Spirit Airlines — Proxy Contest (May 2022)
41 slides from Spirit Airlines's proxy contest presentation, May 23, 2022
Slide 1: JetBlue's $30 all-cash proposal offers MORE for Spirit shareholders
May 23, 2022 Investor Presentation JetBlue’s $30 all-cash proposal offers MORE MORE for Spirit shareholders and MORE for all stakeholders of the new JetBlue
Slide 2: Important information for investors and stockholders
Important information for investors and stockholders Forward looking statements Statements in this presentation contain various forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, or the Securities Act, and Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Ac
Slide 3: JetBlue offers you MORE...
JetBlue offers you MORE... More value and more certainty for Spirit shareholders More value NOW More value at CLOSING More competition for the Big Four airlines More of the great experience and low fares only JetBlue can offer customers nationwide – a prospect, coupled with the ease of ultra-low-cos
Slide 4: JetBlue's proposal is clearly superior to Frontier's in all respects
JetBlue’s proposal is clearly superior to Frontier’s in all respects Frontier JetBlue Price $30.00 per share offer ($33.00 per share in consensual transaction): now a higher premium to Frontier’s offer value, given market decline $3.3bn1 Equity Value $19.73 total consideration2 per Spirit share $2.0
Slide 5: JetBlue offers superior value to Spirit shareholders in any scenario
Short-term trading JetBlue offers superior value to Spirit shareholders in any scenario Transaction closes Transaction does not close Frontier Transaction ~$161 ~$202 ~$184 JetBlue Transaction ~$181 $303 up to $333 ~$235 up to ~$255 Source: Bloomberg; market data as of May 20, 2022. 1 Estimated as S
Slide 6: NEA is irrelevant for Spirit
NEA is irrelevant for Spirit… JetBlue to divest Spirit’s holdings in NYC and BOS JetBlue’s NEA – either approved by the courts or blocked – does not hinder a JetBlue-Spirit transaction Market shares are basically the same… JetBlue / Spirit combined market share of 8%1 Frontier / Spirit combined mark
Slide 7: Spirit's Board is entrenched and conflicted
Spirit’s Board is entrenched and conflicted Multiple Spirit Directors involved in the decision to merge with Frontier have significant ties to Bill Franke, who appointed each to the Spirit Board Length of tenure and known conflicts display poor governance Frontier has promised Board seats on the com
Slide 8: Vote against the Frontier transaction at the Spirit special meeting
Vote against the Frontier transaction at the Spirit special meeting Exercise your appraisal rights Tender your shares in JetBlue’s tender offer Spirit shareholders have an important choice to make about their investment; vote against the Frontier transaction on June 10 and exercise your appraisal ri
Slide 9: Vote AGAINST the Frontier transaction and exercise appraisal rights
Spirit shareholders should vote AGAINST the Frontier transaction and also exercise appraisal rights they are entitled to under Delaware law Section 262 of the Delaware General Corporation Law provides Spirit shareholders with appraisal rights which could apply in the event the Frontier transaction i
Slide 10: Key takeaways
Key takeaways jetBlue
Slide 11: Key takeaways for Spirit shareholders
Key takeaways for Spirit shareholders JetBlue offers superior value to Spirit shareholders JetBlue has strong conviction in its ability to close – Spirit’s regulatory objections have no merit Spirit’s Board is entrenched, conflicted, has failed to maximize shareholder value, and ignores the similar
Slide 12: JetBlue offers superior value to Spirit shareholders
JetBlue offers superior value to Spirit shareholders
Slide 13: JetBlue offers superior value for Spirit shareholders
Aggregate Equity Value JetBlue Proposal Spirit Unaffected Share Price1 $21.73 $19.73 Implied Value of Frontier Transaction2 + 52% + 10.27 + 38% + 8.27 $3.3bn JetBlue offers superior value for Spirit shareholders Summary of JetBlue’s Superior Proposal Value per Spirit share comparison ($) 1 Spirit un
Slide 14: Upside if Frontier transaction is rejected
Implied Value of Spirit Upside if Frontier transaction is rejected Average spread1 (5-Apr to 29-Apr) $30.00 JetBlue Proposal $23.14 $16.98 Spirit Trading Price before JetBlue Tender ~36% Premium A rejection of the Frontier transaction will result in a higher price for Spirit stock, even before any c
Slide 15: A Vote for Frontier is a Vote for Spirit Shares to Decline
A Vote for Frontier is a Vote for Spirit Shares to Decline Implied Value of Spirit Share Downside if Frontier Transaction is Approved Average Spread1 (7-Feb to 4-Apr) Source: Bloomberg; market data as of May 20, 2022. 1 Spread represents the difference between the implied price per share in the Fron
Slide 16: Market Reaction Contrast
Market Reaction Contrast Spirit Share Price History The market reaction is clear; the JetBlue offer is good for Spirit shareholders and the conflicted Spirit Board continues to make decisions that are detrimental to Spirit shareholder value Every constructive piece of news around the JetBlue proposa
Slide 17: Value of JetBlue's proposal superior at nearly every probability of closing
Value of JetBlue’s proposal is superior to Frontier’s at nearly every assumed probability of closing Source: Bloomberg; market data as of May 20, 2022. 1 Reflects Spirit HUSP indexed against Frontier stock price performance since 04-Feb-2022 (undisturbed date before Frontier Transaction announcement
Slide 18: JetBlue's synergies are based on realistic assumptions
JetBlue’s synergies are based on realistic assumptions that support the strategic rationale of the acquisition Facts do not support Spirit management’s projections; significantly overstate potential shareholder value and consumer benefits of Frontier transaction Source: Definitive proxy statement fi
Slide 19: JetBlue has strong conviction in its ability to close
JetBlue has strong conviction in its ability to close – the conflicted Spirit Board’s regulatory argument is a red herring
Slide 20: Spirit regulatory arguments are unfounded
Spirit regulatory arguments are unfounded Regulatory facts Spirit claims “The JetBlue Effect on fares is not real…” The JetBlue Effect is established and flourishes today “The JetBlue deal is about a high-cost, high-fare airline buying a low-cost, low-fare airline…” Fundamentally, the JetBlue-Spirit
Slide 21: The JetBlue Effect is real, demonstrable, and foundational
The “JetBlue Effect” is real, demonstrable, and foundational to its business model… The “JetBlue effect” is widely recognized and longstanding; as recently as 2021, the Department of Justice recognized its benefits1: “JetBlue’s reputation for lowering fares is so well known in the airline industry t
Slide 22: … and continues to deliver consumer benefits today
… and continues to deliver consumer benefits today DOT data analysis as recent as this year supports the fact that JetBlue’s presence on a nonstop route decreases legacy fares ~16%, three times more than even Spirit’s (~5%) Since the 2013 MIT study, JetBlue has launched service on each of the routes
Slide 23: The transaction creates a platform for sustainable growth
Fundamentally, the JetBlue-Spirit transaction creates a platform for sustainable growth and establishes a national challenger to the ‘Big Four’ 171 Combined flights at strategic Fort Lauderdale focus city 455 Combined fleet size 312 Aircraft in order book Source: 2021, 2019 company filings; number o
Slide 24: Access to Spirit assets enhances JetBlue's relevance in legacy hubs
Access to Spirit assets enhances JetBlue’s relevance in legacy hubs, bringing the JetBlue effect to significantly more customers paying high fares JetBlue’s contemplated combined network plan includes: ~120 new domestic non-stop routes, bringing more than $500 million of annual consumer savings to c
Slide 25: ULCC competition will continue to grow
ULCC competition will continue to grow… ULCC expansion will combat any potential negative effects from the JetBlue-Spirit transaction ULCC model does not require scale or brand awareness ULCCs are growing rapidly Frontier, with 110 aircraft already, has 230 new Airbus planes on order Sun Country lau
Slide 26: New ULCC entrants will continue to expand rapidly
…and New ULCC entrants will continue to expand rapidly Based on 2021-2022 Department of Transportation schedule data. Breeze routes in year 1 and year 2 1st year of operations 1st year of operations Avelo routes in year 1 and year 2 2nd year of operations 2nd year of operations
Slide 27: The Northeast Alliance unlocks growth in the Northeast
The Northeast Alliance, a limited, pro-competitive, alliance between JetBlue and American, unlocks growth in one of the nation’s most constrained regions, the Northeast, and is guided by four main principles: Remain independent companies Optimize the use of JetBlue’s and American’s assets including
Slide 28: The Northeast Alliance turbocharges JetBlue's ability to compete
The Northeast Alliance turbocharges JetBlue’s ability to compete in the Northeast, already delivering consumer benefits Unlocks JetBlue growth in an otherwise constrained geography, with stated commitments to grow seats at JFK and LGA by 15% by 2025 JetBlue will fly 52 daily flights from LGA in Augu
Slide 29: Analyst commentary on the Northeast Alliance
“Blocking the alliance would ultimately prove anti-competitive. […] The American and JetBlue alliance has been focused on growth in the Northeast which could not have been achieved without additional scale.” –MKM Partners “JBLU is in competitive markets (New York, Boston, Florida), but its alliance
Slide 30: Market share (2021) pro forma
Market share (2021) Pro forma Spirit + JetBlue Pro forma Spirit + Frontier Source: Based on 2021 nonstop US passenger seats (ending December 2021). JetBlue + Spirit would have a combined 8% market share vs. 7% for Frontier + Spirit – a single percentage point of difference – which is completely misr
Slide 31: Analyst views on regulatory approval
Frontier’s Announced Synergies (in $ Millions) "Review [of] the HHI impact at key airports under each merger […] The impacts are modest under both mergers with the exception of FLL and SJU under the JetBlue-Spirit deal. However, when considering South Florida as a whole, i.e., combining MIA and FLL,
Slide 32: Frontier has much more overlap with Spirit than JetBlue
Frontier has much more overlap with Spirit than JetBlue No matter how you cut it, Frontier has greater overlap on nonstop routes with Spirit A third-party assessment determined only 11% of JetBlue and Spirit nonstop routes overlap with each other, compared to 18% overlap for Frontier and Spirit1 In
Slide 33: Frontier and Spirit's overlap extends across almost all US geographies
Frontier and Spirit’s overlap extends across almost all US geographies 1 Based on FY21 domestic Department of Transportation schedule data. 2 JetBlue will offer a remedy package that includes the divestiture of all Spirit assets in New York and Boston. Frontier and Spirit Route overlap1 JetBlue and
Slide 34: Spirit's Board is entrenched, conflicted and has failed to maximize value
Spirit’s Board is entrenched, conflicted and has failed to maximize shareholder value
Slide 35: Spirit Board is conflicted and not serving shareholders' interests
Spirit Board is conflicted and is not serving its shareholders’ best interests Until 2013, Indigo Partners, Bill Franke’s investment firm and the majority shareholder of Frontier, controlled Spirit Airlines Multiple Spirit Directors involved in the decision to merge with Frontier have significant ti
Slide 36: Spirit Directors negotiated with Frontier for ~8 months without calling JetBlue
Spirit Directors negotiated with Frontier for ~8 months without calling JetBlue – to the clear detriment of Spirit shareholders 1 Represents premium of Frontier offer value, using per share pro forma equity value of Spirit / Frontier, over the Spirit undisturbed price of $21.73 on February 4, 2022.
Slide 37: The conflicted Spirit Board has continuously stonewalled JetBlue
The conflicted Spirit Board has continuously stonewalled JetBlue Misled investors about its willingness to negotiate with JetBlue; it did not engage in good faith Provided very limited information making it impossible for JetBlue to complete its due diligence Responded to JetBlue’s initial proposal
Slide 38: JetBlue proposal provides a superior alternative with more benefits
JetBlue proposal provides a superior alternative with more benefits for all stakeholders
Slide 39: JetBlue offers Spirit's customers MORE
JetBlue offers Spirit’s customers MORE Customers should not have to choose between a low fare and a great experience. JetBlue’s customer service has won the company hundreds of awards since its inception; JetBlue is a 13-time J.D. Power Award winner for customer satisfaction JetBlue is loved by cust
Slide 40: The JetBlue transaction is significantly more friendly to Spirit team members
The JetBlue transaction is significantly more friendly to Spirit team members JetBlue is proud of its strong culture, and encourages Crewmember feedback through an open-door policy to address any concerns JetBlue compensates pilots in line with industry standards and has stood by its stated no furlo
Slide 41: JetBlue offers you MORE...
JetBlue offers you MORE... More value and more certainty for Spirit shareholders More value NOW More value at CLOSING More competition for the Big Four airlines More of the great experience and low fares only JetBlue can offer customers nationwide – a prospect, coupled with the ease of ultra-low-cos