Sigma Designs — Proxy Contest (July 2012)
48 slides from Sigma Designs's proxy contest presentation, Jul 16, 2012
Slide 1: Investor Presentation Sigma Designs, Inc.
Investor Presentation Sigma Designs, Inc. July 16, 2012
Slide 2: Overview of Potomac Capital Partners
Overview of Potomac Capital Partners • Potomac Capital Partners, LP is a New York-based investment partnership that invests in deeply undervalued publicly-traded U.S. small-cap companies. Potomac works alongside management and company boards to identify and execute on opportunities to unlock value f
Slide 3: Why We Are Here
Why We Are Here • Sigma’s incumbent Board has overseen an 80% decline in stock price (from January 2007 to April 10, 2012*), declining revenues, escalating operating expenses, significant cash burn, and massive operating losses. • Sigma’s incumbent Board, with an average tenure of 17 years, has mini
Slide 4: Overview of Sigma's Business
Overview of Sigma’s Business • Sigma, through multiple chipset product lines, participates in the convergence of the delivery of home entertainment and home control – burgeoning markets. • Sigma was an early pioneer in the IPTV market and its first mover advantage enabled it to enjoy considerable gr
Slide 5: Sigma's Current Business Strategy Is Failing
Sigma’s Current Business Strategy Is Failing • We believe Sigma has embarked on an ill-advised acquisition strategy to compete head on with companies of far greater size and scale – a strategy that is clearly failing based on Sigma’s poor operational and financial performance. • Sigma has spent over
Slide 6: Strategy Has Resulted in Poor Operational and Financial Performance
Strategy Has Resulted in Poor Operational and Financial Performance • Significant Revenue Declines – Fiscal 2012 revenue decreased 36% to $182.6 million, down from $286.9 million in fiscal 2011. – 43% decline in revenue over past 5 fiscal quarters from $70.6 million to $40.3 million. – Sigma’s net r
Slide 7: Sigma's Stock Price Has Dramatically Underperformed
Sigma’s Stock Price Has Dramatically Underperformed Sigma’s stock price has materially underperformed the broader equity markets and its semiconductor peers over the past 1-, 3-, and 5-year periods Five-Year Sigma Stock Price Chart Summary Returns 200% 150% Share Price Performance(1) 100% 1 Year 3 Y
Slide 8: Significant Shareholder Dilution and Destruction
Significant Shareholder Dilution and Destruction – In the past three years, Sigma has issued approximately 6.3 million shares, resulting in significant shareholder dilution of over 24%. – For fiscal 2012, Sigma reported a loss of almost $150 million in shareholders’ equity from $398 million in fisca
Slide 9: Decline in Revenue from Core Businesses
Decline in Revenue from Core Businesses $ millions % Growth Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years 9
Slide 10: Overall Decline in Revenue and Growth
Overall Decline in Revenue and Growth Revenue $ millions Growth Declining Revenue Growth Despite Acquiring Over $75 Million in New Businesses Note: Unless otherwise noted, years in graph represent fiscal years 10
Slide 11: Undisciplined Spending
Undisciplined Spending Operating Costs as a % of Sales “We believe telco delays of Sigma’s core IPTV set-top box chipsets will persist, leading to continued operating losses and cash burn due to inadequate revenue coverage of opex that is equivalent to 69% of sales.” – UBS (July 13, 2012) Note: Year
Slide 12: Rising Operating Expenses
Rising Operating Expenses Total Operating Expenses $ millions % of Sales “…the opex level is unsustainable in our opinion.” – Lazard Capital Markets (3/8/2012) Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years 12
Slide 13: Overall Profitability Has Imploded
Overall Profitability Has Imploded Operating Profit Margin / Gross Profit Margin Note: 2012 includes one time charges Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years 13
Slide 14: Weak Gross Margins Relative to Peer Group
Weak Gross Margins Relative to Peer Group FY 2012 Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years 14 Note: Peer Group sourced from Sigma Design’s 2011 Proxy
Slide 15: Declining Operating Income
Declining Operating Income Operating Income $ millions Margin For fiscal 2012, Sigma reported a net loss of over $168 million. Trend continues in fiscal 2013 with $13.7 million net loss for first quarter. Note: Unless otherwise noted, years in graph represent fiscal years 15
Slide 16: Weak Operating Margin Relative to Peer Group
Weak Operating Margin Relative to Peer Group FY 2012 Operating Margins “In terms of the recent Trident digital TV acquisition, the business is dilutive to margins and it will take at least a year before cost reduced products help to improve the margin structure all the while competition from a merge
Slide 17: Cash on Pace to Dip Below $100 Million
Cash on Pace to Dip Below $100 Million Working Capital vs. Cash $ millions “…unless management pulls a rabbit out of its hat, its is likely that the company’s net cash could drop by 50% during the next two years.” – BENCHMARK (3/8/2012) Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years 17
Slide 18: Declining EBITDA
Declining EBITDA EBITDA $ millions Margin Sigma’s EBITDA margins since FY 2011 have declined by over 50 percentage points. Note: Unless otherwise noted, years in graph represent fiscal years 18
Slide 19: Declining EBITDA vs. Peers
Declining EBITDA vs. Peers EBITDA Margins Sigma significantly underperforms its peer group. Note: Peer Group sourced from Sigma Design’s 2011 Proxy 19 Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years
Slide 20: More Mouths to Feed on a Shrinking Pie
More Mouths to Feed on a Shrinking Pie Total Employees / Operating Margin Employees % Margin Despite increasing its headcount from 219 in 2008 to 691 in 2012, the Company has not seen a commensurate payback, as revenue per employee has declined from approximately $500,000 in fiscal 2007 to approxima
Slide 21: Sigma's Response to Declining Revenue? Go Shopping!
Sigma’s Response to Declining Revenue? Go Shopping! Annual Revenue vs. Cumulative Acquisition + R&D Spend IPTV Revenue Cumulative Acquisition & R&D Expenses $ millions To mask declining core revenue, Sigma embarked on aggressive acquisition strategy that has not had commensurate revenue growth. 21 N
Slide 22: Undisciplined Expenditures Have Destroyed Enterprise Value
We Believe Undisciplined Expenditures Have Destroyed Enterprise Value Despite spending over $542 million on acquisitions and research and development over the past five fiscal years, Sigma’s enterprise value declined to $5 million as of April 10, 2012.* $ millions 700 300 600 250 500 200 400 150 300
Slide 23: Undisciplined Expenditures Have Crushed Enterprise Value
Undisciplined Expenditures Have Crushed Enterprise Value Acquisitions & R&D Expense 600 563.9 493.1 500 406.6 400 329.4 276.8 300 200 100 62.3 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 10-Apr-12 Cumulative Acquisition and R&D Expenses Enterprise Value 23 Note: April 10, 2012 represents the first trading day after
Slide 24: Unsustainable R&D Expense Growth
Unsustainable R&D Expense Growth R&D Expenses/R&D as a % of Sales $ millions % of Sales Note: Years in graph represent fiscal years 24
Slide 25: Trident Acquisition – Sigma's Latest Treasure Hunt
Trident Acquisition – Sigma’s Latest Treasure Hunt • Trident Microsystems, Inc. declared bankruptcy on January 4, 2012 after having burned through over $100 million in net cash trying to compete in the DTV market. • Sigma acquired Trident’s DTV assets for $48 million. – At the closing of this acquis
Slide 26: Trident Acquisition – Analyst Reaction
Trident Acquisition – Analyst Reaction • “While Sigma is buying Trident’s assets on the cheap and shortens its entry time into DTV, we worry that long term price competition from MediaTek and MStar and smaller market position for Sigma/Trident could lead to lower than expected sales growth and/or ma
Slide 27: Board has sold over $46 million worth of SIGM stock
The only thing this Board has accomplished is selling over $46 million worth of its SIGM stock, including options which have been granted at questionable times.
Slide 28: Current Board has little "Skin in the Game"
Current Board has little “Skin in the Game” Collectively, the Board owns approximately 2.5% of the outstanding shares. Thinh Q. Tran - CEO Julien Nguyen – Director • Currently owns 729,059 Shares of SIGM (2.2%) • Currently owns 8,690 Shares of SIGM (0.026%) • Current Value of SIGM Stock: $4,548,960
Slide 29: Questionable Timing of Options Grants
Questionable Timing of Options Grants • Erik Lie, a Professor at University of Iowa is considered one of the top experts on Options Backdating. • Professor Lie was asked by Potomac Group to look into Sigma’s options grants between August 1994 and June 2007. Here was the professor’s finding: “Overall
Slide 30: Stock Returns for SIGM Options Grants (1994 – 2007)
Stock Returns for SIGM Options Grants (1994 – 2007) Source: Professor Erik Lie – University of Iowa Average cumulative return as a result of timing of option grants = 25% 30
Slide 31: All SIGM Options Grants (1994 – 2007)
All SIGM Options Grants (1994 – 2007) Source: Professor Erik Lie – University of Iowa 31
Slide 32: Stock Performance and CEO Options Granting Dates: Notice a Pattern?
Sigma Designs Stock Performance and CEO Options Granting Dates (1994-2007): Notice a Pattern? HOW CAN SHAREHOLDERS TRUST THIS BOARD? 32
Slide 33: Sigma's Poor Corporate Governance
Sigma’s Poor Corporate Governance • Low number of Board members for a public company – Sigma’s Board is fixed at 4 members. – Average number of Board members of Sigma’s peer group = 7 • An average Board tenure of 17 years. – Thinh Q. Tran – 30 years on the board – William J. Almon – 18 years on the
Slide 34: Questionable Related Party Transactions
Questionable Related Party Transactions • William Almon (the newly appointed Chairman of the Board), invested $200K in Blue 7 in fiscal 2005. • In June 2005, Sigma invested $1 million for an ownership interest of approximately 17%, valuing the company at $5.9 million. Sigma also advanced loans to Bl
Slide 35: To Unlock Value, Sigma Needs a Reconstituted Board
To Unlock Value, Sigma Needs a Reconstituted Board Potomac nominees have the extensive range of relevant financial, transactional and operating expertise and experience necessary to address the difficult challenges currently facing the Company 35
Slide 36: Mark F. Fitzgerald - Strong Relevant Experience to Improve Sigma
Mark F. Fitzgerald - Strong Relevant Experience to Improve Sigma • Mark F. Fitzgerald has over 20 years of experience as a research analyst following the semiconductor industry. His career spanned a critical growth phase of the industry from 1986 through 2009; first in technical roles involved in se
Slide 37: Eric B. Singer - Strong Relevant Experience to Improve Sigma
Eric B. Singer - Strong Relevant Experience to Improve Sigma • As co-managing member of Potomac Capital Management III, L.L.C. (PCM III), Mr. Singer has significant experience evaluating companies from a financial, operational and strategic perspective to identify inefficiencies and drive initiative
Slide 38: Mark J. Bonney - Strong Relevant Experience to Improve Sigma
Mark J. Bonney - Strong Relevant Experience to Improve Sigma • Mark Bonney has over 35 years of experience in the industry, holding various senior executive financial and operating positions in middle market high technology companies, both in the United States and abroad. Mr. Bonney also has substan
Slide 39: Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Create Value at Sigma
Our Nominees Have a Better Plan to Create Value at Sigma 39
Slide 40: First 90 Days
First 90 Days Refocus Sigma’s efforts on restoring profitability to its existing assets – Understand the organization; locations, compensation, measurements/key performance indicators, results, etc. – Analyze all costs, breakdown between variable vs. fixed, location, cost drivers, profitability by c
Slide 41: Operational Fixes – Align Costs with Revenues
Operational Fixes – Align Costs with Revenues • Capital Allocation - A new Board with a fresh unbiased perspective is needed to conduct an honest assessment of how Sigma is allocating its capital relative to ROI hurdles and why, despite the Board’s statements that its strategy is working, its revenu
Slide 42: Shareholders Cannot Afford to Wait
Shareholders Cannot Afford to Wait • Board has missed its guidance twice in the past four fiscal quarters and we believe will miss its guidance for fiscal 2013. • On the Company’s conference call to discuss its first quarter fiscal 2012 results, the Company projected second quarter fiscal 2012 reven
Slide 43: Sigma Designs – A Value Opportunity With a Reconstituted Board
Sigma Designs – A Value Opportunity With a Reconstituted Board A strong Board of Directors is needed to address all current and future decisions Sigma Poor Board Performance Potomac Board Member Goals Operational Oversight • Accepted poor financial results for years • Hold management accountable for
Slide 44: Legal Disclaimer
LEGAL DISCLAIMER • This presentation is for discussion and general informational purposes only. It does not have regard to the specific investment objective, financial situation, suitability or the particular need of any specific person who reads this presentation, and should not be taken as advice
Slide 45: Appendix
Appendix • Director nominees – Mark J. Bonney – Mark F. Fitzgerald – Eric B. Singer 45
Slide 46: Director Nominees
Director Nominees Mark J. Bonney (Age 58) has served as Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Direct Brands, Inc. (“Direct Brands”), a direct to consumer media company, since March 2010. Direct Brands and its affiliate, Bookspan, are the largest direct-to-consumer distributor of me
Slide 47: Director Nominees
Director Nominees Mark F. Fitzgerald (Age 56) has been a private investor since February 2008. From June 2007 to February 2008, Mr. Fitzgerald was a partner in Wilmot Investments L.P., a technology focused hedge fund. From May 2000 to February 2007, Mr. Fitzgerald served as an analyst covering the s
Slide 48: Director Nominees
Director Nominees Eric B. Singer (Age 38) has served as a co-managing member of Potomac Management III, the general partner of PCP III, since March 2012. Since May 2009, Mr. Singer has served as an advisor to Potomac Management and its related entities, and has been a member of Potomac Capital Manag