Baylake — Merger or Acquisition (September 2015)
18 slides from Baylake's merger presentation, Sep 9, 2015
Slide 1: Investor Presentation: Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank
Investor PresentationSeptember 9, 2015 Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank
Slide 2: Forward-Looking Statement Disclosure
Forward-Looking Statement Disclosure Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank This report contains forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995, which Congress passed in an effort to encourage companies to provide information about their
Slide 3: Important Information for Investors
Important Information for Investors Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank This communication relates to the proposed merger transaction involving Nicolet and Baylake. In connection with the proposed merger, Nicolet and Baylake will file a joint proxy statement/prospectus on Form S-4 and othe
Slide 4: Transaction Highlights
Transaction Highlights Creates the leading community bank in the Green Bay MSA and Door County3rd largest Wisconsin-based community bank by deposit market share Combined franchise is positioned for long term growth with the size and scale to compete more effectively in the current marketStrengthens
Slide 5: Enhancing Scale in Northern Wisconsin
Enhancing Scale in Northern Wisconsin * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Nicolet Bankshares (21) Baylake Corp. (24)¹ Source: SNL Financial; ¹ includes Baylake’s pending acquisition of Union State Bank
Slide 6: Transaction Overview
Transaction Overview * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank ¹Ownership assumes impact of stock options, restricted stock and pending acquisition of Union State Bank by Baylake²Based on Nicolet closing price of $[ ] on 9/8/15. Does not include $0.40 per share dividend paid to Baylake shareho
Slide 7: Nicolet and Baylake at a Glance
Nicolet and Baylake at a Glance * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Source: SNL Financial; market data as of 9/8/2015; financial data in $millions and as of 6/30/2015 Note: Baylake financial information as of 6/30/15; does not include any impact of pending acquisition of New Bancshares,
Slide 8: Nicolet Bankshares Financial Highlights
Nicolet Bankshares * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Financial Highlights($millions) Commercially focused bank since inception. Commercial & Industrial and owner occupied CRE loans comprise more than 50% of the loan portfolioEstablished track record of organic asset generationDiversifi
Slide 9: Baylake Corp. Financial Highlights
Baylake Corp. * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Financial Highlights($millions) For more than 139 years, Baylake has been providing financial solutions to individuals and businesses in Northeast WisconsinLongstanding ties as the community bank of choice in Door County and Kewaunee Coun
Slide 10: Building Market Share
Building Market Share * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Strong pro forma market share in Wisconsin - $1.8 billion in deposits and over 40 branchesCreates the 3rd largest community bank in Wisconsin Source: SNL Financial; deposit market share data as of 6/30/2014 and includes Baylake’s
Slide 11: Combined Board and Management Team
Combined Board and Management Team * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Combined Board Robert B. Atwell is the founding CEO of Nicolet National Bank, bringing 22 years of experience as a community banker in Northeastern Wisconsin and Upper Michigan. He is a graduate of Beloit College (198
Slide 12: Combining Complementary Businesses
Combining Complementary Businesses * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Stable, Low Cost Deposit Base62% market share in Door County41% market share in Kewaunee County18 bps cost of deposits Mortgage OriginationOver $330 million in production since 2014 Traditional Community Banking Diver
Slide 13: Strong Core Funding
Strong Core Funding * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Total Deposits: $1,000.0Cost: 0.51% Total Deposits: $758.6Cost: 0.18% Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. Baylake Corp. Pro Forma Company Total Deposits: $1,758.6Cost: 0.37% Source: SNL Financial; financial data in millions and for the six mon
Slide 14: Diversified Loan Portfolio
Diversified Loan Portfolio * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Total Loans: $887.1Yield: 5.14% Total Loans: $687.3Yield: 4.35% Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. Baylake Corp. Pro Forma Company Total Loans: $1,574.5Yield: 4.80% Source: SNL Financial; financial data in millions and for the six mont
Slide 15: Comprehensive Due Diligence and Credit Review
Comprehensive Due Diligence and Credit Review * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Due Diligence Highlights Credit Review Comprehensive reciprocal due diligence process including core systems, legal and creditBoth organizations use the same core processing software through United Financia
Slide 16: Compelling Pro Forma Valuation
Compelling Pro Forma Valuation * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Price / Tangible Book Value Price / LTM EPS Nationwide peers include banks with assets between $2.0bn-$3.0bn, ROAA > .75% and NPAs/Total Assets < 1.50%Midwest peers include Midwest banks and thrifts with assets between $2
Slide 17: Unlocking Shareholder Value
Unlocking Shareholder Value * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank
Slide 18: Summary
Summary * Creating the Premier Wisconsin Community Bank Creates Wisconsin’s premier community bankCombined franchise is positioned for long term growth with the size and scale to compete more effectively in the current marketAttractive financial returns for all shareholdersMeaningfully accretive to