Texas Industries Inc

Texas Industries — Proxy Contest (October 2009)

45 slides from Texas Industries's proxy contest presentation, Oct 1, 2009

  1. Slide 1: Schedule 14A

    UNITED STATES SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. 20549 SCHEDULE 14A (Rule 14a-101) INFORMATION REQUIRED IN PROXY STATEMENT SCHEDULE 14A INFORMATION Proxy Statement Pursuant to Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Amendment No. ) Filed by the Registrant ¨ Filed by a

  2. Slide 2: The Case for Change at Texas Industries, Inc. (NYSE: TXI)

    Shamrock Capital Advisors, Inc. The Case for Change at Texas Industries, Inc. (NYSE: TXI) 1

  3. Slide 3: Purpose

    Purpose Shamrock Activist Value Fund, L.P. is: • Nominating three candidates for election to the nine-member Texas Industries board of directors • Proposing three corporate governance shareholder proposals We believe Texas Industries is substantially undervalued due to: • Operational underperformanc

  4. Slide 4: We believe TXI is undervalued because:

    We believe TXI is undervalued because: TXI has a history of underperformance • TXI operating margins and return on invested capital (ROIC) consistently lag peers • TXI stock has underperformed its peers over a 1-year, 3-year, 5-year and 10-year period Poor shareholder communication • A pattern of ov

  5. Slide 5: Shamrock's nominees will seek to:

    Shamrock’s nominees will seek to: Make operational improvements • Goal is to improve returns on invested capital (ROIC) and operating margins Promote appropriate management oversight and accountability • Goal is to promote management accountability and appropriately link pay to performance Review st

  6. Slide 6: Southeastern Asset Management and Nassef Sawiris support our nominees and proposals

    Southeastern Asset Management and Nassef Sawiris support our nominees and proposals • TXI shareholders representing 24.2% of the TXI outstanding shares have publicly announced they will vote “FOR” our nominees and governance proposals Southeastern Asset Management, Inc., 9.3% shareholder, announced

  7. Slide 7: TXI's Record of Poor Performance

    TXI’s Record of Poor Performance 6

  8. Slide 8: TXI's stock has underperformed its peers over multiple periods

    TXI’s stock has underperformed its peers over multiple periods TXI Historical Stock Performance Summary as of 6/29/09 (1) 40% 31% 29% 30% 23% 20% 10% 6% 0% (10%) (20%) (30%) (21%) (30%) (40%) (39%) (50%) (43%) (2) 1-YR TSR 3-YR TSR 5-YR TSR 10-YR TSR TXI (3) Peer Group (4) (1) 6/29/09 was the date S

  9. Slide 9: TXI stock traded at a discount to its peers as of 6/29/09

    TXI stock traded at a discount to its peers as of 6/29/09 (1) Price / EPS Price / Tangible Book Value ROIC ROIC Martin Marietta Eagle Materials 4.0% Materials 8.1% Martin Marietta Materials 8.1% Eagle Materials 4.0% Texas Industries 2.0% Texas Industries 2.0% Vulcan Materials NM 2.9% Vulcan Material

  10. Slide 10: TXI margins have been among the lowest in its industry

    TXI margins have been among the lowest in its industry LTM EBIT Margins 5-Year Average EBIT Margins Lafarge Titan Cement Buzzi Unicem Eagle Materials Titan Cement Cementos Portland Valderrivas Martin Marietta Materials Buzzi Unicem Holcim Holcim HeidelbergCement Lafarge CEMEX Martin Marietta Materia

  11. Slide 11: TXI's return on invested capital has also been among the lowest in its industry

    TXI’s return on invested capital has also been among the lowest in its industry LTM Return on Invested Capital 5-Year Average Return on Invested Capital Buzzi Unicem Eagle Materials Martin Marietta Materials Titan Cement Lafarge Buzzi Unicem Titan Cement Martin Marietta Materials CRH Vulcan Material

  12. Slide 12: Lack of Effective Board Oversight

    Lack of Effective Board Oversight 11

  13. Slide 13: Better board oversight over capital allocation is required

    Better board oversight over capital allocation is required $427 million spent on Oro Grande expansion (2005-2008) + $294 million spent on suspended Hunter expansion (2007-2009) (1) + $55 million of capitalized interest (2005-2009) $0 in profit (2) Board has authorized management to spend $776 millio

  14. Slide 14: TXI board and management misjudged the market

    TXI board and management misjudged the market • TXI misjudged declining cement demand in its markets and was slow to change course in response to the construction downturn • While competitors conserved capital to preserve balance sheet flexibility, TXI incurred substantial leverage and expended sign

  15. Slide 15: TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering

    TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering Management has repeatedly failed to achieve publicly-stated objectives: Announced Management Issue Target Reality Underperformance Oro Grande budget $350 million $427 million $77 million (22%) Oro Grande EBIT $60 million $0 $60 million (100%)

  16. Slide 16: TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering

    TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering On the Oro Grande, California expansion • Management Claim: “In California, we are in the process of replacing 1.3 million tons of older, inefficient cement capacity with 2.3 million tons of highly efficient annual production… We expect the in

  17. Slide 17: TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering

    TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering On the Hunter, Texas expansion • Analyst Question: “And the second question was, obviously the risk here is with Texas slowing, you bring new capacity on stream in 12 months or 18 months time, there's a risk that we could have a rerun of what'

  18. Slide 18: TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering

    TXI has a history of over-promising and under-delivering On Margin Improvements • Management Claim: “…we had previously set a goal for something over 20% in terms of EBIT margins and with what's happened, particularly in energy price spikes and softness out in California, we haven't changed our goal

  19. Slide 19: Pay not proportionate to performance

    Pay not proportionate to performance – TXI should improve its compensation practices • From 2003 to 2008, the company’s average ROIC was 3.9% (2) , significantly below its current cost of capital • Over the same time period, management’s annual cash compensation grew at a CAGR of 25% • TXI should im

  20. Slide 20: TXI's compensation policies are flawed

    TXI’s compensation policies are flawed Current practice Recommended practice Other metrics should be used, such as ROIC, TXI uses ROE in setting cash incentives given the capital intensive nature of the business Disclosure should clearly define required Calculation methodology for calculating cash p

  21. Slide 21: TXI's Record of Poor Shareholder Communication

    TXI’s Record of Poor Shareholder Communication 20

  22. Slide 22: TXI's communication with the Street shows contempt for shareholders

    TXI’s communication with the Street shows contempt for shareholders • Meryl Witmer (Eagle Capital Partners): “And then just on the request by a 15% shareholder for a Board seat and also his request to increase his share holdings…I'm just curious about your rationale for not offering him a Board seat

  23. Slide 23: Is the board listening to the shareholders?

    Is the board listening to the shareholders? % Votes withheld (1) Proxy Year Mel G. Brekhus David S. Coats Thomas R. Ransdell Robert D. Rogers 2008 Not up for election 49% 49% Not up for election 2007 24% Not up for election Not up for election 25% The board has never explained or responded to high w

  24. Slide 24: Poor communication regarding TXI director elections

    Poor communication regarding TXI director elections • In the 2008 director election, the board circumvented the normal shareholder election process by not including on its slate a director nominee to replace an incumbent director who the board publicly announced in its proxy statement for the 2008 A

  25. Slide 25: Is the board of directors dominated by Robert Rogers?

    Is the board of directors dominated by Robert Rogers? • Robert D. Rogers has been a director of TXI for 40 years, following his father who was a director for 46 years • Almost all of TXI’s current directors have outside relationships with Mr. Rogers that are unrelated to TXI • At a recent meeting wi

  26. Slide 26: Shamrock Nominees (Election of Directors - Proposal 1)

    Shamrock Nominees (Election of Directors - Proposal 1) 25

  27. Slide 27: Shamrock's nominees are qualified to address key concerns

    Shamrock’s nominees are qualified to address key concerns • Our highly qualified nominees collectively have extensive experience in (i) finance and capital markets (including capital allocation matters), (ii) cement operations and (iii) corporate governance matters — all areas in which we believe Te

  28. Slide 28: Shamrock's nominees will seek to:

    Shamrock’s nominees will seek to: Make operational improvements • Our nominees will seek improvements to returns on invested capital (ROIC) and operating margins Promote appropriate management oversight and accountability • Our nominees will call for strict management accountability and appropriate

  29. Slide 29: Shamrock Shareholder Proposals

    (1) Shamrock Shareholder Proposals (1) The full text of the three Shamrock proposals is in Annex B of this presentation. 28

  30. Slide 30: TXI has a number of shareholder-unfriendly corporate governance policies

    TXI has a number of shareholder-unfriendly corporate governance policies Current policy SAVF Recommendation Classified board Annual elections for all directors Majority vote in all uncontested director Plurality voting in director elections elections “Poison pills” implemented by board “Poison pills

  31. Slide 31: TXI should make appropriate corporate governance improvements

    TXI should make appropriate corporate governance improvements • Our three proposals request that the board of directors: Declassify the board and require all directors to be accountable to the shareholders annually by standing for election every year (Proposal 3 - Board Declassification Resolution)

  32. Slide 32: Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3)

    Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3) 31

  33. Slide 33: Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3)

    Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3) • TXI’s classified board currently provides directors with three-year terms, meaning an individual director is only accountable to shareholders every third year • We believe the right to hold directors accountable through annual elections is a fundament

  34. Slide 34: Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4)

    Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4) 33

  35. Slide 35: Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4)

    Majority Voting Resolution (Proposal 4) • We believe plurality voting in the election of directors is a fundamentally flawed system, does not promote true corporate democracy, and allows unpopular incumbents who receive even one vote to be re-elected • TXI’s plurality voting standard ensures that TX

  36. Slide 36: Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5)

    Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5) 35

  37. Slide 37: Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5)

    Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5) • TXI’s board has adopted three successive 10-year shareholder rights plans (“poison pills”) without shareholder approval: first poison pill unilaterally adopted in 1986 second poison pill unilaterally adopted in 1996 third poison pill unilate

  38. Slide 38: Annexes and Additional Information

    Annexes and Additional Information 37

  39. Slide 39: Annex A: Shamrock's Nominees (page 1 of 3)

    Annex A: Shamrock’s Nominees (page 1 of 3) • Marjorie L. Bowen : Ms. Bowen worked at Houlihan Lokey Howard & Zukin from May 1989 until January 2008, where she was a Managing Director, the National Director of the firm’s fairness opinion practice, and was one of five members of the firm’s Financial A

  40. Slide 40: Annex A: Shamrock's Nominees (page 2 of 3)

    Annex A: Shamrock’s Nominees (page 2 of 3) • Dennis A. Johnson, CFA : Since July 2008, Mr. Johnson has served as a Managing Director of Shamrock Capital Advisors, Inc. (“SCA”), the investment advisor for the Shamrock Activist Value Fund, a Vice President of Shamrock Partners Activist Value Fund, L.L

  41. Slide 41: Annex A: Shamrock's Nominees (page 3 of 3)

    Annex A: Shamrock’s Nominees (page 3 of 3) • Gary L. Pechota: Since December 2007, Mr. Pechota has served as President and CEO of DT-Trak Consulting, Inc., a medical coding, billing and data entry services company. From May 2005 until December 2007, Mr. Pechota was a private investor. Mr. Pechota wa

  42. Slide 42: Annex B: Text of Shamrock's Proposals (page 1 of 2)

    Annex B: Text of Shamrock’s Proposals (page 1 of 2) The Board Declassification Resolution (Proposal 3): • “RESOLVED, that the shareholders of Texas Industries, Inc. (the “Company”) hereby request that the Board of Directors take all necessary actions to amend the Company’s bylaws to declassify the B

  43. Slide 43: Annex B: Text of Shamrock's Proposals (page 2 of 2)

    Annex B: Text of Shamrock’s Proposals (page 2 of 2) The Shareholder Vote on Poison Pills Resolution (Proposal 5): • “RESOLVED, that the shareholders of the Company hereby request that the Board of Directors take all necessary action (a) to submit the Company’s rights agreement (the “Rights Agreement

  44. Slide 44: Annex C: About Shamrock Capital Advisors, Inc.

    Annex C: About Shamrock Capital Advisors, Inc. • Shamrock Capital Advisors, Inc. (“SCA”) is the manager of Shamrock Activist Value Fund, L.P. and its parallel fund, Shamrock Activist Value Fund IV, L.P., (collectively the “Shamrock Activist Value Fund”, or “SAVF”). SCA is a subsidiary of Shamrock Ho

  45. Slide 45: Shamrock Activist Value Fund has filed its definitive proxy materials

    The Shamrock Activist Value Fund, L.P. has filed its definitive proxy materials for the 2009 Annual Meeting of Texas Industries Shareholders with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”). Copies of all proxy materials Shamrock Activist Value Fund, L.P. files with the SEC are available with

Texas Industries — Proxy Contest (October 2009) on 6ix