Fiesta Restaurant — Proxy Contest (May 2017)
38 slides from Fiesta Restaurant's proxy contest presentation, May 23, 2017
Slide 1: Investor Presentation May / June 2017
1 www.frgi.com Investor Presentation May / June 2017
Slide 2: Legal Disclaimers
2 www.frgi.com Legal Disclaimers Forward - Looking Statements Except for the historical information contained in this presentation, the matters addressed are forward - looking statements . Forward - looking statements, written, oral or otherwise made, represent the expectation or belief of Fiesta Re
Slide 3: Executive Overview
3 www.frgi.com Executive Overview ▪ Fiesta is a leading restaurant company comprised of two prominent brands with strong long - term performance ▪ Fiesta’s Board has proactively taken bold steps to address recent underperformance ˗ Suspended expansion of Pollo Tropical into Texas ˗ Conducted reviews
Slide 4: Fiesta Operates Two Differentiated Brands with Proven Value Propositions
4 www.frgi.com Fiesta Operates Two Differentiated Brands with Proven Value Propositions ▪ A 38 year old brand originating in San Antonio ▪ 174 restaurants, primarily in Texas, grown from 161 stores in Q1 2011 ▪ Broad, authentic Mexican product offerings − Margaritas and beer, fresh tortillas made da
Slide 5: Pollo Tropical and Taco Cabana Have Strong Underlying Economics
5 www.frgi.com $ 2. 4 $ 2. 7 $ 1.9 $ 1 . 1 $ 1 . 5 $ 1 . 9 $ 1 .0 $ 1 . 2 12.8% 16.7% 19.7% 18.1% 18.8% 12.8% 20.0% 22.6% $ 1.9 $ 1.9 $ 4.9 21.0% 20.5% 28.3% Average Annual Sales per Store at Company - Owned Restaurants Pollo Tropical and Taco Cabana Have Strong Underlying Economics 1 Restaurant - L
Slide 6: Fiesta Demonstrated Strong Performance From Spin-Off to 2015
6 www.frgi.com Fiesta Demonstrated Strong Performance From Spin - Off to 2015 Spin - Off 2 – Q3 2015 Cumulative TSR Fiesta TSR = 263.0% Proxy Peers TSR 3 = 45.8% Russell 2000 TSR = 41.0% 1 Knapp Track Casual Dining annual numbers represent simple average of quarterly numbers 2 Spin - off occurred Ap
Slide 7: Pollo Tropical Expansion Plan Was Supported by Thorough Analysis
7 www.frgi.com Pollo Tropical Expansion Plan Was Supported by Thorough Analysis 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 190 200 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50% Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4 2011 Q1 2012 Q2 2012 Q3 2012 Q4 2012 Q1 2013 Q2 2013 Q3 2013 Q4 2013 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4 2014 Q1 201
Slide 8: Industry and Business Have Faced Recent Challenges
8 www.frgi.com Industry and Business Have Faced Recent Challenges Significant Industry - Wide Headwinds Knapp Track Fast Casual 1 & Casual Dining Same Store Sales 2014 – 2016 Annualized Same Store Sales 2014 2015 2016 (4.0%) (3.0%) (2.0%) (1.0%) 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 3.0% Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q
Slide 9: Long-Term Performance Comparable to Peers and Market Despite Recent Challenges
9 www.frgi.com Long - Term Performance Comparable to Peers and Market Despite Recent Challenges Cumulative TSR: Spin - Off – Present 1 Proxy peers (does not include Popeye's or Krispy Kreme, as these companies are private): Buffalo Wild Wings, Red Robin Gourmet Burgers, Panera Bread Company, Cracker
Slide 10: Business Challenges Impacted the Pollo Tropical Expansion
10 www.frgi.com Business Challenges Impacted the Pollo Tropical Expansion Pollo Tropical Store Count vs. Same Store Sales 125 135 145 155 165 175 185 195 205 215 225 -5.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 40.0% Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4 2014 Q1 2015 Q2 2015 Q3 2015 Q4 2015 Q1 2016 Q2 2
Slide 11: Board Took Proactive Steps to Address Business Challenges
11 www.frgi.com 25 - Aug - 2016 ▪ Announced Timothy Taft would retire at y ear end 2 Board Took Proactive Steps to Address Business Challenges September – October ▪ Appointed Danny Meisenheimer interim CEO ▪ Accelerated Retirement of Timothy Taft to September 30, 2016 ▪ Halted spin - off of Taco Cab
Slide 12: Board Hired Veteran Restaurant Executive to Lead Fiesta Forward
12 www.frgi.com Board Hired Veteran Restaurant Executive to Lead Fiesta Forward ▪ CEO and President of Fiesta Restaurant Group since February 2017 ▪ Brings nearly 30 years of highly relevant senior leadership experience in the restaurant industry, including successfully designing and implementing a
Slide 13: Stockinger Has a Proven Ability to Develop and Execute Restaurant Renewal Plans
13 www.frgi.com ▪ On February 9, 2009, Richard Stockinger was appointed as Chief Executive Officer of Benihana ▪ On August 20, 2009 , Stockinger announced the Benihana Teppanyaki Renewal Program ▪ Selected action steps: ˗ Reintroducing higher quality ingredients without raising prices ˗ Focusing eff
Slide 14: Detailed Renewal Plan Expected to Revitalize the Fiesta Brands
14 www.frgi.com Detailed Renewal Plan Expected to Revitalize the Fiesta Brands Improve Capital and Financial Discipline Establish Platforms for Long - Term Growth Revitalize the Fiesta Brands in Core Markets Optimize Restaurant Footprint 1 2 3 4
Slide 15: Revitalize the Fiesta Brands in Core Markets
15 www.frgi.com Revitalize the Fiesta Brands in Core Markets 1 ▪ Refocus on core markets and suspend expansion in emerging markets ▪ Improve quality and freshness of ingredients across entire menu at both brands, incorporating more natural ingredients into menus ▪ Staff and manage restaurants to del
Slide 16: Improve Capital and Financial Discipline
16 www.frgi.com Improve Capital and Financial Discipline 2 ▪ Review non - operating expenses and high cost areas such as benefits and insurance programs ▪ Update key performance indicators based on our new strategy and cost structures for both Taco Cabana and Pollo Tropical to drive organization - w
Slide 17: Establish Platforms for Long-Term Growth
17 www.frgi.com Establish Platforms for Long - Term Growth 3 ▪ Enhance catering and delivery capabilities , utilizing digital platforms including online ordering ▪ Reformulate strategy to position each brand for successful future expansion outside of its core markets by leveraging a robust analytica
Slide 18: Optimize Restaurant Footprint
18 www.frgi.com Optimize Restaurant Footprint 4 ▪ Monitor key regions on a periodic basis for tactical store location optimization ▪ Evaluate opportunities for store growth as the Renewal Plan gains traction ▪ Evaluate potential opportunities to franchise brands after revitalization of core markets
Slide 19: Our Highly Qualified, Independent and Engaged Board Has the Right Skills
19 www.frgi.com Our Highly Qualified, Independent and Engaged Board Has the Right Skills to Guide Fiesta Through This Revitalization Richard C. Stockinger CEO, Fiesta Restaurant Group Committees : None Paul Twohig Former President, Dunkin Donuts (USA & Canada) Committees : Compensation, Corporate Go
Slide 20: Our Directors Have Highly Valuable and Relevant Skills and Experiences
20 www.frgi.com 3 3 6 6 6 7 7 8 8 Legal, Tax, and Regulatory Risk Management Mergers and Acquisitions Leadership Experience as CEO/COO/President Finance/Financial Industry General Management/Business Operations Corporate Governance Strategy Development Restaurant / Consumer Experience Director Skill
Slide 21: 2017 Director Nominees Bring Complementary Experience to Our Board
21 www.frgi.com 2017 Director Nominees Bring Complementary Experience to Our Board Barry J. Alperin Stephen P. Elker Brian P. Friedman Director Since: 2012 Committees: Finance ( Chair), Audit , Corporate Governance & Nominating ▪ Former Vice Chairman and Co - COO of Hasbro, Inc. (10+ years) ▪ Former
Slide 22: Committed to Strong Governance and Compensation Practices
22 www.frgi.com Committed to Strong Governance and Compensation Practices x 99.7% support for director elections at 2016 annual meeting x Dedicated directors: since spin - off in 2012, all directors have attended 100% of Board meetings x 8 of 9 directors are independent x Strong independent chair pr
Slide 23: The Dissident Group's Claims are Unfounded or Have Been Addressed
23 www.frgi.com Company lacks a strategic plan Board needs additional restaurant experience Board has not been proactive The Dissident Group’s Claims are Unfounded or Have Been Addressed Actions Taken/Facts Board took proactive and decisive action x Began discussions with our former CEO, Timothy Taf
Slide 24: The Dissident Group's Claims are Unfounded or Have Been Addressed (Cont'd)
24 www.frgi.com Improper Jefferies influence Lack of permanent CEO No plan to reduce G&A and achieve operating leverage The Dissident Group’s Claims are Unfounded or Have Been Addressed (Cont’d) Actions Taken/Facts Executing on cost reduction initiatives x Closed 10 Pollo Tropical restaurants in the
Slide 25: The Board Attempted to Reach an Amicable Resolution
25 www.frgi.com The Board Attempted to Reach an Amicable Resolution James C. Pappas JCP Investment Joshua E. Schechter Bradley L. Radoff BLR Partners/Fondren Thomas Purcell Lake Trail Summary of the Settlement Attempts ▪ The Board engaged with the Dissident Group over the course of 9 months ▪ The Co
Slide 26: James Pappas
26 www.frgi.com James Pappas ▪ Most Recent Activist Plan Resulted in Shareholder Value Destruction and a Material Weakness in Internal Controls − In 2+ years, Jamba’s stock price cut in half − Pappas’ plan contributed to a material weakness in internal controls, with Pappas on the audit c ommittee ▪
Slide 27: Pappas' Plan at Jamba Destroyed Shareholder Value
27 www.frgi.com $0.00 $2.00 $4.00 $6.00 $8.00 $10.00 $12.00 $14.00 $16.00 $18.00 Stock Price Pappas’ Plan at Jamba Destroyed Shareholder Value and Contributed to a Material Weakness in Internal Controls 4 - Aug - 2016 Q2 Earnings: Miss 4 - Nov - 2016 Q3 Earnings: Miss 13 - Jan - 2017 Files Form 8 -
Slide 28: Unclear Whether Pappas Has Incentive or Time to Put Fiesta First
28 www.frgi.com Unclear Whether Pappas Has Incentive or Time to Put Fiesta First Pappas family funded JCP and James Pappas has an interest in the family business 1 JCP has interests in public companies with restaurant brands in Fiesta’s core markets 1 Based on publicly available documents, James Pap
Slide 29: John Morlock
29 www.frgi.com John Morlock ▪ Consistent History of Destroying Shareholder Value ▪ Less Experience Than Current Directors − No public company board experience − More limited operating experience than any of the 3 directors recently added to Fiesta’s Board ▪ Unprepared for Board Interview − Had not
Slide 30: Morlock's Successful Turnaround at SpinCycle is Misrepresented
30 www.frgi.com Morlock’s “ Successful Turnaround” at SpinCycle is Misrepresented June 07 , 2004 | Michael Hiltzik This was proven by the absurd history of a company called SpinCycle … The company raised more than $ 150 million in cash and junk - bond debt, leased lavish headquarters space in Scotts
Slide 31: Dissident Nominees Would Not Adequately Replace Existing Skill Sets
31 www.frgi.com Dissident Nominees Would Not Adequately Replace Existing Skill Sets Skills & Experience Brian P. Friedman James C. Pappas Restaurant & Consumer Industry Experience ▪ Over last 20 years has served as director of restaurant companies including Restaurant Associates, California Pizza Ki
Slide 32: Our Directors Have the Right Skills to Oversee Execution of Turnaround
32 www.frgi.com Our Directors Have the Right Skills to Oversee Execution of Turnaround Annual Meeting of Shareholders June 7, 2017 Vote FOR x x Barry J. Alperin Brian P. Friedman Barry J. Alperin Brian P. Friedman x Over a decade as a leader of Hasbro, one of the largest toy makers in the world x Ov
Slide 33: Conclusion
33 www.frgi.com Conclusion WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO SUPPORT ALL OF FIESTA’S HIGHLY QUALIFIED DIRECTOR NOMINEES ON THE WHITE PROXY CARD Fiesta is on the Right Path and h as the Right Board and Management Team to Drive Shareholder Value
Slide 34: Appendix
34 www.frgi.com Appendix
Slide 35: Dallas was a Poor Choice for a Headquarters
35 www.frgi.com Dallas was a Poor Choice for a Headquarters Renewal Plan Lacks Specifics Other Aspects of Dissident’s Analyses are Flawed Adding Dallas as a corporate center was the right strategic decision x Dallas has the most restaurant management talent of any city in the US and was central to o
Slide 36: The Board Attempted to Reach an Amicable Resolution
36 www.frgi.com The Board Attempted to Reach an Amicable Resolution Aug. 2016 Sept. 2016 Oct. 2016 Nov. 2016 Dec. 2016 • On August 9, Fiesta’s management team speaks to James Pappas as part of ongoing shareholder engagement efforts , discussing topics relating to Fiesta’s governance and performance
Slide 37: The Board Attempted to Reach an Amicable Resolution (Cont'd)
37 www.frgi.com Jan. 2017 Feb. 2017 Mar. 2017 Apr. 2017 Current Status The Board Attempted to Reach an Amicable Resolution (Cont’d) • On January 26, the Dissident Group delivers a nomination notice , notifying Fiesta of their intent to nominate John Morlock, James Pappas, and Joshua Schechter to the
Slide 38: GAAP to Non-GAAP Reconciliation (unaudited)
38 www.frgi.com GAAP to Non - GAAP Reconciliation (unaudited) Twelve months ended January 1, 2017 January 3, 2016 Net income $ 16,712 $ 38,536 Add: Depreciation and amortization 36,776 30,575 Impairment and other lease charges 25,644 2,382 Interest expense 2,171 1,889 Provision for income taxes 8,33