American Greetings — Merger or Acquisition (July 2013)
54 slides from American Greetings's merger presentation, Jul 18, 2013
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Cover Page
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a party other than the Registrant ¨ Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy Statement ¨ Conf
Slide 2: American Greetings Investor Presentation
American Greetings Investor Presentation July 18, 2013
Slide 3: Topics
Topics 1. Transaction Summary 2. Strategic Rationale 3. Process 4. Valuation 1
Slide 4: Transaction Summary
X X X X X X 1. Transaction Summary 2. Strategic Rationale 3. Process 4. Valuation 2
Slide 5: Transaction Summary
Transaction Summary On April 1, 2013, American Greetings Corporation announced that it had signed a definitive agreement under which the Weiss Family would acquire the Company for $18.20 in cash. On July 3, 2013, AG announced that it had signed an amendment to the merger agreement providing for an i
Slide 6: Strategic Rationale
* * * * * 1. Transaction Summary 2. Strategic Rationale 3. Process 4. Valuation 4
Slide 7: Strategic Rationale: Executive Summary
Strategic Rationale Executive Summary • American Greetings is at an inflection point – Paper greeting cards and gift packaging constitute ~88% of our business, and the market is shrinking—we are experiencing persistent year-over-year declines in sales of the core greeting card business, due to combi
Slide 8: Executive Summary (cont'd)
Strategic Rationale Executive Summary (cont’d) • The Company’s stock has consistently underperformed in trading markets – Strategy of returning cash to shareholders (over $1 billion to Class A public shareholders through dividends and repurchases since FY2005) has not been successful in driving shar
Slide 9: Business Overview
Business Overview • American Greetings engages in the design, manufacture and sale of greeting cards and other social expression products in the United States and internationally • Segments include: – North American Social Expression Products (includes Cardstore.com) – International Social Expressio
Slide 10: Greeting Cards Industry Faces Persistent, Accelerating Decline
Greeting Cards Industry Faces Persistent, Accelerating Decline • Mature greeting cards industry experiencing long-term and accelerating unit decline (2%-4% decline / year since CY 2007) – Pace of decline meaningfully accelerated in 2011 and 2012, despite improved economy – Most lucrative “heavy user
Slide 11: Declining Industry Trends
Declining Industry Trends • Consumer purchases driven more by selection and convenience than by brand – Adult participation in social networking and media has grown to ~52% in 2012 from ~11% in 2006 • Retailer consolidation increases retailer purchasing power • Channel shift Mass retailers and dolla
Slide 12: Stock Price Performance
Stock Price Performance • In the two years prior to the initial Family offer, AG’s stock price was down 30% despite having returned over $180 million of capital to shareholders in that period – In the same period, the S&P 400 Consumer Discretionary Index was up 40% – Correlation between AG’s stock p
Slide 13: Trading Ranges Nearly Always Below Final Offer
Trading Ranges Nearly Always Below Final Offer • 99% of shares traded over the one-year period prior to the Family’s initial proposal traded below $19.00 • 100% of shares traded below $16.50 in the six months prior to the initial proposal (Period ending September 25, 2012, except where noted) 1-Year
Slide 14: Marked Decline in Equity Value
Marked Decline in Equity Value American Greetings 15-Year Stock Price Chart American Greetings 15-Year Total Shareholders' Equity Value History 12 Source: Capital IQ.
Slide 15: Lackluster Stock Price Performance Despite Major Return of Capital
Lackluster Stock Price Performance Despite Major Return of Capital to Shareholders • Since FY2005, AG has returned over $1 billion of capital to Class A public shareholders through share repurchases and dividends – Despite major share repurchases and dividends, AG’s unaffected stock price has declin
Slide 16: Limited Benefit to Being Public
Limited Benefit to Being Public • Many of the standard benefits enjoyed by public Limited Institutional Support – AG Equity Coverage Analysts companies do not exist for American Greetings – Limited institutional support – only one equity coverage analyst – Industry fundamentals do not support future
Slide 17: Significant Competitive Disadvantage as Long as Publicly Traded
American Greetings is at a Significant Competitive Disadvantage as Long as it is Publicly Traded • American Greetings’ largest competitor is privately held and able to invest and re- invest in its business without the pressure to produce period-over-period revenue, earnings and cash flow growth – Ex
Slide 18: Industry Challenges and Necessary Redirection of Capital
Industry Challenges and Necessary Redirection of Capital Increase Downside Risks for Public Holders • Persistent decline in the core paper greeting cards industry of 2%-4% unit volume annually (including 3.7% decline in most recent year) – Intensifying risks to the core paper greeting cards industry
Slide 19: Process
* * * * * 1. Transaction Summary 2. Strategic Rationale 3. Process 4. Valuation 17
Slide 20: Process: Executive Summary
Process Executive Summary • Fully independent Special Committee advised by nationally recognized independent advisors • Financial advisor’s fees not conditioned on rendering a favorable opinion as to the transaction • Special Committee empowered to consider/pursue alternatives and to reject any prop
Slide 21: Experienced / Independent Special Committee and Independent Advisors
Experienced / Independent Special Committee and Independent Advisors The Special Committee: • Dr. Scott S. Cowen: President of Tulane University, former Dean of Case Western Reserve University, former Chairman of Special Committee for Jo-Ann Stores’ going-private LBO • Jeffrey D. Dunn: Former Presid
Slide 22: Key Process and Proposal Highlights
Key Process and Proposal Highlights • American Greetings was founded by Jacob Sapirstein in 1906, and has remained controlled by descendants of Jacob Sapirstein (now the Weiss Family) throughout the Company’s existence • A/B voting structure in existence since 1955; public shareholders invested know
Slide 23: Robust Special Committee Process
Robust Special Committee Process • Board of Directors delegated to the Special Committee the exclusive power and authority to recommend what action, if any, should be taken with respect to the Family’s proposal – The Committee could have just said no, or approved a financial alternative • Counsel fo
Slide 24: Robust Special Committee Process (cont'd)
Robust Special Committee Process (cont’d) • The Board fully considered and adopted the Special Committee’s recommendation in making its decision to unanimously recommend the transaction to the shareholders • The Special Committee demanded and secured “Majority of the Minority” shareholder approval r
Slide 25: Arm's-Length Legal Negotiations
Arm’s-Length Legal Negotiations • On behalf of the Family, Jones Day delivered the first draft of the Merger Agreement on January 19, 2013, and the agreement was negotiated by Jones Day and Sullivan & Cromwell until March 29, 2013. As compared to Jones Day’s initial draft of the agreement, the final
Slide 26: Valuation
* * * * * 1. Transaction Summary 2. Strategic Rationale 3. Process 4. Valuation 24
Slide 27: Valuation Overview
Valuation Valuation Overview • Special Committee believes that the $19.00 per share consideration (reached after prolonged negotiations) represents the highest per share consideration it could obtain from the Family • $19.00 proposal represents a 32.5% premium to the 9/25/12 unaffected closing price
Slide 28: Valuation Analysis Summary
Valuation Analysis Summary 1/17/13 3/28/13 Offer Offer 7/1/13 Unaffected Share 9/25/12 Initial Offer Offer 9/25/12 52-Week Trading Range Prior $12.50 $19.50 to 9/25/13 Offer Comparable Companies $15.25 $25.00 Precedent Transactions $13.00 $22.50 Present Value of Future Share $16.00 $23.25 Price (a)
Slide 29: Compelling Offer to Shareholders
Compelling Offer to Shareholders • Attractive Premium – 32.5% premium to unaffected share price prior to Family’s initial proposal (9/25/12) – 33.1% premium to 45 trading day average prior to Family’s initial proposal – 18.0% premium to closing stock price prior to announcement of original definitiv
Slide 30: Premium Valuation Achieved
Premium Valuation Achieved Premium to Unaffected Trading Price and Earlier Proposals by the Family $20.00 4.4% premium to 8.6% premium to Revised Proposal Final Offer 10.6% on 3/28 18.00 premium to Revised Proposal on 1/17 Revised Initial Proposal Proposal on 32.5% Revised 3/28/13 (b) premium to Ini
Slide 31: Premium Valuation Achieved
Premium Valuation Achieved Premium to Various Historical Stock Prices $20.00 4.4% premium to Revised Proposal Final Offer on 3/28 18.00 18% premium to Revised prior day Proposal on 32.5% closing stock price 3/28/13 (a) 33.3% premium to premium to 30 unaffected 52.0% 16.00 premium to calendar days pr
Slide 32: Offer Represents Significant Premium
Offer Represents Significant Premium EV / LTM EBITDA – 2 years prior to Initial Proposal 30 Source: Capital IQ. Capital IQ calculation of enterprise value does not include restricted stock units or performance shares and may have different adjustments for EBITDA than those used in other analyses in
Slide 33: Comparative Stock Price Performance
Comparative Stock Price Performance • While the broader market has provided significant returns on equity investments over time, American Greetings has significantly underperformed and, in most periods, has not provided positive return • Furthermore, in all observed time periods, American Greetings
Slide 34: Low Trading Price Correlation to Comparables
Low Trading Price Correlation to Comparables • In addition to the lack of correlation between AG’s stock price and the S&P 400 Consumer Discretionary Index, movement in AG’s stock price has a very low correlation with the selected comparable public companies – While we believe the selected group of
Slide 35: Short Interest
Short Interest • Prior to the announcement of the Family’s initial proposal, approximately 44% of AG’s float was short • Similarly high short interest likely to return if transaction not consummated AG Short Interest as Percent of Float – May 2012 to June 2013 33 Source: Short interest data from NYS
Slide 36: A Leveraged Recap is Not a Viable Alternative
A Leveraged Recap is Not a Viable Alternative • The Special Committee, after careful consideration, concluded that a leveraged recapitalization was not likely to lead to superior value. – Substantially greater debt levels would significantly increase AG’s business risks by reducing (1) the Company’s
Slide 37: Future Stock Price Analysis Based on Illustrative Levered Recap
Future Stock Price Analysis Based on Illustrative Levered Recap • Assumes an $8.00 dividend is paid on 5/31/13,(a) using incrementalborrowing of $265 million, resulting in 2.4x Debt / LTM EBITDA • Assumes no make-whole payment on existing 7.375% Senior Notes(b) (Amounts in Millions, Except Per Share
Slide 38: Pro Forma Effect of Special Dividend
Pro Forma Effect of Special Dividend (Amounts in Millions, Except Per Share Data) Special Dividend Total $ Pro Forma EV / Adj. LTM EBITDA Multiple (a) Per Share Distributed Debt / EBITDA 3.4 x 3.6 x 3.8 x 4.0 x 4.2 x 4.4 x 4.6 x 4.8 x $16.32 $17.63 $18.94 $20.25 $21.55 $22.86 $24.17 $25.48 Proforma
Slide 39: Conclusion
Conclusion • Growth in the paper greeting card space has been negative and this trend is likely to continue – Growth in electronic channels may increase rapidly • American Greetings is at an inflection point; capital will be dramatically redirected – Capital must be redirected from a focus on return
Slide 40: Conclusion (cont'd)
Conclusion (cont’d) $19.00 per share in cash is fair to and in the best interests of the Company and its unaffiliated shareholders based on: • A premium cash offer at a time when industry trends show declining sales – Significant premium above stock’s trading levels over the months leading up to ann
Slide 41: Appendix
Appendix • Chronology of Negotiation Process • Special Committee Qualifications • Forward-Looking Statements • Additional Information and Where to Find It • Participants in the Solicitation 39
Slide 42: Chronology of Special Committee's Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value
Chronology of Special Committee’s Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value 9/25/12 • Family submitted Initial Proposal of $17.18 to acquire all Class A and Class B common shares not owned by the Family 9/30/12 • Special Committee formed by the Company’s Board of Directors 10/7/12 - 10/14/12 • Special C
Slide 43: Chronology of Special Committee's Efforts (cont'd)
Chronology of Special Committee’s Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value (cont’d) 12/19/12 • Zev Weiss stated that the Family had significant concerns about obtaining financing on terms acceptable to them that would support the proposed $17.18 per share price 1/17/13 • Family sent a letter to the Spe
Slide 44: Chronology of Special Committee's Efforts (cont'd)
Chronology of Special Committee’s Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value (cont’d) 3/2/13 - 3/28/13 • Special Committee and representatives of Sullivan & Cromwell and PJSC negotiated price and transaction agreements with the Family and its advisors • Zev Weiss indicated that the Family had no ability
Slide 45: Chronology of Special Committee's Efforts (cont'd)
Chronology of Special Committee’s Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value (cont’d) 6/23/13 • Dr. Cowen, on behalf of the Special Committee, communicated to Zev Weiss that the Special Committee had received new financial information pertaining to AG’s operating results, and was therefore revisiting its
Slide 46: Chronology of Special Committee's Efforts (cont'd)
Chronology of Special Committee’s Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value (cont’d) 6/27/13 • Dr. Cowen, on behalf of the Special Committee, communicated to Zev Weiss that the Special Committee would be willing to recommend a price increase to $19.50 per share and a reciprocal, proportionate increase i
Slide 47: Chronology of Special Committee's Efforts (cont'd)
Chronology of Special Committee’s Efforts to Maximize Shareholder Value (cont’d) 7/3/13 • PJSC gave the Special Committee an oral fairness opinion (subsequently confirmed in writing) as to the price of $19.00 per share, and the Special Committee accepted the Family’s proposal (including the unchange
Slide 48: Special Committee Qualifications
Special Committee Qualifications • Dr. Scott S. Cowen – Dr. Cowen has been a director since 1989. Dr. Cowen is President and Seymour S Goodman Professor of Management and Professor of Economics, Tulane University, a position he has held since 1998. Prior to that, Dr. Cowen served as Dean and Albert
Slide 49: Special Committee Qualifications (cont'd)
Special Committee Qualifications (cont’d) • William E. MacDonald, III – Mr. MacDonald has been a director since 2007. Mr. MacDonald was Vice Chairman and member of the Office of the Chairman of National City Corporation from 2001 until his retirement in 2006. Prior to that, Mr. MacDonald held variou
Slide 50: Special Committee Qualifications (cont'd)
Special Committee Qualifications (cont’d) • Jeffrey D. Dunn – Mr. Dunn has been a director since 2007. Mr. Dunn served as president and chief executive officer and was a director of HIT Entertainment Limited (a children’s entertainment company), from 2008 until the company was sold in February 2012.
Slide 51: Special Committee Qualifications (cont'd)
Special Committee Qualifications (cont’d) • Michael J. Merriman, Jr. – Mr. Merriman has been a director since 2006. Mr. Merriman has been an operating advisor with Resilience Capital Partners, LLC (a private equity firm) since 2008. From 2006 until its sale in 2007, Mr. Merriman served as Chief Exec
Slide 52: Forward-Looking Statements
Forward-Looking Statements • Statements about the expected timing, completion and effects of the proposed transaction and all other statements in this communication, other than historical facts, constitute forward-looking statements within the meaning of the safe harbor provisions of the Private Sec
Slide 53: Additional Information and Where to Find It
Additional Information and Where to Find It • In connection with the proposed merger transaction, the Company filed with the SEC a definitive proxy statement and other relevant documents, including a form of proxy card, on July 10, 2013. The definitive proxy statement and a form of proxy card have b
Slide 54: Participants in the Solicitation
Participants in the Solicitation • The Company and its directors, executive officers and certain other members of management and employees of the Company may be deemed “participants” in the solicitation of proxies from shareholders of the Company in favor of the proposed merger. Information regardin
American Greetings — Merger or Acquisition (July 2013) on 6ix