consumer-Focused Board Experience
Jeff Gramm’s Only Consumer - Focused Board Experience Does Not Inspire Confidence $6.50 $7.00 $7.50 $8.00 $8.50 $9.00 $9.50 $10.00 2/11/2014 2/11/2015 2/11/2016 2/11/2017 2/11/2018 Tandy Leather Factory 2/11/14: Mr. Gramm joins the Board Source: Bloomberg as of 12/19/18 42
Slide 43: Bandera's Disastrous Proxy Contest Against Fiesta Restaurant Group
• In 2017, Bandera formed a group with other activists to wage a proxy fight against Fiesta Restaurant Group • Each of ISS, Glass Lewis and Egan - Jones recommended in favor of Fiesta’s Board and against the director candidates of the Bandera group • With one of the highest vote margins in proxy con
Slide 44: Bandera's Disastrous Proxy Contest against Fiesta Restaurant Group
Sources: Company filings, FactSet , Yahoo! Finance • 09 - 19 - 16: Bandera and its group filed Schedule 13D and disclosed intent to engage regarding capital allocation, corporate governance, and strategic plans • 01 - 30 - 17: Nominated three candidates for election at the 2017 annual meeting and re
Slide 45: Is Bandera Taking the Proxy Contest Seriously?
• Luby’s enjoys the Holiday Season as much as anyone, but we believe Bandera’s cartoonish approach calls into question Bandera’s credibility • We also find it concerning that when describing his “qualifications” Jeff Gramm spent three words on his investing experience and 22 words on his academic an
Slide 46: Timothy Brog as proposed director
Bandera’s initial settlement proposal set forth Mr. Timothy Brog as a director. When a settlement was not reached, Bandera indicated in its formal nomination notice its intent to nominate a majority slate of six director candidates, one of whom was Mr. Brog . • Brog is another cohort of Mr. Gramm: t
Slide 47: Shareholder contacts and proxy solicitor
Shareholders Media Sloane & Company Dan Zacchei / Joe Germani, 212 - 486 - 9500 [email protected] / [email protected] If you have any questions or require any assistance with respect to voting your shares, please contact the Company’s proxy solicitor using the information listed below: 509 M
Slide 48: Appendix
Appendix
Slide 49: Appendix A: Settlement Agreement Term Sheet
49 Appendix A: Settlement Agreement Term Sheet
Slide 50: Appendix B: Bandera Email on November
50 Appendix B: Bandera Email on November 12
Slide 51: Appendix C: Letter from Bandera's Counsel to Luby's Counsel
51 Appendix C: Letter from Bandera’s Counsel to Luby’s Counse l on December 3
Slide 52: Appendix D: Luby's Counsel Letter to Bandera's Counsel
52 Appendix D: Luby’s Counsel Letter to Bandera’s Counsel on December 9
Slide 53: Appendix E: Bandera's Activist Track Record
53 Appendix E: Bandera’s Activist Track Record
Slide 54: Bandera's Activist Investment in Tix Corporation (2018)
54 Bandera’s Activist Investment in Tix Corporation (2018) Sources: Company filings, FactSet , Yahoo! Finance Letter to board • 07 - 18 - 18: Sent letter to board stating that sale of company to MGM Resorts was in the best interests of shareholders • Claimed Bandera would act to protect the best int
Slide 55: Bandera's Activist Investment in PICO Holdings (2017–2018)
55 Bandera’s Activist Investment in PICO Holdings, Inc. (2017 – 2018) Sources: Company filings, FactSet , Yahoo! Finance • 01 - 30 - 17: PICO filed a Form 8 - K with the SEC announcing that Gregory Bylinsky would be nominated by the company to stand for election as a director at the company’s next a
Slide 56: Bandera's Activist Investment in Morgan's Foods (2013–2014)
56 Bandera’s Activist Investment in Morgan’s Foods, Inc. (2013 – 2014) • 04 - 22 - 13: Bandera filed an initial Schedule 13D reporting ownership of 26.4% of the company and entry into a share purchase agreement, which provided for, among other things, the appointment of Jefferson Gramm to the board
Slide 57: Bandera's Activist Investment in Kenneth Cole Productions (2012)
57 Bandera’s Activist Investment in Kenneth Cole Productions (2012) Sources: Company filings, FactSet , Yahoo! Finance • 05 - 18 - 12: Public letter urging special committee to reject unsolicited take - private offer from Mr. Kenneth Cole at $15/share • 06 - 06 - 12: The board agreed to a $15.25 off
Slide 58: Bandera's Activist Investment in Ambassadors Group (2012–2015)
58 Bandera’s Activist Investment in Ambassadors Group, Inc. (2012 – 2015) Sources: Company filings, FactSet , Yahoo! Finance • 08 - 10 - 11: Files Schedule 13G reporting 5.6% stake • 02 - 10 - 12: Files Schedule 13D reporting 12.1% stake • 04 - 02 - 12: Urged board to settle with activist Lane Five
Slide 59: Bandera's Activist Investment in Tandy Leather Factory (2011–2014)
59 Bandera’s Activist Investment in Tandy Leather Factory, Inc. (2011 – 2014) Sources: Company filings, FactSet , Yahoo! Finance • 01 - 19 - 11: Bandera filed an initial Schedule 13D reporting ownership of 24.5% of the company • 01 - 03 - 14: Bandera filed Amendment No. 4 to it Schedule 13D providin