Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — National Bank of Belgium — Investor Presentation (October 2014)
34 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's investor presentation, Oct 26, 2014
Slide 1: Comprehensive Assessment: Belgian banks results
Comprehensive Assessment Belgian banks results October 26th 2014
Slide 2: Agenda
Agenda ► Introduction ► Methodology ► Process and organization ► Results ► Conclusions 2 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 3: Comprehensive Assessment was granted in the SSM regulation
Before ECB takes over its new supervisory role, a “Comprehensive Assessment” was granted in the SSM regulation From the entry into force of this Regulation, in view of the assumption of its tasks, the ECB may require the competent authorities of the participating Member States and the persons referr
Slide 4: Comprehensive Assessment is a prudential exercise composed of an AQR and a Stress Test
Comprehensive Assessment is a prudential exercise composed of an Asset Quality Review and a Stress Test The ECB together with the national competent authorities is carrying out a comprehensive assessment on major European banking groups, in line with the provisions regarding the Single Supervisory M
Slide 5: A capital plan will be required for banks that fail the exercise
A capital plan will be required for banks that fail the Comprehensive Assessment exercise ► Outcomes of the Comprehensive Assessment are CET1 ratios following the Asset Quality Review and the Stress Test projections ► The following CET1 ratio thresholds have been defined by the ECB to assess the out
Slide 6: Six Belgian banks were in scope
Six Belgian banks were in scope for the Comprehensive Assessment ► Comprehensive Assessment performed by the NBB on six home banks ● Investar (holding of Argenta Bank- Verzekeringsgroep) ● Axa Bank Europe SA ● Belfius Banque SA ● The Bank of New York Mellon SA ● Dexia NV ● KBC Group NV ► In addition
Slide 7: Methodology
Methodology 7 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 8: The AQR comprised three phases
The AQR comprised three phases with final report disclosure in October 2014 constituting the end point ► Phase 1: A Risk-based portfolio selection ● Based on a NBB bottom-up proposal based on risk assessment (50% of credit risk- weighted assets covered by portfolio selection) ● Final selection perfo
Slide 9: The ECB designed a prescriptive AQR methodology based on 9 work blocks
The ECB designed a prescriptive AQR methodology based on 9 work blocks covering banking and trading books January 2014 August 2014 6. Projections of Findings of Credit File Review 2. Loan Tape Creation and 4. Credit 9. Determine Data Integrity 3.Sampling File Review AQR Adjusted Validation 7. Collec
Slide 10: The stress test relied on a shock applied across various risk areas
The stress test relied on a shock applied across various risk areas under a static balance sheet assumption Risk Main stress principle • Static balance sheet unless restructuring plan General approved by EC before end 2013 (applicable for assumption Dexia, KBC, Belfius) Credit risk • Stressed credit
Slide 11: Comparison of macroeconomic scenarios between Belgium and EU average
Comparison of macroeconomic scenarios between Belgium and European Union average Baseline scenario Adverse scenario Belgium EU Belgium EU 1,4% 1,7% 1,4% 1,5% 2,0% 1,8% Real GDP 0,1% 0,1% (% growth year on year) -0,2% -0,7% -1,5% -1,5% Consumer prices 1,7% 1,4% 1,5% 1,2% 1,5% 1,1% (% growth 0,9% 0,8%
Slide 12: Process and organization
Process and organization 12 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 13: A robust quality assurance process has been set up
A robust quality assurance process has been set up to ensure the highest quality of deliverables Asset Quality Review Stress Test ► AQR methodology and technical ► Stress Test methodology has been assistance has been provided by the ECB provided by the EBA, with additional guidance and benchmark fro
Slide 14: Results: Overview of Comprehensive Assessment results for Belgian banks
Results Overview of Comprehensive Assessment results for Belgian banks 14 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 15: Excluding Dexia, average decrease in CET1 ratio of 5.8% under adverse scenario
Excluding Dexia, Belgian banks display an average decrease in CET1 ratio of 5.8% under adverse scenario Average CET1 ratio for Belgian banks (excluding Dexia) Asset Quality Review ST Baseline scenario ST Adverse scenario 16% 14,0% 0,5% 5,4% 14% 13,5% 1,1% 12,5% 12% 10% 8,2% 8% 6% 2013 CET1 AQR AQR a
Slide 16: Heterogeneity in results reflects different business models and restructuring progress
The large degree of heterogeneity in results reflects different business models and progress in restructuring CET1% evolution CET1% evolution Baseline scenario Adverse scenario Stress Test Stress Test CET1% 2013 AQR Result1 Final CET1%3 Final CET1%3 Remedial measures taken Result2 Result2 Argenta 24
Slide 17: Belgian banks represent 2% of total SSM capital shortfalls
Belgian banks represent 2% of total SSM capital shortfalls identified by the Comprehensive Assessment Total capital shortfalls identified by the Comprehensive Assessment 30 24.6 BN 25 20 15 9.5 BN 10 5 0.54 BN 0 BN 0 Belgian banks SSM Shortfall before remedial actions Shortfall after remedial action
Slide 18: Two Belgian banks failed adverse threshold but capital measures already taken
Two Belgian banks failed to meet adverse threshold but required capital measures have already been taken ► In adverse scenario, total capital shortfall in Belgium amounts to 0.54 BN EUR out of 25.2 BN EUR in the SSM due to Axa Bank Europe (200 M EUR shortfall) and Dexia (339 M EUR shortfall) ► Axa B
Slide 19: Results: Asset Quality Review
Results Asset Quality Review 19 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 20: AQR results in an average adjustment of 2013 CET1 ratio by 0.45%
The AQR results in an average adjustment of 2013 CET1 ratio by 0.45%, driven by the application of a conservative methodology AQR work-blocks Average CET1% adjustment for Belgian banks Credit portfolio 0.34% Individually assessed provisions 0.12% Collectively assessed provisions 0.22% Trading portfo
Slide 21: AQR highlighted qualitative shortcomings in banks' practices
Beyond quantitative impacts, the AQR highlighted some qualitative shortcomings in banks’ practices Main topics Areas for improvement • Available information on collateral and credit profile of clients 1 Data quality • Reconciliation of data sources • Correctness of assets classification and portfoli
Slide 22: Results: Stress Test
Results Stress Test 22 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 23: Legacy activities represent about 30% of impact under adverse scenario
Even excluding Dexia, legacy activities represent about 30% of impact on Belgian banks under adverse scenario CET1% impact under adverse scenario (excluding AQR) 2013 CET1 ratio 14.0% State Aid repayments1 -1.1% Divested/Run-off activities2 -0.6% Total legacy impacts -1.8% Credit portfolio – Belgium
Slide 24: Stress test results reflect characteristics and business models of Belgian banking sector
The Stress test results reflect the general characteristics and the business models of Belgian banking sector Main topics Stress test highlights • Severe impact from shock applied to portfolios that are in run-off or already 1 Legacy items sold • Incorporation of full state aid repayment by KBC (1.8
Slide 25: Results: Comparison with SSM results
Results Comparison with SSM results 25 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 26: High-level comparison with average SSM results
High-level comparison with average SSM results has been performed but should be considered with appropriate care ► Given that ING Belgium and BNPP Fortis are consolidated within their mother companies, average results for the six Belgian banks presented in the subsequent slides should not be conside
Slide 27: Belgian average reduction in CET1 under adverse scenario higher than SSM average
Belgian average reduction in CET1 ratio under adverse scenario is significantly higher than SSM average… Reduction in CET1 ratio for SSM countries under the adverse scenario in 2016 Weighted average, NBB estimates 14% 11,9% 12% 10,8% 10% 8,4% 8% 7,2% 6,3% 6,2% 6,1% 5,8% 6% 5,1% 5,0% 4,1% 4,0% 4,0% 4
Slide 28: Belgian average CET1 ratio projected for 2016 in line with SSM average
… but Belgian average CET1 ratio projected for 2016 remains in line with SSM average under both scenarios Average CET1 ratio for SSM countries and Belgium Weighted average 16% 14,6% 14,0% 14% 12,1% 12,5% 11,8% 11,4% 12% 10% 8,4% 8,2% 8% 7,4% 6% 4% 2% 0% SSM BE BE SSM BE BE SSM BE BE (exc. (exc. (exc
Slide 29: Belgium and SSM report a similar average AQR impact
In spite of different drivers, Belgium and SSM report a similar average AQR impact Pre-tax impact of the AQR by component, In % of total AQR impact, excluding Dexia for Belgium 0.9 BN EUR 47.7 BN EUR 60% 56% 50% 41% 40% 34% 30% 27% 23% 20% 10% 10% 6% 3% 0% Individually Collectively CVA Level 3 Indiv
Slide 30: Differences between SSM and Belgium driven by legacy and business model
Differences between SSM and Belgium average in the CA results are mainly driven by legacy and business model specificities ► Under stress test scenarios, Belgium banks are, on average, more severely impacted than SSM average ● Significant impact from legacy activities on Belgian (repayment of State
Slide 31: Belgian banks above 5.5% threshold under fully-loaded CET1
Belgian banks are already above the 5,5% threshold under fully-loaded CET1 definition even after stress conditions 14,0% 12,5% 12,0% 11,3% 10,0% 8,2% 8,0% 8% 6,5% 6,0% 5.5% 4,0% 2,0% 0,0% Baseline - 2016 Adverse - 2016 CET1 with transitional measures CET1 fully loaded (estimates with exclusion of St
Slide 32: Conclusions
Conclusions 32 Comprehensive Assessment – Press Conference
Slide 33: Conclusions
Conclusions ► The Comprehensive Assessment was a unique exercise by its scope and seriousness ► The NBB, the audit firms and the Belgian banks have worked hard together with the ECB to ensure credibility and transparency of the whole exercise. Beyond heterogeneity among banks and portfolios, the Com
Slide 34: Additional information available
Additional information available Source Additional information available on respective website • Press release NBB • Press conference presentation • Press release ECB • Comprehensive Assessment disclosure templates • ECB Comprehensive Assessment aggregate report • Press release EBA • EBA disclosure
National Bank of Belgium — Investor Presentation (October 2014) on 6ix