Edgewater Technology — Proxy Contest (January 2017)
35 slides from Edgewater Technology's proxy contest presentation, Jan 24, 2017
Slide 1: Presentation to ISS Regarding Edgewater Technology, Inc.
A N C O R A® Ancora Advisors, LLC Presentation to ISS Regarding Edgewater Technology, Inc. January 2017 Lead Portfolio Manager: Jim Chadwick 216-825-4000 Proposed Board Members: Frederick DiSanto Jeffrey Rutherford Matthew Carpenter Kurtis Wolf www.ancora.net
Slide 2: Disclaimer
DISCLAIMER ANCORA Stockholders are advised to read the consent proxy statement filed by Ancora Advisors, LLC (“Ancora”) and other documents referred to in this presentation. Ancora believes they contain important information. These materials are available at no change at the Securities and Exchange
Slide 3: Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS ANCORA • Executive Summary Page 4 • Ancora’s Engagement Page 5 • Ancora’s Proposals, Candidates and Plan Page 7 • Section 1: Share Price Underperformance Page 12 • Section 2: Poor Operating Performance Page 16 • Recent Results Page 21 • Section 3: Excessive Executive Compensation P
Slide 4: Executive Summary
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ANCORA Ancora has lost faith in the ability of the long-standing legacy independent(1) members of the Board of Directors (the “Board”) of Edgewater Technology, Inc. (“Edgewater” or the “Company”) to responsibly evaluate the performance of CEO Shirley Singleton and CTO David Clancey
Slide 5: Ancora's Engagement with Edgewater
ANCORA’S ENGAGEMENT WITH EDGEWATER ANCORA Timeline of Events 4/2/2015 Ancora affiliate makes initial investment in the Company. Ancora meets with Ms. Singleton and David Clancey, Edgewater’s Chief Technology Officer, in Chicago to discuss the Company’s business 8/26/2015 and strategy. Under sharehol
Slide 6: Ancora's Engagement with Edgewater (Continued)
ANCORA’S ENGAGEMENT WITH EDGEWATER (CONTINUED) ANCORA Timeline of Events During the follow up discussion with Ms. Singleton and Messers. Clancey and Oakes, Ancora expresses its position that to best serve the interests of all shareholders, the Company should reach a mutually beneficial agreement wit
Slide 7: Ancora Proposals
ANCORA PROPOSALS ANCORA 1. Bylaw Restoration Proposal- to ensure that the incumbent Board does not limit the effect of shareholder consent to the removal of four of the current directors and the election of the Nominees 2. Removal Proposal- to remove four current members of the existing Board, inclu
Slide 8: Why Ancora's Board Candidates
WHY ANCORA’S BOARD CANDIDATES (1) ANCORA Board Candidate Relevant Experience Benefit to EDGW Board Frederick DiSanto • CEO, Ancora Advisors (2006-Present) • Since becoming CEO, Fred DiSanto has grown • EVP, Fifth Third Bank (2001-2005) Ancora Advisors from $80 million of AUM in • Board experience: M
Slide 9: Board Candidates Comparison
BOARD CANDIDATES COMPARISON ANCORA Stock Ownership: • Ancora’s slate of board nominees includes a shareholder representative of one of the Company’s largest shareholders and a nominee who has purchased 50,000 shares • Edgewater’s legacy directors slated for replacement collectively beneficially own
Slide 10: Ancora's Plan
ANCORA’S PLAN ANCORA If elected, our nominees will seek to do the following: 1. Evaluate the need for change in senior executive leadership, specifically for the roles of Chief Executive Officer and Chief Technology Officer, and seek to promote a new CEO from within the Company 2. Broaden equity own
Slide 11: Ancora's Plan (Continued)
ANCORA’S PLAN (CONTINUED) ANCORA Our plan involves the following key organizational changes: • Promotion of key business line leaders to C-level posts (but with continued P&L responsibility) • The goal is to have the strategic vision of the Company driven by those who are truly running the company •
Slide 12: Share Price Underperformance
SECTION 1 ANCORA Share Price Underperformance ANCORA Institutional 12
Slide 13: Share Price Underperformance
SHARE PRICE UNDERPERFORMANCE ANCORA • Edgewater’s stock price has significantly underperformed a peer group comprised of twenty-eight publicly-traded North American-based IT Consulting companies both in terms of total shareholder return and other key operating metrics • Unlike the Company’s self-sel
Slide 14: EDGW Stock Price Performance vs. North American IT Peers
EDGW STOCK PRICE PERFORMANCE VS. NORTH AMERICAN IT PEERS ANCORA Since Shirley Singleton became CEO in January 2002, Edgewater has massively underperformed its North American IT Consulting peers Share Price Performance During Existing CEO Tenure: EDGW vs. NA IT Peers (1) Edgewater Technology, Inc. No
Slide 15: EDGW Stock Price Performance vs. Major Indices
EDGW STOCK PRICE PERFORMANCE VS. MAJOR INDICES ANCORA ...and has also underperformed all the major indices EDGW Share Price Performance vs. Major Indices(1) Edgewater Technology, Inc. Nasdaq Composite Index Total Return Russell 2000 (TR) S&P 500 (TR) 300.00% 250.00% 233% 238% 200.00% 161% 144% 150.0
Slide 16: Poor Operating Performance
SECTION 2 ANCORA Poor Operating Performance ANCORA Institutional 16
Slide 17: Poor Operating Performance
POOR OPERATING PERFORMANCE ANCORA Poor Operating Results + Bad Capital Allocation = Value Destruction • In Edgewater’s most recent investor presentation, filed on January 10, 2017, the Company mentions that the business generated $3.2 million of free cash flow (“FCF”) on $125.2 million of LTM revenu
Slide 18: Poor Operating Performance
POOR OPERATING PERFORMANCE ANCORA • Edgewater’s sub-par operating margins appear to be the result of: 1. High SG&A expenses as a % of revenue, as evidenced by the fact that SG&A expenses as a % of revenues (excluding reimbursements) are more than 50% greater than that of its consulting peers 2. Low
Slide 19: Prolonged Underperformance
PROLONGED UNDERPERFORMANCE(1) ANCORA • Edgewater’s operating metrics have declined since 2011 with flat EBITDA margins and nearly a 50% decline in Return on Capital (“ROC”) • EBITDA margins have consistently remained below the North American IT Consulting Peer group • Utilization rates remain unacce
Slide 20: Prolonged Underperformance Continued
PROLONGED UNDERPERFORMANCE CONTINUED(1) ANCORA • From 2011-2015, ROC has declined as the Company executed $34.2 million of acquisitions, while the CEO and CTO enriched themselves at the shareholders’ expense Edgewater's vs. NA IT Peers Return on Capital(2) 12.0% 10.3% 9.6% 10.0% 10.0% 8.8% 8.8% 8.0%
Slide 21: Recent Results
RECENT RESULTS ANCORA Management’s “rosy” commentary in its recent investor presentation flies in the face of the Company’s recent results. Days prior to announcing the termination of the strategic process, management preannounced an earnings miss and continued execution errors. Commentary from Nove
Slide 22: Excessive Executive Compensation Practices
SECTION 3 ANCORA Excessive Executive Compensation Practices ANCORA Institutional 22
Slide 23: Excessive CEO and CTO Compensation
EXCESSIVE CEO AND CTO COMPENSATION ANCORA • Despite delivering sub-par returns to the Company’s stockholders, both Ms. Singleton and Mr. Clancey have been handsomely rewarded by the Board. • As detailed in the table below, perhaps the most striking data point in terms of excessive compensation is th
Slide 24: Pay for Underperformance
PAY FOR UNDERPERFORMANCE(1) ANCORA • From January 2002 - 2015, cumulative compensation paid to Shirley Singleton, David Clancey and other members of the legacy board was $23.2 million • While a select few were paid handsomely at shareholders’ expense, Edgewater failed to properly incentivize other n
Slide 25: Poor Corporate Governance and Poorly Managed Strategic Alternatives Process
SECTION 4 ANCORA Poor Corporate Governance and Poorly Managed Strategic Alternatives Process ANCORA Institutional 25
Slide 26: Board's Lack of Independence
BOARD’S LACK OF INDEPENDENCE ANCORA • Six of the eight members on Edgewater’s current Board have served as Edgewater directors for over 10 years and have failed to take action to hold Ms. Singleton accountable for a tenure in which the Company has failed its stockholders • Given the recent one-year
Slide 27: Failed Acquisition Strategy – Lack of Diligence
FAILED ACQUISITION STRATEGY – LACK OF DILIGENCE ANCORA • In 2010, Edgewater acquired a company named Fullscope, Inc. for approximately $15mm in cash and stock • Edgewater also paid an additional $2.7mm in earn-outs to Fullscope, which was part of the purchase agreement • Shortly after the acquisitio
Slide 28: Failed Acquisition Strategy – Lack of Revenue Growth
FAILED ACQUISITION STRATEGY – LACK OF REVENUE GROWTH ANCORA • Edgewater’s Board has overseen a significant lack of revenue growth, despite making numerous acquisitions, implying the Company’s organic revenue growth is poor or acquired companies perform poorly post-acquisition, or both • Edgewater ha
Slide 29: Company's Management of Strategic Review Process
COMPANY’S MANAGEMENT OF STRATEGIC REVIEW PROCESS ANCORA • We have serious concerns with the Company’s management of the formal review of strategic alternatives it announced on November 30, 2015, only a month after a consent solicitation was launched by a dissident seeking to remove and replace four
Slide 30: Conclusion
CONCLUSION ANCORA We believe Edgewater’s Board is stale and has failed the Company’s shareholders • With an average tenure of approximately 11 years, the Board has failed to add significant value during that time. Non-legacy directors were only added to the board as a result of settling a potential
Slide 31: Ancora Overview
ANCORA OVERVIEW ANCORA • Cleveland, OH based Registered Investment Adviser with three SEC registered, independent employee owned investment advisors with 61 employees • $4.4 billion of combined firm assets under management (9/30/16) • Significant experience investing in both equities and fixed incom
Slide 32: Appendix
SECTION 5 ANCORA Appendix ANCORA Institutional 32
Slide 33: Ancora's Board Candidate Biographies
ANCORA’S BOARD CANDIDATE BIOGRAPHIES ANCORA Frederick DiSanto Age 54, has served as the Chief Executive Officer of Ancora Advisors, LLC and Ancora Holdings Inc, a registered investment advisor, since January 2006, and as Chairman of the Board of Ancora Advisors, LLC, since December 2014. Previously,
Slide 34: Ancora's Board Candidate Biographies
ANCORA’S BOARD CANDIDATE BIOGRAPHIES ANCORA Matthew Carpenter Age 45, has served as the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Vertical Knowledge, L.L.C., a leading provider of open source data, information services and analytics, since 2007. brings more than 20 years of experience and leadership a
Slide 35: North American IT Consulting Peers
NORTH AMERICAN IT CONSULTING PEERS ANCORA Company Name Ticker Primary Industry International Business Machines Corporation NYSE: IBM Information Technology (IT) Consulting Accenture plc NYSE: ACN Information Technology (IT) Consulting Cognizant Technology Solutions Corporation NASDAQ: CTSH Informati