PDC Energy — Proxy Contest (May 2019)
49 slides from PDC Energy's proxy contest presentation, May 6, 2019
Slide 1: The Need for Change: Performance, Pay and Putting PDC on a Path to Profitability
y Kimmeridge (\ ENERGY The Need for Change: Performance, Pay and Putting PDC on a Path to Profitability May 6, 2019
Slide 2: PDC Energy: The Need for Change
PDC Energy: The Need for Change Kimmeridge + Kimmeridge believes that PDC Energy owns and operates premier oil and gas assets, + Despite the underiying asset quality, PDC has consistently failed to generate a return on average capital employed (ROACE) that exceeds its weighted average cost of capita
Slide 3: Agenda
Agenda + About Kimmeridge + PDC: A History of Underperformance + PDC: A History of Operational Underperformance + PDC: A Lack of Alignment and Accountability + A Better Board and Path to Profitability @ vimmeriage
Slide 4: About Kimmeridge
y Kimmeridge About Kimmeridge
Slide 5: About Kimmeridge
About Kimmeridge Kimmeriage + Founded in 2012, Kimmeridge is a private equity fim based in New York and Denver focused purely ‘on the development of low-cost unconventional oil and gas assets in the US upstream energy sector. + Kimmeridge is differentiated by its direct investment approach, deep tec
Slide 6: Distinctive Integrated Investment & Operating Structure
Distinctive Integrated Investment & Operating Structure #) Kimmeridge The integration of 1meridge operates it investments and operations makes Kimmeridge's direct ‘model efficient and nimble, New York Investm The Kimmeridge investment team has ‘worked together for more than a decade.
Slide 7: PDC: A History of Underperformance
y Kimmeridge PDC: A History of Underperformance
Slide 8: Industry Backdrop
Industry Backdrop Kimmeriage Over the last ten years, the E&P industry has been characterized by the pursuit of production growth ‘over returns. This has largely been at the expense of shareholders, +The fundamental éever ofthis has been a misalignment = inthe management incenve stucte Execulnes nav
Slide 9: PDC Share Price Performance: I
PDC Share Price Performance: | Kimmeridge Over the last three years, PDC has materially underperformed the XOP, SPX, and oll price. A $100 investment in PDC three years ago would be worth $59 today. +3-Year $100 Invested PEP PEPPER ‘nieve atten 822019. eee e500 pees Ha FOC 218 pny tans So acoso mae
Slide 10: PDC Share Price Performance: II
PDC Share Price Performance: II PDC’s total shareholder return is negative over the last one, two and three years, materially underperforming the broader market and XOP index. PDC and Peer Performance - Absolute year year Poe (31%) 05) POC peer group ss) (37%) xo? 27) (16%) sx 1% Bw PDC Relative Und
Slide 11: PDC Share Price Performance: III
PDC Share Price Performance: Ill Kimmeriage PDC has underperformed, albeit largely in line with its internally defined peer group on a one, two and three-year basis. year 2-year
Slide 12: Consistently Poor ROACE vs Peers and vs the WACC
Consistently Poor ROACE vs Peers and vs the WACC Kimmeriage + PDC’s ROACE over the past ten years has averaged 4% and has never been above 6%. This is materially lower than its WACC of 10.5%". + Elementary finance theory explains that investments should only be made if their expected return ‘exceeds
Slide 13: Economic Value Destroyed
Economic Value Destroyed Kimmeriage Since 2009, PDC has invested in projects that generate a return below its WAC, resulting in significant value destruction cumulative Economic Value Added/Destroyed so | omnene TL] 0) | Economic valve Dastoved (51300) (61800) NOPAT- sled Capt“ WACO) Dla an FOCY pui
Slide 14: Historical Focus on Production Growth Over FCF
torical Focus on Production Growth Over FCF Kimmeriage PDC's strategy of outspending cash flow to grow production has not benefited shareholders. si200 120 00 Py $400 rersm $200 (20 $1,200 (120) 20092010 «201l_-««aol2-=—«OH3_«2O14 IS 2018 «2012018 mC (HS) Production (AHS)
Slide 15: PDC Historical Performance Versus Strategic Priorities
PDC Historical Performance Versus Strategic Priorities Kimmeriage In a recent presentation, POC listed four broad strategic priorities. These priorities are gradational (versus the transformational change required) and have never historically been achieved, PDC Strategic Priority! Historical Perform
Slide 16: PDC: A History of Operational Underperformance
y Kimmeridge PDC: A History of Operational Underperformance
Slide 17: Creating Value in E&P: Maximizing the Recycle Ratio
Creating Value in E&P: Maximizing the Recycle Ratio Kimmeriage + Over the long-term, Kimmeridge believes the best performing E&P companies are those that can find oil and gas cheaply and generate a high cash margin + The key to this is the abilty to minimize cash costs to maximize cash margin and ad
Slide 18: Recycle Ratio v Performance
Recycle Ratio v Performance Kimmeridge The U.S. E&P peer group has demonstrated a strong relationship between recycle ratio and performance over time. PDC has underperformed peers and offset operators on this metric. 2016-2018 fo _ no se 7 oe pPeee fer tothe cy alate ie 7. at a pe canny gs: 22018201
Slide 19: Rising Absolute Well Costs Mean Higher F&D Costs
Ri 1g Absolute Well Costs >> Higher F&D Costs @ vimmeriage PDC has consistently revised up Permian well costs, The Company's long laterals are nearly $3.5M above offset peers. Constantly Rising Permian XRL Well Costs! prseaton 2) Want Higher Costs Than Pe
Slide 20: Underperformance on Productivity Per Lateral Foot
Underperformance on Productivity Per Lateral Foot Kimmeriage ‘Since buying its Permian asset from Kimmeridge, PDC’s Permian wells have materially underperformed the wells that Kimmeridge drilled and completed + Production data further demonstrates PDC's lower productivity per foot, despite higher we
Slide 21: Poor Land Management Has Led to Fewer Locations
Poor Land Management Has Led to Fewer Locations Kimmeriage POC originally guided to 785 net locations in the acquired Delaware Permian acreage. The company revised, and redefined these to "MRL equivalent locations’, while lowering the number to 690 locations, ‘These locations have been further revis
Slide 22: Poor Capital Allocation Leads to Write-Offs
Poor Capital Allocation Leads to Write-Offs Kimmeriage PDC has a history of poor capital allocation. The company has written off approximately $1Bn over the last five years, and lost nearly its entire investment in the Utica (approx. $0.58n), Cumulative Impairment of Properties and Equipment (SM PDC
Slide 23: Excessive SG&A Lowers Cash Flow from Operations
Excessive SG&A Lowers Cash Flow from Operations Kimmeriage + PDC's SGBA is materially higher than peers, lowering the company’s cash margins + A telling metric is overhead per active ig running. POC’s overhead in 2018 was 65% above the peer group average, PEPPPPPV22}))33) @22222023
Slide 24: Poor Operational Performance Leads to Missing FCF Targets
Poor Operational Performance Leads to Missing FCF Targets) Kimmeridge + At the start of 2018, PDCE forecasted an outspend of less than $90 milion for 2018, The actual result ‘was nearly twice as high, with an outspend of $176 million despite materially higher commodity prices. Weleverage ato “BK “se
Slide 25: Benchmarking to Offset Operators (SRCI & CDEV)
Benchmarking to Offset Operators (SRCI & CDEV) Kimmeriage SRCI and CDEV are similar-sized operators to PDC who offset the company in the DJ Niobrara and Permian Delaware, respectively. Based on offset company analysis, PDC’s G&A should have been closer to $91M in 2018. Instead, it was nearly double
Slide 26: What Could Have Been: Annual Cash Leakage from Operational Mismanagement
What Could Have Been: Annual Cash Leakage from Operational Mismanagement Kimmeridge By reducing well costs and overhead, improving well productivity to peer-group leading levels and being better stewards of capital, PDC could have generated $450M in additional cash flow annually. This equates to an
Slide 27: What Could Have Been II: Underperformance Quantified
What Could Have Been II: Underperformance Quantified @ vimmeriage Kimmeridge’s cash leakage analysis suggests that PDC could have generated a recycle ratio of nearly 250% if operations were improved and management allocated capital more prudently. This implies an improvement in 3-year share price pe
Slide 28: Potential Free Cash to Shareholders
Potential Free Cash to Shareholders Kimmeriage PDC's announced buyback is a step in the right direction but it is small relative to its 2018 cash leakage, midstream sale proceeds, 2019 G&A budget and forecasted free cash flow for 2019 (at $60/bbI)
Slide 29: PDC First Quarter 2019 Earnings: Continuation of Poor Operational Performance
PDC First Quarter 2019 Earnings: Continuation of Poor Operational Performance Kimmeriage (On 5/1/2019, POC reported first quarter results that were largely below expectations as evidenced by the sell-side research quotes below. The company managed to miss production estimates for the quarter despite
Slide 30: PDC: A Lack of Alignment and Accountability Leads to Underperformance
y Kimmeridge PDC: A Lack of Alignment and Accountability Leads to. Underperformance
Slide 31: Pay for Underperformance
Pay for Underperformance Kimmeridge Despite a three-year TSR of -44% (2016-2018), PDC's top five executives were paid a total of $16.2M in 2018 and a total of $43,8M over the last three years, ad $0 i - i i . | Sow soo & bo ; 7 en os ee 1 Soo Samat 2 Canpareton ct asa on POC pugs Son Bach meca
Slide 32: Metrics Don't Matter: 2018
Metrics Don’t Matter: 2018 Kimmeridge In 2018, the company awarded its management team cash bonuses of 115% of target despite missing four out of five internally-set targets. 2018 QUANTITIVE CORPORATE METRICS Tana reduction ce) plratn/oe septa opr captat ecney
Slide 33: Metrics Don't Matter: 2016 - 2018
Metrics Don’t Matter: 2016 - 2018 Kimmeriage PDC introduced two new metrics into its 2019 compensation plan: free cash flow margin and debt- adjusted cash flow per share. With litle downside risk for missing targets, new metrics won't matter. Did PDC Exceed Target: Metre: Production Production, Expl
Slide 34: CEO Pay Rising as PDC Stockholder Value is Destroyed
CEO Pay Rising as PDC Stockholder Value is Destroyed Kimmeriage Economic Value Added (Destroyed) = NOPAT — (Invested Capital * WACC)' i ser rsean 7 > a A i re ee oat m9 (S10 gig) igus i g £ 1g230) ($400) (5365) baal ‘1Ushg Keo cesso WACK 10 8% 2 Composer dt basd 69 FOC postmen
Slide 35: Above Average CEO Pay for Below Average Performance
Above Average CEO Pay for Below Average Performance Kimmeriage Ina recent presentation, PDC included a chart from a May 2018 ISS report implying that itis a top performer. This chart was based on performance data through the end of 2017. Accurate and current data paints a different story 'S Chat in
Slide 36: COO: Pay For Underperformance
COO: Pay For Underperformance Kimmeriage ‘The COO Scott Reasoner’s pay has risen despite missing targets. Well costs have risen and capital efficiency has underperformed. The COO also received a special equity grant in 2017, Scott Reasoner Ps Cost Underperformance ‘al conpettin ae joo | li i Capital
Slide 37: EVP Corp Dev and Strategy: Pay For Underperformance
EVP Corp Dev and Strategy: Pay For Underperformance Kimmeriage Under Lance Lauck's watch, PDC has spent $1.98n on land, of which $0.748n has been impaired, to ‘add 52,000 net acres at an average cost of $35,930/acre. This will ise to $57,840lacre by the end of 2019 based on PDC's forecasted expirati
Slide 38: Excuses for Pay
Excuses for Pay Kimmeridge PDC's Board has provided excuses for why management should not be held accountable for missing targets... “The Committee estimates that without the Wattenberg Field midstream issues, the Company would have been atthe high end of production targets forthe yoar." = 2048 Prox
Slide 39: Material Weaknesses In Internal Control
Material Weaknesses In Internal Control Kimmeridge 2017 10K, Report of Independent Public Accounting Firm (PWC) "Also in our opinion, the Company did not maintain, in all material respects, offective internal control ‘over financial reporting as of December 31, 2017 based on citeria established in i
Slide 40: Average Cash Yield for PDC's CEO vs. Outside Shareholders
Average Cash Yield for PDC’s CEO vs. Outside Shareholders) Kimmeridge Bart Brookman, PDC's CEO, has generated an average yield on his personal PDC equity of 27% over the last three years." This is the amount of cash Bart receives each year (salary, bonus, and stock sold in the open market) as a perc
Slide 41: Alignment Drives Performance
Alignment Drives Performance Kimmeriage Private eauity in the upstream energy sector has materially outperformed the XOP over the last ten years despite owning assets in the same basins as public operators, + US oil and gas private equity has generated a ‘weighted average IRR of roughly 10% over $10
Slide 42: A Better Model for PDC Compensation and Governance
A Better Model for PDC Compensation and Governance Kimmeriage Kimmeridge believes that more equity and longer hold periods will cause management teams to act Ike owners. As board members, we would advocate significant change fo compensation and governance models. + Compensation ~ Total cash compensa
Slide 43: PDC: A Better Board and a Path to Profitability
y Kimmeridge PDC: A Better Board and a Path to Profitability
Slide 44: A New Board for a New Business Model
A New Board for a New Business Model Kimmeriage + Kimmeridge is nominating three drectors for PDC's eight-person board at the Company's 2019 annual shareholder meeting + Kimmeridge's candidates have extensive experience as investors and asset owners. + Kimmeridge currently owns 6.1% of PDC. Kimmerid
Slide 45: Kimmeridge's Director Nominees
Kimmeridge’s Director Nominees Kimmeriage Ben Dell Alice Gould James Adelson Bon De sto under of Kime whee he leads rs nestnent ashes eg Drerseeng ie scocning ara gene fnew geotpaapurtunies sel ate negation ‘rectum of ester seleis In2016 Mi Dele thecal of Krmesges Osawa Basin "sSattonoe Prortoteunce
Slide 46: Implementing the Vision
Implementing the Vision Kimmeridge ‘Assuming Kimmeridge holds 3 of 8 board seats, the team will work with the remaining board members ‘on a 180-day pian to deliver better performance 180-Day Plan Assess euren staffing costs, data costs, at, byl S688 expenses Develop clear benmarkfor best in class an
Slide 47: The Need for Change: Performance, Pay and Putting PDC on a Path to Profitability
The Need for Change: Performance, Pay and Putting PDC ona Path to Profitability Kimmeriage + PDC Energy owns high quality assets that are trapped behind a poorly performing team, with a board thatis asleep at the wheel, + Over the last three years shareholders have borne the brunt of this mismanagem
Slide 48: Disclosures
Disclosures ) Kimmeridge
Slide 49: Disclosures
Disclosures 4 Kimmeridge “eeu suo nh recites opens enageEaay Monaginrt Com LE nine a ann Kai) Inu cera pty ares lverinet nts nse stv feet lm chr oman oaekel PEE Energy te (POO) Stee (tomato daar rareiston bares use sre Hcmaicn suche rasan paste, presets echt fesse inenaton Hemmanags panei ana anploj