Gas Natural — Proxy Contest (July 2016)
38 slides from Gas Natural's proxy contest presentation, Jul 7, 2016
Slide 1: Investor Presentation July 6, 2016
1 Investor Presentation July 6, 2016
Slide 2: Safe Harbor Statement / Important Shareholder Information
2 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 2 These slides contain (and the accompanying oral discussion will contain) “forward - looking statements” within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Such statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors t hat could
Slide 3: The Situation
3 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 3 ▪ After the dismissal of Richard M. Osborne (RMO), former Chairman and CEO, current management and independent directors launched a turnaround after years of poor regulatory relations, unprofitable investments, weak internal controls and processes and poor morale that exi
Slide 4: PUCO audit and RMO's removal background
4 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 4 ▪ The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) issued an order in November 2013 initiating a management audit of our Ohio utilities due to significant concerns over related party transactions ▪ The audit was ordered in 2013, when RMO was CEO of Gas Natural and the Ohio
Slide 5: EGAS: A Unique, Growing Natural Gas Utility
5 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 5 EGAS: A UNIQUE, GROWING NATURAL GAS UTILITY
Slide 6: Emerging Markets – Growth Opportunity (Maine, North Carolina)
6 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 6 Emerging Markets – Growth Opportunity Maine North Carolina x Service Area: Lincoln to Bucksport x Customers: 6,100 including residential (76%), commercial (23%) and transportation (1%) x Service Area Population: 78,000 x 260 miles of transmission and distribution pipeline
Slide 7: Mature Markets – Stability, Cash Flow (Ohio, Montana)
7 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 7 Mature Markets – Stability, Cash Flow x Service Area: Located in northeastern and central O hio x Customers: 27,700 including residential (92%), commercial (5%) and transportation (3%) x Service Area Population: 5.9 million x 1,380 miles of transmission and distribution p
Slide 8: Increasing Market Penetration
8 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 8 [1] Restated for divestiture of Wyoming operations recorded as discontinued operations ▪ Rapidly expanding market share in ME and NC ▪ Midstream pipeline opportunities ▪ Geographically diverse customer base enhances stability of operations Increasing Market Penetration 65
Slide 9: RMO Nearly Destroyed EGAS
9 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 9 RMO NEARLY DESTROYED EGAS
Slide 10: Regulatory challenges prevalent in Ohio
10 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 10 ▪ The PUCO found issues with two consecutive audit periods of Gas Cost Recovery (GCR) filings by EGAS’ Ohio utilities ▪ PUCO ordered investigation ▪ November 2013, PUCO ordered investigative audit of Ohio utilities and related party transactions with RMO - owned entitie
Slide 11: Ohio regulatory challenges bleed to other jurisdictions
11 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 11 ▪ Threats of show cause orders from Montana, North Carolina, Wyoming and Maine regulators ▪ Wyoming: Commission exerted jurisdiction beyond the utility, to Gas Natural ▪ Montana: Commission threatened jurisdiction over Gas Natural and suspended dividends for violation o
Slide 12: We Are at an Inflection Point
12 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 12 WE ARE AT AN INFLECTION POINT
Slide 13: Gas Natural Transformation
13 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 13 ▪ New management ▪ New Board ▪ Rationalized assets ▪ Improving regulatory relationships ▪ Addressing past operational and control issues Gas Natural Transformation
Slide 14: Making Progress
14 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 14 Making Progress ▪ Acquired Ohio utilities from RMO ▪ GCR audits ▪ 4 stock offerings — 3.9m primary shares issued and 2.1m secondary shares sold by RMO ▪ Acquired JDOG Marketing from RMO ▪ PUCO ordered investigative audit of Ohio utilities ▪ Shareholder lawsuits filed ▪
Slide 15: Improving Operations and Performance
15 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 15 ▪ Fixing capital structure ▪ Refinancing ▪ Agreement with lenders ▪ Organizational structure ▪ In front of four state commissions for approval ▪ Adjusted dividend ▪ Reduced by $0.24, or 44%, to align with earnings at a sustainable level ▪ Expect to maintain payout and s
Slide 16: Improving Regulatory Relations
16 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 16 ▪ Montana Public Service Commission (MSPC) ▪ December 2014: Dividend from subsidiary, Energy West, to parent, EGAS, had been suspended because of ring - fencing violations ▪ July 2015: Regular and special dividend reinstated ▪ Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO)
Slide 17: Decisive Actions
17 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 17 ▪ Engaged regulators, staff and utility management to assess and formulate a plan to rebuild trust and relationships ▪ Established transparency across the organization and with investors; initiated quarterly investor calls in April 2014 ▪ Overhauled leadership across Ga
Slide 18: Decisive Actions (Cont'd.)
18 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 18 Decisive Actions (Cont’d.) ▪ Replaced a majority of the Board ▪ Initiated critical lawsuits to bring finality to PUCO Staff and Ohio Consumers ’ Counsel concerns regarding RMO’s related party transactions ▪ Resolution passed to eliminate all related party transactions n
Slide 19: Results: Driving Value
19 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 19 □ Rationalized non - core assets □ Divested Wyoming assets □ Divested Pennsylvania assets □ Divested Kentucky assets □ Reinstated EWI dividend to parent □ SAP implementation □ Phase I □ Phase II □ Settled COI case with PUCO □ Settled OTP case with PUCO □ Restructuring o
Slide 20: The EGAS Board & Management Are on the Right Track
20 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 20 THE EGAS BOARD & MANAGEMENT ARE ON THE RIGHT TRACK ▪ EGAS has an exceptional market opportunity ▪ EGAS is at the inflection point of the turnaround ▪ EGAS offers the right Board and Executive T eam to execute and grow its business – with strong corporate governance
Slide 21: Board nominee biographies and skills
21 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 21 Nominee Biography Joined BoD Other Public BoD Public Co. Mgmt. Governance Utility Finance Acctg. Strategy Michael R. Winter (Chairman) Retired partner with PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, having served clients principally in the utility and energy industry, also with transa
Slide 22: Strong Corporate Governance
22 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 22 Strong Corporate Governance EGAS’s Strong Corporate Governance Ensures Board and Management Accountability 5 Number of independent Directors of 6 member Board 4 Joined Board post departure of RMO 2.5 Average tenure (years) x Separated Chairman and CEO roles x Two Direct
Slide 23: EGAS Five Year Share Price Catalysts
23 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 23 EGAS Five Year Share Price Catalysts A. 05/15/12 Prospectus for 700k share secondary offering B. 06/26/12 Secondary offering of 700k shares; RMO selling C. 11/13/12 Q3 2012 earnings D. 12/21/12 $50m shelf E. 07/11/13 Priced primary offering at $10 per share; 1.5m shares
Slide 24: Strategic Focus
24 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 24 ▪ Grow customer base by 4% - 5% per year ▪ Increase full service distribution throughput ▪ Proactively ensure regulatory transparency ▪ Continue investments in utility assets for growth ▪ Prudently manage capital allocation and cost structure Strategic Focus
Slide 25: Our Analyst Supports Management and Our Strategy
25 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 25 Liam D. Burke, April 8, 2016 Our Analyst Supports Management and Our Strategy “EGAS shares generate an attractive dividend yield. Despite lowering its annual dividend from $0.54 to $0.30, EGAS shares currently yield 4.2%. The dividend reduction reflects the company’s de
Slide 26: RMO and Slate Bring No Added Value
26 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 26 RMO AND SLATE BRING NO ADDED VALUE
Slide 27: Dissident Nominees Comments
27 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 27 Dissident Nominees Comments ▪ Richard M. Osborne ▪ Removed from EGAS as Chairman and CEO in May 2014, in part for failure to adhere to Board resolution ▪ Several companies owned by Richard M. Osborne are undergoing bankruptcy proceedings, including John D. Oil & Gas Com
Slide 28: Regulatory Citations Referencing RMO
28 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 28 ▪ The PUCO initiated an investigation into the management practices at our Ohio utilities, primarily due to significant concerns over related party transactions between our Ohio utilities and RMO’s companies ▪ The PUCO noted about RMO’s tenure as Chairman and CEO of EGA
Slide 29: PUCO order dated June 15, 2016
29 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 29 ▪ PUCO states the following in order, dated June 15, 2016: ▪ “ OTP, Cobra, and any other pipeline companies owned or controlled by Richard Osborne and regulated by the PUCO should file, within 60 days of this Opinion and Order, a rate case application to establish just
Slide 30: RMO Actions Demonstrate Self-Dealing
30 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 30 RMO Actions Demonstrate Self - Dealing ▪ RMO divested a significant number of shares during his tenure as Chairman and CEO ▪ Dividend payments increased dramatically during his tenure, jeopardizing the sustainability of EGAS’s cash flows ▪ The growing dividends funded R
Slide 31: Capital Investments Strained by RMO Interests
31 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 31 ▪ 2013 and 2014: Included numerous large projects ▪ Significantly exceeded depreciation and amortization ▪ 2015: Reduced capital expenditures to focus on return - generating investments ▪ Adding more services to installed mainlines; investing in growth areas ▪ NC and ME
Slide 32: Darryl L. Knight Unfit to Serve as EGAS Director
32 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 32 ▪ In his capacity as General Manager of Gas Natural’s North Carolina utility, Darryl L. Knight demonstrated a lack of understanding of critical utility operations ▪ NCUC disallowed >$2.4 million regarding gas cost procurement practices under Knight’s management ▪ Gas Na
Slide 33: The Dissident Committee's Solutions
33 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 33 The Dissident Committee’s Solutions Comments ▪ Reinstating the Company’s dividend to $0.54 annually ▪ Under RMO, our outstanding common stock increased more than twofold from 2010 - 2013, more than doubling the total annual dividend to a level that was disproportionate
Slide 34: We Are Driving Change
34 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 34 WE ARE DRIVING CHANGE
Slide 35: Vision, Mission and Strategy
35 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 35 Our VISION: To be a premier natural gas company recognized as the benchmark in the natural gas utility industry by customers, peers and investors Our MISSION: To provide safe, reliable, cost - effective natural gas services to current and future customers Our STRATEGY:
Slide 36: In Closing: Vote the GREEN proxy card
36 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 36 ▪ EGAS has refreshed its business, strategy and Board ▪ EGAS believes it is positioned for significant growth ▪ New management has demonstrated significant progress since RMO’s dismissal ▪ RMO’s committee, representing <0.1% of ShOut, fraught with regulatory investigati
Slide 37: Thank You
37 © 2016 Gas Natural Inc. 37 THANK YOU
Slide 38: Important Shareholder Information
38 July 6 , 2016 Investor Presentation Important Shareholder Information Gas Natural will hold its 2016 Annual Meeting of Shareholders on July 27, 2016. The Company has filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) and mailed to its shareholders a definitive proxy statement toge