Vitacost.com Inc

Vitacost.com — Proxy Contest (June 2010)

31 slides from Vitacost.com's proxy contest presentation, Jun 14, 2010

  1. Slide 1: Vitacost Investor Presentation

    vitacost Live Longer & Save Money™ Investor Presentation June 14, 2010 S.time Ine 600 Ine 500 Internet Retailer Winner Hall Of Fame

  2. Slide 2: Required Disclosures

    Required Disclosures Required Disclosure 14,2010, te, UP, Additional Information and Where to Find It laos comin. aw sctn tho SEC" onlay 28,2010, INVESTORS AND STOCKHOLDERS ARE ADVISED TOREAD THE DEFINITIVE CONSENT REVOCATION STATEMENT ANO OTHER RELEVANT DOCUMENTS FILED WITH THE SEC BECAU CONTAIN IM

  3. Slide 3: Safe Harbor Summary

    Safe Harbor Summary and acompanyiog orl presentation contain foward-ooking statment, Forwartooking statment inde salmon conoming our flows, bec. goa Se, re cr, ur rvean of eurmance, apt goede, ncaa afer man a aes oa ry wari a yer Sh. Tooking sates mpota actors ht coud aise Sea fests oar matey tom he

  4. Slide 4: Company Highlights

    Company Highlights A leading online retailer and direct marketer of health and wellness products, vitamins and dietary supplements (1) Large and growing market opportunity Superior customer value, product selection and experience Growing loyal customer base Strong infrastructure to support growth Ex

  5. Slide 5: Vitacost At A Glance

    Vitacost At A Glance Revenue ‘Company Snapshot ($ mions) 1984 Founded as Natu Wealth Co. 1999 Launched Vitacost com; Invoduced propsctary products 2004 Rapid expansion of proprietary products 2008 Started in-house manufacturing 2009 Initial Public Offering 2010 Substantial increase of third-party SK

  6. Slide 6: Large And Growing Market Opportunity

    Large And Growing Market Opportunity U.S. Online Commerce Industry U.S. Nutritional Industry CTT eos teal UE eet 2009 compared to 2004 6.3% to $25.2 billion from 2007 to 2008. by 2010) Sales for the next five years (3) U.S. Online Supplement Sales Forecast 2008 - 2017 ©) vitacost (SSS °

  7. Slide 7: Value Proposition To Customers

    Value Proposition To Customers Reliable And Timely Order Fulfillment User Friendly Shops Broad Consistently Product rior Selection Value

  8. Slide 8: Broad Product Selection

    Broad Product Selection + 36,000+ SKUs “sobs brands BB OMe <> = CE cur] ns —~ aA A OB Sy Jengens. [ES oon TWINIAB" vitacost

  9. Slide 9: Experienced Management

    Experienced Manageme Ira Kerker Richard Smith Sonya Lambert Robert Hirsch Chief Executive Officer Chief Financial & Accounting Officer Chief Marketing Officer Chief Information Officer ‘enure at Vitacost.com > 5 years > 6 years >7 years > 1.5 years

  10. Slide 10: Company Accomplishments (IPO 9/23/2009)

    Company Accomplishments (IPO 9/23/2009) Delivered revenue growth of 32% yly for 4Q09, 34% for full year 2009 and 25% yly for 1010 Launched mobile version of website and online community site — MyVitacost Community FDA ii ion of Successfully completed installation of Microsoft AX — the next generatio

  11. Slide 11: 2010 Initiatives

    2010 Initiatives Add 4 new directors to the Board with nutraceutical, internet, finance, operations, consumer packaged goods, and public company Board experience — hired SSA Executive Search on 4/29/2010 —- BEFORE GHP’s nomination of candidates Correct manufacturing logistics issues by end of 2Q — o

  12. Slide 12: Steps to Correct Manufacturing Issue

    Steps to Correct Manufacturing Issue Executive management holds daily calls with all departments at the plant — scheduling/purchasing, production, quality control Implemented new scheduling software to enhance visibility and i of the i ling process Adopted additional oversight procedures to ensure t

  13. Slide 13: Peer Group Criteria

    er Group Criteria p (< $1B market cap) pi companies Result Blue Nile (NILE) Drugstore.com (DSCM) Pet Meds (PETS) Overstock.com (OSTK) 1-800 Flowers (FLWS) Shutterfly (SFLY) Stamps.com (STMP) US Auto Parts (PRTS) nal nutrition and wellness players Vitamin Shoppe (VS!) NBTY (N Nutisyatora (NTRI Whole

  14. Slide 14: Peer Group Performance Scorecard — Stock Performance

    Peer Group Performance Scorecard — Stock Performance a VITC has underperformed performance basi

  15. Slide 15: Peer Group Performance — Operating Metrics

    Peer Group Performance — Operating Metrics "WOT BOH GF HD ve Gt 2108 v= GY AAD va ICAGR 03 2008.08 208 20%) 20% 109% 42% however, VITC ‘OUTPERFORMED its peers on a sales growth basis in very period! lar i 4m Om Boe 80% —— ce SE aa tomeampen ty

  16. Slide 16: Peer Group Performance — Operating Metrics (cont'd)

    Peer Group Performance — Operating Metrics (cont'd) “Aajusied EBITDA Grow "HOTT OY 8 ve. GU ZI ve GF 2U10 ICAGR 03 2008-04 208, vite OUTPERFOMED all peers when lookin adjusted EBITDA hin every 1 wos ures sre] Vitacost 20% experienced manufacturing issue. Therefore, no PATTERN of, underperformape: ex

  17. Slide 17: The Company has announced its slate of Directors

    The Company has announced its slate of 7 Directors INCLUDING 4 NEW HIGHLY QUALIFIED CANDIDATES for its August 26, 2010 Annual Meeting If GHP (ONLY A 19.7% SHAREHOLDER) OBTAINS MAJORITY BOARD CONTROL IN ITS CONSENT SOLICIATION — VITACOST.COM SHAREHOLDERS WILL NEVER HAVE THE CHANCE TO CONSIDER AND VOT

  18. Slide 18: Proposed Board Composition

    om Proposed Board Composi 7 Directors up for election at August 26, 2010 shareholder meeting 4 New Directors Barbara Allen - 15 years of Board of Directors experience including CPG companies: Maytag, Tyson, Converse and Co! Sheryle Bolton ~ 20 years internet/technology expertise - former Founder and

  19. Slide 19: New Board Candidate

    New Board Candidate overnance/Marketing Experience Barbara Allen 15 years of Board of Directors experience including CPG companies: Maytag, Converse, Tyson, Lance, Charthouse, and Coty Currently, Chairman of the compensation committee and member of the strategy committee for RLI Corp. (insurance) Fo

  20. Slide 20: New Board Candidate

    iNew Board Candidate Sheryle Bolton 20 years internetitechnology expertise Currently, Board member for LiveDeal, Inc. (NASDAQ: LIVE) 18 years of Board of Directors ; experience including NASDAQ listed internet Learning Ci (SCIL) and HealthCenteral.com (HCEN) Former Founder and CEO of Quixit, Inc. —

  21. Slide 21: New Board Candidate

    New Board Candidate Alan Gallantar, CPA 17 years of financial expertise working for NASDAQ listed “Financial expert” for audit committee purposes Former CFO of Ivivi Technologies, NASDAQ listed technology and medical device company Led company through IPO process Established corporate governance pol

  22. Slide 22: New Board Candidate

    New Board Candidate ance Experience Edwin Kozlowski, CPA 25 years of financial/operations expertise “Financial expert” for audit committee purposes Current Chairman of the Board of Help a Child — a social service, non- profit organization Former EVP/COO of Retail Ventures — a $2.7B retail holding co

  23. Slide 23: Summary of New Board Candidate Experience

    immary of New Board Candidate Expe: 40+ years of combined experience in Health & Wellness industry - OUR CORE CATEGORY 40+ years of combined financial and operations experience 38+ years of combined experience serving on Board of Directors 23+ years of combined experience in consumer packaged goods

  24. Slide 24: Exploring strategic and financial alternatives

    On 5/20/2010 — VITC it is i ‘ifying and strategic and financial alternatives to enhance shareholder value and had hired Oppenheimer as its financial advisor Company has been approached by suitors over the years and believed it was prudent to explore all options to increase shareholder value Manageme

  25. Slide 25: GHP purchased 19.7% of outstanding stock; rights plan adopted

    On March 23, 2010 —- GHP purchased a total of 19.7% of the outstanding stock from the co’s co-founder and 2 other shareholders. Given that GHP had previously expressed its desire to purchase up to 30% of the company’s outstanding stock, the Board deemed it prudent to put in the SRP to protect ALL of

  26. Slide 26: Shareholder Friendly Governance Provisions

    hareholder ndly Governance Prov jing 4 new, independent Directors to be voted upon by the shareholders at didi the August 2010 Annual Meeting Offers shareholders ability to act by written consent 410%+ shareholders can calll special meetings No supermajority approvals Declassified Board structure No

  27. Slide 27: History of Relationship with GHP

    History of Relationship with GHP In early 2008, VITC met with GHP to discuss a possible investment in the Company .. GHP entered into a non-disclosure agreement with VITC and conducted weeks of due diligence. GHP chose not to proceed with an investment. In September 2009, the Company went public. Nu

  28. Slide 28: History of Relationship with GHP (cont'd)

    History of Relationship with GHP (cont'd) On March 24, 2010 - the Board approved a Stockholder Rights Plan (SRP). On March 25, 2010 - GHP contacted the company to express their disappointment with the SRP and that they had a right to receive material non- public information in advance due to their o

  29. Slide 29: GHP Board Nominees Not the Answer for Vitacost.com

    ees Not the Answer for its isiness or operating plan to enhance the Company’s future financial performance GHP wants CONTROL of the company (demanding 4 out of 7 seats or 57%) with only a 19.7% investment and WITHOUT MAKING ANY PAYMENT TO STOCKHOLDERS Numerous times VITC has offered GHP 2 Board seat

  30. Slide 30: GHP Board Nominees Not the Answer for Vitacost.com (cont'd)

    GHP Board Nominees Not the Answer for Vitacost.com (cont'd) ‘According to GHP's Consent Christopher Gaffney health & wellness industry any CPG company Linked-in page states that GHP does not invest in any “manufacturing companies” Currently sits on 8 other Boards Mark Jung No reported experience in

  31. Slide 31: Conclusion

    Conclusion Current senior management credited with growing sales at a CAGR of 45.3% from 2004 — 2009 and growing Adjusted EBITDA* at a CAGR of 295.2% from 2005-2009 Management upgrading current Board with candidates with expertise in critical areas such as: health & wellness, operations and finance

Vitacost.com — Proxy Contest (June 2010) on 6ix