Emulex — Proxy Contest (June 2009)
34 slides from Emulex's proxy contest presentation, Jun 3, 2009
Slide 1: Emulex Tender Offer & Written Consent Solicitation
Emulex Tender Offer & Written Consent Solicitation June 3, 2009
Slide 2: Cautionary Statement
Cautionary Statement: This presentation does not constitute an offer to buy or a solicitation of an offer to sell any securities. Broadcom has filed a Tender Offer Statement on Schedule TO with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") containing an offer to purchase all of the outstanding
Slide 3: Cautionary Statement (continued)
Cautionary Statement: (continued) All statements included or incorporated by reference in this presentation other than statements or characterizations of historical fact, are forward-looking statements. These forward-looking statements are based on our current expectations, estimates and projections
Slide 4: Situation Overview
Situation Overview December 2008 Broadcom approached Emulex to explore a strategic combination January 2009 Emulex rejected offer to explore discussions Emulex subsequently adopted a Poison Pill, amended its bylaws and enhanced employment contracts with senior management to thwart the ability of Emu
Slide 5: Why Emulex Stockholders Should Act
Why Emulex Stockholders Should Act Broadcom's high premium, all cash offer is highly attractive Provides high premium to unaffected market value Delivers highly certain value to Emulex stockholders Emulex's standalone prospects for value accretion are highly uncertain Track record of underperformanc
Slide 6: Broadcom's Compelling Offer
Financial / Legal Advisors: Bank of America Merrill Lynch Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP o Broadcom's Compelling Offer Offer Price: * Based on Emulex stock price as of 4/20/2009, the day prior to the public announcement of Broadcom's proposal. Emulex cash of $302.7mm as of 3/29/2009 per Em
Slide 7: What Emulex Stockholders Should Do
What Emulex Stockholders Should Do Step One - Now! Submit Consents in Favor of Proposals Enables stockholders to call Special Meeting Provides forum for stockholders to express their will Provides stockholders with options without obligations No obligation to tender shares No obligation to elect new
Slide 8: Compelling Offer
Compelling Offer . www.broadcom.com
Slide 9: High Premium to Key Benchmarks
Compelling Offer High Premium to Key Benchmarks * Premium to Street Expectations * 90% Premium to Core Business Value * CY 2010E PE Multiple ** * Based on Emulex stock price as of 4/20/2009, the day prior to the public announcement of Broadcom's proposal. Emulex cash of $302.7mm as of 3/29/2009 per
Slide 10: Above Average Premium for Technology M&A Since 2005
Above Average Premium for Technology M&A Since 2005 Source: Dealogic. * Includes announced domestic public transactions between 1/1/2005 and 4/20/2009 with deal values greater than or equal to $100 million. Does not include minority stake transactions. ** For Emulex, based on $4.99, the price 1 mont
Slide 11: A Clear Choice: Highly Certain Value vs. Risky Outcomes
A Clear Choice: Highly Certain Value vs. Risky Outcomes for Target Shareholders in Rejected Transactions Broadcom's offer is an all cash offer, no financing contingencies Rejecting an all cash offer subjects stockholders to significant risk Source: Company Filings and FactSet. Note: Includes unsolic
Slide 12: Emulex's Standalone Risks
Emulex’s Standalone Risks . www.broadcom.com
Slide 13: Why has Emulex been an Underperforming Stock?
Why has Emulex been an Underperforming Stock over the last 7+ Years? (50.4%) (84.3%) Source: FactSet. * Based on 4/20/2009, the day prior to the public announcement of Broadcom's proposal. (18.8%)
Slide 14: A History of Missing Street Revenue Estimates
Reason: A History of Missing Street Revenue Estimates Source: Company Filings and Reuters' Estimates. * Estimates represent consensus figures compiled 1 week after the preceding period's report date. Recent Quarterly Performance
Slide 15: Emulex Has Failed to Grow Market Share Despite Design Wins
CY2007 Q4 - Added several key 8-Gig wins in the quarter with total wins at 13 Q2 & Q3 - Referenced multiple design wins with 8-Gig HBAs Reason: Emulex Has Failed to Grow Market Share Despite "Design Wins" QLogic Emulex Others* Source: Dell'Oro Group and Emulex earnings call transcripts. * Others inc
Slide 16: Unsatisfactory Track Record of Translating Design Wins into Revenue
Reason: Emulex's Unsatisfactory Track Record of Translating "Design Wins" into Revenue Growth "Emulex has recently won tier-one original equipment manufacturer contracts at the expense of Broadcom and our other competitors, and as such, we are well positioned to gain share in this rapidly growing se
Slide 17: Over-Promising and Disappointing on Market Opportunities
$0.0 $0.5 $1.0 $1.5 $2.0 $2.5 $3.0 ($ in Billions) 2006 $1.4 B Reason: Over-Promising and Disappointing on Market Opportunities $2.7 B 2009E CAGR: 24% 8/29/2006 Emulex Press Release Emulex Acquires Sierra Logic Paul Folino expects the TAM to increase to $2.7 billion by 2009
Slide 18: Over-Promising and Disappointing on Market Opportunities
$0.0 $0.5 $1.0 $1.5 $2.0 $2.5 $3.0 ($ in Billions) 2009E Reason: Over-Promising and Disappointing on Market Opportunities 05/15/2009 Reuters McCluney expects the market to double to $1.7 billion by 2013 CAGR: 19% $1.7 B 2013E $2.7 B $850 M
Slide 19: Growth Projections Not Supported by Historical Performance
Emulex's Growth Projections are Not Supported by Historical Performance Source: Public Filings and Emulex management estimates. * Ending March 2009. $403 M FY2006A FY2007A $470 M FY2008A $488 M LTM* $412 M Dramatic opportunity in converged networking ^ FY12 is only the beginning Sustained core busin
Slide 20: Growth Projections Not Supported by Historical Performance
Emulex's Growth Projections are Not Supported by Historical Performance Source: Public Filings and Emulex management estimates. * Ending March 2009. $403 M FY2006A FY2007A $470 M FY2008A $488 M $364 M FY2004A FY2005A $376 M Dramatic opportunity in converged networking ^ FY12 is only the beginning Su
Slide 21: Wall Street is Skeptical of Forecasts
Wall Street is Skeptical of Forecasts and has Expressed Doubts about Standalone Prospects "In ELX's depiction of revenue growth, all of the incremental $200 million from now until F'12 is driven by the combination of FCoE and converged networking. ELX actually expects its core business of fibre chan
Slide 22: Analysts' Estimates Reflect Skeptical View of Growth Story
Despite aggressive assertions regarding product momentum, analyst consensus estimates for FY 2009, 2010 and 2011 remain lower than those published prior to our public bid Emulex's recent FY 2012 revenue target of $600M+ suggests "hockey stick" optimism about its growth rate vs. FY 2011 consensus est
Slide 23: Stock Historically Traded at 20% Discount to Price Targets
Stock Has Historically Traded at 20% Discount to Consensus Price Targets Source: FactSet. * Graph depicts rolling 60 day average for the Premium / (Discount) of Emulex's closing stock prices to the median 12 Month Analyst Price Targets published 1 year prior. *Average price levels have been approxim
Slide 24: Emulex Board Has Acted to Impede Consideration of Offer
Emulex Board has acted in ways to impede consideration of acquisition offer Insular Board Dismissive of Exploring a Transaction "Tenured membership" ~15 year average Represent only small share ownership Rebuffed Broadcom's initial approach Adopted new "Pill" and changed bylaws Enhanced and expanded
Slide 25: Broadcom Best Positioned to Succeed
Broadcom Best Positioned to Succeed
Slide 26: A Compelling Combination
A Compelling Combination Combines leaders in enterprise data networking and storage networking Broadcom: leader in Ethernet switches, controllers, processors and PHY devices Emulex: leader in Fibre Channel host bus adapters and embedded switch bridges Combines highly complementary customer bases Acc
Slide 27: Broadcom's Proven Track Record of Execution
Combination Increases Probability of Success Given Broadcom's Proven Track of Execution Source: WSTS and company data Broadcom Semiconductor Industry - -40% - -20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 260% 110% 140% 412% Revenue Growth
Slide 28: Current Leadership Positions
Current Leadership Positions Mobile & Wireless Broadband Communications Security Switch Storage PHY Enterprise Networking Cable STB Cable modem Satellite STB Digital TV xDSL modem Red denotes a leadership position Cellular GPS Bluetooth VoIP Wireless LAN Controller
Slide 29: Combination Creates Ability to Accelerate Market Transition to FCoE
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009E 2010E 2011E 2012E Fibre Channel 943 946.1 895.5 834.2 691.5 724.1 752.5 731.9 FCoE 1.3 12.7 61.7 134 232 Combination Creates Ability to Accelerate Market Transition to FCoE Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) market anticipated to reach ~20% of market in 2012 Acquisition acc
Slide 30: Skilled at Closing and Integrating Acquisitions
Experienced: Skilled at Closing and Integrating Acquisitions Executed 42 acquisitions or asset purchases Averaged ~1 per quarter since 1999 Acquired companies in 12 different countries Over 2,500 employees have joined Broadcom from acquisitions Approximately 81% employee retention rate on 18 acquisi
Slide 31: Conclusion
Conclusion bg www.broadcom.com
Slide 32: Supporting the Consent Solicitation Maintains Options Without Obligation
Supporting the Consent Solicitation is about stockholders maintaining their options without obligation The Consent Solicitation - Reality vs. Emulex Misinformation What It Doesn't Do... Does not obligate stockholders to tender shares nor agree to a sale Does not obligate stockholders to vote for new
Slide 33: Consent Solicitation Proposals
The consent solicitation seeks to: Amend Emulex's Bylaws to authorize stockholders who collectively own 10%+ of the outstanding shares to call a special meeting; Authorize Broadcom representatives to call a special meeting for Emulex stockholders to consider removing and replacing Emulex's board; Am
Slide 34: Summary: Why Emulex Stockholders Should Act
Summary: Why Emulex Stockholders Should Act Broadcom's high premium, all cash offer is highly attractive Provides high premium to unaffected market value Delivers highly certain value to Emulex stockholders Emulex's standalone prospects for value accretion are highly uncertain Track record of underp