American Greetings — Merger or Acquisition (July 2013)
19 slides from American Greetings's merger presentation, Jul 22, 2013
Slide 1: Schedule 14A - American Greetings Corporation / Zev Weiss
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a party other than the Registrant x Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy Statement ¨ Conf
Slide 2: The Weiss Family's Perspective
The Weiss Family’s Perspective July 22, 2013
Slide 3: Agenda
1. The Enhanced Price 2. The Family’s View of the Industry and Its Investment 3. The Company’s Q1 Results 4. American Greetings’ Position in the Equity Markets 5. Necessary Capital Redeployment 6. What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down? 1
Slide 4: The Family increased its offer price; the price will not be increased further
The Family increased its offer price after the original definitive agreement was signed; the price will not be increased further • The enhanced price of $19.00 per share represents a 4.4% premium to the original price of $18.20, and a 10.6% increase over the price initially offered by the Family in
Slide 5: The Family's View of the Industry and Its Investment
1. The Enhanced Price 2. The Family’s View of the Industry and Its Investment 3. The Company’s Q1 Results 4. American Greetings’ Position in the Equity Markets 5. Necessary Capital Redeployment 6. What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down? 3
Slide 6: Paper greeting cards industry is facing persistent and accelerating decline
The Company’s core business is paper greeting cards, and the paper greeting cards industry is facing persistent and accelerating decline • The Company’s paper greeting cards business accounts for 74% of revenue. • The paper greeting cards industry has been shrinking since 2007 (2-4% annually). • In
Slide 7: The Family views the merger as necessary to long-term prospects of the Company
The Family views the merger as necessary to the long-term prospects of the Company, not in terms of typical investment metrics • The Family has guided the Company for more than 100 years—because the Family is fully committed to the Company’s long-term viability, it is willing to take the risks inher
Slide 8: The Company's Q1 Results
1. The Enhanced Price 2. The Family’s View of the Industry and Its Investment 3. The Company’s Q1 Results 4. American Greetings’ Position in the Equity Markets 5. Necessary Capital Redeployment 6. What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down? 6
Slide 9: AG's FY 2014 and long-term outlooks have not materially changed
The Family believes that AG’s FY 2014 and long-term outlooks have not materially changed, and that the moderately improved Q1 results have no discernible effect on the trajectory of AG’s core business • The Company’s operations are heavily seasonal, and annual results are largely driven by Q3-Q4 per
Slide 10: American Greetings' Position in the Equity Markets
1. The Enhanced Price 2. The Family’s View of the Industry and Its Investment 3. The Company’s Q1 Results 4. American Greetings’ Position in the Equity Markets 5. Necessary Capital Redeployment 6. What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down? 8
Slide 11: Historical public market performance does not support higher multiples
The Family believes that American Greetings’ historical performance in the public markets does not support the contention that it would trade at higher multiples in the foreseeable future • The Company’s stock trades at low multiples. • 3.5x LTM EBITDA average for 24 months prior to the initial prop
Slide 12: Over $1 billion returned to shareholders, yet stock lagged the consumer index
Despite over $1 billion in cash returned to shareholders since FY 2005, the Company’s stock traded at 3.0-3.5x EBITDA and fell 78% behind the consumer index. • The Family believes that the equity markets have not rewarded the Company for shareholder capital returns. • The Company has returned over $
Slide 13: Necessary Capital Redeployment
1. The Enhanced Price 2. The Family’s View of the Industry and Its Investment 3. The Company’s Q1 Results 4. American Greetings’ Position in the Equity Markets 5. Necessary Capital Redeployment 6. What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down? 11
Slide 14: Capital must be redirected to capital expenditures and electronic channels
The Family believes that capital must be redirected to capital expenditures and investment in electronic channels • The Family believes that capital redeployment is essential; substantial investment is required for all of the following: • advancing the Company’s paper card business in order to overc
Slide 15: Capital must be redirected to capital expenditures and electronic channels
The Family believes that capital must be redirected to capital expenditures and investment in electronic channels • The Family intends to support these investments whether or not the merger is completed. • Contrary to the suggestion of some shareholders, given these capital requirements, the Family
Slide 16: What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down?
1. The Enhanced Price 2. The Family’s View of the Industry and Its Investment 3. The Company’s Q1 Results 4. American Greetings’ Position in the Equity Markets 5. Necessary Capital Redeployment 6. What Happens if the Deal is Turned Down? 14
Slide 17: Further capital deployment to shareholders is not sustainable
The Family believes that further capital deployment to shareholders is not sustainable until American Greetings is fully repositioned for long-term viability • The Family believes that it is important for American Greetings’ unaffiliated shareholders to understand the Family’s commitment to the long
Slide 18: Forward Looking Statements
Forward Looking Statements • Statements about the expected timing, completion and effects of the proposed transaction and all other statements in this communication, other than historical facts, constitute forward-looking statements within the meaning of the safe harbor provisions of the Private Sec
Slide 19: Additional Information and Where to Find It
Additional Information and Where to Find It • In connection with the proposed merger transaction, the Company filed with the SEC a definitive proxy statement and other relevant documents, including a form of proxy card, on July 10, 2013. The definitive proxy statement and a form of proxy card have b
American Greetings — Merger or Acquisition (July 2013) on 6ix