Gas Natural — Proxy Contest (July 2016)
23 slides from Gas Natural's proxy contest presentation, Jul 5, 2016
Slide 1: The Committee to Re-Energize Gas Natural
The Committee to Re-Energize Gas Natural July 5, 2016 The Committee to Re-Energize Gas Natural made the following presentation to Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc., on July 5, 2016.
Slide 2: Gas Natural Overview
Gas Natural Overview Operates local natural gas distribution companies in Maine, Montana, North Carolina, and Ohio Reports results in three business segments Natural Gas Marketing and Production Corporate and other (acquisitions, equity transactions, discontinued operations)
Slide 3: About the Committee
About the Committee Led by Richard M. Osborne, Sr., former Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Gas Natural Composed of six director candidates nominated to replace current Board Richard M. Osborne, Sr. Darryl L. Knight Terence S. Profughi Joseph Michael Gorman (Mike) Martin W. Hathy Lauren Trist
Slide 4: Underperforming & Overcompensated
Underperforming & Overcompensated Gas Natural’s financial metrics have plummeted since Mr. Osborne was ousted in 2014 while management enriches itself at the expense of shareholders. Operating income has plummeted 80%. Stock prices have dropped almost 43% and dividends have been cut by 45%; by contr
Slide 5: Our Action Plan
Our Action Plan Our nominees would use the detailed financial and operational information available to them as directors to pursue the following objectives: Reinstate the Company’s dividend to $0.54 annually as soon as possible, though we may first need to improve the Company’s financial performance
Slide 6: Dismal Operating Income
Dismal Operating Income Since FY 2013, operating income has declined 80%. Operating income for peer companies has increased as much as 25%.
Slide 7: Falling Stock Prices
Falling Stock Prices Under Mr. Osborne’s stewardship, stock prices increased from a low of about $2.40 to an all-time high of about $12.00 (adjusted for dividends and stock splits). Together with dividends reinstated under his watch, shareholders experienced a total return of almost 475%.
Slide 8: Falling Stock Prices
Falling Stock Prices Stock prices have declined almost 43% since Mr. Osborne’s ouster in 2014. Over the same period, the stock prices for Gas Natural’s peers have increased as much as 60%.
Slide 9: Soaring Executive Compensation
Shareholder support for the say-on-pay proposal declined from 89.2% of shares voted in 2013 to 66.9% in 2014. Undeterred, the Board increased executive compensation dramatically from 2014 to 2015. Gregory Osborne’s base salary increased almost 53% from $250,000 to $382,000. James Sprague’s base sala
Slide 10: Soaring Director Fees
Soaring Director Fees Prior to May 2013, director fees were $3,500 per meeting. In July 2013, in Mr. Osborne’s absence, the Board voted to increase director fees to $4,200 per meeting. After Mr. Osborne’s ouster in 2014, the Board increased director fees (again) to $5,000 per month and granted thems
Slide 11: Reduced Dividends
Reduced Dividends On April 21, 2016, after Increasing executive compensation substantially from 2014 to 2015; and Increasing director fees three times between 2013 and 2015 the Company cut its dividend from $0.54 per share annually to $0.30, a 45% decline.
Slide 12: Poor Corporate Governance: Threshold for Calling Special Shareholder Meeting
Poor Corporate Governance: Threshold for Calling Special Shareholder Meeting In August 2014, the Board amended its Code of Regulations to increase the stock ownership percentage required to call a special meeting of shareholders from 10% to 25%. This change was made in response to a less than 5% sha
Slide 13: Poor Corporate Governance: Employment Agreements
Poor Corporate Governance: Employment Agreements Richard Osborne did not have an employment agreement during his tenure as CEO of Gas Natural. After Mr. Osborne’s ouster in 2014, the Company entered into an employment agreement with Gregory Osborne. Increased base salary 10% (subsequently increased
Slide 14: Poor Corporate Governance: Indemnification Agreements
Poor Corporate Governance: Indemnification Agreements In July 2015, the Company entered into indemnification agreements with each of its directors. These agreements insulate the directors from liability for their actions.
Slide 15: The Company's Mischaracterizations: Related Party Transactions
The Company’s Mischaracterizations: Related Party Transactions The Company repeatedly attacks Mr. Osborne regarding the commercial relationships between the Company and Mr. Osborne’s entities. All were approved by a disinterested committee, and in some cases by shareholders. The Board’s own minutes
Slide 16: The Company's Mischaracterizations: PUCO Order–Related Party Transactions
The Company’s Mischaracterizations: PUCO Order–Related Party Transactions The Board states that commercial arrangements between the Company and Mr. Osborne’s entities have “raised the concern of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio.” The Company filed a complaint with the PUCO challenging a trans
Slide 17: The Company's Mischaracterizations: PUCO Order – Investigative Audit
The Company’s Mischaracterizations: PUCO Order – Investigative Audit The Board repeatedly stresses that the investigative audit only identifies issues that took place when Mr. Osborne was Chairman and CEO. The audit was conducted after Mr. Osborne departed in 2014. The PUCO order never states that M
Slide 18: Biographies of Director Nominees: Richard M. Osborne, Sr.
Biographies of Director Nominees Richard M. Osborne, Sr. Many years of experience owning and managing companies in energy and utility related industries. Past Positions Joined Gas Natural’s board as a director in 2003 and served as chairman of the board of the Company from 2005 to May 2014 and chief
Slide 19: Biographies of Director Nominees: Darryl L. Knight
Biographies of Director Nominees Darryl L. Knight Years of industry experience and background managing companies in the energy and utility related industries. Present Position Since September 2014, President of Ohio Rural Natural Gas Co-Op, a natural gas distribution cooperative located in Mentor, O
Slide 20: Biographies of Director Nominees: Terence S. Profughi
Biographies of Director Nominees Terence S. Profughi Years of experience owning, acquiring and managing companies in energy and utility related industries. Present Position Since 1979, Chairman of Chagrin Venture Ltd. Inc., a holding company for investments in real estate and manufacturing companies
Slide 21: Biographies of Director Nominees: Joseph Michael Gorman
Biographies of Director Nominees Joseph Michael Gorman (Mike) Background of business development for companies in highly regulated industries. Present Position Since 2006, President of Gorbec Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a contract developer and manufacturer of prescription pharmaceutical products. Past P
Slide 22: Biographies of Director Nominees: Martin W. Hathy
Biographies of Director Nominees Martin W. Hathy Years of experience owning and managing industrial companies. Present Position Currently retired. Past Positions Co-owner and President of Lake Erie Iron and Metal Company and its subsidiaries Welder’s Supply, Great Lakes Propane and Great Lakes Oxyge
Slide 23: Biographies of Director Nominees: Lauren Tristano
Biographies of Director Nominees Lauren Tristano Diverse background and public service experience. Present Position Since February, 2016, Executive Liaison for Mr. Osborne and the various companies he owns and manages. Member of Junior League of Chicago, Chicago Cares. Board member of Holy Name Cath