Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — Technical Presentation (April 2018)
39 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's technical presentation, April 2018
Slide 1: Estimating Macroeconomic Models of Financial Crises: An Endogenous Regime-Switching Approach
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Estimating Macroeconomic Models of Financial Crises: An Endogenous Regime-Switching Approach Gianluca Benigno1 Andrew Foerster2 Christopher Otrok3 Alessandro Rebucci4 1 London School of Economics and CEPR 2 Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas
Slide 2: Motivation
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Motivation • Global Financial Crisis Proved Costly to Resolve • Long History of Painful Financial Crises in Emerging Markets • Large Theoretical Literature in Response • Models of Collateral Constraints for Amplification of Shocks • Norma
Slide 3: The Objective of this Paper
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion The Objective of this Paper • Formulate a Model with Occasionally Binding Constraint • Quantitative Analysis of Financial Crises in Mexico • Address Several Questions • Which Shocks Drive Crises? The Same Ones that Drive Normal Cycle? • I
Slide 4: Pre-Crisis and Post-Crisis Consensus on Methodology
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Pre-Crisis and Post-Crisis Consensus on Methodology • Pre-Crisis: Medium Scale Estimated DSGE Models • Estimate Importance of Shocks and Frictions • Analyze Policy Questions in this Fully Specified Empirical Framework • Post-Crisis: Calib
Slide 5: This Paper
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion This Paper • New Approach to Specifying, Solving, Estimating Models of Crises • Financial Crises Rare but Large Events, so Model Must be Non-Linear • Provide a Tractable Formulation of Collateral Constraint • Develop Methods to Solve and
Slide 6: Output and Debt in Mexico
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Output and Debt in Mexico Output 0.05 0 -0.05 -0.1 -0.15 Q1-85 Q1-90 Q1-95 Q1-00 Q1-05 Q1-10 Q1-15 Debt-to-Output Ratio -0.4 -0.6 -0.8 -1 -1.2 Q1-85 Q1-90 Q1-95 Q1-00 Q1-05 Q1-10 Q1-15
Slide 7: Outline of Talk
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Outline of Talk • Introduction • Model • Standard Open Economy Preferences and Production • Collateral Constraint as Endogenous Regime-Switching • Solution and Estimation • Solving the Endogenous Switching Model • Importance of Non-Linear
Slide 8: Model Overview
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Model Overview • Small Open Economy that Borrows from Abroad • Imported Goods used in Production • Working Capital Constraint for Labor and Import Payments • Value of Capital Serves as Collateral • Pecuniary Externality and Overborrowing
Slide 9: Preferences and Production
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Preferences and Production • Representative Household-Firm with Preferences ∞ ( 1− ρ ) 1 Hω U ≡ E0 ∑ βt Ct − t t =0 1−ρ ω • Production uses Capital, Labor, and Imported Intermediate Goods η 1− α − η Yt = At Kt −1 Htα Vt • Investment with
Slide 10: Collateral Constraint: Motivation
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Collateral Constraint: Motivation • The Agent Faces a Regime-Specific Collateral Constraint • When st = 1, in the Crisis Regime and Borrowing is Constrained • When st = 0, in the Normal Regime and Borrowing is Unconstrained • Internationa
Slide 11: Collateral Constraint: Crisis Regime
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Collateral Constraint: Crisis Regime • In Crisis Regime, Total Borrowing is a Fraction of Value of Collateral 1 Bt − φ (1 + rt ) (Wt Ht + Pt Vt ) = −κt qt Kt (1 + rt ) • Debt and Working Capital Restricted • Collateral in the Model is Def
Slide 12: Collateral Constraint: Normal Regime
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Collateral Constraint: Normal Regime • In Normal Regime, Borrowing is Unconstrained • Collateral Value is Sufficient for International Lenders to Finance all Desired Borrowing • No Explicit Constraint on Borrowing • Two Forces Limiting In
Slide 13: Endogenous Switching
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Endogenous Switching • In Normal Regime, Probability that Constraint Binds or Not Next Period Depends on Borrowing Cushion and Monitoring Shock st +1 = Γ etM+1 |st = 0, Bt∗ • In Crisis Regime, Probability that Constraint Binds or Not Next
Slide 14: Endogenous Switching
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Endogenous Switching • Assume that etM+1 Distributed to Induce Logistic Distributions exp (−γ0 Bt∗ ) Pr (st +1 = 1|st = 0) = 1 + exp (−γ0 Bt∗ ) exp (−γ1 λt ) Pr (st +1 = 0|st = 1) = 1 + exp (−γ1 λt ) • Logistic is Common, Parsimonious For
Slide 15: Form of the Logistic Function
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Form of the Logistic Function Prob(s t+1 =0|s t =0,B *t ) 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 . = 1000 0 . 0 = 100 0.1 .0 = 0 0 -0.1 -0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 B *t
Slide 16: Regime Switching Slackness Condition
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Regime Switching Slackness Condition • “Typical” Slackness Condition is Bt∗ λt = 0 • Need to Adapt to Regime-Switching Framework • Introduce Indicator Variables ϕ (st ) = ν (st ) = st • Regime Switching Slackness Condition ∗ ϕ (st ) Bss +
Slide 17: Timing of the Model
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Timing of the Model t t+1 Agents enter knowing Realize the regime 𝑠𝑠𝑡𝑡 Realize shocks to Make decisions that pin lagged states and a which determines exogenous processes, down 𝐵𝐵𝑡𝑡∗ and λt, which probability distribution whether…
Slide 18: Interest Rates and Exogenous Processes
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Interest Rates and Exogenous Processes • Interest Rate Process rt = r ∗ + ψr e B̄ −Bt − 1 + σr (st ) ε r ,t • Productivity log At = (1 − ρA (st ))a∗ (st ) + ρA (st ) log At −1 + σA (st ) ε A,t • Terms of Trade log Pt = (1 − ρP (st ))p ∗ (
Slide 19: Leverage Shocks
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Leverage Shocks • Interested in Role of Leverage Shocks • Importance as a Cause of Crises • Relative Importance in and Out of Crisis • Stochastic, Regime-Dependent Restrictions on Leverage κt = (1 − ρκ (st ))κ ∗ (st ) + ρκ (st ) κt −1 + σ
Slide 20: Solution
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Solution • Full Set of Equilibrium Conditions • First-Order Conditions • Constraints • Regime-Switching Slackness Condition • Exogenous Processes • Nonlinear Model that Can in Principle be Solved with Global Methods • This Paper: Compute
Slide 21: Properties of the Solution
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Properties of the Solution • Approximation Point Ergodic Mean of Regimes exp(−γ B ∗ ) ∗) exp(−γ0 Bss " # 1 − 1+exp(−0γ0 Bss ∗ ) 1+exp(−γ0 Bss∗) Pss = exp(−γ1 λss ) ss exp(−γ1 λss ) 1+exp(−γ1 λss ) 1 − 1+exp(−γ1 λss ) • General Result: End
Slide 22: Approximation and IRF to TFP Shock
-3 C B (level) Introduction6 #10 Model Solution and 0.04 Estimation Results Conclusion 4 Approximation and IRF 0.02 to TFP Shock 2 0 0 -0.02 0 5 10 15 20 0 5 10 15 20 * B (level) #10 -3 A 0.04 6 Second Order 0.03 First Order 4 0.02 2 0.01 0 0 0 5 10 15 20 0 5 10 15 20
Slide 23: Estimating the Nonlinear Model
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Estimating the Nonlinear Model • Second-Order plus Endogenous Probabilities Complicates Estimation • Rational Expectations • Links Parameters Across Regimes and Economic Behavior • Two-Step Procedures Inappropriate • Agents in the Model F
Slide 24: Data for Estimation
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Data for Estimation • Data for Mexico from 1981Q1 to 2016Q4 • Includes Financial Crises of 1982, 1994, 2007 • Also Periods of Expansion and Recession • Observables • Real GDP Growth • Investment Growth • Consumption Growth • Interest Rate
Slide 25: Quick Recap
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Quick Recap • Set up a Small Open Economy Model • Hit with 4 Types of Shocks • Borrow to Smooth Consumption, Pay for Inputs • As Debt Increases Relative to Capital, Probability of a Crisis Increases • Crisis Constrains Borrowing • Develop
Slide 26: Calibrated Parameters
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Calibrated Parameters Parameter Value Discount Factor β = 0.97959 Risk Aversion ρ=2 Labor Share α = 0.592 Capital Share η = 0.306 Wage Elasticity of Labor Supply ω = 1.846 Capital Depreciation δ = 0.022766 Interest Rate Elasticity ψr = 0.
Slide 27: Estimation Results: Key Structural Parameters
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Estimation Results: Key Structural Parameters Parameter Prior Mean 5% 95% ι Uniform(0,100) 2.8233 2.8144 2.8360 φ Uniform(0,100) 0.3036 0.2697 0.3217 γ0 Uniform(0,1000) 89.0076 73.2143 108.1845 γ1 Uniform(0,1000) 1.9676 0.0892 5.8921 ρa (
Slide 28: Posterior of Logistic Function
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Posterior of Logistic Function Prob(s t+1 =0|st=0,B * t ) 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 Bss 0.1 0 -0.1 -0.08 -0.06 -0.04 -0.02 0 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 B* t
Slide 29: Crises Estimates vs. Reinhart-Rogoff Currency Crisis Dates
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Crises Estimates vs. Reinhart-Rogoff Currency Crisis Dates 1 Smoothed Probability of Binding 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 1981.1 1986.1 1991.1 1996.1 2001.1 2006.1 2011.1 2016.1
Slide 30: Crises Estimates vs. OECD Recession Dates
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Crises Estimates vs. OECD Recession Dates 1 Smoothed Probability of Binding 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 1981.1 1986.1 1991.1 1996.1 2001.1 2006.1 2011.1 2016.1
Slide 31: Transition Prob. vs. Reinhart-Rogoff Currency Crisis Dates
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Transition Prob. vs. Reinhart-Rogoff Currency Crisis Dates 1 Transition Probability of Nonbinding 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 1981.1 1986.1 1991.1 1996.1 2001.1 2006.1 2011.1 2016.1
Slide 32: Estimation Results: Shock Standard Deviations
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Estimation Results: Shock Standard Deviations Parameter Prior Mean 5% 95% σr (0) Uniform(0,1) 0.0007 0.0001 0.0015 σr (1) Uniform(0,1) 0.0438 0.0332 0.0496 σa (0) Uniform(0,1) 0.0056 0.0043 0.0068 σa (1) Uniform(0,1) 0.0091 0.0062 0.0123
Slide 33: Variance Decomposition
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Variance Decomposition Shock Regime C I r Y Interest Rate Shock ε r ,t Non-Binding 0.0001 0.0128 0.0066 0.0000 Technology Shock ε a ,t Non-Binding 0.3087 0.2670 0.6390 0.3158 Import Price Shock ε p ,t Non-Binding 0.6817 0.3777 0.1971 0.68
Slide 34: Crisis Frequency
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Crisis Frequency
Slide 35: What Drives the Crisis Frequency?
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion What Drives the Crisis Frequency? Shock Mean 70% 90% All Shocks 10.99 13 44 Individual Interest Rate Only ε r ,t 0.01 0 0 Technology Only ε a,t 2.07 0 7 Import Price Only ε p,t 4.81 4 17 Leverage Only ε κ,t 3.26 0 0
Slide 36: The Research Agenda: Capital Controls and Crises
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion The Research Agenda: Capital Controls and Crises • Would Different Capital Control Policies help Avoid or Mitigate Crises? • Given Estimated Shocks and Frictions, Regenerate Data with Counterfactual Policy • Consider Specific Rules or Fin
Slide 37: Crisis Frequency with 1% Tax
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Crisis Frequency with 1% Tax
Slide 38: Crisis Frequency with Various Tax Rates
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Crisis Frequency with Various Tax Rates 12 10 Crisis Frequency 8 6 4 2 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 Tax Rate (%)
Slide 39: Conclusion
Introduction Model Solution and Estimation Results Conclusion Conclusion • New Approach to Specifying, Solving, Estimating Models of Financial Crises • Probability Regime Switch Depends on State of Economy • Endogenous Switching Impacts the Economic Behavior in Qualitatively and Quantitatively Impor
Banque Nationale De Belgique — Technical Presentation (April 2018) on 6ix