Mac-Gray — Proxy Contest (April 2011)
17 slides from Mac-Gray's proxy contest presentation, Apr 28, 2011
Slide 1: Mac-Gray: Time For A Change
TUC Investor Value Creation Group, LLC April, 2011 Mac-Gray: Time For A Change
Slide 2: Agenda
2 Introduction And Background Need To Improve Board Oversight Our Nominees Are Agents For Change Agenda
Slide 3: Mac-Gray Overview
3 Business Description Mac-Gray provides coin- and card-operated laundry contracting services to multi-unit housing facilities including apartment buildings and universities. The company services over 88,000 laundry rooms across 44 states and is the second largest laundry facilities management contr
Slide 4: TUC Investor Value Creation Group, LLC Overview
4 Introduction and Background TUC Investor Value Creation Group, LLC Overview We have been shareholders of Mac-Gray for over 11 years and currently own approximately 2.8% of the company's total shares outstanding Our investment in Mac-Gray pre-dates the tenure of ALL of the current board members We
Slide 5: Objectives
5 Introduction and Background Objectives ELECT Richard Drexler, Michael J. Soenen and Benjamin Kovler to serve as Class II directors on the Board of Directors of Mac-Gray DECLASSIFY the Board of Directors and reorganize it into one class, thereby empowering shareholders to hold all of the Mac-Gray's
Slide 6: Agenda
6 Agenda Introduction And Background Need To Improve Board Oversight Company has underperformed relative to key operating metrics The Board has supported high-priced acquisitions Corporate governance policies are inconsistent with "best-practices" Our Nominees Are Agents For Change
Slide 7: Declining Financial Metrics
7 Note: ROIC Calculated as EBIT*(1-Tc) / Average Invested Capital; EBIT Calculated as EBITDA as adjusted less Depreciation and Amortization; Assume 10% cash taxes; Invested Capital Calculated as Total Assets, less cash, less non-interest bearing current liabilities Sources: 2010 and 2006 10-Ks Need
Slide 8: Flawed Acquisition Strategy
8 Need to Improve Board Oversight Flawed Acquisition Strategy (1) Enterprise value calculated as [(share price * weighted average shares outstanding) + Long-Term Debt and Capital Leases (Incl. Current Portion) - Cash & Equivalents]; EBITDA is EBITDA as adjusted as defined in TUC SEC Filings Sources:
Slide 9: Flawed Acquisition Strategy (Cont.)
9 We believe Mac-Gray paid the sellers for synergies that should have belonged to Mac-Gray shareholders We believe the EBITDA-driven compensation structure adopted by the board incentivizes management to grow through acquisitions, even if the acquisitions have low consolidated returns on invested ca
Slide 10: We Do Not Believe The Board Has Created Real Value
10 The stock price is a short-term function of the supply and demand of the stock; The 52-wk range is approximately $10 - $17. Our analysis below shows that had TUC traded at a constant 5x EV/EBITDA multiple over the past 10 years (roughly the average over this timeframe), the stock price would have
Slide 11: Corporate Governance - The Board Does Not Listen to Shareholders
11 Need to Improve Board Oversight Corporate Governance - The Board Does Not Listen to Shareholders The current board has explicitly disregarded the wishes of shareholders with respect to certain corporate governance practices MAC-GRAY SHAREHOLDERS DESERVE A BOARD THAT WILL PUT THE INTERESTS OF SHAR
Slide 12: Corporate Governance - Not "Best Practices"
12 Need to Improve Board Oversight Corporate Governance - Not "Best Practices" Mac-Gray's corporate governance policies are inconsistent with "Best Practices." MAC-GRAY SHAREHOLDERS DESERVE A BOARD THAT WILL PUT THE INTERESTS OF SHAREHOLDERS FIRST! Classified Board of Directors Shareholder Rights Pl
Slide 13: Agenda
13 Agenda Introduction And Background Need To Improve Board Oversight Our Nominees Are Agents For Change
Slide 14: Our Nominees
14 Benjamin Kovler Chief Investment Officer and Director of Research for Kovpak II, LLC Mac-Gray shareholder for over 11 years; current owner of approximately 2.8% of the Company Investment in Mac-Gray pre-dates the tenure of ALL of the current board members Past Board membership: Trausch Inc. (the
Slide 15: Richard Drexler biography
15 Richard Drexler has served as the Chairman of the Board of Directors and CEO of Quality Products, Inc., a public company involved in manufacturing, since October 2002. From 1969 to 2006, Mr. Drexler served in various executive positions at Allied Products Corporation, an industrial manufacturing
Slide 16: Summary
16 Our nominees have the financial and operational expertise required to evaluate opportunities to create shareholder value including: Potential acquisition opportunities Potential divestiture decisions Operational synergies Capital allocation strategies Our nominees will advocate for corporate gove
Slide 17: Contact Information
17 Contact Information TUC Investor Value Creation Group, LLC Benjamin Kovler 312.664.5050 Innisfree M&A Incorporated Alan Miller/Scott Winter/Larry Miller 212.750.5833