Morgan Stanley · NYSE:MS
Morgan Stanley — Morgan Stanley Dean Witter — Ariba User Group and Advisory Council Conference 1999
44 slides from Morgan Stanley's conference presentation, Sep 28, 1999
Slide 1: A Framework for B2B
A FRAMEWORK FOR B2B Mary Meeker / 212-761-8042 / [email protected] Chuck Phillips / 212-761-4450 / [email protected] David Edwards / 212-762-6853 / [email protected] Ariba User Group and Advisory Council Conference September 28, 1999 MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 1 September 28, 1999
Slide 2: Internet Market Cap Attention Grabbers
Internet Market Cap Attention Grabbers ● AOL ($118B, fully diluted) > Time Warner ($74B) ● Schwab ($29B) > Merrill Lynch ($25B) ● Yahoo! ($48B) > New York Times ($7B) ● Amazon.com ($22B) > Barnes & Noble ($2B) ● Excite@Home ($12B) > Cablevision ($11B) ● eBay ($19B) > Sotheby’s ($2B) ● Priceline.com
Slide 3: Internet Trend Attention Grabbers
Internet Trend Attention Grabbers ● 120MM Internet users - Internet growth is like an "epidemic.” ● Internet will alter many traditional business practices. ● A few early leaders are driving consolidation in Internet markets. ● Owing in part to economics of increasing returns, the revenue/profit str
Slide 4: Internet Investing Attention Grabbers
Internet Investing Attention Grabbers Caveat Emptor! There will be Lots of Pain... •Demand -- Extremely High... •Investment Banks -- Increasing Volume... •Equity Capital Markets -- Increasing Prices... •Boards -- Market Cap Envy… •Venture Capital -- In the Public Markets... MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTE
Slide 5: Corporate Tech Spending Continues to Rise
Corporate Tech Spending Continues to Rise U.S.-based Information Technology Spending as a Share of Business Capital Equipment Spending - 1960 to 1998 60% 55% Commercial Internet 50% 45% 40% 35% PC Introduction 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 1960 1961 1962 1963 1965 1966 1967 1968 1970 1971 1972 1973 1975
Slide 6: Internet as a Mass Medium
Internet as a Mass Medium - On to 150MM Worldwide Web Users by 2000 N. American Adoption Curves for Various Media — The Web Is Ramping Fast 120 N. American Users/ Households (MM) Years to reach 50MM users: 100 Radio = 38 TV = 13 Cable = 10 (1) 80 Internet = 5 (2) 60 50 40 Cable Radio Commercial 20 T
Slide 7: An Interesting Look at e-Commerce and Nominal GDP
An Interesting Look at e-Commerce and Nominal GDP At Some Point in the next 10 years, 100% of GDP Growth may be Derived from eCommerce… ($ Billions) 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 U.S. GDP $7,636 $8,053 $8,415 $8,802 $9,223 $9,672 $10,160 Y/Y Change 6.2% 5.5% 4.5% 4.6% 4.8% 4.9% 5.0% Internet Co
Slide 8: Internet Development Framework
Internet Development Framework Timing and Development of Internet Market Segments YO UA RE HE Path of Growth/Digestion/Growth... RE New Phases/Segments Drive New Growth s tical /Ver ic e s ng/ ness es Serv on c i ervi gati e rc e Bus e dS re ctur om m Agg eeri e an astru il/C n g in / tent war Infr
Slide 9: B2C e-Commerce Leads to B2B
B2C e-Commerce Leads to B2B MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 9 September 28, 1999
Slide 10: Evolution of Internet Commerce
Evolution of Internet Commerce Market Opportunities for Leading Players are Significant -- Note Economics of Increasing Returns -- The Best Big Get Bigger -- Networking/Viral Effects. First Mover Advantage and Great Execution and Loyal Customers = Barriers to Entry with Benefits to Sellers and Vendo
Slide 11: B2C Exchanges - eBay Sets the Stage
B2C Exchanges - eBay Sets the Stage B2C markets are more inefficient than B2B markets. Bring buyers and sellers together in a frictionless way -- in one community. Maximum convenience for sellers and buyers. All markets begin to resemble current markets for financial assets -- 24 x 7 trading. All da
Slide 12: The B2B Markets
The B2B Markets MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 12 September 28, 1999
Slide 13: B2B Opportunity Should Eclipse B2C
B2B Opportunity Should Eclipse B2C US E-Commerce ($ billions) $1,600 B2B Goods $1,400 $1,331 $1,200 $1,000 $843 $800 B2B Services $600 B2C $499 $400 $251 $220 $200 $143 $109 $83 $108 $52 $76 $18 $22 $33 $44 $0 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 Source: Forrester Research MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RE
Slide 14: Why B2B Now?
Why B2B Now? ● Big Business is Waking Up to the Web • Web spending is increasing • Business media is full of Internet stories/ads/etc. • Talented execs are moving from traditional businesses to Web businesses • Market Leading Companies are Experiencing Growth Issues • Coca Cola, Disney, Compaq, Banc
Slide 15: Why B2B Now? The Technology is in Place
Why B2B Now? ● The Technology is in Place • Web Infrastructure -- Browser persaviveness is a new enterprise application platform and the Web can be leveraged for e-Commerce. • XML -- provides for more intelligent data exchanges between web sites and back-end systems • ERP Infrastructure Investment -
Slide 16: The Flip Point
“The Flip Point”... ● B2B Commerce is Mission Critical (owing to cost savings) to buyers. The big question is how quickly will industries “flip” to e-commerce… • Possible -- 1-3 years… • Probable -- 2-5 years… ● Flipping is a “Chicken and the Egg” Situation • If you build it, will they come? • Liqui
Slide 17: Rapid Adoption of B2B E-Commerce
Rapid Adoption of B2B E-Commerce When Will Purchasing Pros Buy on the Net? 59% Within 1 Year 3-5 years Never Now 2% 8% 25% 2-3 years 31% 6 months 11% 1 year 23% Source: NAPM survey of purchasing professionals, April 22, 1999 MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 17 September 28, 1999
Slide 18: 50% of CIOs Say They are Likely to Integrate with Suppliers
50% of CIOs Say They are Likely to Integrate with Suppliers over the Internet Q: Is your organization electronically integrated with suppliers? 60% Now Evaluating Likely to Implement Percentage of Respondents 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% EDI Internet pt. to pt. Internet trading ERP led trading E-mail comm
Slide 19: What Is B2B?
What Is B2B? MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 19 September 28, 1999
Slide 20: A Quick History of B2B
A Quick History of B2B B2B E-Commerce enabling commerce through aggregation many-to-many commerce SUPPLIER BUYER SUPPLIER B2B BUYER Brochure-ware SUPPLIER BUYER publicize online, sell offline Basic E-Commerce one-to-one selling from web site BUYER EDI Networks Supplier BUYER closed, expensive, non-s
Slide 21: B2B e-Commerce Business Models
B2B e-Commerce Business Models BUY-SIDE PROCUREMENT VERTICAL DISTRIBUTORS Empowering the Buyer Multiple Buyers to Multiple Suppliers SUPPLIER SUPPLIER BUYER SUPPLIER Buyer SUPPLIER SUPPLIER B2B BUYER SUPPLIER BUYER FUNCTIONAL COMMUNITIES MARKET MAKERS Manage Complex Business Online Competitive Biddi
Slide 22: B2B e-Commerce Business Model Examples
B2B e-Commerce Business Model Examples BUY-SIDE PROCUREMENT VERTICAL DISTRIBUTORS Empowering the Buyer Multiple Buyers to Multiple Suppliers CommerceOne -- Procurement Software Chemdex -- Life Sciences SAP -- ERP Procurement Software ChipCenter -- Electronic Parts E-Chemicals -- Chemicals FUNCTIONAL
Slide 23: Ariba's Role Enables the Connection of Buyers and Suppliers
Ariba’s Role Enables the Connection of Buyers and Suppliers Buyer Supplier Ariba ORMS Ariba Buyer Supplier Ariba Network Buyer Supplier Source: Morgan Stanley Internet Research. MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 23 September 28, 1999
Slide 24: B2B: Past, Present, and Future
B2B: Past, Present, and Future MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 24 September 28, 1999
Slide 25: Pre-Internet e-Commerce Paradigm
Pre-Internet e-Commerce Paradigm Buyers Suppliers EDI Large Large Proprietary Value Added Network VAN provider may establish community and enforce standard Medium Medium Automate links where volume makes it feasible -- too costly for small businesses Small Small Source: Morgan Stanley Internet Resea
Slide 26: Internet-Based B2B E-Commerce -- Dynamic Trade
Internet-Based B2B E-Commerce -- Dynamic Trade -- Buyers Suppliers EDI Large Large Software Interface Software Interface Medium Medium Public / Private B2B Exchanges Small Small Source: Morgan Stanley Internet Research. MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 26 September 28, 1999
Slide 27: EDI vs. Internet-based e-Commerce
EDI vs. Internet-based e-Commerce ● EDI Networks ● Internet/XML • Batch • Dynamic • Complicated formats • Flexible format • Affordable by a small % of • Affordable for most businesses businesses • <2% of 6.2MM businesses • 120MM connected are EDI enabled MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH
Slide 28: B2B Exchanges Combine the Best of EDI and the Web
B2B Exchanges Combine the Best of EDI and the Best of the Web... ● The Best of EDI • Secure, one-to-one transactions • Real-time transactions • ERP integration -- automatic accounting updating ● The Best of the Web • Global reach -- access trading partners worldwide • Marketing capability -- integra
Slide 29: But There's an Integration Challenge
...But There’s anThe Integration Challenge Buyers Suppliers •Price •Available to Software Interface Software Interface Promise •Expense limits •Capable to Promise •Purchase approval Public / Private B2B Exchanges •Transportation •Accounts payable route integration •Distribution alternatives •Substit
Slide 30: B2B Exchanges
B2B Exchanges ● Aggregates buyers and suppliers in a single, central, neutral/unbiased marketplace ● Uses the power of the network to optimize the supply chain ● Trading can be conducted in public or private depending on the needs of the market ● Provides just-in-time inventory capabilities through
Slide 31: What We Look for in B2B Markets
What We Look for in B2B Markets ● Large, Fragmented Market -- no concentration of buying or selling power ● Transaction Randomness -- buyers who change suppliers on a regular basis ● Dynamic Products -- i.e. scrappage and spoilage which have non- standard/changing values based on product quality and
Slide 32: B2B Exchange Benefits
B2B Exchange Benefits ● Dynamic Trade -- enter asks/bids and receive transaction results on a real-time basis ● Standardized Data -- apples-to-apples purchase comparisons ● Automated ERP Integration -- between suppliers and buyers ● Real-Time Demand Forecasting -- more accurate data collection can r
Slide 33: Power to the Buyer!
Power to the Buyer! ● B2B adds value to the supply chain by giving power to the buyer -- can leverage purchasing power to gain more influence ● The buyer has more power over the purchasing process… • bigger selection • better control • more competition... ● Suppliers benefit too… • bigger market opp
Slide 34: Nuts & Bolts: Real Impact from B2B
Nuts & Bolts… Real Impact from B2B Ordering Reduce order costs; increases sales per rep; Richer ordering experience; real time substitutions; pricing based on availability/quality; accurate configuration Inventory Reduce parts shortages; shorter replenishment times; reduce time to shipment; early no
Slide 35: Analyzing the Opportunity
Analyzing the Opportunity MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 35 September 28, 1999
Slide 36: B2C vs. B2B E-Commerce
B2C vs. B2B E-Commerce B2C B2B ● Small purchase size ● Large purchase size ● Network effect ● Network effect?? ● 2 constituents ● 3 constituents ● Payment by credit card ● Payment by P.O. ● Limited reporting needs ● Advanced reporting needs ● Negotiation is not ● Negotiation is the norm common/wante
Slide 37: Some things we've learned from B2C apply to B2B
Some things we’ve learned from B2C apply to B2B... ● First Mover Advantage and Critical Mass -- whoever signs up the buyers and suppliers first will have strong potential to keep them ● Increased Productivity -- B2B success will be based on increasing customer’s productivity by reducing cost, improv
Slide 38: But Some Things Will Be Different from B2C
...But Some Things Will Be Different from B2C ● Domain Expertise -- companies need to understand the industry to understand the problem that needs to be solved ● Strong Back-End System Integration -- businesses need to keep records so system integration is key…this creates much higher switching cost
Slide 39: Displacing will be Much Harder in B2B than in B2C
Displacing will be Much Harder in B2B than in B2C ● Harder to “Amazon” the entrenched ● B2C switching costs are nominal ● B2B switching costs are high -- both offline and online ● Lower risk strategies: • Add value to channel without replacing • Create channel where one does not currently exist • Ri
Slide 40: B2B Sweet Spots: Market Size and Inefficiency
B2B Sweet Spots Market Size and Inefficiency Real Estate Insurance/Financial Service Business Services Wholesale Energy Telecom Services Healthcare Construction Transportation Size of Market Industrial Equipment Electronics Chemicals Food Metals Autos Paper Products Apparel Life Sciences Degree of M
Slide 41: Questions e-Commerce Forces Businesses to Answer
Questions e-Commerce Forces Businesses to Answer ● Who are my best customers • Most loyal; Most profitable; Fastest growing ● How will customers behave and why ● Why do they buy from me ● How will they buy in the future ● Is my business in a relationship driven market ● Would my customers behave dif
Slide 42: Get a Handle on Your Customer – And Fast
Get a Handle on Your Customer – And Fast Direct Sales Call Center Catalog Resellers Customer Support Electronic Marketing Distributors Store Integrated Across Customer Across Product Lines Profile Biz units MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 42 September 28, 1999
Slide 43: Internet Development Framework
Internet Development Framework Timing and Development of Internet Market Segments YO UA RE HE Path of Growth/Digestion/Growth... RE New Phases/Segments Drive New Growth s tical /Ver ic e s ng/ ness es Serv on c i ervi gati e rc e Bus e dS re ctur om m Agg eeri e an astru il/C n g in / tent war Infr
Slide 44: A Framework for B2B
A FRAMEWORK FOR B2B Mary Meeker / 212-761-8042 / [email protected] Chuck Phillips / 212-761-4450 / [email protected] David Edwards / 212-762-6853 / [email protected] Ariba User Group and Advisory Council Conference September 28, 1999 MORGAN STANLEY DEAN WITTER INTERNET RESEARCH 44 September 28, 1999
Morgan Stanley Dean Witter — Ariba User Group and Advisory Council Conference 1999 on 6ix