Banque nationale de Belgique SA · EURONEXT:BNB
Banque nationale de Belgique SA — presentatie franck portier
62 slides from Banque nationale de Belgique SA's investor presentation, Mar 22, 2006
Slide 1: Gold Rush Fever in Business Cycles
Gold Rush Fever in Business Cycles Paul Beaudry, Fabrice Collard & Franck Portier University of British Columbia & Université de Toulouse Banque Nationale Nationale Bank Belgischen de Belgique van Belgı̈e Nationalbank March, 22, 2006 1
Slide 2: Plan of the talk
Plan of the talk 1. Motivation (with Some Interesting Features of the Data) 2. An Analytical Model 3. Taking The Model to the Data 4. Conclusion 2
Slide 3: Road map
Road map 1. Motivation (with Some Interesting Features of the Data) 2. An Analytical Model 3. Taking The Model to the Data 4. Conclusion 3
Slide 4: Macroeconomic Facts (1)
Macroeconomic Facts (1) • A well known set of facts shed some light on the existence of market rushes • Run a VAR on consumption and output (US quarterly data 1947Q1 to 2004Q4) [in the line of Cochrane, QJE 1991] 4
Slide 5: Macroeconomic Facts (2)
Macroeconomic Facts (2) • LR matrix associated with the Wold representation has 1 full zero column =⇒ puts some structure on the permanent/temporary and Choleski identifications: Permanent shock = Consumption shock • C is only explained by the permanent shock (at all horizons) (⩾ 96%) • The other sh
Slide 6: Long Run Identification
Long Run Identification 15 0.5 LS Consumption - ¢ P Output - e 15 0.5 0 -0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 Quarters Quarters Consumption - et Output - et 15 5 15 20
Slide 7: Long Run Identification versus Choleski Identification
Long Run Identification versus Choleski Identification 7
Slide 8: LR-SR Comparison
LR-SR Comparison 4 4 2 2 εT εP 0 0 −2 −2 −4 −4 −4 −2 0 2 4 −4 −2 0 2 4 εC εY 8
Slide 9: Very Robust Feature: Specification
Very Robust Feature: Specification LR Identification P P Consumption − ε Output − ε 1.5 1.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Consumption − εT Output − εT 1.5 Benchmark 1.5 Coint. Est. 8 lags 1 1 Levels 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters 9
Slide 10: Very Robust Feature: Specification (2)
Very Robust Feature: Specification (2) Choleski Identification C C Consumption − ε Output − ε 1.5 1.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Consumption − εY Output − εY 1.5 Benchmark 1.5 Coint. Est. 8 lags 1 1 Levels 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Qu
Slide 11: Very Robust Feature: Data
Very Robust Feature: Data LR Identification P P Consumption − ε Output − ε 1.5 1.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Consumption − εT Output − εT 1.5 Benchmark 1.5 C−Y C(ND+S)−(I+C) 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters 11
Slide 12: Very Robust Feature: Data (2)
Very Robust Feature: Data (2) Choleski Identification C C Consumption − ε Output − ε 1.5 1.5 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters Consumption − εY Output − εY 1.5 Benchmark 1.5 C−Y C(ND+S)−(I+C) 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Quarters Quarters 12
Slide 13: Forecast Error Variance Decomposition, (C, Y) Benchmark VECM
Forecast Error Variance Decomposition, (C, Y ) Benchmark VECM. Horizon Output Consumption εT εY εT εY 1 62.01% 79.86% 3.90% 0.00% 4 28.10 % 46.05 % 1.16% 1.25% 8 17.20 % 32.73% 0.91% 1.26 % 20 9.79 % 22.21 % 0.42% 2.13% ∞ 0 % 3.89 % 0% 3.89% 13
Slide 14: Hours Worked
Hours Worked PK • (ML) Regression: xt = c + k=0 αk εP T H t−k + βk εt−k + γk εt−k , Level Specification Difference Specification Horizon εp εt εH εp εt εH 1 19 % 75 % 6 % 21 % 74 % 5 % 4 37 % 56 % 7 % 46 % 52 % 2 % 8 61 % 32 % 7 % 66 % 32 % 2 % 20 60 % 21 % 19 % 69 % 28 % 3 % 40 54 % 20 % 26 % 57 %
Slide 15: Nominal and Real Interest Rates
Nominal and Real Interest Rates • Same regressions for the interest rate (Tbill, and Tbill-Pgdp) T bill − ∆P GDP e T bill − ∆P GDP+1 k εP εT εP εT 1 0.1116 0.0970 0.0683 0.0606 4 0.0817 0.0909 0.0875 0.0831 8 0.0598 0.0826 0.0686 0.0729 • Interest rates do not respond negatively to the second shock
Slide 16: Summary
Summary Data suggest that • There is a shock that acts as an investment shock, • with no long run impact (not technology), • that explains a good part of the BC fluctuations in Y and H • and that does not look either like a monetary or preference shock in the short run 16
Slide 17: A possible story
A possible story • Suggest shocks that essentially affect investment leaving con- sumption unaffected: • Investment specific shock? • Questions: 1. What are these shocks in, say, the business press, at a business cycle frequency? 2. Not much variability in the data 3. A quantitative problem 17
Slide 18: Investment Specific Shocks vs TFP
Investment Specific Shocks vs TFP 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 Quarters 18
Slide 19: Investment Specific Shocks vs TFP
Investment Specific Shocks vs TFP σ(∆ TFP): 0.7999, σ(∆ ISTP): 0.5020 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 ISTP TFP 0 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 Quarters 19
Slide 20: Our View
Our View • Role of investors’ expectations in fluctuations (Pigou, Wicksell, Keynes) • New (perceived) opportunities of profit lead to waves of invest- ment • Research program on the role of fundamental shocks to expecta- tions (“news”) (Beaudry and Portier JME 2004, AER 2006, JET 2007) • Not a suns
Slide 21: Elements of the Model
Elements of the Model • Expanding varieties model • The growth in the potential set of varieties is technologically driven and exogenous. 21
Slide 22: Road Map
Road Map 1. Motivation (with Some Interesting Features of the Data) 2. An Analytical Model 3. Taking The Model to the Data 4. Conclusion 22
Slide 23: An Analytical Model
An Analytical Model • The objective here is to derive an analytical solution to a model that possesses “Market Rush” properties • I will then discuss some of the implications of the model 23
Slide 24: Technologies
Technologies Final Good: (1−αh )(1−χ) 1−αh α − χ R Nt χ χ • Qt = (Θtht) Nt h 0 Xj,t dj , • No impact of Nt Intermediate Good: • Each existing intermediate good is produced by a monopolist, • Survive with probability (1 − µ), • It takes 1 unit of the final good to produce 1 unit of Xj,t. 24
Slide 25: Technologies (2)
Technologies (2) Startups: • Invest 1 in t and be a monopolist in t+1 with probability ρt 25
Slide 26: Households
Households Preferences: ∞ X Max E [log Ct+i + g(h − ht+i)] i=0 Budget constraint: Period t: Ct + PtE Et + St = wtht + Etπt + PtE (1 − µ)Et−1 + PtE ρt−1St−1 Period t+1: E E Ct+1+Pt+1 E E t+1 +St+1 = wt+1 ht+1 +Et+1 πt+1 +Pt+1 (1−µ)Et+Pt+1 ρtSt 26
Slide 27: New Markets
New Markets • Probability that a startup at time t will become a functioning firm at t + 1: ( ) tNt ρt = min 1, St • Evolution of markets 27
Slide 28: Important remark
Important remark Parameters are such that it is always optimal to fill available space on the market 28
Slide 29: Value Added
Value Added • Value added is given by: Z N t Yt = Qt − Pj,tXj,tdj = AΘtht 0 • Value-added Yt is used for consumption Ct and startup expendi- tures (St) purposes Yt = Ct + St 29
Slide 30: Equilibrium
Equilibrium • From the household program: " # " # 1 π (1 − µ) = β Et t+1 + β Et ρt C t Ct+1 ρt+1Ct+1 ∞ X τ τ Ct ⇐⇒ 1 = βρtEt (1 − µ) β πt+τ τ =1 C t+τ • Startup cost = discounted sum of expected profits • Expectation driven startup investment 30
Slide 31: Equilibrium (2)
Equilibrium (2) Using labor decisions, equilibrium conditions collapse to " ! # h i 1 (ht − ζ0) = βδtζ1Et ht+1 + βδtEt − 1 (ht+1 − ζ0) . δt+1 with • δt = εt/(1 − µ + εt) is a increasing function of the fraction of newly opened markets εt, • ζ0 and ζ1 are complicated functions of the deep parameters.
Slide 32: Equilibrium (3)
Equilibrium (3) Result 1 Employment is a purely forward looking, and therefore in- directly depends on all the future δt 32
Slide 33: VAR Representation
VAR Representation • Output and consumption are given by Yt = ky Θtht and Ct = kcΘt s.t. log Yt = ky + log Θt + log ht log Ct = kc + log Θt • Assume – log Θt = log Θt−1 + εΘ t , – εt i.i.d., E(εt) = µ and εN t = log(εt) − log(µ). 33
Slide 34: Implications
Implications • We have ! ! ! ! ∆ log(Ct) 1 0 εΘ t εΘ t = = C(L) ∆ log(Yt) 1 b(1 − L) εN t εN t • Shares a lot of dynamic properties with the data: 1. Consumption is a random walk, only affected by εΘ 2. Output is also affected in the short run by εN 3. Orthogonalization would give: εP = εC = εΘ and
Slide 35: Implications (2)
Implications (2) • One can prove that the decentralized investment decisions are the same that previously, so that the dynamics of h is the same. • The socially optimal allocations are in this case ht = C te • All εN -driven fluctuations are suboptimal 35
Slide 36: The Klondike Gold Rush of 1896-1904
The Klondike Gold Rush of 1896-1904 First, Rushing 36
Slide 37: The Klondike Gold Rush of 1896-1904 (2)
The Klondike Gold Rush of 1896-1904 (2) Second, Working Hard and Investing 37
Slide 38: The Klondike Gold Rush of 1896-1904 (3)
The Klondike Gold Rush of 1896-1904 (3) Then, Registering 38
Slide 39: Back to Modern Macro
Back to Modern Macro • Gold rushes: economic boom – large increases in expenditures – securing claims near new found veins of gold. • Define Market rush: economic boom – securing “position” (monopoly rents) on a market. • Define gold rush: inefficient market rush: Historically, gold even- tually exp
Slide 40: Road Map
Road Map 1. Motivation (with Some Interesting Features of the Data) 2. An Analytical Model 3. Taking The Model to the Data 4. Conclusion 40
Slide 41: An extended Model
An extended Model • Turn to the quantitative aspect of the problem • Aim: Assess the quantitative relevance of the model • Some extra features: 1. Capital accumulation, 2. Adjustment costs to investment, 3. Habit persistence in consumption, 4. Two types of intermediate goods. 41
Slide 42: Extra Features
Extra Features • Final Good 1−αx −αz −αh Qt = Kt (Θtht)αh × . . . Z N ! αx Z N ! αz x,t χ z,t χ ξ ξe × Nx,t Xt(i)χdi Nz,t Zt(i)χdi 0 0 with αx, αz , αh ∈ (0, 1), αx + αz + αh < 1 and χ ⩾ 1. • ξ = −αx(1 − χ)/χ : Nx,t has no impact • ξe = (χ(1 − αx) − αz )/χ: Qt is linear in Nz,t 42
Slide 43: Extra Features (2)
Extra Features (2) • Variety: Nx,t+1 = (1 − µ + εxt)Nx,t Nz,t+1 = (1 − µ + εzt )Nz,t. • Shocks: log(εxt) = ρx log(εxt−1) + (1 − ρx) log(εx) + νtx log(εzt ) = ρz log(εzt−1) + (1 − ρz ) log(εz ) + νtz log Θt = log Θt−1 + εΘ t . 43
Slide 44: Estimation: Simulated Method of Moments
Estimation Simulated Method of Moments 44
Slide 45: Estimation (2)
Estimation (2) Not all parameters are estimated Preferences Discount factor β 0.9926 Technology Elasticity of output to intermediate goods αx 0.3529 Elasticity of output to hours worked αh 0.4235 Depreciation rate δ 0.0250 Elasticity of substitution bw intermediates χ 0.8333 Rate of technology growt
Slide 46: Impulse Response Functions VAR versus Model (LR identification)
Impulse Response Functions VAR versus Model (LR identification) Consumption − εP Output − εP 1.5 1.5 1 S.D. Shock 1 S.D. Shock 1 1 0.5 0.5 Data 0 Model 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Horizon Horizon Consumption − εT Output − εT 1.5 1.5 1 S.D. Shock 1 S.D. Shock 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 2
Slide 47: Impulse Response Functions VAR versus Model (SR identification)
Impulse Response Functions VAR versus Model (SR identification) Consumption − εC Output − εC 1.5 1.5 1 S.D. Shock 1 S.D. Shock 1 1 0.5 0.5 Data 0 Model 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 20 5 10 15 20 Horizon Horizon Consumption − εY Output − εY 1.5 1.5 1 S.D. Shock 1 S.D. Shock 1 1 0.5 0.5 0 0 −0.5 −0.5 5 10 15 2
Slide 48: Estimated Parameters
Estimated Parameters Persistence of the X Variety shocks ρx 0.9166 (0.0336) Standard dev. of X Variety shocks σx 0.2865 (0.0317) Persistence of the Z Variety shocks ρz 0.9164 (0.6459) Standard dev. of Z Variety shocks σz 0.0245 (0.1534) Standard dev. of the Technology shocks σΘ 0.0131 (0.0015) Habit
Slide 49: Goodness of Fit
Goodness of Fit J–stat(Y) Chi–stat(C) Chi–stat(C,Y) Test 17.41 42.51 92.78 P–value [0.99] [0.12] [0.06] 49
Slide 50: Does the model match Hours variance decomposition?
Does the model match Hours variance decomposition? PK • (ML) Regression: ht = c + k=0 αk εP T H t−k + βk εt−k + γk εt−k , Data Model Horizon εp εt εh εp εt εh 1 19 % 75 % 6 % 35 % 65 % 0% 50
Slide 51: Business cycle accounting
Business cycle accounting Horizon Output Consumption Hours εΘ εx εz εΘ εx εz εΘ εx εz 1 64 % 36 % 0 % 94 % 6 % 0 % 15 % 85 % 0% 4 86 % 14 % 0 % 95 % 5 % 0 % 19 % 81 % 0% 8 92 % 8 % 0 % 96 % 4 % 0 % 32 % 68 % 0% 20 96 % 3 % 1 % 98 % 1 % 1 % 40 % 59 % 1% ∞ 96 % 0 % 4 % 96 % 0 % 4 % 41 % 57 % 2% 51
Slide 52: Alternative Stories
Alternative Stories • Common to all models – habit persistence, – adjustment costs to investment – permanent technology shock – Shut down the permanent market shock Z N ! αx x,t χ 1−αx −αh ξ Qt = Kt (Θtht)αh Nx,t Xt(i)χdi . 0 • Compete our market shock against alternative shocks. 52
Slide 53: Alternative Stories (2)
Alternative Stories (2) Investment Specific Shock Yt = Ct + St + e−ζt It, PIS–1 PIS–2 TIS–1 TIS–2 J–stat 17.31 60.96 14.89 59.48 [0.99] [0.86] [1.00]) [0.87] D(C, Y ) 99.42 92.34 [0.03] [0.06]) 53
Slide 54: Alternative Stories (3)
Alternative Stories (3) Investment Specific Shock: Variance decomposition Horizon Output Consumption Hours εΘ ν x ζ εΘ νx ζ εΘ νx ζ PIS–1: ζ=Permanent Investment Specific Shock 1 64 % 36 % 0 % 95 % 5 % 0 % 15 % 85 % 0 % ∞ 100 % 0 % 0 % 100 % 0 % 0 % 44 % 56 % 0 % PIS–2: ζ=Permanent Investment Specif
Slide 55: Alternative Stories (4)
Alternative Stories (4) Transitory technology and preference shocks • Transitory technology shock Z N ! αx x,t χ 1−αx −αh ξ Qt = eζt Kt (Θtht)αh Nx,t Xt(i)χdi , 0 • Preference shocks ∞ h i ) + ψeζt+τ (h − h X Et log(Ct+τ − bCt+τ −1 t+τ ) , τ =0 T.T. T.P. J–stat 54.65 50.56 [0.95] [0.98] 55
Slide 56: Alternative Stories (5)
Alternative Stories (5) Horizon Output Consumption Hours εΘ ν x ζ εΘ νx ζ εΘ νx ζ T.T.: ζ=Temporary Technology Shock 1 21 % 38 % 41 % 44 % 17 % 39 % 0 % 98 % 2 % ∞ 99 % 0 % 0 % 100 % 0 % 0 % 10 % 66 % 24 % T.P.: ζ=Temporary Preference Shock 1 27 % 39 % 34 % 55 % 15 % 30 % 1 % 53 % 46 % 20 70 % 8 % 2
Slide 57: Road Map
Road Map 1. Motivation (with Some Interesting Features of the Data) 2. An Analytical Model 3. Taking The Model to the Data 4. Conclusion 57
Slide 58: Conclusion
Conclusion • We have found a new source of shocks, that looks like animal spirits, although it comes from a model with determinate equilib- rium. • A quite pessimistic view that a non trivial share of the Business Cycle is inefficient large welfare cost of fluctuations. • Part of a research program
Slide 59: Extra material
Extra material 59
Slide 60: Alternative Stories? Estimation Results
Alternative Stories? Estimation Results RBC–P RBC–T RBC–Q CEE b 0.8813 0.8813 0.7181 0.0000 (0.0289) (0.0289) (0.0739) (0.0000) ϕ 0.6682 0.6683 2.0353 0.6353 (0.4305) (0.4369) (0.6242) (0.1811) σγ 0.0143 0.0143 0.0153 0.0129 (0.0019) (0.0019) (0.0016) (0.0015) ρT 0.5973 0.4974 0.6024 – (0.0996) (0.1
Slide 61: Alternative Stories?
Alternative Stories? PIS–1 PIS–2 TIS–1 TIS–2 b 0.6108 0.3125 0.6457 0.3062 (0.1229) (0.1921) (0.1180) (0.2184) ϕ 0.4195 0.2534 0.6099 0.2775 (0.3227) (0.3201) (0.6675) (0.4235) σΘ 0.0131 0.0088 0.0126 0.0089 (0.0017) (0.1592) (0.0017) (0.0016) ρx 0.9117 0.8919 0.9143 0.8967 (0.0323) (0.0395) (0.0374
Slide 62: Alternative Stories?
Alternative Stories? T.T. T.P. b 0.3420 0.3877 (0.1869) (0.1472) ϕ 0.3125 0.3699 (0.2645) (0.3228) σΘ 0.0062 0.0075 (0.0044) (0.0037) ρx 0.9195 0.9075 (0.0234) (0.0259) σx 0.1768 0.1825 (0.0278) (0.0297) ρT 0.9143 0.8799 (0.1148) (0.1959) σT 0.0046 0.0068 (0.0021) (0.0030) 62
Banque Nationale De Belgique — presentatie franck portier on 6ix