Associated Estates Realty Corp
Associated Estates Realty — Proxy Contest (February 2015)
45 slides from Associated Estates Realty's proxy contest presentation, Feb 24, 2015
Slide 1: Schedule 14A Proxy Statement Information
UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION WASHINGTON, DC 20549 SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) _________________ Filed by the Registra
Slide 2: News Release: Associated Estates Files Investor Presentation
NEWS RELEASE For Immediate Release Release Date: February 24, 2015 Associated Estates Files Investor Presentation to Set the Record Straight CLEVELAND, February 24, 2015 -- Associated Estates Realty Corporation (NYSE, NASDAQ: AEC) today filed an investor presentation detailing the significant value
Slide 3: Fully Funded Development Pipeline
Associated Estates maintains a robust, fully-funded pipeline of active development projects. The Company has numerous projects underway in attractive, high-growth markets such as Fully Funded Dallas, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Bethesda, all of which are progressing on time and Development on bud
Slide 4: Questions or assistance voting your shares
If you have questions or need assistance voting your shares please contact: 105 Madison Avenue New York, New York 10016 [email protected] Call Collect: (212) 929-5500 or Toll-Free (800) 322-2885 About Associated Estates Associated Estates is a real estate investment trust and a member of the
Slide 5: Important Additional Information
Important Additional Information Associated Estates, its directors and certain of its executive officers will be deemed to be participants in the solicitation of proxies from Associated Estates shareholders in connection with the matters to be considered at Associated Estates' 2015 Annual Meeting. A
Slide 6: Investor Presentation February 2015
{ 9 = = - Alpha Mill — Charlotte, NC aut pe a Br Loe 267 Units Investor Presentatio February 2015 ry Associated Estates Great Living - it's What We Do*
Slide 7: Safe Harbor Statement
Safe Harbor Statement LL ————————————L——————————E—T This presentation contains, and our officers and representatives may make, forward-looking statements within the meaning of the federal securities laws. These forward-looking statements are intended to be covered by the safe harbor provisions of th
Slide 8: Important Additional Information
Important Additional Information —E>E>E>~x—_—~—Ey—_—>_——_—_————>>— ————_———_{__————EE—_——EEEEE Associated Estates, its directors and certain of its executive officers will be deemed to be participants in the solicitation of proxies from Associated Estates shareholders in connection with the matters
Slide 9: Executive Summary
Executive Summary . . . Management team and Board of Directors have delivered ~195% total return to Leadi ng Multifam ily shareholders as compared to ~138% average for the Multifamily sector and ~98% REIT with for the RMS over the last ten years") Sustained NOI growth through Financial Crisis and ha
Slide 10: Leading Multifamily REIT with Demonstrated Performance
oe Feo (24) y Car ntabri ria at Turtle cra eek — Dallas, TX 249 Units \ezding Multifamily REIT with Demonstrated Performance ry Associated Estates
Slide 11: History of Driving Total Shareholder Return
History of Driving Total Shareholder Return Associated Estates has consistently delivered best-in-sector total return over the last ten years. 10 Year Total Shareholder Return 203.8% From 12/31/2004 to 5/30/2014" 171.1% 177.0% UI oo 1 if ii i | 89.1% 93.6% basinal AV RMS 5 yaar Total Shareholder a F
Slide 12: Resilient and Sustained NOI Growth
Resilient and Sustained NOI Growth SSE Associated Estates has delivered solid NOI growth performance vis-a-vis Multifamily REIT peers since the Financial Crisis, even while transforming its portfolio. NOI CAGR H Financial Crisis (2007 - 2009) : Post-Financial Crisis (2010 — 2014) (1.1%) AEC Average
Slide 13: Prudent Capital Allocation — Acquisitions and Dispositions
Prudent Capital Allocation — Acquisitions and Dispositions —eaEaEaEUEUEyEoEy——~yEyE>c~L—>>L_—L_>>>EE_—_—_—xxL_—Ex~_x—_—_x_—_>___—_—_——_E=a Associated Estates has successfully navigated multiple cycles in the apartment business, consistently selling near the top and buying near the bottom. RMS Index
Slide 14: Late Stages of a Complete Portfolio Transformation
| my 1 TT =e ‘i (Foo fame ia HG =| om cae fi = Park at Crossroads ee Late Stages of a Complete Portfolio Transformation 3 | ry Associated Estates Great Living ~ it's What We Do®
Slide 15: Diversified Portfolio with High Quality Assets
Diversified Portfolio with High Quality Assets Properties located in high barrier-to-entry submarkets in major metropolitan areas. Southeast Michigan: agrees glo: Metro DC: a] Northern Virginia: aha Southeast Virginia: ahah Raleigh-Durham: Southeast Florida: ahaha AE Stabilized property (49 properti
Slide 16: 2014 Strategic Dispositions at Attractive Yields
2014 Strategic Dispositions at Attractive Yields —————————————E—_—_—— eee Completed Dispositions Sales Market Cap Unlevered Gain Property Closed Location Units Age Price Rate"? IRR (GAAP) Hampton Point February Silver Spring, MD 352 28 $60,000 6.0% 15.3% $41,000 Vista Germantown April Nashville, TN
Slide 17: Committed Acquisitions: Best-in-Class Portfolio
Committed Acquisitions: Best-in-Class Portfolio 1,026 units under contract in various stages of development and lease-up 1160 Hammond (345 units) Atlanta, GA (Perimeter Submarket) + Property under contract in Q3 2013; currently 42% leased + Expected to close Q1 2015, once construction is complete Va
Slide 18: Improving Efficiencies By Creating Scale in Strategic Markets
Improving Efficiencies By Creating Scale in Strategic Markets Raleigh-Durham, North Carolina - 5 Properties / 1,109 Units Dallas, Texas — 5 Properties / 1,342 Units vA “ Young ‘s ee -, G} 3] BH Operating Property BBB Current Development Associated Estates Great Living ~ It's What We Do®
Slide 19: Class A Portfolio Across All Markets
Class A Portfolio Across All Markets AEC Revenue / Occupied Region Units Property Grade Unit Q4 2014 Indianapolis 836 AJA $994 Central Ohio 1,581 AJA $1,039 Northeast Ohio 1,303 B+/A- $1,243 Southeast Michigan 1,778 B+/A- $1,043 Western Michigan 438 BO) $954 Total Midwest 5,936 $1,072 Metro DC 250 B
Slide 20: Attractive Same Store Rent / Unit Growth in Multifamily Sector
Attractive Same Store Rent / Unit Growth in Multifamily Sector LanBaaEaEaEaEaE»E»=m ed Associated Estates has achieved above average Rent / Unit growth in the Multifamily sector over the past 10 years. 10 Year Same Store Rent / Unit Growth” 172% 134% 100% 89% 65% 60% 52% 42% 42% ' i: [J MAA HME PPS
Slide 21: Associated Estates' Transformation Into a Class A Portfolio
Associated Estates’ Transformation Into a Class A Portfolio Associated Estates’ portfolio transformation will be complete once our development pipeline stabilizes. Associated Estates only owns 1 property from time of IPO and has disposed of over $800 million of assets over the past 10 years. Portfol
Slide 22: Experienced Associated Estates Regional Development Team
Experienced Associated Estates Regional Development Team Cindy Harris VP of Development - Central Q Joined Associated Estates in 2012 Q Senior Project Manager at Huffines Communities from February 2011 until 2012 Q VP of Development at Post Properties and Columbus Realty Trust from February 1994 unt
Slide 23: Market Leading Value Creation Through Development
Market Leading Value Creation Through Development —EeEIlUElElElElL——L—E>E~—_~L_~— —_>>>——E—_——_—xx—yxy—_>_ __=Ez>—&—_E==a Stabilized yield on current developments is 6.75%, which is 260 bps higher than current market cap rates. Estimated Stabilized Total Market Estimated Active # of Stabilized Rent
Slide 24: Well Endorsed JV Development Pipeline
Well Endorsed JV Development Pipeline Associated Estates has received the endorsement of a leading institutional partner for our exciting development project at 350 8" in San Francisco. Rendering Rendering * Off-market purchase in the South of Market * Off-market purchase in the Arts District of “So
Slide 25: Delivering Strong Value from Our Development Pipeline
Delivering Strong Value from Our Development Pipeline Cantabria at Turtle Creek (249 units) Dallas, TX + Total Estimated Cost: $56.8 million + Cost Per Unit: $228,000 * Stabilized Rent per Unit: $2,286 7001 Arlington at Bethesda (140 units) Bethesda, MD + Total Estimated Cost: $53.4 million + Cost P
Slide 26: A Fully Funded Active Development Platform
A Fully Funded Active Development Platform Associated Estates’ active development pipeline will be funded via in-place construction loans and strategic asset dispositions. Sources & Uses Construction Loan Draws $150 Remaining Development Spend $200 Forecasted Dispositions $50 Total Sources $200 Tota
Slide 27: Corporate Governance Enhancements
S The Apartments at Blakeney — Charlotte, NC 295 Units Corporate Governance Enhancements Associated Estates Ls | e
Slide 28: Corporate Governance Enhancements
Corporate Governance Enhancements Appointment of Douglas Crocker, former CEO of Equity Residential, as Independent Director and Chair of the Finance and Planning Committee — The Business Review will be headed by Douglas Crocker Appointment of Jon Fosheim, co-founder of Green Street Advisors, as Inde
Slide 29: Corporate Governance Enhancements
Corporate Governance Enhancements * The Associated Estates Board of Directors has approved the following actions to further enhance the Company's governance standards: - Eliminated the Executive Committee of the Board, which the Company has used in the past to declare dividends in between regular me
Slide 30: Highly Qualified and Experienced Board of Directors
Highly Qualified and Experienced Board of Directors —LEEyEEE>E>E>E>E>E>EyEL~L>E>E>E>>>E>E>>E~E~Esesesese>ESSEEEEEE~L_ SEE —_——SE]_—_—S_ The Board of Directors and Management continue to work together to build long-term value for shareholders with 3 Directors joining since 2012. Douglas Crocker Il Fi
Slide 31: Addition of Douglas Crocker to Board of Directors
Addition of Douglas Crocker to Associated Estates’ Board of Directors . Currently serves as a Director / Trustee for the following companies: Acadia Realty Trust (NYSE: AKR), Ventas, Inc. (NYSE: VTR), and CYS Investments, Inc. (NYSE: CYS) . Former Director of Post Properties . Previously, Mr. Crocke
Slide 32: Addition of Jon Fosheim to Board of Directors
Addition of Jon Fosheim to Associated Estates’ Board of Directors The appointment of Jon Fosheim to Associated Estates’ Board of Directors adds a REIT industry veteran that we believe will enhance Associated Estates’ operations going forward. Currently serves on the Board of Directors of Apple Hospi
Slide 33: Undergoing Thorough Review of the Business
NN * ti Alexander at Ghent — Norfolk, VA 268 Units Undergoing Thorough Review of the Business ry Associated Estates Great Living - It's What We Do®
Slide 34: Undertaking a Thorough Business Review With Citigroup
Associated Estates is Undertaking a Thorough Business Review With Citigroup * The Company has engaged Citigroup Global Markets Inc. as a financial advisor to assist the Board in conducting a thorough review of the Company's business — Mr. Crocker, in his capacity as Chairman of the fully independent
Slide 35: Focused on Shareholder Returns
Associated Estates: Focused on Shareholder Returns Attractive Total Shareholder Returns y, 30 | | Associated Estates 120 pss Buel
Slide 36: The Truth About Land & Buildings
Dwell Vienna Metro — Fairfax, VA 250 Units The Truth About Land & Buildings 2: | ry Associated Estates Great Living - I's What We Do*
Slide 37: Shifting Land & Buildings Requests
Shifting Land & Buildings Requests > "Las's suggested 10% Blue Chip premium is far from obtainable in the = foreseeable future.” ae - Green Street Advisors January 28, 2015 . & “Inour view, the 900bps of NOI recapture seems aggressive given that ~ AEC’s net rents are already ~10% above market and th
Slide 38: Committed to Good Governance and A Fair Settlement
Associated Estates: Committed to Good Governance and A Fair Settlement ggg + Associated Estates has made numerous good-faith attempts at a settlement agreement * Land & Buildings continues to mislead shareholders by contending that Associated Estates is unwilling to reach a settlement agreement Land
Slide 39: Setting the Record Straight — The Edge at Flagler Village
Setting the Record Straight — The Edge at Flagler Village Despite the misleading characterization of Land & Buildings, Associated Estates does not currently own The Edge at Flagler Village and the property is not on LRO. + Associated Estates began managing the property in April 2014 but the current
Slide 40: Upgrading of Doral West Property Almost Complete
Upgrading of Doral West Property Almost Complete —EeElUlElElL——L—L—EE>E~L—_—L_L_— —EEE__——_—xL—EE>E~~—__————EEE Associated Estates’ Doral West property in South Florida is undergoing an extensive renovation to upgrade the interior and exterior of the property. + Associated Estates acquired Doral Wes
Slide 41: Market-Leading Properties in Southeast Florida
Market-Leading Properties in Southeast Florida Independent, third-party company confirms that Associated Estates’ operating metrics are ahead of their market comparables. Waterstone at Wellingto aa ] "When looking at both property level and floor "The fact that the Waterstone at Wellington has “With
Slide 42: Relative Performance — EQR Outperformed Archstone
Relative Performance — EQR Outperformed Archstone Total Return Performance (1997 — 2002) Overlapping Time Period When Douglas Crocker and Scot Sellers were CEOs of EQR and ASN, respectively 120.00 100.00 80:00 EQR outperformed ASN by 21.5% EQR: 73.8% 60.00 ASN: 52.3% 40.00 RMS: 39.5% 20.00 0.00 (20.
Slide 43: Relative Performance — EQR Outperformed Gables As Well As Archstone
Relative Performance — EQR Outperformed Gables As Well As Archstone —E>E>E>~x—_—~—Ey—_—>_——_—_————>>— ————_———_{__————EE—_——EEEEE Total Return Performance (1997 — April 1999) Overlapping Time Period When Douglas Crocker, Scot Sellers and Marcus Bromley were CEOs of EQR, ASN and GBP respectively EQR
Slide 44: Executive Summary
Executive Summary Management team and Board of Directors have delivered ~195% total return to shareholders as compared to ~138% average for the Multifamily sector and ~98% Leading Multifamily REIT with for the RMS over the last ten years) Sustained NOI growth through Financial Crisis and has achieve
Slide 45: AssociatedEstates.com
See Lofts at Weston Lakeside — Cary, NC i 215 Units AssociatedEstates.com
Associated Estates Realty — Proxy Contest (February 2015) on 6ix