Stillwater Mining Company

Stillwater Mining — Proxy Contest (April 2013)

39 slides from Stillwater Mining's proxy contest presentation, Apr 8, 2013

  1. Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement - Stillwater Mining Company

    Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement - Stillwater Mining Company

    UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 Filed by the Registrant x Filed by a Party other than the Registrant ¨ Check the appropriate box: ¨ Preliminary Proxy Statement ¨ Conf

  2. Slide 2: Investor Presentation April 2013

    Slide 2: Investor Presentation April 2013

    Investor April 2013 Presentation

  3. Slide 3: Forward-Looking Statements

    Slide 3: Forward-Looking Statements

    isclaimer SUNALLA > Forward-Looking Statements *SOME STATEMENTS CONTAINED IN THIS PRESENTATION ARE FORWARD-LOOKING WITHIN THE MEANING OF SECTION 27A OF THE U.S. SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, AND SECTION 21E OF THE U.S. SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934, AS AMENDED, AND, THEREFORE, INVOLVE UNCERT

  4. Slide 4: Exceptional Palladium Exposure: Key Investment Points

    Slide 4: Exceptional Palladium Exposure: Key Investment Points

    Exceptional PGM Palladium Palladium’s Projected Solidified Stillwater Consistent One 3Attractive ofFundamentals theLong-Term Remains PGM is Lowest-Cost Palladium Re-Rating Outlook the Project PGMthe Are for Production, Supply of to Premier Pipeline PGM Stillwater Stronger Choice Platinum Deficit Pro

  5. Slide 5: 1. PGM Fundamentals Are Stronger Than Ever

    Slide 5: 1. PGM Fundamentals Are Stronger Than Ever

    1. PGM Are EverStronger Fundamentals Than

  6. Slide 6: Palladium's Position as PGM-of-Choice for Auto Catalysts Strengthened

    Slide 6: Palladium's Position as PGM-of-Choice for Auto Catalysts Strengthened

    Palladium’s Position inas PGM-of-Choice for Auto Catalytic Converters Strengthened 2012E Auto Electrical Dental Palladium: Source: (1) Strong (light Excludes Remains Catalysts duty Palladium 6% Global Johnson 13% vehicles Chemical 9,340k investment Car Palladium’s 69%Matthey. Demand Build oz,6% mill

  7. Slide 7: Investor Demand Remains Strong

    Slide 7: Investor Demand Remains Strong

    Investor Demand Remains Strong Gold ETF Ou nces 2,000,000 2,500,000 1,000,000 Apr-07 Apr-08 1,500,000 Investment CAGR: Oct-07 Oct-08 500,000 24% oy Apr-09 (April TrSilver 0as of Oct-09 2007 CAGR:–Apr-10 March 25% as2013) Oct-10 aPlatinum metalApr-11 CAGR: Oct-11 169%Apr-12 Oct-12 Apr-13 Palladium 6S

  8. Slide 8: Palladium's Re-Rating Versus Platinum Is Structural

    Slide 8: Palladium's Re-Rating Versus Platinum Is Structural

    Palladium’s Ratio Structural 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Mkt. Jan-03 Nov-04 We 7Source: believe Average: ofDec-03 Bloomberg Oct-05 Palladium Shift our Re-Rating 42.4% 26.4% marketing Sep-06 in PGM Price as of to Aug-07 Market to 4/1/13. Platinum efforts Platinum Jul-08 have is Price Underway Jun-09 p

  9. Slide 9: Palladium Supply Deficit and Constrained Supply

    Slide 9: Palladium Supply Deficit and Constrained Supply

    (‘000s Case Supply 2.0 2006 2011 2010 4F Palladium 2020F 2019F nMuted deficit South Persistent Russian Mine Limited 2015F 1.0 for 2012E 2007 African Africa of supply 0.0 Constraints disruptions Stockpile Palladium oz) 2016F power number Surplus/Deficit Platinum -1.0 2008 2013F accounts side Producti

  10. Slide 10: 2. Stillwater Remains the Premier PGM Play

    Slide 10: 2. Stillwater Remains the Premier PGM Play

    2. Stillwater Premier PGMRemains Play the

  11. Slide 11: Long-Lived Palladium Reserves in Montana

    Slide 11: Long-Lived Palladium Reserves in Montana

    Long-Lived Palladium Reserves in Montana Over 0Proven Stillwater 16,774 4,681 21,455 9,638 2,676 12,314 7,136 2,005 9,141 Palladium Montana Source: (1) 105,000 Based 40and 10,000 Company. years proven on Mine Platinum Probable current of15,000 East and Proven mining Boulder probable Reserves 20,000

  12. Slide 12: Consistent, Predictable Palladium Production Without South Africa Risk

    Slide 12: Consistent, Predictable Palladium Production Without South Africa Risk

    Consistent, Predictable Palladium Production Without South Africa Risk Annual 0Palladium 2009 PGM Source: 514 518 485 530 111002010 Production 200 PGM Company 300 Platinum 2011 Production 400 2012 (000s filings, 500 Annual 600 ozs) oz)(000s press Guidance ounces) release.

  13. Slide 13: Excellent Cash Cost Management

    Slide 13: Excellent Cash Cost Management

    Excellent Cash 12% 15% Stillwater 14% 12% 8% 6% 5% PGM Metals Note: North Metals: Platinum, IAMGOLD, Source: 12 Cost Cost Producer North American Inmet Company Management Lonmin North 9% Increases American Eldorado. 6% Mining, Diversified American Base 3% filings. (FY2008 (2008 0% Base –Record Capst

  14. Slide 14: Among the Best in the Industry on Cost Position

    Slide 14: Among the Best in the Industry on Cost Position

    Platinum Cash CostEquivalent Position Among ofTotal South Cash the African Best Costsin Producers and the Industry Capital Compared Expenditures to Stillwater per Ounce Cost $3,000 Stillwater Platinum-Equivalent 000 per Average Price: 2000 $2,500 PtMining 01Break-Even 3000 Cumulative Note: 13 4000 E

  15. Slide 15: Adjusted G&A Supports Current Operations and Near-Term Growth

    Slide 15: Adjusted G&A Supports Current Operations and Near-Term Growth

    Montana The Adjusted ($ –$$40 2009 $30 $29 2011 Note: 14 25in$26 $30 slight millions) 2012 2010 Figures $20 G&A U.S. increase $10 represent G&A Supports has seen been Expenses Montana in relatively Current 2011(Montana and Operations G&A consistent 2012 adjusted Operations) is due and since for larg

  16. Slide 16: Strategic Priorities: Capital Allocation Focused on Montana

    Slide 16: Strategic Priorities: Capital Allocation Focused on Montana

    Stillwater Strategic Montana Graham Far 15 Altar Marathon BlitzWestGreek and will Operations Hascapital account Focused priority for its87% Capital is of Montana $173 Allocation millionand of Strategic capital expenditures Priorities budgeted for 2013E

  17. Slide 17: 2013E Montana PGM Production Profile

    Slide 17: 2013E Montana PGM Production Profile

    PGM500 400 500 2013E 600 575 550 530 Montana Source: 16 450 Production 2014E Company 500 PGM Projects 550 2015E Production 600 (000 Will Leverage estimates. 2016E ozs) DriveProfile Existing 2017E Increased toLong Infrastructure Increase PGM TermProduction Approximately 20% in the Coming Years

  18. Slide 18: Growing, Stable Recycling Business

    Slide 18: Growing, Stable Recycling Business

    Growing Stable Substantial 17 andRecycling High growth Return inBusiness volumes Business processed in fourth quarter of 2012 continuing into 2013 Low capital requirements

  19. Slide 19: Stillwater Highly Attractive Marathon and Altar Options

    Slide 19: Stillwater Highly Attractive Marathon and Altar Options

    Stillwater Highly Marathon interest Complete Option Altar significantly forward, 18 attractive to for amaximize Has final range $81 less Excellent engineering million of palladium than options value 2012 (implied Additional without exist: design ($13 deposit valuation million ndiverting work Sale of

  20. Slide 20: Well-Funded Growth Strategy with Convertible Notes

    Slide 20: Well-Funded Growth Strategy with Convertible Notes

    Well nConvert Attractive After-Tax 2% $10.00 0% Stillwater Illustrative Stillwater’s Source: Bond (1) 19 Retire 2013 Montana Graham Far Blitz Represents 4%Capitalized West $209 capital $12.50 6% Company $167 Funding Share Cost Creek $28 PGM Bond 8% Convertible million million expenditures $15.00 aft

  21. Slide 21: Our Strategy Continues to Create Shareholder Value

    Slide 21: Our Strategy Continues to Create Shareholder Value

    Our Strategy Continues to Create Shareholder Value SWC Stillw Mar-12 5-year(17.0%)(62.6%)(70.1%) 3-year(5.4%)(43.4%)(60.5%) South North (25%) 21% –(SWC’s 30 60 Jan-12 (60) Stillwater Stillwater’s Correlated 86% 6.3% Source: Note: 30) return Remains South American African ater (36%) Mar-12 Share May-

  22. Slide 22: Analyst Commentary on Stillwater

    Slide 22: Analyst Commentary on Stillwater

    Analysts Broker JPMorgan labor CIBC and RBC the Wells on Barclays allocation Credit Source: Note: 21 Stillwater.” workforce view Capital unrest Permission Fargo World Suisse Date Equity 2/27/2013 are the risks 3/27/2013 in Securities Recommendation Increasingly Markets whole 2/27/2013 and South Rese

  23. Slide 23: Stillwater's Strategy Provides Exceptional Leverage to Palladium

    Slide 23: Stillwater's Strategy Provides Exceptional Leverage to Palladium

    Stillwater’s PGM Palladium Palladium’s Projected Solidified Stillwater Consistent One Attractive 22 ofFundamentals theLong-Term Remains PGM is Lowest-Cost Palladium Strategy Re-Rating the Project PGMthe Are Provides Production, Supply of to Premier Pipeline PGM Stronger Choice Platinum Deficit Excep

  24. Slide 24: 3. Strong Corporate Governance and Track Record

    Slide 24: 3. Strong Corporate Governance and Track Record

    3. Strong of Governance Corporate Track Record

  25. Slide 25: Shareholder-Friendly Board with Mining and Financial Expertise

    Slide 25: Shareholder-Friendly Board with Mining and Financial Expertise

    Shareholder Mining Financial Strong 35Refreshed Directors Added 24out oftwo Board Experience 8 have Expertise Directors Board new Friendly Alignment aDirectors strong have possess Corporate balance with significant with financial Industry extensive of Governance mining experience expertise mining an

  26. Slide 26: Stillwater Board Nominees

    Slide 26: Stillwater Board Nominees

    Stillwater Name Francis Since Patrick industry Sheryl Steven Craig Michael Gary nGeorge Various Investment Partner Public Chairman Significant Open-pit Extensive Former President A. L. Key K. S. *Denotes 25 M. R. Sugar Advocate S. Fuller* at Chairman President Chairman, Chief CFO Managing COO Lucas*

  27. Slide 27: We Continue to Strengthen Our Board

    Slide 27: We Continue to Strengthen Our Board

    We Continue Two Gary Served Director Independent University George Currently Previously and Holds Cornwall, 26 Sandspring Qualified, Sugar aas Bee Bachelor ofserves Managing United of held Osisko Non-Executive to Toronto Independent Resources various Proactively asof Kingdom Mining the Science Direc

  28. Slide 28: Stillwater's Nominees Have More Relevant Mining Experience

    Slide 28: Stillwater's Nominees Have More Relevant Mining Experience

    Stillwater’s Relevant 7Clinton’s Mining Average 38 126 143 2A 16 5S 14 Note: 27tillwater verage of 8 Years ofCompany Mining Public Clinton’s Experience slate Mining Directors of experience ofCompany Experience nominees Board nominees Have Clinton Experience Experience based has Significantly per hav

  29. Slide 29: Clinton's Nominees Lack Relevant Experience

    Slide 29: Clinton's Nominees Lack Relevant Experience

    Clinton’s Name John union mine Charles high-cost nSeth 28 Attended We BullE. Repeated Poor Material Involved Sundance Catalytic Cutanix Has Board Currently No DeMichiei PGM record public invite been Key Mountain labor safety attendance Gardner R. experience Nominees producer Corporation: inconsisten

  30. Slide 30: Clinton's Nominees Lack Relevant Experience (continued)

    Slide 30: Clinton's Nominees Lack Relevant Experience (continued)

    Clinton’s Name and Faso Michael Brian himself Patrice had Gregory nfraud, 29We Financial Less Limited Investments Reflects Sold Noadevelopment (West U.S. corporate public invite joint Schweitzer Mr. Key than Glass Merrin with “Mick” McNamara P.Nominees management public Taxin short-term venture Attr

  31. Slide 31: Proactively Addressed Compensation and Governance Concerns

    Slide 31: Proactively Addressed Compensation and Governance Concerns

    Proactively Compensation ll Stock Marathon Claw-Back Planning Spending Altar Adopted Reviewed D cash nU the Benchmark comparator CEO Unfavorable Potential Implemented finalization Final No relative Stillwater Source: (1) IAMGOLD,producerKinross North 30irectors nfavorable ll ComparPalladiumtor execu

  32. Slide 32: Stillwater Share Price Indexed Versus Palladium

    Slide 32: Stillwater Share Price Indexed Versus Palladium

    When 75 100 February Indexed 2002 02001 April Stillwater 2003 Palladium Note: 31300 Returns 2004 16, 1, Market 600 Frank 2013 Returns 12, 2003 Has share 900 price price: Price 2005 50McAllister 2001 data Indexed Been 1,200 price: low Stillwater 2006 $781 as Palladium aofLong-Term 2007 $35.10 $2.31 $

  33. Slide 33: 4. Conclusion

    Slide 33: 4. Conclusion

    4. Conclusion

  34. Slide 34: Clinton's Misguided, Value-Destructive Demands

    Slide 34: Clinton's Misguided, Value-Destructive Demands

    Clinton Several Montana Assess Reduce Re-Make …Others Sell Suspend •Replace 33 A Working The Two Montana First Mitsubishi project Stillwater’s Recent Potential Stillwater Platinum outperform Palladium’s cash Mr. Furthermore, forced Altar McAllister Board new flow production Marathon of Cost Brings t

  35. Slide 35: Clinton Group Track Record of Short-Term Activism

    Slide 35: Clinton Group Track Record of Short-Term Activism

    Short-term Value nClinton 13 ($ Current Market Company Board Digital Dillards Lenox Nutrisystem Red Wet No California Carrols China Community Finish Griffon HealthSpring Neutral Optimal Overland Pacific Porter Select Sharper Steven Viking World Average Source: (1) Group 34Small Underperformance in o

  36. Slide 36: Stillwater Conclusion

    Slide 36: Stillwater Conclusion

    Stillwater Conclusion Company “Having longer-term Leon 35 Esterhuizen, looked is hasview the well-positioned taken premier atcan CIBC the decisive appreciate complaints North World to action American deliver Markets this.” ofover thesignificant Clinton Inc. past PGM (3/20/13) 5 years producer Group,

  37. Slide 37: Appendix

    Slide 37: Appendix

    Appendix

  38. Slide 38: Stillwater Reserves as of December 31, 2012

    Slide 38: Stillwater Reserves as of December 31, 2012

    Stillwater Ore Tons (000’s)(oz. As Proven Probable Total Reserves Palladium Platinum Source: 37 of Average Grade Proven December Reserves Company Reserves 15,482 0.13 Reserves Mine 0.46 /Ounces ton)(000’s)(000’s)(000’s)(oz. Contained and 428 1,577 2,005 1,524 5,612 7,136 East 31, 0.59 3,333 Probable

  39. Slide 39: Reconciliation of GAAP to Non-GAAP U.S. G&A Expenses

    Slide 39: Reconciliation of GAAP to Non-GAAP U.S. G&A Expenses

    Reconciliation ($ 2009 GAAP Non-U.S. Unadjusted One Norilsk-Related Acquisition Financing Other Adjusted Source: (1) 38 inIncludes -Time thousands) 2010 Adjustments Reported Company U.S. Attributable Expenses 2011 Expenses U.S. /restructuring Disposition G&A ofExpenses 2012 G&A G&A filings. (1)(8) –

Source: SEC EDGAR · DEFA14A filed Apr 8, 2013

More decks from Stillwater Mining Company