Destination Maternity Corporation
Destination Maternity — Proxy Contest (May 2018)
28 slides from Destination Maternity's proxy contest presentation, May 3, 2018
Slide 1: Shareholder Presentation – May 2018: A Credible Turnaround Plan
DESTINATION MATERNITY CORPORATION SHAREHOLDER PRESENTATION – MAY 2018 A CREDIBLE TURNAROUND PLAN VOTE THE GOLD PROXY CARD
Slide 2: Disclaimer
DISCLAIMER The information contained in this presentation (the “Information”) is based on publicly available information about Destination Maternity Corporation (the “Company”), which has not been independently verified by Nathan G. Miller or Peter O’Malley (the “Investors”). The Investors recognize
Slide 3: Cautionary Statement Regarding Forward-Looking Statements
CAUTIONARY STATEMENT REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS The analyses provided herein may include certain forward-looking statements, estimates, and projections prepared with respect to, among other things, general economic and market conditions, changes in management, changes in Board composition,
Slide 4: Certain Information Concerning the Participants
CERTAIN INFORMATION CONCERNING THE PARTICIPANTS This presentation relates to the Investors’ solicitation of proxies in connection with the 2018 annual meeting (the “Annual Meeting”) of stockholders of the Company. The Investors have filed a definitive proxy statement and an accompanying GOLD proxy c
Slide 5: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS CHANGE IS NEEDED AT DESTINATION MATERNITY 7 BOARD HAS FAILED 8 “WOEFUL” TOTAL SHAREHOLDER RETURNS 16 FAILED EXECUTION OF A “TURNAROUND” 17 DISQUALIFYING CORPORATE GOVERNANCE 21 WE HAVE A CREDIBLE PLAN TO RESTORE SHAREHOLDER VALUE 22 OUR ROBUST TURNAROUND PLAN 23 EXPERIENCED TEAM 26
Slide 6: Excited About Destination
EXCITED ABOUT DESTINATION DESTINATION IS A COMPANY WITH AN ICONIC BRAND PORTFOLIO AND SIGNIFICANT UPSIDE POTENTIAL 4MM BIRTHS ANNUALLY AND 75% OF FIRST TIME MOMS SHOP WITH DESTINATION MATERNITY 1 SIGNIFICANT MARKET SHARE (~65%), HIGH GROSS MARGINS (~52%) AND STRONG BRAND RECOGNITION (85% AIDED AWARE
Slide 7: Change Is Needed at Destination Maternity
CHANGE IS NEEDED AT DESTINATION MATERNITY
Slide 8: Board Has Failed
BOARD HAS FAILED LAST THREE YEARS: STOCK PRICE -84% FROM $15.44 TO $2.38 BOOK VALUE -67% FROM $9.25 TO $2.95 REVENUE -21% ($111MM) FROM $517MM TO $406MM EBITDA -65% FROM $36.8MM TO $13.0MM; AND NET INCOME OF +$10.7MM TO NET LOSS OF -$10.2MM (GAAP NET LOSS OF -$21.6MM) CASH OF +$13MM -$48MM TO NET DE
Slide 9: Stock Price -84%, Market Cap -80%
STOCK PRICE -84%2 MARKET CAP -80%2 2Based on closing share price of Common Stock as of fiscal year end 2014 ($15.44) and fiscal year end 2017 ($2.39) OVER THE LAST 3 YEARS
Slide 10: Book Value -67%, Revenue -$111MM
BOOK VALUE -67%3 REVENUE -$111MM4 3 Based on the book value of $125.5 million and 13.5 million shares outstanding as of September 30, 2014 (end of fiscal year 2014) and book value of $40.7 million and 13.8 million shares outstanding as of February 3, 2018 (end of fiscal year 2017), as reported in th
Slide 11: EBITDA -65%, Net Income -$20MM
EBITDA -65%4 NET INCOME -$20MM4 4Based on the Company’s Adjusted EBITDA and net income (using the Company’s adjusted net income) for the year ended September 30, 2014 (fiscal year 2014) and for the year ended February 3, 2018 (fiscal year 2017), as reported in the Company’s 10-Ks OVER THE LAST 3 YEA
Slide 12: Net Cash -$48MM: Compromised Liquidity Position
NET CASH -$48MM4 COMPROMISED LIQUIDITY POSITION 4Based on the Company’s Adjusted EBITDA and net income (using the Company’s adjusted net income) for the year ended September 30, 2014 (fiscal year 2014) and for the year ended February 3, 2018 (fiscal year 2017), as reported in the Company’s 10-Ks OVE
Slide 13: Highest SG&A of Peer Group
HIGHEST SG&A OF PEER GROUP Highest SG&A Ratio Of Peers Average SG&A Ratio Of 34% Among The Lowest Net Profit Margin Of Peers Based on respective company 10-Ks for fiscal year 2016; peer group named in the Company’s 2017 annual meeting
Slide 14: Operating Results Deteriorating
OPERATING RESULTS DETERIORATING Record High SG&A Ratio in 2017 Up 220bps YOY to 53.8% Board Lacks Credibility On Returning To Revenue Growth & Cutting Costs Despite Their Repeated Claims Of Doing So Based on Destination Maternity 10-Qs and 10-Ks
Slide 15: Board Missed Its Own Incentive EBITDA Targets for Seven Years
BOARD MISSED ITS OWN INCENTIVE EBITDA TARGETS FOR THE LAST SEVEN YEARS FY18 TARGET LOWER THAN FY17 TARGET WHILE GUIDED TO $10MM--$11MM IN COST TAKEOUT AND IMPROVED PROFITABILITY OVERPROMISE AND UNDERDELIVER Average Miss Of $9MM Or 24% Implies Just $13MM-$16MM For FY18 Note: Goals were established in
Slide 16: "Woeful" Total Shareholder Returns
Note: As of closest month end to company FY end (1/31/18, 1/31/17, 1/30/15, 1/31/13); using all trading days rather than ending stock price does not materially change the result (intended to reduce point-to-point stock price volatility) Based on October 2017 ISS Report, DQYDJ.COM, Yahoo Finance ISS
Slide 17: Failed Execution of a "Turnaround"
FAILED EXECUTION OF A “TURNAROUND” FINANCIAL METRICS SHOW FAILURE BOARD RESPONDED WITH A TURNAROUND PLAN THAT HAS FAILED EXECUTING ON ITS “TURNAROUND PLAN” FOR OVER 3 YEARS CLEARLY NO CREDIBLE TURNAROUND PLAN AS THE COMPANY HAS: NOT PROVIDED SHAREHOLDERS WITH AN IDENTIFIED LIST OF COST AND REVENUE I
Slide 18: Book Value During "Turnaround Plan"
BOOK VALUE DURING “TURNAROUND PLAN” BOOK VALUE FROM $125MM TO $41MM SINCE 20146 BOOK VALUE FROM OVER $9.00 TO $3.00 6Based on the book value of $125.5 million and 13.5 million shares outstanding as of September 30, 2014 and book value of $40.7 million and 13.8 million shares outstanding as of Februa
Slide 19: A Rudderless Ship Can't Change Course
A RUDDERLESS SHIP CAN’T CHANGE COURSE LACK OF STRATEGIC VISION--LOSSES ACCELERATED SINCE THE LAST PROXY FIGHT 8 MONTHS SINCE COMPANY HAD A PERMANENT CEO (SEPTEMBER 7, 2017) 12 MONTHS + SINCE A PERMANENT CEO ADDRESSED SHAREHOLDERS (Q1-17 EARNINGS CALL) YET BOARD CLAIMS TO BE IMPROVING PROFITABILITY A
Slide 20: We Gave the Board a Roadmap—They Failed to Act
WE GAVE THE BOARD A ROADMAP--THEY FAILED TO ACT COST REDUCTIONS OF 5% CUTS SG&A FROM ~$220MM TO ~$200MM --- $20MM DROPS TO THE BOTTOM LINE NET PRICING INCREASE OF 5% RAISES REVENUE FROM ~$400MM TO ~$420MM ---$20MM DROPS TO THE BOTTOM LINE RESULTS IN: RAISE EBIT/EBITDA MARGINS BY 10% RAISE EBIT/EBITD
Slide 21: Record of Disqualifying Corporate Governance
RECORD OF DISQUALIFYING CORPORATE GOVERNANCE BOARD HAS FAILED TO ALIGN EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION WITH PERFORMANCE BOARD HAS FAILED TO APPOINT A PERMANENT CEO FOR ALMOST 8 MONTHS BOARD REFUSED TO COMMIT TO THE USE OF A UNIVERSAL PROXY CARD COMPOSITION OF THE BOARD WAS CHANGED THREE TIMES IN A TWO-WEEK P
Slide 22: We Have a Credible Plan to Restore Shareholder Value
WE HAVE A CREDIBLE PLAN TO RESTORE SHAREHOLDER VALUE
Slide 23: Our Robust Turnaround Plan
BOARD SPENT 9 MONTHS LOSING -$20MM, WHILE DECLARING THEY HAVE TAKEN SWIFT AND DECISIVE ACTIONS TO PROTECT YOUR INVESTMENT BOARD HAS LOST ALL CREDIBILITY WE HAVE SPENT 9 MONTHS BUILDING AND DEVELOPING: A WELL REASONED AND DETAILED BUSINESS PLAN (30, 100, 180 DAY PLANS) STRATEGIC INITIATIVES AND A COM
Slide 24: Our Turnaround Plan: Grow Sales, Right-Size Cost Structure
OUR TURNAROUND PLAN GROW SALES DRIVE GROWTH VIA THOUGHTFUL, STRATEGIC PLAN CATEGORY EXPANSION TO INCREASE SALES AND TRAFFIC LEVERAGE DATA ANALYTICS TO FUEL ONLINE GROWTH OPTIMIZE LOYALTY PROGRAM TO DRIVE CONVERSION SEAMLESS OMNI-DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS RE-INVIGORATE PARTNERSHIP REVENUE RIGHT-SIZE COST
Slide 25: Our Turnaround Plan: Investor Communications and Accountability
OUR TURNAROUND PLAN INVESTOR COMMUNICATIONS FREQUENT, TRANSPARENT DISCLOSURES AND COMMUNICATION WITH SHAREHOLDERS DISCLOSE CHANNEL REVENUE STREAMS INTERNALIZE IR FUNCTIONS BUILD STABLE SOURCES OF CAPITAL AND INCREASE INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AS LONG-TERM PARTNERS ADD INVESTMENT BANK RESEARCH COVERAGE
Slide 26: Experienced Team
EXPERIENCED TEAM HOLLY N. ALDEN - 25 YEARS EXPERIENCE, MARKETING, BRANDING AND BUILDING LIFESTYLE COMPANIES INTO SUCCESSFUL BUSINESSES. CO-FOUNDER OF SKULLCANDY, CO-FOUNDER OF STANCE SOCKS INC., PARTNER AT NATIONAL SNOWBOARD INC. CHRISTOPHER B. MORGAN – 25 YEARS EXPERIENCE, EQUITY ANALYST/INVESTOR,
Slide 27: Conclusion
CONCLUSION THE LAST 3 YEARS… STOCK PRICE FELL -80% BOOK VALUE FELL -67% REVENUE FELL -21% NET CASH FELL -$48MM $10MM PROFIT FELL TO $22MM LOSS EXPENSES (SG&A MARGIN) INCREASED 5.30% …IN CONTRAST TO NEXT 3 YEARS CUT COSTS (SG&A MARGIN) BY 5% IN NEAR-TERM, 10% OVER LONG-TERM WITH BENEFIT OF REVENUE LE
Slide 28: It's Critical You Make Your Voice Heard
IT’S CRITICAL YOU MAKE YOUR VOICE HEARD PLEASE RETURN THE GOLD PROXY CARD EMAIL: [email protected] OR CALL TOM BALL AND HIS TEAM (800) 662-5200