Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. · NYSE:HRTG
Heritage Insurance — Q3 2026 Earnings Presentation
25 slides from Heritage Insurance's earnings presentation, November 2026
Slide 1: Investor Presentation 3Q 2026
Investor Presentation 3Q 2026 Heritage Insurance Holdings, Inc. NYSE: HRTG www.heritagepci.com
Slide 2: Safe Harbor
SAFE HARBOR Statements in this presentation that are not historical facts are forward-looking statements that are subject to certain risks and uncertainties that could cause actual events and results to differ materially from those discussed herein. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing,
Slide 3: 3Q26 Highlights
3Q26 HIGHLIGHTS $1.40B $51.1M $1.72 73.0% Premiums In-Force Net Income Diluted EPS Net Combined Ratio as of 9/30/26 3Q26 · record $149.3M YTD 3Q26 · +5.5% YoY 3Q26 · YTD 72.9%, 3.9 pts better $20.22 36.1% 70.6% 10.5% Book Value Per Share Return on Avg. Equity TIV Outside Florida Debt to Capital +42.
Slide 4: Heritage Overview
H E R I TA G E O V E R V I E W NYSE: HRTG Super-regional U.S. property and Total Insured Value at 9/30/2026 casualty insurance holding company Total Assets: $2.3bn Personal residential (PRES) and Market Cap: ~$1.0bn Northeast 47.4% commercial residential (CRES) Southeast 29.7% property insurance Mid
Slide 5: Investment Highlights
INVESTMENT HIGHLIGHTS Experienced Returning to a Controlled Management Team Growth Strategy CEO with Heritage since its 2012 New personal lines business founding resumed Vertically Integrated A Robust Reinsurance Structure Program to Protect Capital In-house underwriting, claims and 2026–27 program
Slide 6: Vertically Integrated Structure
V E R T I C A L LY I N T E G R AT E D S T R U C T U R E o Vertically integrated structure includes a preferred provider network, minimizing third-party reliance, reducing costs, and providing a strategic hedge during catastrophe years o Vertically integrated structure reduces our earnings volatility
Slide 7: Geographic Diversification and Intelligent Growth
G E O G R A P H I C D I V E R S I F I C AT I O N A N D INTELLIGENT GROWTH o Strategically diversified portfolio to achieve better risk distribution, claims trends, and lower reinsurance costs o As of Q3 2026, 70.6% of total insured value (TIV) is positioned outside of Florida. Moreover, 70.3% is out
Slide 8: Profitable Foundation, Controlled Growth
P R O F I TA B L E F O U N D AT I O N , CONTROLLED GROWTH Generate Underwriting Profit o Rate adequacy and selective, profit-oriented underwriting o Excess & Surplus lines in several states add rate and filing flexibility Optimize Capital Allocation o Capital allocated to the most profitable segment
Slide 9: Heritage Evolution
H E R I TA G E E V O L U T I O N o 2014 -2020: Top-line Focus o Initiate profitability initiatives o 2021- 2025: Bottom-line Focus o Opportunistic growth (Commercial, CA) o Increased analytics o Positions company for managed growth o 2026: Managed Growth with continued o Re-underwrite the entire por
Slide 10: Profitable Through Cat Events Since 2024
P R O F I TA B L E T H R O U G H C AT E V E N T S S I N C E 2 0 2 4 Net Income Trajectory (in thousands) o 2022 includes pre-tax $94 million of goodwill write off and $250,000 $40 million of retained losses from Hurricane Ian $195,595 $200,000 o 2023 includes pre-tax $149,317 $40 million of retained
Slide 11: CAT XOL Reinsurance Program
C AT X O L R E I N S U R A N C E P R O G R A M Fully placed the 2026–2027 catastrophe excess-of-loss program in May 2026, adding multi-year coverage, achieving substantial cost savings and enhancing vertical protection for each insurance entity. Program Overview Northeast Southeast / Mid-Atlantic Ha
Slide 12: Technology Overview
TECHNOLOGY OVERVIEW Data-driven insurance operations, augmented by technology Data Warehouse: A Robust, Mature and Rich Policy Admin, Enterprise Analytics Platform Claims, Billing KPI dashboards on a cloud- New policy admin, claims and based visualization platform billing system (Guidewire) Alerts a
Slide 13: Experienced Management Team
EXPERIENCED MANAGEMENT TEAM Ernie Garateix Kirk Lusk Jim Hodson Tim Moura Tim Johns Chief Executive Officer Chief Financial Officer President, Commercial President, NBIC President, Zephyr o CEO since 2020 o CFO since 2018 o Leading Heritage Commercial o NBIC President since 2017 o Zephyr President s
Slide 14: Financial Highlights
FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS 2026 Investor Presentation 14
Slide 15: In-Force Metrics
IN-FORCE METRICS Personal Lines: Premiums in force held steady (+0.2%) as In-Force by Line average premium per policy rose 4.7% to $3,446, offsetting a 3Q25 3Q26 Change 4.3% lower policy count. Premiums In-Force ($M) Personal residential $1,155 $1,157 0.2% Commercial Residential: After growing from
Slide 16: Book Value Per Share Up Nearly 4x Since 2022
B O O K VA L U E P E R S H A R E U P N E A R LY 4 X S I N C E 2 0 2 2 Shareholders Equity (in 000s) Book Value Per Share $700,000 $23.00 $599,141 $20.22 $567,728 $20.00 $19.09 $600,000 $505,251 $520,372 $16.39 $17.15 $500,000 $17.00 $14.00 $400,000 $290,799 $11.00 $9.50 $300,000 $220,278 $8.00 $7.22
Slide 17: 3Q26 Operating Performance Summary
3 Q 2 6 O P E R AT I N G P E R F O R M A N C E S U M M A R Y Record nine months Profitable through cat losses Top-line pressure $149.3M net income (+15.8%) and $4.94 $51.1M 3Q26 net income despite $15.8M of Gross premiums written down 3.1% on Florida diluted EPS (+18.5%) catastrophe losses commercia
Slide 18: Capital Management & Operating Leverage
C A P I TA L M A N A G E M E N T & O P E R AT I N G L E V E R A G E Ongoing evaluation of dividend distribution and stock repurchases on a quarterly basis Responsible steward of shareholder capital o Share repurchase plan authorized $50.0M through December 31, 2026; $34.1M remaining at September 30,
Slide 19: Conservative Investment Portfolio
C O N S E R VAT I V E I N V E S T M E N T P O R T F O L I O Net investment income was $11.4 million in Q3 2026, up from $9.7 million in Q3 2025, on a $185 million larger average portfolio of short-duration, high-quality fixed income and cash. Cash and investments of $1.39 billion at 9/30/2026 +17.3%
Slide 20: Why Heritage
W H Y H E R I TA G E o Super-regional U.S. P&C insurer with 70.6% of total insured value outside Florida o Record nine months: $149.3M of net income (+15.8%) and $4.94 of diluted EPS (+18.5%) o Profitable through cat season: $51.1M of 3Q26 net income despite $15.8M of catastrophe losses o Book value
Slide 21: Additional Information
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION EMAIL: [email protected] WEBSITE: investors.heritagepci.com 2026 Investor Presentation 21
Slide 22: Appendix
APPENDIX 2026 Investor Presentation 22
Slide 23: Reinsurance Placements
Top10 Reinsurers REINSURANCE PLACEMENTS D.E. Shaw Re (Bermuda) Ltd., Bermuda (Collateralized) Reinsurance rate favorable in 2026 with significant risk adjusted savings. Fidelis Insurance Bermuda Ltd (AM Best A, S&P A-) Swiss Reinsurance America Corporation Noteworthy Reinsurance Placements for 2025
Slide 24: Appendix: Investment Portfolio Detail
A P P E N D I X : I N V E S T M E N T P O R T F O L I O D E TA I L Fixed income securities available for sale as of September 30, 2026 ($ in millions). Sum of Unrealized Sum of Unrealized Sum of Market % of Invest NAIC General Category ($ in MMS) Sum of Book Value Notes Gains Losses Value Portfolio
Slide 25: Mission, Vision & Values
M I S S I O N , V I S I O N & VA L U E S Mission Mission: To deliver insurance products and services that offer the greatest value in the most challenging markets. Innovation Integrity Claims Mission: Provide We are on a constant quest to Doing the right thing even find better ways to do things when
Heritage Insurance Holdings — Q3 2026 Earnings Presentation on 6ix