ALTERRA CAPITAL HOLDINGS Ltd

ALTERRA CAPITAL — Max Capital Group — Investor Presentation (August 2009)

43 slides from ALTERRA CAPITAL's investor presentation, Aug 5, 2009

  1. Slide 1: A World Class Specialty Insurer and Reinsurer Investor Presentation

    Exhibit 99.1 A World Class Specialty Insurer and Reinsurer Investor Presentation Second Quarter 2009 BERMUDA IRELAND UNITED STATES LLOYD’S

  2. Slide 2: Information Concerning Forward Looking Statements

    INFORMATION CONCERNING FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS CAUTIONARY NOTE REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING INFORMATION This presentation includes statements about future economic performance, finances, expectations, plans and prospects of the Company that constitute forward-looking statements for purposes of the s

  3. Slide 3: Max Capital Today

    Max Capital Today Global underwriter of specialty insurance and reinsurance Short-Tail 38% Multiple operating platforms - Bermuda, Dublin, United States, and Lloyd’s Diversified business profile across specialty classes of business Highly experienced management with proven track record 62% Long-Tail

  4. Slide 4: Strong First Half 2009 Results

    Strong First Half 2009 Results Total GPW of $830.8 million, up 22.9% compared to H1’08 Reflects the build-out of the global platform Max Specialty GPW: $150 million Max at Lloyd’s GPW: $90 million Profitable underwriting results - Overall combined ratio 90.8% in the Q2 and 90.3% in the H1 2009 Marke

  5. Slide 5: Recent Developments Further Build Out The Platform

    Recent Developments Further Build Out The Platform Underwriting International casualty reinsurance team at Max at Lloyd’s Professional liability team at Max Specialty Geographic The addition of California gives Max a 50 state franchise for admitted Marine products on both Inland and Ocean With Puert

  6. Slide 6: Global Reach Through Established Platforms

    Global Reach Through Established Platforms Bermuda / Dublin Bermuda / Dublin Lloyd’s U.S Specialty Insurance Reinsurance Insurance Agriculture Aviation Personal accident General liability Aviation Excess liability Financial institutions Marine Excess liability Professional liability Professional lia

  7. Slide 7: Diversified Platforms Generate More Consistent Margins

    Diversified Platforms Generate More Consistent Margins Max has performed well within its diversified peer group with less volatility than property focused reinsurers Diversified Reinsurers Property Focused Reinsurers 300% 300% 252% 150% 150% 124% 140% 125% 125% 112% 101% 103% 96% 96% 97% 100% 100% 9

  8. Slide 8: Diversified Premium Mix: A Key Differentiator

    Diversified Premium Mix: A Key Differentiator Reinsurance TRH PTP PRE MRH IPCR FSR RE RNR ORH AHL VR Casualty Property ACGL AXS MXGL ENH AWH Incumbent (Re) Insurers Insurance Class of 2001 ____________________ Class of 2005 Source: Merrill Lynch Note: Based on full year 2008 property and casualty gr

  9. Slide 9: Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes

    Max Has a Strong Market Position in Specialty Classes … Bermuda / Dublin Insurance Bermuda / Dublin Reinsurance 2008 GPW - $389 million 2008 GPW - $420 million General Marine &Liability Property Whole Energy Other Account 14% 3% Excess Aviation 3% Property Liability 8% 25% 32% Aviation Prof. 14% Lia

  10. Slide 10: With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd's

    … With an Attractive Position in the U.S. Market and Lloyd’s U.S. Insurance Max at Lloyd’s 2008 GPW - $194 million 2008 GPW - £65 million (1) Accident & Health Marine 17% 20% Property 45% Treaty Fin. 18% Property 49% Institutions 31% General 19% 1% Casualty Prof. Employers' Indemnity / Public Liabil

  11. Slide 11: Max Investment Portfolio Highlights

    Max Investment Portfolio Highlights Distressed Cash Securities 19.7% 16.5% Opportunistic Arbitrage 0.6% strategies Emerging / Global 28.5% Markets Hedge funds 20.9% 8.5% Fixed income 71.8% Long / Short funds 33.5% Hedge fund allocation is decreasing As % of Total Investments Market neutral / absolut

  12. Slide 12: Bermuda/Dublin P&C Insurance: A Consistently Profitable Performer

    Bermuda/Dublin P&C Insurance: A Consistently Profitable Performer Max Capital 2008 GPW Bermuda / Dublin Insurance 2008 GPW Bermuda/Dublin Reinsurance 34% Property 14% Excess Liability 32% Bermuda/Dublin 14% Aviation Insurance 31% Life & Annuity Reinsurance 19% 41% Max at Lloyd's (1) Professional 1%

  13. Slide 13: Bermuda/Dublin P&C Insurance: Historical Results

    Bermuda/Dublin P&C Insurance: Historical Results 2008 GPW GPW ($MM) Casualty Combined Ratio 73% $600 110.0% 107.3% 27% (78.4% excluding KRW) Property / Short- $500 Tail 100.0% 92.8% $396.6 $389.4 $400 $382.9 $355.3 90.0% $300 80.5% 88.2% 86.2% 80.0% $248.1 $200 $163.2 70.0% $100 70.6% $0 60.0% 2003

  14. Slide 14: Bermuda/Dublin P&C Insurance: Solid Casualty Results

    Bermuda/Dublin P&C Insurance: Solid Casualty Results GWP ($MM) Policy Year Loss Ratio Max has demonstrated profitable $700 110.0% underwriting and risk selection Max entered in 2002 / 2003 $600 100.0% Strong underwriting teams Quantitative models 90.0% “Tougher”, better priced classes $500 82.7% Pre

  15. Slide 15: Bermuda/Dublin: Casualty Insurance

    Bermuda/Dublin: Casualty Insurance Highlights 2008 GPW Expected 2009 GPW of $125mm Aviation Average premium of approximately $1mm per policy Excess Liability 32% Major classes – healthcare, pharma, railroad, industrial Excess Liability Market conditions – Q1 09 rates stable Professional Liability Ex

  16. Slide 16: Bermuda/Dublin: Specialty Insurance

    Bermuda/Dublin: Specialty Insurance Highlights 2008 GPW Expected 2009 GPW of $60mm Average premium of approximately $250,000 per policy Property 14% Property Major classes – commercial, industrial, & energy Insurance Market conditions Up 10% to 15% on accounts with no losses Significantly higher on

  17. Slide 17: Bermuda/Dublin: P&C Reinsurance Premium Contribution

    Bermuda/Dublin: P&C Reinsurance Premium Contribution Max Capital 2008 GPW Bermuda / Dublin Reinsurance 2008 GPW Life & Annuity Reinsurance 19% Max at Lloyd's (1) Workers Prof. Liabliity 1% Comp Aviation 9% 13% 8% Other U.S. Specialty Marine & 15% 4% Energy 3% 2% Excess Liability Bermuda/Dublin Med.

  18. Slide 18: Bermuda/Dublin P&C Reinsurance: Historical Results

    Bermuda/Dublin P&C Reinsurance: Historical Results GPW ($MM) Combined Ratio $800 Casualty 110.0% 105.7% 43% 57% Property / $700 Short-Tail $583.2 $615.7 100.0% 96.7% 93.9% $600 $500 $246.1 87.4% 90.0% $248.6 83.9% $400 $423.6 $419.5 80.0% $300 $345.2 $200 $334.6 $369.6 70.0% $100 $0 60.0% 2004 2005

  19. Slide 19: Bermuda/Dublin: Specialty Reinsurance

    Bermuda/Dublin: Specialty Reinsurance Highlights 2008 GPW Agriculture Expected 2009 GPW of $100mm Average premium of approximately $700,000 per treaty Property 25% Property US nationwide, super regional, Japan, Europe Reinsurance Market conditions Excess Nationwide up 15%, regional & super regional

  20. Slide 20: Bermuda/Dublin: Specialty Reinsurance (cont'd)

    Bermuda/Dublin: Specialty Reinsurance (cont’d) Highlights 2008 GPW Expected 2009 GPW of $20mm Excess Agricult Average premium of approximately $1.0mm per treaty Liability Marine & Onshore and offshore energy Marine & Energy Energy 3% Energy Market conditions Other Gulf market is seeking 60% to 75% r

  21. Slide 21: Bermuda/Dublin: Casualty Reinsurance

    Bermuda/Dublin: Casualty Reinsurance Highlights 2008 GPW Expected 2009 GPW of $25mm Agriculture Property Average premium of approximately $2mm per treaty General liability, auto liability, public entity business 2% 2% Excess Liability Excess Market conditions Liability Me Primary rates flat to incre

  22. Slide 22: Bermuda/Dublin: Casualty Reinsurance (cont'd)

    Bermuda/Dublin: Casualty Reinsurance (cont’d) Highlights 2008 GPW Workers Prof. Liabliity Expected 2009 GPW of $60mm Comp Aviation Average premium of approximately $2.0mm per treaty Other Marine Energ Exces Medical Physicians & surgeons, hospitals, surgery centers Liabilit Malpractice Med. Mal. 18%

  23. Slide 23: Max at Lloyd's: Max's Newest Platform

    Max at Lloyd’s: Max’s Newest Platform Manage £125.0 million of 100% owned capacity in Syndicate 1400. Also manage two partially owned third party syndicates Offices in London, Copenhagen, and Tokyo - total staff of 85 Syndicates under management Syndicate 1400 - 2008 stamp capacity of £125.0mm – 100

  24. Slide 24: Max at Lloyd's: 2009E Gross Premiums Written

    Max at Lloyd’s: 2009E Gross Premiums Written Reinsurance: $99 million Accident & Health 25% Property Max At Lloyd’s 2009E GPW Treaty 75% Other Professional 2% Indemnity 15% Property Treaty Insurance: $51 million Financial Institutions 50% 17% PL/EL 5% Financial Institutions 50% Accident & Health Pro

  25. Slide 25: Max at Lloyd's: Geographic Reach

    Max at Lloyd’s: Geographic Reach Property Accident & Health Other Other Australasia 2% 6% 12% Japan 5% Japan USA USA 24% 39% 39% Europe 30% Total Europe 9% Other UK/Eire Canada Canada 15% Caribbean 5% UK/Eire 5% USA 7% 8% 9% 29% Japan 13% Financial Institutions Professional Indemnity Other USA 6% Ca

  26. Slide 26: Enhancing Max at Lloyds in 2009

    Enhancing Max at Lloyds in 2009 Maintain and strengthen our existing Lloyd’s underwriting resources Continuing emphasis on robust pricing process and superior risk selection Market conditions improving – but slowly Strategy of diversification to add further experienced underwriting teams, to further

  27. Slide 27: Max Specialty: An Important and Growing Business for Max

    Max Specialty: An Important and Growing Business for Max Product diversification allows resources to be reallocated as market cycles change Max Capital 2008 GPW Max Specialty 2008 GPW Bermuda/Dublin Insurance 31% Marine 20% U.S. Specialty 15% 49% Property 1% (1) 34% Max at Lloyd's Bermuda/Dublin Gen

  28. Slide 28: Max Specialty – Leading E&S Writer

    Max Specialty – Leading E&S Writer Nationwide excess and surplus lines writer of property, casualty and marine Three distinct divisions: Brokerage, Marine and Contract Binding Six strategically placed offices in the US Strong financial strength and technical expertise Significant product diversifica

  29. Slide 29: Max Specialty Segment Review

    Max Specialty Segment Review Highlights 2008 GPW Contract Bindi Expected 2009 GPW of $90mm Average premium of approximately $45,000 per policy Brokerage Apartments, offices, mixed use, hotels, shopping centers Division Market conditions 41% Brokerage Marin Loss effected layers up 25% to 30%, others

  30. Slide 30: Max Specialty Segment Review (cont'd)

    Max Specialty Segment Review (cont’d) Highlights 2008 GPW Expected 2009 GPW of $53mm Average premium of approximately $30,000 per policy Contractors equipment, builders risk, motor truck cargo 20% Marine Marine Market conditions Primary rates flat with meaningful increases on loss affected accounts

  31. Slide 31: Overview of Life Reinsurance

    Overview of Life Reinsurance Spread management business, comparable to basic full Loss Portfolio Transfer Purchase blocks of existing policy or claim reserves (reserve buy outs) All originated transactions – winner takes all Max at Lloyd's (1) 1% Life & Annuity U.S. Specialty Known data files – no u

  32. Slide 32: Overview of Life Reinsurance

    Overview of Life Reinsurance Business targets 3 or 4 deals per year - $150+ million new business Remain expense efficient Gross Premiums Written ($MM) Price and realize ROE of 15%+ $350.0 Sales: 2000 to 2008 in excess of $1.75 billion $302.0 $300.0 27 transactions; 15 counterparties; 3 deals per yea

  33. Slide 33: Max is Strongly Positioned in 2009

    Max is Strongly Positioned in 2009 Max Bermuda and Dublin (Insurance/Reinsurance) Rates rising in short-tail property cat and energy Long-tail lines have stabilized and stopped declining Max at Lloyd’s Provides access to global specialty business, high credit ratings, worldwide licenses Experienced

  34. Slide 34: 2009 Guidance

    2009 Guidance* Property and Casualty GPW growth target of 20% to 22% driven by: Max at Lloyd’s Max Specialty Bermuda/Dublin Insurance and Casualty Reinsurance relatively flat Expected combined ratio of 88% to 90% Assumes a cat load of 4-6 points Improved profitability at Max Specialty as earned prem

  35. Slide 35: Stock Valuation Is Lagging Underwriting Performance

    Stock Valuation Is Lagging Underwriting Performance 1.60x Average Price / Book Value 3-Year 2-Year 1-Year Current Max 0.96x 0.88x 0.76x 0.88x 1.40x Diversified 1.11 1.01 0.89 0.96 1.20x Max Average 1.00x 0.80x 0.60x 0.40x 0.20x 7/28/06 11/26/06 3/28/07 7/28/07 11/27/07 3/27/08 7/27/08 11/26/08 3/28/

  36. Slide 36: Investment Opportunity in Max Today

    Investment Opportunity in Max Today Strongly positioned to capitalize on market dislocations Diversified portfolio with four robust underwriting platforms Significant reduction in hedge fund exposure Bringing hedge funds down to 5-7% of total investments Meaningful investment opportunity to redeploy

  37. Slide 37: Strong Balance Sheet

    Strong Balance Sheet June 30, December 31, ($ in millions) 2009 2008 Cash & Fixed Maturities $4,687 $4,603 Other Investments 437 754 Premium Receivables 670 555 Losses Recoverable 930 847 Other Assets 568 493 Total Assets $7,292 $7,252 Property & Casualty Losses $3,058 $2,938 Life & Annuity Benefits

  38. Slide 38: Quarterly Results Comparison

    Quarterly Results Comparison Three months ended June 30, ($ in millions) 2009 2008 Gross Premiums Written $397 $369 Net Premiums Earned 229 235 Net Investment Income 42 43 Net Gains on Other Investments 21 39 Net Realized Losses on Fixed Maturities (2) (2) Other Income 1 - Total Revenues 291 315 Tot

  39. Slide 39: Diversified Operating Platform

    Diversified Operating Platform Life & Three months ended June 30, 2009 Property & Casualty Annuity Corporate Consolidated ($ in millions) Bermuda / Dublin Max at Insurance Reinsurance U.S. Specialty Lloyd's Total Reinsurance Gross premiums written $133.9 $95.2 $81.0 $45.4 $355.5 $41.0 $0.0 $396.5 Re

  40. Slide 40: Profitable Underwriting Trends

    Profitable Underwriting Trends Gross Premiums Written $1,500 $1,250 $1,000 $1,246 $1,078 $1,254 $750 $1,044 $500 $865 $250 Life, $302 Life, $212 Life, $275 Life, $45 Life, $242 $0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 125% P&C Combined Ratio 100% 106% 94% 92% 86% 88% 75% 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Operating Earnin

  41. Slide 41: A Growing, Global Insurance / Reinsurance Company

    A Growing, Global Insurance / Reinsurance Company ($ in millions) Invested Assets (Ratio to Shareholders’ Equity) $6,000 $5,000 $5,123 $5,357 $4,000 $4,536 $4,223 $3,000 $3,515 $2,000 $1,000 (3.9:1) (3.6:1) (3.3:1) (3.2:1) (3.9:1) $0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 Operating Cash Flow $900 $600 $799 $300 $

  42. Slide 42: High Quality Cash and Fixed Income Portfolio

    High Quality Cash and Fixed Income Portfolio Average quality of AA 70%+ of fixed income securities rated Aa or better Less than 7% rated Baa or below Approximately 42% of portfolio is Cash, Governments, Agencies, and Agency MBS Cash balance is approximately $1,008 million or 22% of the portfolio U.S

  43. Slide 43: Supplemental Investment Data

    Supplemental Investment Data Fair Investment Credit Fair Ratings ($ thousands) Value Distribution Rating Value Distribution Cash and Cash Equivalents $1,008,178 19.7% (1) U.S. Government and Agencies $964,246 26.2% U.S. Government and Agencies 392,847 7.7% AAA 1,335,687 36.3% Non-U.S. Government 650

Max Capital Group — Investor Presentation (August 2009) on 6ix