Ohio Casualty Corp

Ohio Casualty — Investor Day (September 2005)

67 slides from Ohio Casualty's investor day presentation, Sep 14, 2005

  1. Slide 1: Creating Shareholder Value

    Creating Shareholder Value Ohio Casualty Corporation September 2005

  2. Slide 2: Welcome/Purpose of Today’s Meeting

    Welcome/Purpose of Today’s Meeting Dennis McDaniel Vice President – Investor Relations

  3. Slide 3: Forward Looking Statements

    Forward Looking Statements Certain of the statements contained in these materials, including all financial forecasts and projections, are forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act. Forward-looking statements are typically identified herein by words

  4. Slide 4: Introductions & Progress On Our Strategic Plan

    Introductions & Progress On Our Strategic Plan Dan Carmichael Chief Executive Officer

  5. Slide 5: Agenda

    Agenda Strategic Overview Dan Carmichael Operations Review Competitive Position and Trends Mike Michael Commercial Lines Mike Sullivan Personal Lines Derrick Shannon Specialty Lines John Busby Lunch with Management and Agents Technology John Kellington Agents’ Roundtable Tom Cassady – USI Midwest Bi

  6. Slide 6: Execution Against Successful Strategy

    Execution Against Successful Strategy A Year Ago, We Promised Achieve improved profitability Focus organization on process improvements Deliver superior easy to use processes Earn higher financial ratings Deliver greater shareholder value Results Since Then 95.5% CR 6 points better than 1H04, 1st ha

  7. Slide 7: Our Main Challenge: Growth

    Our Main Challenge: Growth A Year Ago, We Also Promised Above-market real growth More sophisticated pricing of risks Grow within independent agent and broker distribution channel Results Since Then New COO Mike Michael adding financial services marketing depth, focused on accelerating growth Sophist

  8. Slide 8: Then and Now

    Then and Now Greater Scale and Strength Surplus $812M $929M Equity $1,117M $1,411M Restructured and Reduced Debt Debt $215M Short $200M Long Debt / Capital Ratio 16.5% 12.5% Better Leverage and Flexibility Operating Leverage 1.9X 1.6X Holding Co. Liquidity $44M $250M Improved Underwriting Profitabil

  9. Slide 9: Positioned For Future Success

    Positioned For Future Success Since 2000, we have substantially repositioned 23% of our book of business Retention ratios remain strong, with adequate pricing 2005 reflects benefits of expense reduction initiatives Overall reserve adequacy has been demonstrated, and investment portfolio is high qual

  10. Slide 10: Operations Review

    Operations Review Ohio Casualty Corporation

  11. Slide 11: Building On Our Successes

    Building On Our Successes Mike Michael Chief Operating Officer

  12. Slide 12: A Banker??? What does he know about insurance??

    A Banker??? What does he know about insurance??

  13. Slide 13: Industry Comparison

    Industry Comparison Commercial Banks and P&C Insurance Commoditized Competitive Consolidating Yet the sector has produced very attractive returns

  14. Slide 14: Opportunity for Ohio Casualty

    Opportunity for Ohio Casualty Fundamental Strengths Nimble and focused Have great insurance technicians Opportunities Develop a marketing culture A more scientific approach using database management Serving agents is the first order of business Enhanced growth with strong agency plant

  15. Slide 15: What Our Agents Say

    What Our Agents Say Fundamental Strengths Well-regarded brand: 86% call Ohio Casualty “respected” or “preferred” carrier Trusted: 84% say Ohio Casualty is “important” or “mission critical” to their business Opportunities Responsive: 80% say coverage meets customers needs Capable: 76% satisfied with

  16. Slide 16: Establishing A Marketing Culture

    Establishing A Marketing Culture Become “mission critical” partner for more agents, raising average premium volume per agent Better agency segmentation, recognizing agency life cycle Strengthen ties with key agents Develop a world-class marketing operation Apply technology both for easy use by agent

  17. Slide 17: Commercial Lines Overview

    Commercial Lines Overview Presented by: Mike Sullivan Senior Vice President, Commercial Lines

  18. Slide 18: Operating Results Improving

    Operating Results Improving Commercial Lines Combined Ratio Calendar Year Statutory Basis 116.2% 115.1% 112.3% 99.3% 103.3% Expense Ratio Loss + LAE Ratio 36.4 36.3 36.4 34.3 32.8 79.8 78.8 75.9 65.0 70.5 1H05 Accident year combined ratio: 100.0% 103.7% 100.3% 99.1% Workers’ compensation adverse pri

  19. Slide 19: Competitive Environment

    Competitive Environment Current Trends Carriers are focused on renewal retention Price decreases are common on medium and large accounts Competition is intense for new business Service, agency automation, and relationships can be leveraged Our Price Adequacy and Profitability Actions Pricing goals a

  20. Slide 20: Growth Initiatives

    Growth Initiatives Leverage underwriter-agency relationships Incentives for underwriting staff Agency segmentation and improved agency management Agency automation to make it easier for agents Policy quote, issuance, and endorsement capabilities through P.A.R.I.S. ExpressSM Rapid quote Navigation im

  21. Slide 21: Increased Pricing Sophistication

    Increased Pricing Sophistication Wide range of pricing available for many commercial products Differences in loss potential across different territories and classes not always reflected in bureau loss costs Pricing goals for underwriters reflect these differences in loss potential Predictive modelin

  22. Slide 22: Personal Lines Overview

    Personal Lines Overview Presented by: Derrick Shannon Senior Vice President, Personal Lines

  23. Slide 23: Operating Results Improving

    Operating Results Improving Personal Lines Combined Ratio Calendar Year Statutory Basis Expense Ratio Loss + LAE Ratio 119.2% 114.1% 105.6% 97.6% 80.9% 33.7 29.6 27.1 28.9 24.1 85.5 84.5 78.5 68.7 56.8 1H05 Accident year combined ratio: 111.5% 101.4% 95.5% 89.0% NJ personal auto transfer and guarant

  24. Slide 24: Competitive Environment

    Competitive Environment Industry pricing has remained rational Moderate pricing decreases as declining frequency continues Some evidence of substantial pricing decreases by class Pricing sophistication has increased Industry underwriting appetite increased due to rate adequacy Increased incentives a

  25. Slide 25: Growth Initiatives

    Growth Initiatives Focus on agency workflow to increase quote volume Partner with comparative raters to ensure accurate quoting Expand solutions allowing agents to work from their agency management systems Expand underwriting appetite through improved pricing sophistication Expand breadth of product

  26. Slide 26: Expanding Agency Workflow Solutions

    Expanding Agency Workflow Solutions Comparative Raters Real time Web-based Upload/Download Given relatively stable conversion rates, increased quote volume means increased premium volume

  27. Slide 27: Specialty Lines Overview

    Specialty Lines Overview Presented by: John Busby Executive Vice President & Chief Operating Officer, Specialty Lines

  28. Slide 28: Positive Operating Results

    Positive Operating Results Specialty Lines Combined Ratio Calendar Year Statutory Basis Expense Ratio Loss + LAE Ratio 90.8% 94.0% 77.2% 97.2% 87.6% 38.4 44.1 43.5 49.7 36.4 52.4 49.9 33.7 47.5 51.2 1H05 Accident year combined ratio: 87.1% 88.5% 102.9% 93.7% Bond calendar year combined ratio: 81.7%

  29. Slide 29: Competitive Environment

    Competitive Environment Bonds: Contract Surety—four companies have left the market this year, underwriting standards maintained, focus on quality accounts with appropriate work program size Commercial Surety—competition reasonable for license, public official, probate bonds Financial Institution—ext

  30. Slide 30: Growth Initiatives

    Bonds: Identify potential new agent appointments, target agents for increased production Automate agency bond issuance to enhance excellent service Leverage local presence—20 strategically located offices Commercial Umbrella: Additional cross-selling for Commercial Lines accounts as business shifts

  31. Slide 31: Price Adequacy and Profitability

    Price Adequacy and Profitability Bonds: Experienced staff—average bond manager has > 25 years Loss ratio averaged 15.1% for past 15 years Stable underwriting appetite with appropriate field authority Commercial Umbrella: Focus on low to medium severity with appropriate attachment points Underwriting

  32. Slide 32: Katrina Update

    Katrina Update Rapid claims response Loss estimate Ohio Casualty Corporation

  33. Slide 33: Operations Questions and Answers

    Operations Questions and Answers

  34. Slide 34: Luncheon

    Luncheon Ohio Casualty Corporation

  35. Slide 35: Technology Update

    Technology Update Ohio Casualty Corporation

  36. Slide 36: Responding to Agents’ Needs

    Responding to Agents’ Needs John Kellington Senior Vice President & Chief Technology Officer

  37. Slide 37: Technology Agents Use Today

    Technology Agents Use Today New functionality is continuing to be rolled out Before 3Q03 4Q03 1Q04 2Q04 3Q04 4Q04 1Q05 2Q05 Billing Inquiries Auto Quote Homeowner Quote Homeowner Issuance 1st Notice of Loss Auto Issuance P.A.R.I.S. ExpressSM

  38. Slide 38: P.A.R.I.S. Access Via Our Website

    P.A.R.I.S.SM Access Via Our Website P.A.R.I.S. ExpressSM provides P.A.R.I.S.SM functionality to the agents via the OCG Website Currently quotes new business for businessowners, workers’ compensation, commercial auto, artisans, and inland marine Issuance and endorsements is in pilot for businessowner

  39. Slide 39: Transparent Connection for Agents

    Transparent Connection for Agents P.A.R.I.S. ConnectTM leverages P.A.R.I.S.SM functionality to provide interface capabilities to the agents via the agents management system Currently quotes new business for businessowners & workers’ compensation for Applied users Development under way for commercial

  40. Slide 40: Agents Choose Commercial Workflow

    Agents Choose Commercial Workflow via OCG Website OR via agency system

  41. Slide 41: Agency Interfaces Prove Value

    Agency Interfaces Prove Value Real Time Billing Inquiries (includes Transformation Station, TransactNow, SIS Web Link, Consumer Website and Agency Website) - 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 40,000 Jul-03 Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan-04 Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan-05 Fe

  42. Slide 42: Agency Interfaces Prove Value

    Agency Interfaces Prove Value Personal Lines SEMCI (Quoting and Issuance) - 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 3,000 3,500 Jul-03 Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan-04 Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan-05 Feb Mar Apr May Jun Transactions

  43. Slide 43: Best-practices Focus to Ensure Success

    Best-practices Focus to Ensure Success Software Industry Risks In the Software Industry: 74% of all new projects fail 66% of all successful projects have significant cost and time over-runs Failed projects result in: Zero results for resource (dollars) investment Missed business opportunities Missed

  44. Slide 44: Our Technology At Work

    Our Technology At Work Video Clip How our technology is being used in our agencies’ offices Ohio Casualty Corporation

  45. Slide 45: Agents’ Roundtable

    Agents’ Roundtable Ohio Casualty Corporation

  46. Slide 46: Agents’ Perspectives

    Agents’ Perspectives Panel of Independent Agents Tom Cassady – USI Midwest Bill Dillhoff – Kneflin-Dillhoff-Hils & Kruse Inc. Jack Massey – Putnam Agency Inc.

  47. Slide 47: Financial Update

    Financial Update Ohio Casualty Corporation

  48. Slide 48: Maximizing Risk-Adjusted Returns

    Maximizing Risk-Adjusted Returns Paul Gerard Senior Vice President, Investments

  49. Slide 49: Solid Investment Strategy

    Solid Investment Strategy Overall Strategy Remain fully invested ($20-40 million in operating cash) Optimize after-tax income with disciplined risk profile Balanced cash flow distribution across the curve Fixed Income “A” or better average rating Bond duration of 5.3 years @ 6/30/05 Superior relativ

  50. Slide 50: Quality with Tax-Exempt Emphasis

    Quality with Tax-Exempt Emphasis Total fixed income portfolio $3.8 billion Fixed Income Credit Quality NAIC 3 2.1% NAIC 2 16.2% NAIC 4 .3% NAIC 1 81.4% Total invested assets $4.2 billion Invested Asset Allocation Other 4% Equity 9% Mortgage & Asset Backed 16% Tax Exempt 29% Investment Grade Corporat

  51. Slide 51: Performance Attributes

    Performance Attributes Book yield focus Duration and convexity considerations Portfolio quality Asset allocation Maximizing after-tax investment income Benchmark comparisons

  52. Slide 52: Keys to Investment Success

    Keys to Investment Success Risk management processes in place, focused on credit analysis and portfolio modeling Modeling operating cash flows and liability duration drive investment portfolio duration management Ongoing review of tax position and strategies Focus on maximizing risk-adjusted returns

  53. Slide 53: Financial Highlights

    Financial Highlights Presented by: Mike Winner Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer

  54. Slide 54: Strong Balance Sheet

    Strong Balance Sheet Cash/securities at holding company of $250 million* for financial flexibility High quality diversified investment portfolio Reinsurance program with security emphasis Diversified group of highly rated reinsurers Funds held for reinsurance treaties secures 24%* of reinsurance rec

  55. Slide 55: Outstanding Capital Adequacy

    Outstanding Capital Adequacy A.M. Best Capital Adequacy Ratio (BCAR) of 222.7% as of 12-31-04 Implied balance sheet strength rating is A++ A.M. Best Financial Strength rating also considers operating performance and business profile—ours has improved S&P Capital Adequacy Ratio is 181.2% Assessment o

  56. Slide 56: Parent Company Capital Strategy

    Parent Company Capital Strategy Objectives: Long-term common stock appreciation Growth in EPS, ROE, and book value Increase in price-to-book multiple Underwriting profit to drive growth in capital, 10-12% ROE Significant liquidity and ready access to capital Conservative operating and financial leve

  57. Slide 57: Recent Capital Management Actions

    Recent Capital Management Actions Initiated buyback program for up to 4 million shares Renewed revolving credit agreement with borrowing capacity of $80 million Reinstated dividend with yield of approximately 1% Redeemed convertible debt, reducing dilution impact from 8.9 million shares to 1.3 milli

  58. Slide 58: Execution Reflected In Results

    Execution Reflected In Results Operating EPS* 36% 131% 275% 62% 68% 83% ** 31% 11% Quarter over quarter Increase $0.50 $0.28 $0.13 $0.12 $0.21 $0.38 $0.30 $0.45 $0.34 $0.64 $0.55 $0.59 4Q02 1Q03 2Q03 3Q03 4Q03 1Q04 2Q04 3Q04 4Q04 1Q05 2Q05 * Non-GAAP financial measure; see explanation and reconcilia

  59. Slide 59: Operating Return

    Operating Return* Operating Return on Equity -10.2% -4.8% -3.8% 6.3% 12.3% 13.3% 1H 2005 * Non-GAAP financial measure defined as net income excluding gains and losses on security sales and equity excludes impact of FAS 115 adjustments

  60. Slide 60: Narrowing the Gap

    Narrowing the Gap * As of June 30, 2005. Gross premiums written is on a rolling twelve month basis. Combined Ratio Improvement YTD 2005 vs. Year 2000 23.3 Points Ohio Casualty 15.2 Points Selected Competitors Selected competitors include CINF, ERIE, HGIC,HIG, SAFC, SIGI, STA, STFC. Gross Premiums Wr

  61. Slide 61: Expense Initiatives

    Expense Initiatives 2005 performance reflects positive impact of prior efforts Process re-engineering Benefit plan savings Claims legal savings Additional efforts under way Procurement Centralized processing Efficiency from technology Staff reductions of 37% since 2000 3,470 Employees 2,170 Employee

  62. Slide 62: Overall Financial Excellence

    Overall Financial Excellence Track record of consistently improving operating profitability Significantly improved loss ratio since 2000 Permanent benefits from expense reduction initiatives Investment in proven, industry-leading technology Highly rated capital adequacy, strong loss reserves, conser

  63. Slide 63: Where We’re Headed

    Where We’re Headed Ohio Casualty Corporation

  64. Slide 64: Conclusion/Discussion

    Conclusion/Discussion Dan Carmichael

  65. Slide 65: What’s Next for Ohio Casualty?

    What’s Next for Ohio Casualty? Management Remains Confident of Success Cost reductions will continue to benefit future results Targeted marketing, pricing sophistication and continued underwriting/pricing discipline for profitable growth Superior service and technology attract and retain top agents,

  66. Slide 66: Price/Book Value per share

    Price/Book Value per share 1.2 1.2 1.5 1.5 1.6 1.7 OCAS CINF SIGI HIG SAFC STFC A top market performer (up 101% since 2002), but only 1.2 times book vs. comparable average* of 1.5X Midwest values, Midwest market focus Results prove we can execute Dedicated to maximizing shareholder return * For sele

  67. Slide 67: Questions and Answers

    Questions and Answers 67

Ohio Casualty — Investor Day (September 2005) on 6ix