Bob Evans Farms — Proxy Contest (December 2013)
70 slides from Bob Evans Farms's proxy contest presentation, Dec 27, 2013
Slide 1: Investor Presentation
Steve Davis, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Paul DeSantis, Chief Financial Officer Scott Taggart, VP, Investor Relations Exhibit 99.1 December 2013 (revised 12.27.13) Investor Presentation
Slide 2: Safe Harbor Statement Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995
Safe Harbor Statement Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 Negative publicity or litigation regarding allegations of food-related illness, Failure to achieve and maintain positive same-store sales, Changing business conditions, including energy costs, Overall macroeconomic cond
Slide 3: Important Additional Information
IMPORTANT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The Company and certain of its directors and executive officers may be deemed to be participants in the solicitation of consent revocations from stockholders in connection with the potential consent solicitation by Sandell Asset Management and its affiliates. The Com
Slide 4: Non-GAAP Financial Measures
Non-GAAP Financial Measures The Company uses non-GAAP financial measures within this presentation. These financial measures are used by management to monitor and evaluate the ongoing performance of the Company. The Company believes that the additional measures are useful to investors for financial a
Slide 5: Growing Our Regional Brands into Powerful National Brands
GROWING OUR REGIONAL BRANDS INTO POWERFUL NATIONAL BRANDS 191 60 16 21 3 51 31 38 8 23 3 17 7 4 48 “Discover farm-fresh goodness” “Come see what’s cooking” 2 COMPANY FACT SHEET FISCAL 2014 Q2 NASDAQ: BOBE NEW RESTAURANTS FY’14 4 FY’15E up to 10 561 Restaurants 19 States As of 10/25/13 REMODELS FY’14
Slide 6: Powerful National Brands Make Our Regional Brands
BOB EVANS RESTAURANTS 6 Powerful NATIONAL BRANDS Make Our REGIONAL BRANDS BEF FOODS, INC. VISION
Slide 7: Well-Positioned to Capture Both Grocery and Restaurant Consumption
Bob Evans is Well-Positioned to Capture Both Grocery and Restaurant Consumption $12 Billion+ (The value of a single share point) Source: IFMA Forecast & Outlook ‘82-’11 Percent Dollars Spent Over Time 35% 40% 45% 50% 55% 60% 65% Restaurant Grocery Technomic ‘12
Slide 8: Our Shareholder Value Creation Goal
Our Shareholder Value Creation Goal: 8 to 12 Percent Annual Earnings Growth TRANSFORM OUR CORE BUSINESSES TO ENABLE EXPANSION DRIVE SHAREHOLDER VALUE WITH DISCIPLINED CAPITAL ALLOCATION SELECTIVELY INVEST IN HIGH R.O.I.C. GROWTH OPPORTUNITIES (Internal & External)
Slide 9: Strategic and Balanced Approach to Capital Allocation
BOBE Employs a Strategic and Balanced Approach to Capital Allocation
Slide 10: A Track Record of Balanced Capital Allocation
A Track Record of Balanced Capital Allocation $270M $401M $110M $163M $52M $30M $124M $63M Dividends Share Repurchases Acquisition CapEx Dividends Share Repurchases Debt Repayment CapEx Fiscal 2008-2012 Fiscal 2013
Slide 11: Transforming our Company and Rewarding Shareholders
Transforming our Company and Rewarding Shareholders ($ millions) Share Repurchases Capital Expenditures For additional details concerning FY 2014 guidance, see the Company’s 2Q Fiscal 2014 earnings release dated December 3, 2013. Note: excludes Mimi’s Café.
Slide 12: Investing Efficiently with Prudent Debt Management
Investing Efficiently with Prudent Debt Management ($ millions) Net Debt Capital Expenditures Note: excludes Mimi’s Café.
Slide 13: Evolution of our Capital Allocation Strategy
Evolution of our Capital Allocation Strategy After significant capital investment in fiscal 2014 ($175-$200M), we expect to: target a 3.0x debt/EBITDAR ratio, with additional leverage capacity for restaurant incubator or bolt-on foods acquisitions reduce annual capital expenditures to maintenance le
Slide 14: Target Leverage Ratio In-line with other Restaurant Companies
Target Leverage Ratio In-line with other Restaurant Companies
Slide 15: Evaluation of Debt Financing Alternatives
Evaluation of Debt Financing Alternatives Highly restrictive Minimally restrictive Low cost High cost Highly restrictive Minimally restrictive Incremental Term Debt Revolving Credit Facility Low cost Secured Financing Unsecured Bonds Sale Leaseback High cost
Slide 16: Share Repurchase Programs Have Reduced Diluted Shares Outstanding
Weighted Average Diluted Shares Outstanding (00 0 ’s) Ongoing Share Repurchase Programs have Reduced Diluted Shares Outstanding by 25% Since Fiscal 2007 Projected share count reduction of ~33% by FYE’14 36,484 33,315 30,744 30,890 30,422 29,781 28,094 27,184 25,000 27,000 29,000 31,000 33,000 35,000
Slide 17: Annual Dividend has Doubled Since FY 2009
Annual Dividend has Doubled Since FY 2009 101% Increase (quarterly dividend raised to $0.31 as of August 19, 2013/$1.24 annually) $0.60 $0.68 $0.78 $0.95 $1.075 $1.205 FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014E
Slide 18: Mimi's Café Divestiture Improves Adjusted Operating Margin Profile
Mimi’s Café Divestiture Improves Adjusted Operating Margin Profile 1 See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) in the Appendix of this presentation. For additional details concerning FY guidance, see the Company’s 2Q Fiscal earnings release dated
Slide 19: Margin Innovation: Key Components of Long-Term Earnings Growth Guidance
Margin Innovation: (300-350 basis point improvement) Key Components of 8-12% Long-Term Earnings Growth Guidance workforce management food cost optimization menu management FFR 2.0 plant optimization implement Lean manufacturing w/side dish production transformational systems upgrades 3.0% to 3.5% ER
Slide 20: Farm Fresh Refresh Financial Impact Improves Free Cash Flow in FY2015
Farm Fresh Refresh Financial Impact Improves Free Cash Flow in FY2015 $0.0 -$1.1 -$2.5 -$3.0 -$1.6 -$3.4 -$3.8 * 40% sales flow-through assumed -$2.7 -$5.9 -$6.8 Impact to P&L ($ millions) ** Includes incremental repair and maintenance expense associated with remodel construction. FY2012 FY2013 FY20
Slide 21: Plant Network Optimization Leading to New Adjusted Operating Margin Trajectory at BEF Foods
Strategic Plant Network Optimization Leading to a New Adjusted Operating Margin Trajectory at BEF Foods 7.5-8.0% 1 See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) in the Appendix of this presentation. 8.8% 7.5-8.0% 11.8-12.3% +2.5% 10.0-10.5% 2Q’14: Ric
Slide 22: Margin Improvement Backed by Past Productivity Performance
300-350 Basis Point Margin Improvement Backed by Past Productivity Performance Sources of Recent Cost Savings Initiatives Reflect Enterprise-Wide Focus on Productivity supply chain cost of sales labor Categorization of cost savings initiatives reflects company estimates. 23% 23% 54% Fiscal Yr. Fisca
Slide 23: Transformations Drive Five Year Margin Improvement
1 Transformations Drive Estimated Five Year 300-350 Adjusted Operating Margin Basis Point Improvement 1 See reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) in the Appendix of this presentation. For additional details concerning FY 2014 guidance, see the Com
Slide 24: Business Segments (FY 2013)
* Excludes Mimi’s Café segment (sold 2-15-13) 26% * 74% * Business Segments (FY 2013)
Slide 25: Come see what's cooking
25 “Come see what’s cooking ” TM 561 restaurants in 19 states as of 10/25/13 Full-service family restaurants featuring a wide variety of menu items for both on-and-off premise dining
Slide 26: Overview: Bob Evans Restaurants
Overview: Bob Evans Restaurants 33% 37% 30% * Excludes Mimi’s Café segment (sold 2-15-13) Net Sales (FY 2013) $981 million (74% of total * ) Average Annual Unit Sales (FY 2013) $1.74 million ALL THREE DAY PARTS SERVED (2Q FY 2014) Breakfast Lunch Dinner Avg. Dine-In Guest Check/Per Guest (2Q FY 2014
Slide 27: FY 2014 Vital Few Priorities
Build bench strength and staffing to enable profitable expansion Drive profitable guest counts – dine-in and off-premise (bakery, carryout, and catering) Improve controllable expenses: Cost of Sales, Cost of Labor, Direct Operating Expenses Elevate the guest experience through execution of “Best for
Slide 28: Accelerated Farm Fresh Refresh Program Complete by FY2014
Approximate % of Chain Remodeled by Fiscal Year Accelerated Farm Fresh Refresh Program Complete by FY2014 (32 units) (87 units) (195 units) 5% 20% 100% 56% (228 units) FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14E Average capital investment per remodeled restaurant: ~$225k
Slide 29: Farm Fresh Refresh: Consistent Outperformance
Farm Fresh Refresh: Consistent Outperformance Farm Fresh Refresh Outperformance vs. Non-remodeled Restaurants FFR Year 1 Not Remodeled Restaurant count FFR Year 1 Not Remodeled -5.0% -4.0% -3.0% -2.0% -1.0% 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 3.0% 4.0% 5.0% 6.0% 159 170 FFR Year 1 96 Not Remodeled
Slide 30: Bob Evans' Off-Premise Opportunity
Bob Evans’ Off-Premise Opportunity QSR 74% FULL SERVICE 15% 9% Dine-In 39% Off-Premise 61% Annual Consumption of Restaurant Meals (per capita) FAMILY SEGMENT Source: NPD Group - 12 months ending 3/31/13
Slide 31: Farm Fresh Refresh: Enabling an Aggressive Off-Premise Strategy
Bakery Farm Fresh Refresh: Enabling an Aggressive Off-Premise Strategy 1.4% ~7% 0.6% Total off-premise sales to reach 25% of sales mix by fiscal 2018. Bakery Dine-in Carryout Catering Retail Total 87.7% 11.1% 0.5% 0.7% 100.0% 2018E ~75% 100.0% 25% 25% 90.1% 7.9% 0.0% 2.0% 100.0% (embedded in dine- i
Slide 32: Off-Premise Sales Layers
Off-Premise Sales Layers FY 2013 Growth / Mix BAKERY CARRYOUT FY 2013 Growth / Mix CATERING FY 2013 Growth / Mix 30.5% / 1.4% 7.4% / 11.1% 20.4% / 0.5%
Slide 33: Bold Goal: Drive Off-Premise to 25% of Sales Mix
Bold Goal: Drive Off-Premise to 25% of Sales Mix Growth % Catering/Carryou t Bakery Family Meals to Go Off-Premise Sales Mix and Growth % by Year Sales Mix +8.6% +5.3% +8.5% +3.9% +15.4% +7.9% 8.0% 7.5% 6.5% 7.0% 8.5% 9.0% 9.5% 12.0% 11.5% 11.0% 10.5% 10.0% +12.9% +0.6%
Slide 34: Dine-In Value Sales Layers
Dine-In Value Sales Layers BREAKFAST The Rise & Shine Breakfast currently drives of annual revenue. DINNER 3-Course Dinners currently drive of annual revenue. LUNCH $6.99 Lunch Combos currently drive of annual revenue. $7.99 Knife and Fork Sandwiches Available December 5 th ! ~ $75 million / 7.6% ~$
Slide 35: Back of the House Improvements to Drive Guest Satisfaction Gains
Back of the House Improvements Required to Drive Further Guest Satisfaction Gains Overall Guest Satisfaction Speed of Service 82.7 84.4 88.0 88.4 71.7 77.9 83.0 83.1 Farm Fresh Refresh 2.0 Designed to Further Elevate the Guest Experience through Back of the House Upgrades FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
Slide 36: New Restaurant Opening Strategy
New Restaurant Opening Strategy New Albany, IN Fort Smith, AR NEW CONTIGUOUS MARKETS FILL-IN EXISTING MARKETS Up to 4 new restaurants planned for FY 2014. Up to 4 new restaurants planned for FY 2014. Up to 10 new restaurants annually beginning FY 2015. Up to 10 new restaurants annually beginning FY
Slide 37: New Restaurant Prototype: Finneytown, Ohio
New Restaurant Prototype: Finneytown, Ohio Opened September 30, 2013 • Test new “back-of-the- house” technologies and layouts • Reduce building cost through efficient design • Leverage Farm Fresh Refresh program insights • Accentuate Farm heritage Objectives:
Slide 38: Bob Evans Express Licensing Opportunity
Bob Evans Express Licensing Opportunity • Partnering with AVI Food Systems, Inc. • Increases brand awareness in existing and new geographies and new venues • Popular favorites covering all day parts • High quality menu to ensure serving guests in a quick manner 38 • First location, BMW USA manufactu
Slide 39: Driving Sales Across Multiple Digital Platforms
Mobile Site 46,595 100% increase Driving Sales Across Multiple Digital Platforms FY14 – Q2 Digital BOBEVANS.COM 2,095,451 Visits -6.6% Email Database 976,284 Subscribers +107,148 email names Online Ordering 125,119 Orders +15.6% increase YouTube Channel 342,419 Video Views
Slide 40: Social Media: A Key Component of Our Digital Strategy
Social Media: A Key Component of Our Digital Strategy FY14 – Q2 Digital Foursquare 375,124 Check Ins Facebook 291,727 Likes / + 59,638 Likes Instagram 635 followers / +315 Twitter 9,222 Followers / + 268 Yammer Internal Sales Blog
Slide 41: Discover farm-fresh goodness
41 “Discover farm-fresh goodness ” TM TWO BRANDS distinct geographic strengths
Slide 42: Overview: BEF Foods
Overview: BEF Foods 26% of total (excluding Mimi ’ s Caf é Segment) 29% 14% 36% 14% 7% 39% 24% 29% FOUR KEY LINES OF BUSINESS Sausage, Refrigerated Side Dishes, Frozen and Food Service Sold at 30,000+ retail locations in 50 states and Mexico sausage mix (% of total sales): 43% sausage mix (% of tota
Slide 43: BEF Foods Transformations Offset Estimated Impact in Fiscal 2014
BEF Foods Transformations Offset $20-$25 Million Estimated Impact in Fiscal 2014 Adjusted Operating Income ($ millions) 1 Avg Sow Cost $44.93 $61.58 $53.87 $65-$70 Est. Sow cost impact vs 2009 ($ millions) $17 $9 $20-25 FY 12 No Mitigation Launched lean mfg. program Transitioned from DSD to warehous
Slide 44: FY 2014: Vital Few Priorities
FY 2014: Vital Few Priorities Expand “in-source” supplier relationships for the restaurant segments and the food service industry Drive sales through new authorizations and geographic expansion Drive margin expansion through Lean efficiencies Optimize our plant and distribution network Drive best-in
Slide 45: BEF Foods: Store/SKU Count
BEF Foods: Store/SKU Count Source: IRI 30,193 31,070 40,000 2Q13 2Q14 11.1 11.7 ~17 2Q13 2Q14 average SKUs per store # of stores
Slide 46: BEF Foods: SKU Count and ACV Distribution Core vs. Non-Core
BEF Foods: SKU Count and ACV Distribution Core vs. Non-Core CORE MARKETS NON CORE MARKETS SKUs/Store ACV SKUs/Store ACV 21.8 9.0 80.9 68.1 Opportunity in Non-Core Markets SOURCE: IRI, FY14 Q2 - 13 weeks ending 10/20/13 Core Market: Chicago, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, Toledo, Detroit, Grand Rap
Slide 47: Kettle Creations Plant Expansion Drives Vertical Integration
Kettle Creations Plant Expansion Drives Vertical Integration • Accelerated product innovation • Proprietary manufacturing capability • Opportunities to drive food service business during off- peak production • Profitable growth reduces reliance on sausage business Completed October 2013 Completed Oc
Slide 48: Sulphur Springs Plant Expansion Enables Sales Growth
Sulphur Springs Plant Expansion Enables Sales Growth and New Distribution Completed October 2013 • Adds 60,000 sq. feet to facility • 165,000 total sq. feet after expansion • Two new 57,000 sq. foot production lines, with a third to be added later
Slide 49: Management and the Board are Aligned with Shareholders
Management and the Board are Aligned with Shareholders 1.1 million shares beneficially owned and held 1.1 million shares beneficially owned and held in deferred compensation plans in deferred compensation plans (1) (1) by officers by officers and directors and directors Represents approximately 2x c
Slide 50: = ‘tots Sade,
= ‘tots Sade,
Slide 51: Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café GAAP Segments as reported Net Sales 1,608,909 $ 981,418 $ 348,808 $ 278,683 $ 1,654,413 $ 973,6
Slide 52: Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) ($ thousands) Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Bob Evans BEF Mimi's Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café Consolidated Restaurants Foods Café Non-GAAP Adjustments Net Sales (19,968) (19,968) (6,985) (5,086) (1,899) Cost of
Slide 53: Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP)
Reconciliation of Adjusted Operating Income (Non-GAAP) to Reported Operating Income (GAAP) 2009 BEF Foods’ (formerly “Food Products”) Operating Income Reconciliation Fiscal 2009 BEF reported operating income (GAAP) $15,571 Non-GAAP adjustment: Other operating expenses Fiscal 2009 BEF reported operat
Slide 54: Board of Directors
Bob Evans Farms, Inc. Board of Directors Pre - FY2007 FY2007 - Present Larry C. Corbin • • Paul S. Williams • • G. Robert Lucas • • Cheryl L. Krueger • • Michael J. Gasser • • E.W. (Bill) Ingram III • • Mary Kay Haben • • Dr. E. Gordon Gee • • Eileen A. Mallesch • • Steven A. Davis • • Elected 1997.
Slide 55: Strong Corporate Governance is a Priority
Strong Corporate Governance is a Priority at Bob Evans Farms, Inc. Source: ISS, August 2013. Peer average (ex-BOBE): 4.1 Higher Lower ISS Quickscore Governance Rank
Slide 56: Family Dining Stock Performance: Transformational Investments Leading to Recent Outperformance
Family Dining Stock Performance: Transformational Investments Leading to Recent Outperformance
Slide 57: Improved Relative Performance to Peer Groups and Overall Market
Transformational Investments also Leading to Improved Relative Performance to Peer Groups and Overall Market
Slide 58: Strong Balance Sheet and P&L Discipline Through Market Decline
Strong Balance Sheet and P&L Discipline Enabled BOBE to Weather the Most Recent Significant Market Decline Well STOCK PRICE PERFORMANCE (10/9/07 to 3/9/09)
Slide 59: BOBE's Strong Balance Sheet Enables Above-Average Returns of Capital
BOBE’s Strong Balance Sheet Enables Above- Average Returns of Capital
Slide 60: BOBE's Valuation Relative to other Restaurant and Branded Protein Companies
BOBE’s Valuation Relative to other Restaurant and Branded Protein Companies:
Slide 61: Slide 61
Slide 62: Slide 62
Slide 63: History of Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions
History of Significant Asset Closures/Dispositions to Drive Margin Improvement and Transformational Growth Fiscal Year Business Strategic Announced Unit Action(s) Announced Rationale Bob Evans Restaurants 16 underperforming restaurants closed margin/ROIC improvement Owens Restaurants 8 underperformi
Slide 64: New Exterior Design Restaurant Remodels
New Exterior Design Restaurant Remodels Original Exterior Design
Slide 65: Restaurant Remodels New Center Entrance
Restaurant Remodels New Center Entrance Original Center Entrance Since Technomic began polling consumers about their most recent visits to Bob Evans in Q1 2011, consumers increasingly indicate that several aspects of the brand’s unit appearance and ambiance are good or very good: Overall atmosphere
Slide 66: Restaurant Remodels New Expanded Dining Room
Restaurant Remodels New Expanded Dining Room New Counter Source: September 2013 Bob Evans Farms, Inc. Consumer Brand Metrics Analysis, Technomic, Inc. The increases on these four distinct metrics of store atmosphere suggest that consumers are responding positively to the brand’s “Farm Fresh Refresh”
Slide 67: New Bakery Restaurant Remodels New Carryout
New Bakery Restaurant Remodels New Carryout “Taste of the Farm ” Retail and Carryout Areas Designed to Drive Sales Layers with On-Brand Offerings ®
Slide 68: BER Bakery: A Sales Layer with $75M+ Potential
BER Bakery: A Sales Layer with $75M+ Potential Incorporating a variety of elements to achieve estimated weekly bakery sales of $2,500 per restaurant by FY 2018. $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 $2,500 $3,000 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E Farm Fresh Refresh Surprise & Delight Bread Expansion Pie Reinvent
Slide 69: $5 Platform: A Sales Layer with $40M+ Potential
$5 Platform: A Sales Layer with $40M+ Potential New Occasions Flavor Expansion Soup Success Making Bob Evans a destination for home meal replacement. $0 $500 $1,000 $1,500 $2,000 2014E 2015E 2016E 2017E 2018E
Slide 70: Frozen Coffee Beverages: A $20M+ Incremental Sales Opportunity
BOLD Coffee Beverage Destination Expanded Soda Options Shakes & Smoothies Fresh Lemonade & Fruit Fizzes Frozen Coffee Beverages: A $20M+ Incremental Sales Opportunity 76% 78% 80% 82% 84% 86% 88% 90% 92% FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014E FY 2015E FY 2016E FY 2017E FY 2018E Executing a multi-faceted beverage p